google391cb86d20654c76.html

We at, Followers of the Messiah, would like to sincerely welcome all to our website.

The following groups of people are especially welcome. We hope that you will learn new skills & knowledge , and/or confirm what you already know.

We warmly welcome :
+ ALL who have a deep, & genuine belief in Messiah Yahushua (Jesus)
+ Anyone who has stopped going to Church for whatever reason
+ Those who consider themselves to be Yahweh’s (God's) family, Israel
+ People interested in learning practical strategies to study the Bible
+ Independent Bible Researchers
+ Seekers of Yahweh's TRUTH

This is a very long topic, but for now, I’ll introduce it briefly. For those who are interested, I will provide much more detail after this introduction.

Who is the Messiah ?

In the Tanach (OT), it is believed to be are over 300 prophesies about a character whose main role is to restore Yahweh’s original kingdom. There, He is referred to by various metaphors including  “the seed of the woman” (Gen 3:15), a “promised lamb of Yahweh (God)” (Gen 22:8), “a branch” (Isaiah 11:1), “a Prophet from the midst of Israel like me (Moses)” (Deut 18:15), & many others, but probably, He is best known as “the Messiah”, the anointed one, the Mashiyach in Hebrew, & Christos in Greek.

Who was Messiah Yahushua ?

According to the Renewed Covenant Scriptures (RC) or New Testament, Messiah Yahushua was born into a Jewish family, & so first of all, He was a Jew. He was raised to be Torah-observant,  (law obedient), as most of His fellow Jews were - Torah is the Hebrew word, poorly translated as "law", which means “instructions”. The following verses are evidence to support this :

Luke 1:59 tells us He was circumcised on the eighth day.

Luke 2:41 & John 2:23 say that He & His parents went to the feast of Passover.

Luke 8:44 explains that He wore "fringes" on His garments in accordance with the Torah command of Num 15:38.

What did Messiah Yahushua believe ?

Yahushua believed in His heavenly Father, & prayed to Him often (Matt 14:23, Mark 6:46 & Luke 9:28).

He believed in upholding, keeping, & teaching the Torah (law) of Yahweh (God) (Matt 5:17-19). 

As a Torah-observant Jew, Yahushua would have been taught as a child, & knew that He had to follow Yahweh’s plan, and that meant giving Himself up for others. This is why He replied to His parents in Luke 2:49, "did you not know that I must be my father’s business". 

What did Messiah Yahushua do ?

Because He was a Torah-observant Jew, He was therefore, an Israelite. We note that all Jews are Israelites, but not all Israelites are Jews - there are 12 tribes of Israel. Messiah Yahushua kept all the Torah commands that He could - no one can keep all the Torah, because some commands are for the high priest, some are for priests, some are for Levites, some are for women, some are for farmers, while some are for all.

He did the will of His Father in heaven (Matt 26:39)

Yahushua, as a Torah-observant Jew, in summary, He was circumcised on the eighth day (Lev 12:3), kept the seventh day Sabbath (Exod 20:8-11), celebrated Yahweh's moedim, appointed times, according to Lev 23, followed Yahweh's food commands of Lev 11, & observed the Covenant requirements of Exod 20-24.

If you would like to read more details about who the Messiah is, what He believed, & what He did, I have provided details of them in the following section.

Above, I’ve already introduced the Messiah of the Tanach, but if you are not convinced about whether that character came to Earth, as Yahushua (Jesus), I strongly encourage you to view Chuck Missler’s video, Chuck Missler What is Truth (Session 2) @ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mI77pIarER4

Chuck’s two sessions are very interesting, but if you forward the above video to about the 30th minute mark, I believe that you will find Chuck’s explanation of the Messiah of the Tanach fascinating.

If you are unfamiliar with the more than 300 Tanach prophesies related to the Messiah, they can be found @ http://therefinersfire.org/prophecies.htm


Most people know what they understand about “the Messiah” from the Renewed Covenant (RC) Scriptures (NT). I will be quoting from the King James Bible translation of the RC, in this section, unless otherwise noted. I will be using the Hebrew name for the heavenly Father, Yahweh, & the Hebrew name for His Son, Yahushua, whom you may know as Jesus. Any added emphasis is mine ! 

As an introduction to my comments about “the Messiah” of the RC, I’d like to begin with a quote from Michael Rood, who wrote about the genealogy of the Messiah. Michael writes :

The genealogy of Yeshua through his only earthly parent, Miriam, is detailed in Matthew’s account of the origin of the “king from heaven”. The Messiah must be from the lineage of King David (Jeremiah 23:5). Though translations derived from the Greek text of Matthew confuse the genealogy, the Ancient Hebrew text of Matthew’s Gospel, from which the Aramaic and, later, the Greek were translated, clearly details Miriam’s lineage through her father Yoseph ben Yaakov through the kingly line of David through Solomon. Luke’s Gospel, on the other hand, details the lineage of Miriam’s husband Yoseph ben Eli through David’s son Nathan. Luke’s lineage is inserted directly after Matthew’s genealogy for comparison. It is clear that the Yoseph ben Yaakov mentioned in Matthew 1:16 and the Yoseph ben Eli cited in Luke 3:23 (which is the Yoseph who is Miriam’s husband in Matthew 1:19) are two different men with two distinct genealogical lines back to David – yet they both bear a very common Israelite name. A woman marrying a man with the same first name as her father is very common in every culture – this led a careless translator into profound error”.

From : https://restorationdownunder.com/genealogy-and-birth-of-messiah/

I hope this insight is helpful.

Matt 1:1 begins with a statement about the book of the genealogy of Messiah Yahushua. The character called “Messiah”, is first mentioned in Matt 1:16, as part of the genealogy of His only earthly parent, Miriam (Mary).

Mat 1:1 The Book of the genealogy of Yahushua Messiah the Son of David, the son of Abraham. (HRB)

 Mat 1:16 and Jacob fathered Joseph, the father of Mariam, out of whom Yahshua was born, the One called Messiah(HRB)


The next mention of the Messiah, occurs in Matt 2:4, where we are told that king Herod “asked the chief priests & scribes where the Messiah was to be born” ? They answered in verses 4-5, “in Bethlehem of Judea”, quoting the prophesy of Micah 5:2.

Mat 2:4 And having gathered all the chief priests and scribes of the people, he asked of them where the Messiah was to be born.

Mat 2:5 And they said to him, In Bethlehem of Judea, for so it has been written by the prophet,

Mat 2:6 "And you, Bethlehem, in the land of Judea, in no way are you least among the governors of Judah, for out of you shall come out One ruling, who shall shepherd My people Israel." (Mic. 5:2)

Matt 11:2 tells us that John the Baptist heard from his prison cell, about “the works of Messiah”, & that he, John, sent two disciples to ask whether Yahushua was the one coming, to fulfil the prophesy of Isaiah 60:1

Mat 11:2 But hearing in the prison of the works of Messiah, sending two of his disciples,


Then we have in Matt 16:13-16, the scene in which Yahushua asks His disciples of Himself, ”whom do men say the Son of Man to be?” They respond by answering, “some say John the Baptist, & others Elijah, & others Jeremiah, or one of the prophets”. Yahushua then asks Simon Peter the personal question, “whom do you say Me to be?In Matt 16:16, Simon Peter answers saying, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living Elohim”.  

I’m not really sure why, but Yahushua then tells them in Matt 16:20, that they were not to tell anyone that He is the Messiah.

 Mat 16:16 And answering, Simon Peter said, You are the Messiah, the Son of the living Elohim.

 Mat 16:20 Then He warned His disciples that they should tell no one that He is Yahshua the Messiah.

There are 75 verses in the RC that specifically mentions, “the Messiah”. By now, I hope that it is obvious that Yahushua is the Messiah, so :


What did Yahushua the Messiah, believe ?


It is a bit difficult to identify every belief that Messiah Yahushua had, but, based on the RC, here are some of His important beliefs, that we, as Followers of the Messiah, have discovered, & attempt to emulate. I have provided some of the scriptural evidence as support, sometimes just quoting the verse, while at other times, copying the whole or partial verse. They are not written in any specific order.


Because Yahushua was raised in a Jewish family, & lived in a Jewish community, He & His family  were Torah-observant – they obviously believed in the heavenly Father, Yahweh, & they believed in, & kept the “Torah (law) of Yahweh (God)”. There are several verses that support this, including :


Luke 2:39they performed all things according to the law of Yahweh

Luke 2:40 Yahushua grew – He waxed strong in spirit, filled with wisdom – the favor of Yahweh was upon Him.

Luke 2:41-52 In v41 – He & His parents went to Jerusalem every year at the feast of Passover.

Luke 4:15-16 – He went to Synagogue on the Sabbath, & taught there.


Yahushua believed in praying to His heavenly Father – in Matt 11:25, He praised His heavenly Father. Yahushua taught His disciples to pray in      Matt 6:8-13. He often went off to pray alone (Matt 14:23, Mark 6:46 & Luke 6:12)


In Matt 4:1-11, we are told that He was led by the Holy Spirit into the wilderness, where He fasted for 40 days & 40 nights.  When He was tempted by the tempter, Yahushua quoted Deut 8:3, 6:13, Ps 91:11-12, & Deut 6:16, to defend Himself from this spiritual attack. He obviously believed in, & used, the powerful words of Torah.


Yahushua believed that being baptized was important – He was baptized by John the Baptist (Matt 3:13).


There are many times we read of Yahushua healing people who were sick with disease, or who were possessed by demons (Mark 2:1-12,                Luke 5:17-26, John 9:1-7, Matt 8:28-34). He obviously believed in the power of being spiritually & physically, healthy.


Yahushua believed in learning as much as possible about Yahweh & His Word - see Luke 2:49 – Yahushua, as a 12 year old, sat with the doctors of the law, hearing them, & asking them questions (presumably, about His Israelite faith) [Luke 2:46], & in v49.


He believed in giving credit to His heavenly Father. In John 4:19, He says – “the Son does nothing of Himself, but what He see the Father do”; in John 7:16, He tells the Jews & us – “My doctrine is not mine, but His that sent Me”;  in John 12:49, He explains – “For I have not spoken of myself; but the Father which sent me, he gave me a commandment”.


Clearly, Yahushua believed in sharing what He knew, & understood about Yahweh, His Word, His Kingdom, & His Torah, by teaching & preaching these to others (sermon on the mount (Matt 5) & the many parables in Matthew, Mark & Luke).


He believed in making disciples – He called the 12 apostles (Luke 6:12-16),


Yahushua believed that the lost tribes of Israel were among the gentiles, & needed to be taught, & gathered. Matt 10:6 & 15:24).


He believed in educating His followers

~   As an adult, Yahushua certainly understood & believed that the Torah (law) & the Prophets still applied, & needed to be kept (Matt 5:17-19)

~   He also believed in empowering them. In Luke 9:1 & Matt 10:1 & Mark 6:7, Yahushua gave the 12 disciples power, and authority over all devils, and to cure diseases

~ He gave His disciples strategies for evangelism  - in Luke 10:1, Yahushua sends out 70 in pairs, & in v2-12, He gives them specific instructions


Yahushua believed in encouraging His disciples. In Matt 5:14, He tells them, "they are the light of the world", in Luke 12:22, He says to them, “don’t be anxious”, while in Matt 11:30, Yahushua says “come to Me, for rest – My burden is light”.


He believed in warning His disciples & others not to be deceived (Matt 24 & Luke 21:9-19).

 

Yahushua believed in correcting the “theological” errors of the Pharisees, Sadducees, & scribes.

Examples include : Luke 11:37-44 & 11:45-53 (the Pharisaic washing of hands); in Luke 13:14 & 14:1 (criticism for healing on the Sabbath day); in Matt 12:1-8 (for plucking corn on the Sabbath); in Luke 20:2 & Matt 21:23 & Mark 11:27, when they challenged "His authority", & in Matt 15:2-9, & Mark 7:1-13, when they elevated the “tradition of the elders”.

He clearly believed in, & understood the concept of the two Houses of Israel. Yahushua tells His disciples in Matt 15:24, that He "came only for the lost sheep of the House of Israel (the ten northern tribes), while in Matt 10:6, He told His disciples not to go the the cities of the Samaritans, but to go the the lost sheep of the House of Israel.


What did Yahushua the Messiah, do ?


Messiah Yahushua put into action His most important beliefs – they were the things He did. Again, these are based on the RC, & are not meant to be a complete list of His activities.


In Luke 4:1-13, Matt 4:1-11 & Mark 1:12-13, we see that Yahushua was led by the Spirit into the wilderness for 40 days – there He fasted, & was tempted of the devil. Yahushua, believing in, & then used the powerful, words of Torah, (Deut 8:3, 6:13, Ps 91:11-12, & Deut 6:16), to fend off the devil’s spiritual attack.


Yahushua, as was His custom, went to synagogue on the Sabbath (Matt 4:23 & Luke 4:16). There He sometimes read. In Luke 4:16-17, we hear that He read from Isaiah 61:1-2, & in v21, He prophesied saying, “Today this Scripture has been fulfilled in your ears”.  


In Luke 4:33, we read that “the people were astonished at His message” because it was delivered with authority. Matt 7:20 supports this.


According to Luke 5:8-11 & Luke 6:12-16, Yahushua calls those men, especially selected to be His apostles.


Again, as an adult, Yahushua understood, believed, & carefully taught that the Torah & the Prophets still applied, & needed to be kept, explained, & filled with meaning (Matt 5:17-19). Sometimes, He did this by expanding on the written command, as in Matt 5:27-30, where He says , “when a man looks at a woman with lust, he has already committed adultery with her”. At other times, Yahushua simply reminds His audience not to judge another, as we are told about the woman was caught in adultery (John 8:3-11, specifically v7). Still at other times, He simply explained something, such as His last Passover meal, by doing it with His apostles (Matt 26:17-29).


Yahushua ate with “publicans & sinners”, explaining to the critical scribes & Pharisees in Luke 6:31-32, that the “sick need a physician, & that He called sinners, not the righteous”.


In Luke 6:1-5 & 6-11 respectively, Yahushua was criticized by some Pharisees & scribes, for breaking the “traditions of the elders”, their “oral law”, by plucking corn & eating it on the Sabbath, & then healing a man’s withered hand on the Sabbath. Yahushua corrected them, here & in Matt 15:9 & Mark 7:8, for elevating their “traditions” above Yahweh’s Word.


Yahushua, at different times, heals people with unclean spirits (Luke 6:18-19 & Mark 5:13), & gives His apostles authority & power over devils         (Matt 10:1, Mark 6:7 & Luke 9:1). At the same time, this power & authority was extended to the apostles to cure diseases.


There were numerous times when Yahushua healed individuals. Those who were healed included people who were “lunatic” (Matt 4:24), those with the “palsey” (Matt 4:24), those who were either "blind or dumb" (Matt 12:22), those who were lame (Matt 21:14), many with “divers diseases”       (Mark 1:34), & a woman who had blood issues for 12 years (Mark 5:29).


Yahushua taught in synagogues (Mark 1:21), on a mountain (Matt 5:1), in the Temple (Mark 12:35), from a ship (Luke 5:3), & by the seaside       (Mark 2:3).


He often taught the ordinary people with many parables, including, the parable of the sower (Matt 13:1-9), the parable of the good Samaritan       (Luke 10:25-37), the parable of the lost sheep (Matt 18:10-14), the parable of the ten talents (Luke 19:11-27), & the parable of the ten virgins       (Matt 25:1-13). He also taught several times about the kingdom of Yahweh (Matt 6:33, 19:24, Mark 4;26, 9:47, Luke 6:20, 8:10).


Yahushua taught His disciples on several specific subjects including, serious warnings such as, “beware of the leaven of the Pharisees” (Mark 8:15), “take heed that no man deceive you” (Matt 24:4), beware of false prophets” (Matt 7:15). He taught them that “Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven”, (expanding it in Matt 7:21-23). From Him they learned “I am the bread of life” (John 6:35), & “I am the way, the Truth, & the Life” (John 14:6)


Several times, Yahushua explains His connection with His heavenly Father including, “the Son does nothing of Himself, but what He see the Father do” (John 4:19), search the scriptures – they are they that testify of me” (John 4:39), Had you believed Moses, you would have believed me” (John 4:46), “no man can come to Me unless the Father draw him” (John 6:65), & “My doctrine is not mine, but His that sent Me (John 7:17).


Yahushua kept those parts of the Torah that applied to Himself. Clearly, He could not keep it all, because some of it was for the high priest, some for the Levitical priests, some for women, some for farmers, & some for everyone.

Examples include :

His family performed all things according to the Torah of Yahweh (Lev 2:39)

His family went to Jerusalem every year at the feast of Passover (Luke 2:40). He went to Jerusalem for Passover (John 2:23)

His family kept Yahweh’s moedim (feasts) as indicated in Lev 23  (Luke 2:41-52)

Yahushua went to synagogue on the Sabbath (Luke 4:16 & 5:6-11)

He went to Jerusalem for the feast of Tabernacles (John 7:1-6, 10)

He was circumcised on the 8th day (Luke 2:21-24).

He wore fringes on his garments (Luke 8:44), in accordance with Num 15:38 & Deut 22:12.

In Luke 17:14, He told the ten lepers who were cleansed to show themselves to the priests, as was required by Lev 13:2.

In John 5:46-47, He taught about the teachings of Moses.

It is important to note that most of the above are not, part of the Ten Commandments of Exod 20.


Following the Messiah

In the RC, there are 18 verses where Messiah Yahushua said to His apostles & disciples, “follow Me”. When He said this, He meant that they, & us, are to believe what He believed, & do what He did (as much as possible). We, at Followers of the Messiah, attempt to do both these things, to the best of our ability. Again, I have provided a list of Messiah Yahushua’s beliefs & actions above.

In following Messiah Yahushua, He told His apostles & disciples, & us, the following :

I will make you fishers of men” (Matt 4:19)

If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross” (Matt 16:24)

My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow Me (John 10:27)

 “If any man serve me, let him follow Me (John 12:26)

"Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit: 

 Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you" (Matt 28:19-20)


Followers of the Messiah Disclaimer

Although I have a university degree (BA), & have been a teacher of high school students for 42 years, I am not a trained biblical teacher. I have no degree or qualification from any biblical college or university.

What I am is a student of the heavenly Father, (Yahweh), & of His Word, the Bible. What I know & understand about Yahweh & His son, Messiah Yahushua (Jesus), I believe I have been shown by Yahweh through others, & by learning & practising skills that I have acquired. Because I am a student, I know that I don’t know everything – not even close - I believe I have only just begun to “scratch the surface”, so to speak. Because of my past experience, what I currently believe & understand, in many cases, is anything but “absolute” Truth. As I continue to study, I find new “nuggets” about Yahweh & His Word, on a regular basis – I guess He knows that I can’t take it all in at once.

Because we are so far removed from the original languages, & the culture of the original audiences, I believe, we are all, “New” to Yahweh’s word. I don’t believe that anyone is “old” to it.

I therefore, reserve the right to be wrong about anything that I have written or spoken in any of my studies. It is my intention to continue to study & learn, & be open to receive more & more from Yahweh’s Ruach, (Holy Spirit) until I die.

It is my desire to empower & be of assistance to all who visit our website. If you have an questions, or require more information, or help, please contact Pete at askseekknockandtest@gmail.com

I have also discovered that sometimes, others do not agree with some of what I have written. In Challenge Question 1 below, if you are unable to agree with our response to it, there may be no point in continuing with the Challenge Questions, because those answers are based on that response to that first question. I do however, encourage you to read the following very important information, with a focus on point 2.


Very Important


Before you read any of the information provided on Followers of the Messiah website, we ask, & encourage you to apply the five principles :


Firstly, pray to only receive the Creator's (Yahweh's) Truth, and to not be deceived by any false information.


Secondly, I challenge our readers to choose to have an open, teachable mind.

To do this, I ask them to mentally put on the table near them, any ideas they may have about the topic covered. By doing this, they are allowing the ideas presented, to come into their mind for consideration. There is an old saying “If you love something, set it free. If it comes back, it’s yours; if not, it never was”. So if at the end of this topic, individuals decide that none of it is worthwhile, they can take back all of their previous ideas and continue their life as it was. If they decide that some or all of what is presented is useful and helpful to them, they can take those ideas into their belief system and use them to develop their belief system further. This is what having “an open, teachable mind” means !


Thirdly, please do not believe what we have presented, but check & TEST the Scriptures as Paul tells us in 1 Thes 5:21.

Paul also tells us in 1 Cor 4:6 not to think above what is written (in the Tanach). Acts 17:11 describes what the Bereans did when Paul taught them – they checked (searched) the Scriptures (the Tanach) daily, to see if what he said was correct.


Fourthly, remember that we are studying to show ourselves approved to Yahweh.

(2Tim 2:15)


Fifthly, please understand that I are not here to convince you of anything. That is Yahweh's job.

I am simply explaining to you what I have found, & what I have been shown. The fact that you are reading this study is good evidence that you are seeking Yahweh’s Truth, that you are a sincere person, and that you are wanting to do His will. You certainly have the intelligence to decide things for yourself.


If, at any time, you may believe that what I have written is an error or mistake, please, please show me from Scripture that error or mistake, as I never ever, want to lead others astray.

Followers of the Messiah - Introduction to my Bible Study Principles

Although I’ve been around this walk since 2003 - I have been a devout, diligent Follower of the Messiah since 2006.

During that time, I’ve made several serious mistakes about what I had believed, & learned.

Over time, I realised that I had done this because :

1:   I did not know the Scriptures - I did not know how to study them well enough, &

2:   I did not know the power of Yahweh   (Mark 12:24)

From these mistakes, I learned that if I haven't studied Yahweh's Word, His Scriptures, for myself, then I had no opinion !

As well, I came to understand that even if I have studied a matter carefully before, if someone presents information that contradicts or challenges what I currently believe is true, re-examining it, will either strengthen that belief, or expose an error I may have made.

I choose not to take offence when someone disagrees with what I have discovered.

Over the years, I became aware of some beliefs about which I had been deceived, but, when I was being deceived, I was totally unaware of the deception.

Once I realised that I had been deceived, the deception was obvious, & I decided that :

1: I do not want to disbelieve the Truth.

2: I certainly do not want to believe a lie.

3: I must know precisely what I believe, and more importantly, why I believe it,

4: I must be very careful what I really believe, because, it will totally control the way I think, and what I do.

5: I must be careful not to be deceived because I have found that it is easy to produce a very convincing study, that is partially or totally wrongI must be very aware of the unsubstantiated statements that people make !

I also came to appreciate that the only real drawback to finding Yahweh’s Truth, is to believe that I already have it !

Q: That led me to the question – how do I really, really know, that what I have believed, have been taught, have viewed, have read, or have heard, is accurate, true & correct ?

A: I have discovered that there is only one answer, namely,  consider ALL the EVIDENCE !


May I explain the strategy that I usually follow when analyzing Scriptures, videos, studies or teachings ?

I like to pray to Yahweh, & ask that He guides me in finding only HIS TRUTH, & to reject anything that is not of Him. 

My goal is to always do Yahweh’s will, His way !

I decide to have an open, teachable mind. In doing this, I choose to put my previous ideas aside,  & start with a blank page. This allows me to receive, & examine what a teacher or author is presenting and/or offering.  After all, what if I am wrong about what I currently understand & believe !

Followers of the Messiah - Lesson One

Yahweh (God) has already given us all we need to do His will !

The first part of this lesson is INTRODUCTION. Please read it very carefully.

I believe that many people have been taught that you need to be extremely intelligent, or university trained, to study Yahweh's Word. I most strongly disagree.

As a teacher, I discovered three very important ideas :

A: Any activity is a SKILL

B: Every skill can be LEARNED, & 

C: Someone knows a great way to do EVERYTHING.


Are you aware that there are four stages of Learning anything ?

Stage 1: I don't know, that I don't know something

Stage 2: If someone explains about something that I didn't know, then, I now know that I don't know it

Stage 3: If I follow the steps necessary to learn something, I CAN LEARN HOW to DO IT, & then, DO IT

Stage 4: If I practise, practise these steps, after a while, not only can I perform it, the skill becomes automatic, & then requires very little effort.

I hope you understand these steps, & APPLY them to learning any Bible Study strategy. Most of us get stuck in Stage 3, & that is where we give up our Learning.


I wonder if you can agree that :

Yahweh’s Word, the Bible [the Tanach (OT) & the Renewed Covenant Scriptures (NT)] is the inspired (influenced), inerrant, unchanging, revealed and written Word of Elohim (God).

The Bible was NOT originally written TO me – Genesis, for example,  was originally written TO and FOR the Hebrews (by Moses), who were freed from their bondage in Egypt, by Yahweh. It was written FOR you and me – after all, we were not there !

The Bible therefore, is only "inspired" in its original languages, & in the original context, and therefore, there is no such thing, as an "inspired translation".

In those original languages, & the original context, Yahweh’s Word

   says what it says;

      not what I think it says,

          not what I believe it says,

             not what I’d like it to say,

                not what others say it says,

 and not necessarily what I’ve been taught that it says.

If you are unconvinced that the Bible is Yahweh's inspired Word, please watch Chuck Missler's video, "Chuck Missler What is Truth (Session 2)" @   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mI77pIarER4

Again, this video series is very worthwhile, but if you fast-forward it to the 53.30 minute mark, you can view Chuck's explanation for evidence of why the Bible is Yahweh's inspired Word. 

I believe that our current generation is so blessed, because,  we have more access to Yahweh’s Written Word, in many, many translations, & with numerous dictionaries, lexicons & concordances, than any previous generation in history.


WHY  SHOULD   WE  STUDY  YAHWEH’S  W O R D

 In 2 Tim 3:16-17, Paul explains the purpose of Scripture

 2Ti 3:16 All Scripture is written by inspiration of the Holy Spirit and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness,

2Ti 3:17 so that the man of YAHWEH may be perfected, and complete for every good work.


An Extremely Important Question

I am sure that you have heard, read or viewed teachings that seem to be very convincing ! In these teachings, the speaker or author usually makes statements that appear to be so persuasive that you want to agree with what is being said or written.

SO, how do we really know, that what we have being taught, or what we have believed, or what we have read, heard, or viewed, is TRUE, ACCURATE, and CORRECT ?

Let me ask it again, another way ?

How can we really KNOW whether a statement, a scripture verse interpretation, or even a version of a scripture verse itself, is true, accurate and/or correct ?

Isn’t it so, that the only way we can really KNOW whether a statement, a scripture verse interpretation, or even a version of a scripture verse is true, accurate and/or correct, is to TEST it in some way ?

Does Scripture tell us anything about this ?

1 Thes 5:21(a) tells us to "prove (TEST) ALL things" !

In order to TEST what we have read, heard, viewed and have been taught & believed about Yahweh’s Word, shouldn’t we do what the Bereans did as described in Acts 17:11 ?

Act 17:11 And these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, for they received the Word with all readiness, daily examining the Scriptures if these things are so.

2 Tim 2:15 encourages us to study Yahweh’s Word.

2Ti 2:15 And study to present yourself approved to YAHWEH, a workman unashamed, rightly dividing the Word of Truth.

In order to study Yahweh’s Word, it is important to again realise that, ALL versions of the Bible are translations, & therefore, have biases & errors.

Strategy 1

Let’s begin with the very first verse in the Bible, Genesis 1:1. 

What TEST could you apply in order to understand what this verse is really telling us ? 

I’ll use this example to show a most basic method of studying Yahweh’s Word – Strategy 1. The KJV and many other translations of Gen 1:1, read as follows :

Gen 1:1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth

If we read this verse carefully, it seems clear that there are several ideas being expressed, namely “the beginning”, “God”, “created”, “the heaven” and “the earth”.

In order for us to understand what each of these ideas is, don’t we need to know what each one means ?

Isn’t it true, that if we apply our 21st century understanding of each of these English terms, we can obtain an understanding of Genesis 1:1 ? An important question however might be, is our 21st century understanding of this verse the meaning meant by the original author of the book of Genesis ?

I believe that in order to gain a greater, & more clear understanding of verses such as Genesis 1:1, it is useful to apply a most basic method of study, Strategy 1, by asking as many questions as you can think of, & then attempt to find answers to them. I suggest that initially, you don’t get too technical with your questions.

What are some questions that we could ask about Genesis 1:1 ?

Here are the questions that I asked, & answered for Strategy 1 :

Q: When was “the beginning” ?

A: Was it the moment just before anything existed or was  created ?

Q: What does “created” mean ?

A: Looking at other verses in Genesis 1, it appears to be different from the word translated as “made”. “created” could mean “made from nothing”.

Q: Who is “God” ?

A: Based on the verse alone, is appears that “God” is the creator of the heaven & the earth.

Q: What are “the heavens” ?

A: Again, based on the verse alone, “the heavens” appears to be something or some places different to “the earth”. Based on what we believe we know, “the heavens” could mean the sky and/or the space above.

Q: What is “the earth” ?

A: The term translated as “the earth” appears to refer to the place where all living things live.

So, based on our questions & answers, one possible understanding of Genesis 1:1 might be :

In the beginning (the moment before anything existed), God (the creator), created (made out of nothing), the heaven       (the sky or space above the earth) and the earth (the place where all living things live).

Exercise

Apply Strategy 1 to one of the following verses, or choose a verse for yourself :

Genesis 6:9

Exodus 20:8

John 4:6


Followers of the Messiah - Strategy 2

I love, & really enjoy studying Yahweh’s Word because :

A: Yahweh’s Word is alive – it’s powerful. It is filled with wisdom, & instruction, & stories about how amazing Yahweh is.

B: Yahweh’s Word explains in great detail that Yahweh is awesome, powerful, loving & merciful. It tells us amazing details about what He did (Noah’s flood, the plaques of Egypt, crossing the Red Sea, the giving of Torah at Mt Sinai, to name but a few).


Suppose someone came to you, & claimed that the Third Commandment has been mistranslated. What TEST could you apply in order to check this claim ? I’ll use this example to show Strategy 2 of studying Yahweh’s Word.

Many people use the King James version of the Bible (KJV), so let’s begin by quoting the verse that tells us about the Third Commandment,                    Exodus 20:7 using the KJV.

Exod 20:7 Thou shalt not take the name of the LORD thy God in vain; for the LORD will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain. (KJV)

How can we know whether this translation of Exodus 20:7 is accurate, true and/or correct ?

One simple way is to use Strategy 2 by comparing it with how others have translated it. Let’s do that, & see if this basic method sheds any more light on the person’s claim.

We will use the Hebrew Roots Bible (HRB), the Complete Jewish Bible (CJB), the Scripture Bible (SB), & the Lexham English Bible (LEB) here, but you could use any other versions if you wish.

I’ll begin with the KJV as we can compare all five translations.

(KJV) Thou shalt not take the name of the LORD thy God in vain; for the LORD will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain.

(HRB) You shall not take the name of YAHWEH your Elohim in vain; for YAHWEH will not leave unpunished the one who takes His name in vain.

(CJB) "You are not to use lightly the name of Adonai your God, because Adonai will not leave unpunished someone who uses his name lightly.

(The Scriptures 1998+) “You do not bring the Name of Yahweh your Elohim to naught, for Yahweh does not leave the one unpunished who brings His Name to naught.

(LEB)  “You shall not misuse the name of Yahweh your God, [Literally “take up/bear/carry the name of Yahweh your God for what is worthless/false/empty”] because Yahweh will not leave unpunished anyone who misuses his name. [Literally “bears his name for what is false”]

I have colour-coded each phrase so that they can be more easily compared.

(KJV) Thou shalt not take the name of the LORD thy God in vain; for the LORD will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain.

(HRB) You shall not take the name of YAHWEH your Elohim in vain; for YAHWEH will not leave unpunished the one who takes His name in vain.

(CJB) "You are not to use lightly the name of Adonai your Godbecause Adonai will not leave unpunished someone who uses his name lightly.

(The Scriptures 1998+) You do not bring the Name of Yahweh your Elohim to naughtfor Yahweh does not leave the one unpunished who brings His Name to naught.

(LEB)  “You shall not misuse the name of Yahweh your God, [Literally “take up/bear/carry the name of Yahweh your God for what is worthless/false/empty”] because Yahweh will not leave unpunished anyone who misuses his name. [Literally “bears his name for what is false”]

I am sure that you noticed that each phrase is either quite different, or slightly different.

Q: As a side issue, why are there variations in the translation of some of the words and phrases, in different English versions ?

A: I believe that there could be two main reasons for this. Firstly, it can be based on the denominational mind-set of those who translated their version, and/or secondly, in some cases, the translators MAY NOT really know what the meaning of the original word or phrase was.

Back to Strategy 2 - If we compare each phrase, & use the collective “wisdom” of these comparisons, perhaps we can determine what this verse is really telling us.

The first phrase in each version seems to carry the same idea of “you shall not”, so it would be reasonable to assume that the translation of this phrase is accurate.

The other phrases in each version however, seems to vary slightly, so perhaps we can incorporate the different ideas to help our understanding of this verse.

Exod 20:7 might be read as follows : 

You shall not take the name of Yahweh (Adonai, Lord), your Elohim (God) in vain, misuse it, or use it lightly, or bring it to naught. Yahweh (Lord), your Elohim (God) will not hold him guiltless, nor leave unpunished, anyone who takes the name of Yahweh (Adonia, Lord), your Elohim (God) in vain, nor misuses it, nor uses it lightly, nor brings it to naught.

While this gives us a good idea of how people translate this verse, isn’t it true that it doesn’t really tell us what each different phrase means ?

One strategy to help us figure out what a phrase may mean is to find other places in Scripture where that term is translated. We can do this by checking the Subject Concordance that most Study Bibles have.

Let’s use this strategy to locate some verses where the phrase translated as “in vain” occurs. I located Lev 26:16, 1 Sam 25;21, Job 9:29 &              Psalm 127:1, & have copied them below.

Lev 26:16 I will also do this to you, and I shall appoint terror over you, the wasting, and the burning fever, destroying the eyes, and consuming the soul; and you shall sow your seed in vain, and your enemies will eat it.

1Sa 25:21 And David had said, Surely, in vain I have guarded all that belongs to this fellow in the wilderness, so that not anything was missed of all that was his. And he has returned to me evil for good.

Job 9:29 I have been condemned; why should I labor in vain?

Psa 127:1 [A Song of Ascents, for Solomon.] If YAHWEH does not build the house, they who build it labor in vain; if YAHWEH does not keep the city, the one keeping it stays awake in vain.

If we read each of the above verses carefully, the term "in vain" seems to mean “without success”, or “without purpose”, or “to no vail

To test whether any of these meanings may be appropriate, we can insert them into our original text, & see if it adds any clarity. Let’s do this with the KJV of Exod 20:7

(KJV) Thou shalt not take the name of the LORD thy God in vain (without success or purpose, or to no avail); for the LORD will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain (without success or purpose, or to no avail).

Would you agree that each probably adds some clarity ?

Let’s check some other verses where the idea of bringing something “to naught” is used.

Neh 4:15 And it came to be, when our enemies heard that it was known to us, and that Elohim had brought their counsel to naught, that all of us returned to the wall, everyone to his work.

Psa 1:6 For Yahweh knows the way of the righteous, But the way of the wrong comes to naught.

Isa 8:10 “Take counsel, and it comes to naught; speak a word, and it does not stand, for Ěl is with us.”

2Cor 10:10 Because they say, “His letters are truly weighty and strong, but his bodily presence is weak, and his speech amounts to naught.”

The plain reading of each of these verses seems to indicate a meaning of, “to nothing”.

Again, if we insert this meaning, “to nothing”, back into the original text, we get :

Thou shalt not bring the name of the LORD thy God in vain (to nothing); for the LORD will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain (to nothing).

 It probably adds some clarity but I'm not sure it adds a significant understanding to the previous meanings.

If we compare the terms LORD our God, Yahweh or Yahweh our Elohim, & Adonai your God, we can see that they are similar, & so in terms of clarity, any of them could be used.

The next phrase in Exod 20:7 has been translated as “for  the LORD our God, Yahweh or Yahweh our Elohim, & Adonai your God will not leave you unpunished or guiltless”. This phrase seems to be accurate.

If we examine the LEB version of Exod 20:7, we notice that it has added a couple of phrases to explain its translation.

(LEB)  You shall not misuse the name of Yahweh your God, [Literally “take up/bear/carry the name of Yahweh your God for what is worthless/false/empty”] because Yahweh will not leave unpunished anyone who misuses his name. [Literally “bears his name for what is false”]

While this is helpful, again, how can we know that the LEB translation is correct & accurate ?

So putting all this together, we can come up with the following understanding of Exod 20:7 :

You shall not take the name of Yahweh (Adonai, LORD), your Elohim (Godin vain, by misusing it, or using it lightly, or bringing it to naught. Yahweh (Adonai, LORD), your Elohim (Godwill not hold him guiltless, nor leave unpunished, anyone who takes the name of Yahweh (Adonia, LORD), your Elohim (Godin vain, by misusing it, nor using it lightly, nor bringing it to naught.

Even though this expands our understanding a little, is it a correct & accurate translation of Exod 20:7 ?

Exercise

Use Strategy 2, comparing how different versions translate a verse, to find out how to better understand Matt 5:17.

Followers of the Messiah - Strategy 3

Before we continue our investigation, again, I would like to make some comments on how very blessed we are in this time in history, in terms of Yahweh’s Word.

I believe that our generation has far more access to different versions of the Bible that any other group in history. Because of technology, we can easily examine the meaning of the original Hebrew or Greek words, & so can have improved understanding of Yahweh’s Word.

Let’s give praise & thanks to Yahweh for this wonderful blessing, & let’s decide to use it as well as we can !


Another strategy that we can & should use, Strategy 3, involves what is called checking the CONTEXT of a word, verse or chapter. It is very important to discover the “correct context” that an author may have intended, if we are going to understand Yahweh’s Word.

I encourage you to use the following information & questions to establish the "correct context" of a word, a scripture verse or chapter. As well as reading verses before and after the verse we are studying, we can further define the CONTEXT of a word or verse, by answering the following questions as they relate to the verse or chapter.

Who wrote this book ? When was it written ?

Who was the original audience - who was it originally written to ?

Why was it written ?

What was their culture ?  What was their legal system ?

What was their religious background ?

What Hebrew idioms did they use ?

What did they already know about the subject ?

What future group does it affect, & how will they be affected ?

Let’s apply Strategy 3 to Exod 20:7 to see if we can find out more. - remember, these are "my" answers; yours may vary.

Q: Who wrote the Book of Exodus ?

A: It is generally agreed that Moses wrote the first five books of the Bible, including the Book of Exodus.

Q: When did Moses write the Book of Exodus ?

A: It seems likely that Moses wrote the Book of Exodus sometime after Yahweh spoke to Israel at Mt Sinai.

Q: Who was the original audience - who was the Book of Exodus originally written to ?

A: The original audience was the Israelites who had been freed from their slavery by Yahweh.

Q: Why did Moses write the Book of Exodus to the Israelites ?

A: The Book of Exodus was written to the now freed Israelites who, as a result of their assimilation into Egypt, had forgotten who Yahweh really was, and what He required of them – they needed to be re-educated about Yahweh’s kingdom.     

Most of them had lost their identity, their land, their language, their independence, & their rituals. Yahweh wanted to build His kingdom - one based on a different foundation to the Egyptian one, these now free Israelites had experienced for a long time.

Q: What was their culture  ?

A: Because of their assimilation into Egypt, the Israelites knew all about the Egyptian culture, history, mythology, religion & cosmology. They understood & believed the same as the Egyptians did – they had a Egyptian world-view.

Q: What was their legal system ?

A: While in Egypt, the Israelites lived in a legal system where the Pharaoh was a god – everything he said was law. The Pharaoh also had conquered other nations, & these lesser nations were often vassal states of Egypt. There was what is known as a suzerainty-vassal treaty or covenant, where the greater king would promise his protection, in exchange for the weaker nation paying taxes, & for their loyalty.

In Exodus 19:5-6, Yahweh offers a suzerainty type covenant to Israel. He promises to be their Elohim, (God) if they listen to His voice, & keep His covenant. There are conditions for being in this covenant with Yahweh, which are written in Exodus 20 to 23.

Again, this covenant is between the great king (Yahweh), & the weaker party (Israel). When Israel accepted Yahweh’s covenant proposal, (Exod 19:8 & Exod 24:3 & 7), they understood that it had legal conditions attached to it, & there were blessings for keeping it, & serious curses for breaking it.

Q: What religious background did the Israelites have ?

A: When they first came to Egypt about 400 years before their Exodus out of Egypt, the Israelites had a belief in Yahweh, their one & only Elohim. Because the Israelites had been slaves in Egypt for probably 150 to 200 years, they probably had assimilated with Egypt, & almost certainly, they had adopted their religious practices. This would include the Egyptian’s many gods, & their various Egyptian pagan rituals, such as worshipping images of those gods, such as a calf.

Q: What Hebrew idioms did the Israelites use ?

A: Let’s review a couple of English idioms so that we get the idea of their use.

When someone says, “I’ll give you a penny for your thoughts”, they are really asking “what are you really thinking ?”

When someone says, “please don’t beat around the bush”, they are really saying, “please stop avoiding the subject”.

There are many Hebrew idioms used in the Bible. Again, these are phrases that were used by the original author that don’t make sense literally, but were clearly understood by his original audience. 

Example      In Gen 9:13, Yahweh says “He have set His bow in the cloud”.

Gen 9:13 I have set My bow in the cloud, and it shall be a sign of a covenant between Me and the earth.

A “bow in the cloud” is a Hebrew idiom for a “RAINBOW”.

Example    In Gen 14:22, Abram says “I have lifted up my hand to Yahweh”.

Gen 14:22 And Abram said to the king of Sodom, I have lifted up my hand to Yahweh, the most high El, the possessor of Heaven and earth (HRB)

I have lifted up my hand to Yahweh” is a Hebrew idiom meaning “I have taken a solemn oath”.

Q: What did the original Israelites already know about a subject ?

A: To demonstrate this, let’s look again, at  Exod 20:7.

You shall not take the name of YAHWEH your Elohim in vain; for YAHWEH will not leave unpunished the one who takes His name in vain.

Have you ever noticed that this is simply a statement that is made only once, with absolutely no explanation ?

What does this imply ?

It implies that the original audience clearly understood who Yahweh was, that He was their Elohim, their “mighty one’, & that Yahweh would punish them if they brought His name to naught.

If you take notice, you will see that there are many, many times in Yahweh’s Word, when statements are made, just once, indicating a clear understanding of what is written !

On the other hand

If we consider verses such as Exod 20:9-10, where Yahweh instructs the Israelites that they are to work for six days, & rest on the 7th day, we notice that this is repeated several times – see Exod 23:12, 31:15, 34:21 & 35:2. I'll provide Exod 23:12, & allow you to check the others.

Exo 20:9  Six days shalt thou labour, and do all thy work: 

Exo 20:10  But the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates: 

Exo 23:12  Six days thou shalt do thy work, and on the seventh day thou shalt rest: that thine ox and thine ass may rest, and the son of thy handmaid, and the stranger, may be refreshed. 

Why would Yahweh repeat certain instructions ?

I believe it is because, as slaves in Egypt, they worked everyday, & so had no concept of having a day off to worship an Elohim like Yahweh, on His 7th day Sabbath - they needed to be reminded a few times.

Q: Why is knowing what Yahweh’s Word is saying in its original language, to an original audience, important ?

A: Yahweh’s Word was written TO an original audience, not to us. While it was written FOR us, if we are to understand it, & interpret it correctly, we must know what it meant to its original audience.

Because Yahweh’s Word was written TO an original audience, if we are going to correctly interpret what He is telling us in His written word, don’t we need to find out as much as we can about what that original audience knew & understood about that written word ?

Q:  What future group does a biblical topic affect, & how will they be affected ?

A: Again, Yahweh’s Word was written at first, TO an original audience. However, it was written FOR those who lived after that original audience died.

Sometimes, Yahweh tells us specifically in His Word, that an instruction or principle, is also for those who follow the original audience, such as in Exod 31:16.

Exo 31:16 Wherefore the children of Israel shall keep the sabbath, to observe the sabbath throughout their generations, for a perpetual covenant.

For our generation, because we are so far removed from the original audience, & the original languages in which Yahweh’s Word was originally written, it is often difficult for us to really know what His Word is telling us.

For most of us, all we have are different versions, that are all translations. Without going into all the details, all translations are problematic !

So if we are to really understand what Yahweh’s Word is telling us, & requiring of us, isn’t it important that we take the time to learn as much as we can, about those original audiences, & what they knew & understood by what was originally written ?

 Strategy 4 A very simple & extremely useful Bible Study Strategy is to LISTEN to the Chapter as you READ it.

If you have e-Sword, click the Concordance Tab, & click the KJV Audio, as shown below.

Another source of an audio Bible is @      https://www.biblestudytools.com/audio-bible/kjv/

Exercise

Use Strategy 3 to carefully examine 2 Tim 3:16. Here are the questions again.

Who wrote this book ? When was it written ?

Who was the original audience - who was it originally written to ?

Why was it written ?

What was their culture ?  What was their legal system ?

What was their religious background ?

What Hebrew idioms did they use ?

What did they already know about the subject ?

What future group does it affect, & how will they be affected ?


NB - Please note that Lessons 4 to 6, are at a more advanced level ? If you decide to continue, may I please ask you to work very slowly through the next lessons, so that you can learn, & master the advanced skills presented.



Followers of the Messiah - Bible Study Tools

There are several very good tools that can be used to study Yahweh’s Word. Each has a purpose that may be different from other tools. You will need a PC computer to best use these Bible Study Tools.

The following information on several Bible Study Tools is just an introduction, & is not meant to be a detailed presentation.

The first part of this lesson is meant to be an overview to each Bible tool - more details will be provided in a later lesson

A:  Free Download of E-Sword bible software. You can download this great free bible software version at :

    http://www.e-sword.net/

Unfortunately, the graphics shown may not be very clear - please refer to your "downloaded" version for specific details.

Once you have downloaded E-Sword to your computer, & opened it, you will find the following main screen :

B:  Biblehub.com      Please use the website if possible, as the screen-shots may be too small to read

    http://www.biblehub.com/

As an example, I have provided one window showing some information on Exod 20:7.


BibleHub.com is an excellent online Bible software with many very helpful features.

In the next slide, I have included Biblehub’s Hebrew-English Interlinear page for Exod 20:7.

I will now demonstrate how to study just one Hebrew word from this verse. Here is an enlarged view of the Hebrew word, translated as “in vain” in this translation. Please note that, Hebrew reads right to left.

If you click on the number, 7723, called a Strong’s Number, the following window opens :

Please examine the information in the above slide – while there is a lot to consider, I encourage you to begin by reading the details below “Strong’s Concordance”, & the “NAS Exhaustive Concordance”. As you learn more, the other details will become more understandable & useful.

More details of this word, H7723, can be found at Brown-Driver-Briggs, by clicking BDB - details are shown below :


C:  Blue Letter Bible      This Bible software can be accessed at :

                                 http://www.blueletterbible.org/

If you type in Exod 20:7 in the SEARCH THE BIBLE box, the following window opens :

If you click the TOOLS tab on the LHS, the following window opens :

If you click the INTERLINEAR Tab, the following window opens :

If you click on Strong’s Number, H7723, the following window opens, & as you can see, it provides a great deal of information that can be used to study this Hebrew word - please examine it carefully. Because it is a large window, I have copied it in two sections.

D:  Scripture4all.org             can be accessed at        

  http://www.scripture4all.org/

If you Click Hebrew Interlinear (towards the bottom on the LHS), it takes you to a PDF document of the verse you want to look at. The web address is :

http://www.scripture4all.org/OnlineInterlinear/Hebrew_Index.htm

The following window opens :

If you click Exod 20, and it will take you to a PDF document – scroll down to verse 7, where the following window opens. In this document it is a little difficult to read, but online, it is much more clear.

I hope this Introduction to the above very useful Bible software programs was helpful.

Before we continue our lesson, I’d like to show you how to get much more from your basic e-Sword package. When you first download e-Sword, I believe you get the KJV & the KJV+ versions of the Bible. The KJV version is the plain King James translation, while the KJV+ is the King James version with Strong Numbers included. I will show you the difference below :

If you click on Strong’s Number H7723, the following screen-shot shows what happens :

Please notice that we are given several pieces of information :

  A:     Strong's Number is   H7723

  B:     The Hebrew letters that form the ROOT      שָוְא

  C:   The Hebrew word formed by those letters can be pronounced as  shav

  D:  שָוְא transliterated into English, can be pronounced  shav

  E:  Strong's explanation of what he believes this “root” Hebrew word means, AND a list of the words that are TRANSLATED from this Hebrew word. Let's examine this more closely.

STRONG’S

From the same as H7722 in the sense of desolating; evil (as in destructive), literally (ruin) or morally (especially guile); figuratively idolatry (as false, subjectively), uselessness (as deceptive, objectively; also adverbially in vain): - false (-ly), lie, lying, vain, vanity.

My understanding is that ONLY the words in italics indicate the possible literal meanings of the ROOT of this word. All the other information has been added by Strong to help clarify its meaning.

The words provided AFTER the colon [:-] are the different ways that the King James Bible translates this Hebrew word (they are not necessarily the correct meaning in every case).

While the KJV+ translation of the Bible, with its Strong Numbers is useful, it should be noted that, it is very limited in its accuracy, because it only provides possible meanings for the ROOT words, which do not always appear in the original Hebrew language of the various manuscripts. The following information gives an idea - sorry it isn't clearer.

Important

To study Yahweh’s Word at a deeper level by examining the actual Hebrew words written in the original manuscripts, it is important to download the Hebrew-English Interlinear into their e-Sword program. You can access this module and many others at :       http://www.biblesupport.com

To access hundreds of free downloads, you will need to create an account (for free), & sign in.

Once you have signed in, click the Downloads tab at the top on the LHS, and scroll down to Top 500 e-Sword Downloads. The following window will open.

Click e-Sword Module Installer 0.5 Updated. This file will be needed to download for use in e-Sword, every module in this section. Click the green Download button, & follow the instructions provided.

If you return to the Top 500 e-Sword Downloads window, you will find the following :

Click Hebrew Study Bible (Interlinear Hebrew Old Testament with Strong’s numbers and Transliteration). Click the green Download button, & install this module.

You can also download many modules WITHIN e-Sword. Click the Download Tab as shown.

Click the Download Tab at the top – the following window will open.

Let’s say you want to download the JUB Bible. Click it and the file will be added at the File section at the very bottom of the slide.

Click the jub.bblx row at the very bottom in the File section. Go up the top to the Download Tab, & click Start. The download will begin. The next time you open e-Sword, any new downloaded versions will be included.

You can use this procedure to download any commentaries, dictionaries, etc, into your own personal version of e-Sword.

Here is the website of a tutorial –

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JzcamKCJNqg


                                       If you need assistance with this, please email me – I would be happy to help.

                                                                          askseekknockandtest@gmail.com



Followers of the Messiah - How to use Biblical Study Tools

Remember, no translation can be considered totally reliable.

When you really want to know what the passage says, I believe that you’ll have to do a lot of comparison shopping.

Let me explain, by examining the possible meaning of a single Hebrew word in a verse using at least two biblical dictionaries or lexicons.

Let’s check the idea that, there may have been a mistranslation in Exod 20:7, by examining just one Hebrew word, לשׁוא, l’shav, H7723.

For this step, I’ll demonstrate how to use e-Sword, & Biblehub.com, however, we could use any of the biblical tools shown in Lesson 4.

I'll begin by using e-Sword

Open the e-Sword software – again, a window like the one below will appear.


Click the B tab on the top line to maximise the Bible version that is displayed. Since I have the KJV+ version checked, that translation will appear as shown below.

To load the Hebrew-English Interlinear version, click the Interlinear Button, & it will load as shown below. Hebrew reads "right to Left".

Click on Exodus in the first column, then scroll down to chapter 20 in the 2nd column, & then verse 7 in the 3rd column – it will look like this.

When you click on the verse number, “7” in this case, the Hebrew-English Interlinear opens at that verse as shown. The highlighted verse is shown in a brown colour as shown.

The Hebrew word translated as “in vain” is H7723.  If I click on Strong’s number H7723, the following window opens.

Please read it carefully, focusing on the words in italics (desolating, evil, destructive, ruin, guile, idolatry, uselessness, & vain). I believe these are the possible meanings of the ROOT word, shav.

NB - I never trust just one concordance or dictionary, so I always check at least two, & I encourage you to check at least two, as well.

I usually use e-Sword to examine another dictionary, namely, the Brown-Driver-Briggs Lexicon, but since I want to demonstrate how to use Biblehub.com, I’ll open it below.

Again, when we go to the Internet, & type in www.biblehub.com, we get :

If we click the Interlinear  tab, the following window opens :

If we type in Exodus 20:7 at the top, we get :

If we scroll down, we can view Exod 20:7 fully as shown :

If we click Strong’s number H7723, we are taken to the following window :

While this window contains a lot of useful & interesting information, for now, let’s click the BDB tab 

(the Brown-Driver-Briggs Lexicon) – where the following information is displayed :

As you can see, there is a lot of information provided here. For now, let’s just focus on the three main points written in italics :

1 emptiness, nothingness, vanity

2 emptiness of speech, lying

3 worthlessness

I used BibleHub.com to demonstrate how to use it, but I usually just use e-Sword because :

(a) it is really easy to find the information I am looking for, &

(b) I don’t need to access the Internet.

In using e-Sword, I generally copy the details of Strong’s Concordance, & the Brown-Driver-Briggs Lexicon in a table like the one below :

Again, please note that the words in italics, give the most literal meanings of the Hebrew word being studied.

Summary

The Hebrew word that is translated “in vain”, is  לשׁוא, l’shav, comes from the ROOT word, שׁוא shav, which can mean,

emptiness, nothingness, vanity, lying, worthlessness, falsehood, desolating, evil, ruin, or uselessness.

The prefix ל, at the beginning of the Hebrew word, שוא  shav, can mean “for, to, or at”, but has been translated as “in” vain, in the KJV, HRB, CJB, & the Hebrew-English Interlinear, & but “lightly”, in the CJB.

Q:  Which meaning is most correct for l’shav, in Exod 20:7 ?

A:  I believe that in this verse, the translators of The Scriptures & the LEB have the correct sense of this verse, namely, “not bringing the name of Yahweh to naught (nothingness)”. 

Now to the "Context".

Q:   What is the context of this specific verse within Exod 20 ?

A:   Again, my research shows me that the Book of Exodus was originally written by Moses TO  the now free Israelites, sometime during their 40 years in the wilderness. Exod 20 follows Exod 19, where Moses reminded these free Israelites in Exod 19:5-6, of the covenant Yahweh offered to them, & that they accepted.

Exod 20 is the start of what Yahweh required of Israel, as the conditions for being in Covenant with Him. The whole set of requirements, Yahweh’s Torah (instructions), commandments, judgments & statutes are written from Exod 20 to Exod 24:11, but I believe that all of the first five books of the Bible, also known as Yahweh’s Torah, are Yahweh’s instructions to His people, Israel.

Exod 24:4 reminds these free Israelites that Moses wrote ALL the words of Yahweh in the Book of the Covenant (v7).

After you have completed your study of a verse, the next step is to re-write it by inserting clarifying words based on the correct context. The following is an example of how this might look.

Exod 20:7

Thou shalt not take (bring) the name (reputation) of the LORD thy God (Yahweh your Elohim) in vain (bringing it to naught); for the LORD (Yahweh your Elohim) will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain (bringing it to naught).

NB  it is strongly recommended that you carefully check the translations of any abstract words such as love, grace, faith, or salvation, by examining their meaning in the original languages, as well as establishing their correct context.

While the above information has been based on studying just one Hebrew word, the same principles can be applied to a study of a whole verse, and/or passage.

Importance of knowing something about the Hebrew

Example

Q:  Have you ever wondered why the story of the tragedy of Joseph, where the eleven brothers sold him off into slavery (Gen 37:12-36), is seemingly taken on a “detour” ? In this “detour”, we peer into the sexual escapades of Judah’s two sons, and Judah himself with Tamar.

A:  Well, the answer is completely lost when reading it in English, but in Hebrew, the reason is quite obvious.

Let’s have a closer look at that “detour” story.

If we look at Gen 37:32 in an English translation such as the KJV, it reads :

Gen 37:32 And they sent the coat of many colours, and they brought it to their father; and said, This have we found: know now whether it be thy son's coat or no.

The Hebrew-English Interlinear translates Gen 37:32 as follows :

The important Hebrew word for this example is H5234, הכר  ha’kar, translated as “know” in both the above versions. Strong’s tells us that it can mean scrutinize, recognize, acknowledge, be acquainted with, respect, revere, suspicion, disregard ignore, reject, resign or dissimilate. In this context, it probably means “recognize”.

In the “detour” story, Gen 38:1-26, we are told that Judah impregnates Tamar, who is disguised as a temple prostitute, & that later, she presents herself, obviously pregnant, to the chief of the tribe - Judah. He, of course, is outraged. In Gen 38:25, we are told that Tamar offers the articles that will identify the father of her child, & provides the signet, bracelets & staff, of the child’s father.

Gen 38:25 When she was brought forth, she sent to her father in law, saying, By the man, whose these are, am I with child: and she said, Discern, I pray thee, whose are these, the signet, and bracelets, and staff. (KJV)

In the Hebrew- English Interlinear, it reads :

If you look carefully at the Hebrew words used in this verse, the Hebrew word, translated as “discern”, is H5234, הכר  ha’kar; the same Hebrew word, Judah used to deceive his father Jacob, in Gen 37:32.

So, thinking about these two seemingly, unrelated stories, we can now see that the original intention of Moses the author, was to show the connection between the way Judah deceived Jacob about Joseph, & how Judah is reminded of this deception by Tamar’s plea to him.

Once Judah deals with this deception trauma, the Joseph story can continue.

Exercises

1:  Use the above method to examine & study Lev 23:3

Q:  What is a sabbath of rest ?

Q:  What is a holy convocation ?

Q:  What is the difference between the work done for six days & the command “you shall do no work” ?

2:  Choose a Bible verse of your own, & study it using the method above. Write down any differences that you observe, & attempt to explain why they are there.

3:  In Genesis 1:1, there is a Hebrew word that is not translated. What is this Hebrew word ? Think about this word, & write down some thoughts about it. Is this word untranslated anywhere else in the Tanach (OT)?

Followers of the Messiah - How to do a Hebrew search

Suppose you wanted to know the places where a particular Hebrew word was written in a specific book of the Bible. How could you do this ? Let’s use as an  example, the Hebrew word translated as “Sabbath”.

Step 1:  Open e-Sword

Step 2:   Click the binoculars symbol just below the Bibles Tool bar as shown :

When you do, the following window opens :

Step 3: Type in the word “sabbath” as shown below :

Step 4: Click the binoculars icon on the far right hand side, & the following window opens :

This window tells us two main things :

1: The first verse where “Sabbath” is found in the HRB is Exod 16:23, & 

2: There are 113 verses where the word “Sabbath” is found.

If you click Exod 16:23, e-Sword takes you to that verse in the HRB. It is highlighted in "brown" as shown :

If you click the Hebrew-English Interlinear tab, you will be transferred to that version of Exod 16:23, again, highlighted in "brown", as shown below :


Copy this word by "highlighting" it as shown :

If you click the Bible Search binoculars again, the following window will open :

You will need to change the “search criteria” by clicking the arrow next to the word “Regular”. Select “Search for all of the words”. I apologise for not being able to show this in more detail, but you can do this by clicking the small "arrow" next to "Search fo"

Click the binocular icon on the far right hand side. The following window will open :

Exercises

A:  Find the verses that contain the Hebrew word translated as “light”.

B:  Find the verses that contain the Hebrew for a word that you choose.

Analysing the GREEK

Suppose someone said that they believed your understanding of the word translated as “fulfil” in Matt 5:17, was incorrect ? What could you do, to TEST this claim ?

While I have demonstrated how to use software to analyse Hebrew words, we also need to be able to use software to analyse Greek words.

In order to do this, we can download into e-Sword, a Greek-English Interlinear.

We can do this by once again going to biblesupport.com, & downloading the Interlinear Greek New Testament Keyed to Strong’s, as is shown :

Once we have done this, I can demonstrate how to analyse a Greek word, & even a whole verse, in the Renewed Covenant Scriptures (New Testament).

I’ll begin by examining the Greek word that is translated as “fulfil” in the KJV of Matt 5:17.

Below I have copied the KJV, & the Interlinear Greek New Testament Keyed with Strong’s translations of Matt 5:17.    

Note : Greek is read left to right.

Many Christians believe, based on Col 2:14, that the Torah, the law of Moses, was “nailed to the cross”, & therefore was “done away with”, or “completed”, & thus was “ended”. 

Col 2:14  Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross

Let's use this strategy to TEST whether this understanding is valid, & therefore correct !

There are only four verses that contain this precise Greek word, whose root is G4137. To demonstrate this, I've copied the Greek word translated as "fulfil", & carried out a search in the Renewed Covenant Scriptures. The results & verses are shown below :

I have copied these four verses below, & inserted the possible meaning “do away with” next to the KJV translation of our Greek word. Let's read each of them carefully, & TEST whether the possible meaning, “do away with”, fits the context of each verse.

Is this possible meaning valid in each case ?

How could we TEST that idea ?

Perhaps, the first thing that we could do is to look at the surrounding verses, & see if that assists our understanding.

Mat 5:17 Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.

Mat 5:18 For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled (a different Greek word, G1096, γενηται to verse 17).

Reading verse 17 with verse 18, aren’t we told that :

A:  Yahushua (Jesus) said, “do not think that He came to destroy (annul or demolish) the law or the prophets

B:  He came to fulfil (to teach fully, cram full) the law 

C:  He then saidUntil heaven & earth pass, not one jot or one tittle shall pass from the Torah (law), till all be fulfilled (come to pass).

Q:  Has heaven & earth passed ?

A:  No - then doesn’t that mean that, not one jot or one tittle has passed from the Torah, & so, it all is applicable !

If this isn’t convincing enough, we can apply the strategy we demonstrated in lesson 2, namely, compare other places where this exact same Greek word is used.

You may remember that when using this strategy, we replace our “target” word with the possible meaning.

Let’s see what this looks like.

Isn't it true that, based on the above "strategy" the more correct meaning of "pleroai" in Matt 5:17 is "to make replete or full, or "to cram full". "Do away with, complete or end" are inappropraite meanings for this verse.


Exercises

In Matt 24:4, Yahushua warns us not to be “deceived”, because He says, “MANY shall come in my name, saying, I am Christ; and shall deceive many”. KJV

Do a search of the KJV Bible for the phrase “Jesus Christ”. What did you find ? Now do a search for the single word, “Christ”. What did you find ?

Q: Is the term “Christ” a personal name, & therefore, worthy of being “transliterated” ?

Q: If not, why has it been “transliterated”, & not “translated” ?

Q: Again, if you carefully examine Matt 24:5, we have the warning of Yahushua about being deceived. Copy the KJV of Matt 24:5 & compare it with the New Testament Interlinear.

Q: What is the Greek word, “transliterated” as “CHRIST” ? What does it mean ? How should it be translated ?

Q: Why do you think many translators have “transliterated” it instead ?

Isn’t this an example of “doctrinal BIAS”  ?

Now that we are aware of this BIAS, how will we now respond when we read this word ?

Followers of the Messiah - a guide for those who have stopped going to Church 

If you have stopped going to Church, or, are just interested in this subject, the questions of WHY ?, & What to do now ?,

with their answers, will almost certainly appeal to you.

A quick GOOGLE search on the number of people who describe themselves as Christian in America, has shown that there has been a drop from 78.4% in 2007 to 70.6% in 2014, according to the Pew Research Centre (2015). Barna.com, a Christian Research organisation, in April 2016, estimated that of these, only 31% attended Church regularly.

Could the following, be some of the reasons for you, stopping going to Church ?

The gospel & many sermons taught, seems different to the one in the Bible

The institutional Church seemed inappropriate

The biblical Yahushua (Jesus) can be hard to find in Church

Women & men aren’t treated equally

The Church is totally about preserving itself

Everyone is expected to believe exactly alike

The Church was less welcoming of the poor, the unlovely, & the homeless

The Church does not welcome those who ask questions, or those who disagree with leadership

There are often “cliques” in Church

I wasn’t able to share what I believe Yahweh (God) gave me with others

I wasn’t able to receive what others had received from Yahweh

Some of the institutional Church wasn’t biblical

Church was always predictable

My denomination hasn’t taught me how to really study Yahweh’s Word

The Church doesn’t teach, or do, what the New Testament Yahushua did.


Q: Are you someone who can resonate with some, or all of the above ?

Q: Are you a person who senses that they have been called out from Church ?

Q: Are you just someone who feels that their peace has been disturbed, & that something is wrong, or that something is missing ?

Please realise that you are not alone !

We too, with many others, have also had this same experience of coming out of Church.


I wonder what you think of this statement ?

Our experience, both personally, & from connecting with others, indicates that the reasons for leaving Church, may differ from person to person, but we believe that ultimately, our heavenly Father has ‘seriously disturbed our peace’, because He wanted to get our attention”.

Once we realised that our shalom (peace) was seriously disturbed, we began to ask, to seek, & to knock,  (Matt 7:1-14 & Luke 11:9-10), in an effort to restore our shalom (peace).

WE STARTED TO QUESTION, & RE-EXAMINE A LOT OF THINGS, that we thought we believed, including :

Who is “God” ?

     What is the Bible, & what does it tell us about God & His Messiah ?

          Why did God create the universe and us ?

               What does God want us to do ?

                    What does God want us to be ?

How do I really know, that what I’ve been taught, & believed, what I've heard, seen or viewed, is valid, accurate & true ?

OUR LIST of POSSIBLE QUESTIONS, continued

     What is the Creator’s name ?

          Are names important ?

               Who is the Messiah (Christ) ?

                    Is the Messiah’s name Jesus ?

          What do we really know about the Messiah's parents ?

               What was He taught, & what did He do ?

                    Have we been taught what the Messiah believed, & what He did ?

     When did the Church begin ?

          Who were the first, Messianic believers ?  

                What did those first believers in Messiah, do in the 1st century ?

                     What evidence do we have for the beliefs we have been taught ?

                          Who are the chosen people of God ?

     When is the biblical Sabbath ?

          Do we believe, & do, anything that the 1st century Messianic believers didn’t do ?

The list could go on, and on !


In an attempt to find answers to these, & other questions, we may ask others, & most likely, we will check the Internet for possible insights. We noticed, that this can be even more confusing, & so we asked the very important question, “how do we know, if what we discover, is actually correct ?”


At some point in this process, we started to realise that, we are on a journey into Yahweh’s truth. It is an expedition out of confusion, into clarity !

As we continued to progress, it occurred to us to consider where we are now, & contrast that, with where are we supposed to be.

We noticed that we needed a “reality check” ! We carefully asked, “who am I”, & this resulted in a search for our real identity.

It was about this point, that we personally understood, that the biblical names of the Creator, & His Messiah were important.

We began using their Hebrew names – Yahweh is the heavenly Father’s name, yod-hey-vav-hey in Hebrew, translated as LORD,  & that Yahushua, is His Messiah’s Hebrew name. You may know Him as Jesus.

We realized that “God” was not a name, but a description, or a title.

An interesting ANALOGY

We started to appreciate, & understand more about our Saviour, Yahushua. The River & Riverbank ANALOGY helped.

In the analogy, Yahushua is the river, but we have been on the riverbank. He wants us to come from the riverbank, & get into the river, & live our lives in the same way that He did, when He was on Earth.

We are comfortable on our riverbank – the water looks cold, & possibly dangerous. Perhaps we want to put our toe into the river, or splash some water on our faces, but we are very reluctant to get into the river.

Some use a “flying fox” or “zip ride”, that goes from one river bank to the other – going from one source of confusion, Christianity, to another source of confusion, Judaism.

Riverbanks can refer to the World, or again, to the different Christian denominations, or Judaism – they are everything, that is not “the river”.

We’ve grown up living our lives on the riverbank, but now, as a result of the disturbance of our shalom (peace), we realise that we are supposed to be, “in the river”.           

There is no place in Scripture where we are supposed to fix the riverbank. Once people realise that they are supposed to be in the river, they want to fix the riverbank – by taking buckets of river water, & throwing it on the riverbank, or giving it to those still on the riverbank. We are only ever told to “come out of her My people”, & get into the river. It is Father Yahweh’s job to “fix the riverbank”.

Can you relate to this analogy ?

Aren’t we all on a journey  that is about growing, & being transformed into Yahushua’s image ?

We haven’t been taught what this looks like, & so it can be a real struggle.

We all have cultural influences, societal influences, denominational influences, even spiritual influences (Babylon), that we need to let go of.

As a result of all these influences, each of us has personal preferences – unfortunately, there are no denominational organisations, or other religious groups in Scripture, that are called to be Yahweh’s people - there are only the 12 tribes of Israel !

A very important question is, “Who are we supposed to be according to Scripture” ?

Again, let us use another analogy to explain this. Below, I have copied one example of a Shopping Mall map, that may help us with this question.

Finding out who we are supposed to be according to Scripture, is a bit like trying to figure out where a particular store is in this Shopping Mall. We are attempting to work out, “where we are”, & “where we need to go” on our journey.

Let’s consider the, “You are HERE  idea !

For most of us, we have a problem. It is like we are standing in front of a large sporting store, but we think we are in front of a department store.

Our problem sometimes is that, we don’t have good, & accurate “You are Heres” – so if this is so, when we are trying to get to where we want to go, we may be coming from a wrong place.

An example that we might think of, is that we are driving on an unfamiliar Highway 40, headed towards our destination, Los Angeles. We look at our map, believing that we are at Flagstaff, Arizona, but in fact, we are at Kingman, Arizona. We inadvertently, take a wrong turn, & end up heading towards Las Vegas, but we are totally unaware of it. Can you see why we need to know our starting point ?

Let’s review what we have noticed so far.

1:   Yahweh serious disturbs our shalom (peace), to get our attention.

2:   In an attempt to restore our shalom, we ask questions, we seek answers, & we knock on doors.

3:   We realise that we are on a journey into Yahweh’s Truth.

4:   We discover that we are not sure, where we are on this journey.

A:   In questioning a lot of things, we realise that we have to let go of some things, & we have to embrace other things.

B:   We may come to really understand what James writes in James 4:8,

  Jas 4:8 Draw near to Elohim and He shall draw near to you

C:   We are reminded, that all this activity involves change, & that any kind of change is stressful.

NB - don’t fall for the lie, “the Ruach (Holy Spirit) will teach me”, without remembering that, He disturbed our shalom (peace) in the first place. If this was true, wouldn’t it mean that the Ruach would give us an instant download, with all the answers ?

D:   We come to understand, that going through the process of asking, & seeking, & knocking, & journeying, allows us to find others who are also asking, seeking, knocking & journeying too.

E:   We now realise, that we need a guide that we can trust, because we are going somewhere, that we have never been before.

F:   In this process, we start to evaluate a lot of things that we may need to add to our walk. It is important to remember that the Heavenly Father is developing a “forever community”, in which He wants us to be able to live with each other, to support to each other, & to obey His kingdom rules.


As we are travelling on our journey, we may realise that this process is taking place in, what can be described as “the Battlefield of the Mind”.

We may come to understand that the place where we are right now, is where & when Yahweh chooses – it is not our choice.

He disturbed us in the place where we are now living, in the time period we are presently in, & in the culture we were raised in.

Once we realise what Yahweh has done, we can be confident that we can go from where Yahweh has called us, to where He wants us to be.

In doing this, we have to make a “conscious choice”, to choose Yah (short for Yahweh) as He is, over our own version of Him, which has been shaped by our personal preferences (our self-sovereignty & culture), and our interaction with “Babylon”.

Doesn’t Rev 18:1-5 refers to the system that keeps us away from Yahweh asBabylon”, the mindset that takes us away from obedience & submission to our Creator.

The Babylonian system will cause us to justify our wrong choices, or excuse our disobedience.

Doesn’t Rom 12:1-2 tell us,  “…do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind…”.

If we renew our minds, won’t we be able to do Yahweh’s will, better ?

In Phil 2:1-8 “, we are told, “…let this mind be in you which was also in Messiah Yahushua...”. If we do this, aren’t we desiring to be conformed to Messiah’s  image, & not the other way around ?

Aren’t our preferences, our likes & dis-likes, essentially on the wrong side of the “Battlefield of our Minds” ?

Don’t we need to ask ourselves, “Are we willing to lay down our sovereignty, for His sovereignty ?”.

Yahweh doesn’t want us to just exist, He wants us to really live !  

Let’s examine a previous statement about being on a journey into Yahweh’s Truth, by asking, what then, is Yahweh’s TRUTH ?

In John 8:31-32, we are told, “…If you stay in My Word, you are truly My disciples…”.

Yahushua made them disciples, so that they could then "disciple", someone else. Isn’t the role of a disciple (the one who has been discipled), to help turn others into Yahushua’s imageto come into a relationship with the Truth !

Verse 32 reads “…and you shall know the Truth, and the Truth shall make you free.”

So what specifically, is TRUTH ?

Interestingly, there is a “cycle of Scriptural verses” that explain what, & who TRUTH is.

John 14:6 tells us that Yahushua is TRUTH

Psa 119:142 explains that The Torah (law) is TRUTH

Psa 119:160 explains further that The Word is TRUTH, and  

John 1:14 tells us that The Word put on flesh,

All this shows us that, Yahushua in the flesh, is the walking, talking, living Torah (Truth) !

So, how do we find Yahweh’s TRUTH ?

1 John 2:4 explains “The one who says “I know Him”, and does not guard His commandments, is a liar, and the TRUTH is not in him”.

If we are to “know Him” (Messiah Yahushua), shouldn’t we, as 1 John 2:6 tells us, “WALK as He WALKED” ?

Shouldn’t we live our lives, by doing what He, & the first century believers did ?


So what did Messiah Yahushua believe, & do ?

In order to find the answers to these questions, shouldn’t we search the Renewed Covenant Scriptures (NT), rather than simply rely on, & accept, what we have been taught in the Church ?

Did our denomination teach us how to really study Yahweh’s Word, (as was shown in the six lessons on how to study Scripture), or did they teach us to come to their pastors, ministers or priests, their experts, for the answers to our questions ? Wasn’t this one of the reasons we stopped going to Church ?

Isn’t it true, that if we haven’t studied Yahweh’s Word for ourselves (in the original languages), then we have NO opinion ! This statement is saying that if we have not studied His Word, then we can’t have an opinion about that Word, because we really don’t know what it actually says. All we really know, is someone else’s opinion - in other words, our opinion is based on “hearsay” !

Very Important Question – am I willing to accept the opinions of others, for my eternal salvation, & walk of faith ?


Based on several verses in the Gospel of John, we know that Yahushua did the will of His heavenly Father (John 6:39-40). We also know that Yahushua & His Father are one (John 10:30). John 15:8-10, tells us that the Father loves Yahushua, & that Yahushua kept His Father's commandments.

Joh 6:39  And this is the Father's will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day. 

Joh 6:40  And this is the will of him that sent me, that every one which seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life: and I will raise him up at the last day. 

Joh 10:30  I and my Father are one.

Joh 10:38  But if I do, though ye believe not me, believe the works: that ye may know, and believe, that the Father is in me, and I in him.

Joh 15:8  Herein is my Father glorified, that ye bear much fruit; so shall ye be my disciples. 

Joh 15:9  As the Father hath loved me, so have I loved you: continue ye in my love. 

Joh 15:10  If ye keep my commandments, ye shall abide in my love; even as I have kept my Father's commandments, and abide in his love. 

Clearly, from Matt 22:37-40, Yahushua knew & taught the first & great commandment, "love Yahweh your Elohim, with all your heart, soul, & mind", as well as the second commandment, "love your neighbour as yourself", explaining in verse 40 that, on these two commandments hang all the Torah (law) & the Prophets.

Mat 22:37  Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. 

Mat 22:38  This is the first and great commandment. 

Mat 22:39  And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself. 

Mat 22:40  On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets. 

We, at Followers of the Messiah, believe what Messiah Yahushua believed, & do, as much as we can, what He did !

Final REVIEW

1:   We stopped going to Church, & listed some of the reasons why

2:   We did some asking, seeking & knocking, to try to restore our shalom (peace)

3:   We came to understand that, there was a battle going on in our minds

4:   We realised that we needed a guide – we at Followers of the Messiah can be that guide, until you learn more, and/or, until you find your own guide

5:   We hope you now realise that your new journey is one, to find Yahweh’s TRUTH


There is much, much more to learn, & we invite you to explore other presentations, & resources that we have prepared on our website.

Thank you for viewing our presentation on “Have you stopped going to Church”.

If you have any feedback, positive or negative, or would like to ask any questions about the material contained in this presentation, please contact us at :

  askseekknockandtest@gmail.com



We hope this presentation has encouraged you. To learn how to study Yahweh’s Word in the original languages, again, please check out , the six lessons on, How to Study Yahweh’s Word.

Followers of the Messiah - a guide to your spiritual journey

INTRODUCTION

In the teaching, "Have you stopped going to Church", I introduced the idea that, those who's shalom had been disturbed, are starting on a journey.

My goal is that this teaching will be to be a learning, growing & positive experience, & perhaps be a guide and/or mentor for some of our readers.

Mentor/Guide

My goals as a potential Mentor/Guide, includes :

1: to assist you in learning the things that Yahweh wants you to learn

2: to teach you the absolutely vital skill of how to study Yahweh’s Word at deeper & deeper levels

3: teach you the skill of answering the vital question, “How do I really know, that what I have believed, what I have been taught, & what others are saying, & teaching, what I've read, viewed & heard, is accurate, correct & true ?”. This always involves checking & TESTING ALL the available evidence !

4: teach you how to defend your beliefs & actions

5: AFTER you have learned the above aspects, you would then be able to teach others to learn & TESTto do or apply the learned skills & knowledge, to defend their faith.

The SPIRITUAL JOURNEY

Let's begin !

Have you ever been on a guided tour ? Can I use a tour we did to Ephesus as an example ? The following is a map of the guided tour area of Ephesus.


Information about a Guided Tour

If you are going on a Guided Tour, to get the most out of it, you will need to first of all :

1: Research it

2: Book it

3: Pay for it

The next step is to prepare for your guided tour by :

4: Doing more detailed research

5: Travelling to the location

What you may discover is that you don't know :

6: The actual location

7: The main highlights

8: The interesting side-trails

What you do know is :

9: Details from your personal research

10: Information from other sources

Your Tour Guide 

11: Will explain the RULES for being in her/his group


The Guided Tour     What we can learn & apply

A: The Tour Begins


B: Remember to keep up (with the Tour Guide)


C: Listen carefully


Be Aware - others are also on the Tour

D: Be Aware of distractions

If you'd like me to assist you, please email me, Pete, with your request, & may I strongly suggest that you :

1: make a commitment to carefully read, listen to, study, & analyse the materials that I will provide you with

2: provide feedback, preferably in writing to those materials

3: respond in writing to some questions that I might ask

4: keep a journal, detailing your spiritual journey

5: create a list of written email questions you may have, as they come up

6: keep a file indicating the various resources, & subjects that you encounter during your studies

7: create a file that gives details of the various “gems of wisdom” that Yahweh reveals to you as you ask, seek, knock & test during your spiritual journey

My email address is :        askseekknockandtest@gmail.com













Followers of the Messiah - How can I know if I’ve been deceived ?

Have you ever heard this saying ? “It is easier to deceive someone, than to convince them that they have been deceived”.

Well, I partly disagree because if someone really wants to know if they have been deceived, it is relatively easy to check to see if they have been deceived !

There are just two steps, as Peter explains in 2 Peter 2:1-2

1:  Examine whether the one teaching you is “contradicting Scripture”

2:  See if he/she has ”trained you”, intentionally or unintentionally, to speak evil of truth.

Please read it carefully.

2Pe 2:1 But there were false prophets also among the people, even as there shall be false teachers among you, who privily shall bring in damnable heresies, even denying the Lord that bought them, and bring upon themselves swift destruction. 

2Pe 2:2 And many shall follow their pernicious ways; by reason of whom the way of truth shall be evil spoken of. (KJV)

There is a lot of detail in these two verses, but perhaps for now, the most important thing we need to be aware of is that the Greek word translated as “denying” is αρνουμενοι, arnoumenoi, G720, which can mean denying, but in this context, means “contradicting”.

In order to TEST these two steps, can I ask you to please consider the following examples :

A:  If someone says that, “all days are holy”, hasn't he/she called Yahweh (God) a liar, because Yahweh command us in His Word, (Exod 20:8), to, “keep the Sabbath day, the seventh day, holy”. In Gen 2:3, Yahweh says that the 7th day is to be sanctified/holy, & is therefore set-apart from all the other days - surely, the 7th day is the only day that is “holy”.

B:  If someone says that, “Sunday is the holy day”, hasn’t he/she too, called Yahweh a liar, because of what Yahweh declared in Gen 2:3, & commanded in Exod 20:8 ?

Gen 2:3  And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it: because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made. 

Exo 20:8  Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.

In saying, “all days are holy” and/or “Sunday is the holy day”, isn’t that person speaking “evil of truth”, since we are told in Ps 119:151 that “ALL Your (Yahweh's) commandments are truth” ?

C:  If someone says that, “the law has passed away”, isn’t he/she, calling Yahushua (Jesus) a liar, because Yahushua said in Matt 5:17-18 that, “He didn’t come to destroy the law” (v17), & “that until heaven & earth pass away, not one jot or tittle of the law would pass away” (v18) ?

 Mat 5:17 Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil. 

Mat 5:18 For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled. 

Very sadly, many people have been “conditioned”, usually without realising it, to attack, with their doctrines, the Truth written in their Bibles, & in doing so, “ignorantly, they are speaking evil of truth”, by contradicting what is written  !

Haven’t these people been taught that a really good way to serve Yahweh & Yahushua is to contradict what each has said, by “tossing Yahweh’s law out” ! Surely, when you carefully consider this, it is obvious that they are “speaking evil of truth”.

Don’t many Christians believe that Yahweh is a merciful Elohim (God), & that He will judge them accordingly ?Again sadly, Peter tells us & them in verses 4-7, how Yahweh dealt with various "guilty" groups in the past.

Wouldn't it be fair to say that the angels who rebelled against Yahweh believed that He was a merciful Elohim, & would forgive them for what they did, but in verse 4, we are told that Yahweh didn’t spare the angels that sinned.

2Pe 2:4  For if God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down to hell, and delivered them into chains of darkness, to be reserved unto judgment; 

Again, it is likely that many of the people who lived in the time of Noah, also believed that Yahweh was a merciful Elohim, & that He would show them mercy by forgiving them for their deeds, but, verse 5 tells us that only eight were saved from the flood.

2Pe 2:5  And spared not the old world, but saved Noah the eighth person, a preacher of righteousness, bringing in the flood upon the world of the ungodly; 

I could provide several other examples of people who believed that Yahweh was a merciful Elohim who would forgive them, but again sadly, they were destroyed for their unlawful & unrighteous deeds (read about Sodom & Gomorrha in 2 Peter 2:6-8, & the people who worshipped the golden calf, & those whom Balaam corrupted into deceiving the Israelites in 1 Cor 10:6-14).

Isn’t it true that the “many” mentioned in Matt 7:13-14 & Matt 7:21-23, believed that Yahweh was a merciful Elohim, who would forgive them for their “law-less-ness” ?  But alas, in Matt 7:23, Messiah Yahushua says, “depart from Me, I never knew you” ! Clearly but sadly, the “many” that entered the gate that was “wide”, with the way, “broad”, in Matt 7:13, ended up in destruction.

 Mat 7:13 Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: 

Mat 7:14 Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it. 

Mat 7:23  And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work (law-less-ness) . 

It is really sad that many don’t carefully read Acts 5:32, which clearly tells us & them, that the Holy Spirit was only given to those who ”obeyed” Elohim (God). So, even though many Christians claim to have the “holy spirit”, based on Acts 5:32, the spirit that they think they have, can’t be Yahweh’s Holy Spirit, since many believe that Yahweh’s law, which reveals His will as a way of life as was given to Moses, has “passed away”, & is no longer relevant. I strongly believe that such persons should read :

1 John 4:1, which tells us to test whether the “spirit” they believe they have, is of Elohim.

Act 5:32 And we are his witnesses of these things; and so is also the Holy Spiritwhom God hath given to them that obey him 

1Jn 4:1 Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try (test) the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.  

The Holy Spirit Test

Isn’t it true that the Holy Spirit of Elohim will never contradict what Yahweh Elohim, & Messiah Yahushua, have clearly stated in the Word, nor will it speak evil of truth ? If a person claims to have a “spirit”, which tells them to contradict what Yahweh & Yahushua have written & said, in the Word, for example, by telling a person that “His law has passed away”, clearly that spirit cannot be Yahweh's Holy Spirit.


Yes, it is very easy to be deceived !

Followers of the Messiah - the question, the story, the TEST

I have been studying the above question, & have found it to be a very serious, thought-provoking & significant question, who’s consequences are so far-reaching, that I believe it is really a “salvation” matter.

I therefore, cannot encourage you the reader, more strongly, to carefully examine & consider everything that I am about to present.

As usual, please do not believe anything I have written, UNTIL, you check it with Yahweh’s (God’s) Word.


I'd like to acknowledge the work of Steve Martin of the Assembly of Yahweh in North Alabama, for his videos on this subject. You can access these videos, & many others at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC9rM83kBQ6DBdn66mFz8D6A/videos 

While I agree with many of Steve Martin's ideas, I do not agree with them all, & as usual, I strongly encourage the reader, who wishes to view his, or any other person's videos, to TEST what is being said, before, taking any information into their belief system.

Isn’t it true that, if your faith is a Bible-based faith, then the very first thing that you know, that you know, that you know, is that the Bible (in the original languages & in the original context), is the "inspired" Word of Yahweh ?

Two significant verses that give us very important information about what Yahweh’s Word is, are Heb 4:12 & 1 Tim 3:16

Heb 4:12 For the Word of YAHWEH is living, and powerfully working, and sharper than every two-edged sword, and piercing as far as the division of both soul and spirit, of both joints and marrow and bones, and able to discern the thoughts and intentions of the heart.

2Ti 3:16 All scripture is given by inspiration of Yahweh, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: 


So based on Heb 4:12, aren’t we told that Yahweh’s Word, the Bible is living, & working powerfully, & that it is sharper than any two-edged sword ? Doesn’t this verse also tell us that Yahweh’s Word is able to discern the thoughts & intentions of the heart ?

Based on 2 Tim 3:16, doesn’t Paul tell us that “Scripture”, Yahweh’s Word, was given by the inspiration of Yahweh, & that it is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, & for instruction in righteousness ?

So I wonder if you can agree that :

1:  Yahweh's Word, the Bible (the Tanach & the Renewed Covenant) is the inspired (influenced), inerrant, unchanging, revealed and written word of Elohim (God).

2:  Some of it is the actual spoken & written word of Yahweh and Yahushua (Jesus), and that much of it is written by men who were guided, motivated, influenced and stimulated by Elohim to write what they wrote.

3:  The Bible was NOT originally written TO me – for example, Genesis to Deuteronomy was originally written TO and FOR the Hebrews (mainly by Moses), who were freed from their bondage in Egypt, by Yahweh. The Bible was written FOR me and you.

      The Bible therefore, is only "inspired" in its original languages, & in its original context, and that there is no such thing, as 

       an “inspired translation".

4:  In those original languages, Yahweh’s Word says what it says; not what I think it says, not what I believe it says, not what I’d like it to say, not what others say it says, and not necessarily what I’ve been taught that it says. This is usually true, although at times, Yahweh uses metaphors and Hebrew idioms or metaphors.

Dear readers, it is at this point that I am going to stop & ask, do you agree with all the above information ? If you do, please read on. If you don’t, then it is clear that we aren’t on the same page when it comes to the Bible. I strongly encourage you to re-examine those beliefs, & to check out what I have written in this presentation.

In this teaching, my goal is to uncover only Yahweh’s Truth.

The following quotes are about “Truth”.


The great auto pioneer, Henry Ford I, wrote: “The truth frequently seems unreasonable; the truth frequently is depressing; the truth sometimes seems to be evil; but it has the eternal advantage, it is the TRUTH, and what is built thereon, neither brings nor yields to confusion.”


Well-known TV and radio commentator Garner Ted Armstrong puts it another way: “To believe that we could be wrong about something--almost anything--is unfortunately a very ego-shattering experience for some (if not most) human beings. The exposure of.. .myths and biases can be so psychologically disruptive that it is tantamount to complete ego destruction.”


 Armstrong continues, “When the....security blanket is gone, so is the particular niche of comfort into which we can conveniently creep when some challenging new thought comes along to disturb our mental processes. We do have our first line of defenses against truth, and they are far more effective than any radar set, or military advance-early-warning missile system. They unfailingly tell us that we are not wrong, but right after all !


Most people stubbornly resist any new truth with a whole series of first-line defenses, and several back-up systems to boot! But when truth finally exhausts all their defenses, they are forced to resort to that one-and-only tired old excuse: ‘Just who do you think you are? Where did you get your authority from ?’ If all else fails, people tend to fall back on this ‘put-down” (Good News Magazine, October 1975).


I wonder what you think of those quotes.


For those of you who know me well, you know that I like to study a subject as thoroughly as I can, by considering all sides of any debate. In the last few years, I have been regularly asking myself, “how do I know, that I know, that I know, that what I have believed, what I have been taught, what I have viewed, what I have read, or what I have heard, is absolutely accurate, true & correct ? After considerable thought, I came up with the only answer that I believe fits, namely, I must examine, consider & TEST, ALL the EVIDENCE that I can find !


With that in mind, I frequently apply the following principles to my studies, particularly, when I study Yahweh’s Word. I wonder if you can agree with them, & perhaps even apply them to your own studies.


Even if I have studied an issue carefully before, if someone presents information that contradicts, or challenges what I currently believe is true, re-examining it, will either strengthen that belief, or expose an error I may have made. 1 Pet 3:15 tells us that we must be willing to give an answer to anyone asking for our reasons concerning the hope of our faith.

1Pe 3:15  But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear: 

If we honestly seek God 's truth, and we are shown that we are in error, we will either cease being honest, or we will change our belief to repair the error.


During the several years I have been carefully studying God’s Word, I came to a deep awareness that when I was being deceived, I was totally unaware of the deception ! Once I realised that I had been deceived, the deception was obvious, and I decided that :


1:   I do not want to disbelieve the truth,

2:   I certainly do not want to believe a lie,

3:   I must know precisely what I believe, and more importantly, why I believe it,

4:   I must be very careful what I really believe, because, it will totally control the way I think, and what I do.

5:   I must be very careful not to be deceived because I have found that it is easy to produce a very convincing study, that is

      totally wrong !

6:   I must be aware of those who make statements without giving any scriptural support or evidence.


With all this in mind, may I present my response to find the Truth of the very important question, “is your faith, a Bible-based faith” ?

While the answer to the question, “is your faith, a Bible-based faith ?”, may seem obvious, I believe it is not as apparent as it may seem at first, & that it is of the upmost importance, & at least one aspect of it, is a “Salvation” matter

What I am about to write, will examine this subject in quite a bit of detail.


Again, in Heb 4:12, aren’t we told that Yahweh’s words are living, & are therefore, alive ? Doesn’t 2 Tim 3:15 explain that “all scripture is written by the inspiration of the Holy Spirit” ?


If Yahweh’s Word, the Bible, is alive, doesn’t that mean that no part of it ever died ?


If, as Paul tells us in 2 Tim 3:15, Yahweh’s Word was written by the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, don’t we know that it was therefore a collection of “what Yahweh said”, & that it was written by holy men who were led, & motivated by that Holy Spirit of Yahweh ?


Don’t we know that Yahweh breathed His words, & that from Exod 31:18, that He actually wrote them on two tablets of stone ? Don’t Exod 33:11a & Deut 5:4 tell us that Yahweh spoke to Moses, “face to face”, thereby communicating to Moses His accurate & precise instructions ?

 

Exo 31:18 And when He finished speaking with him on Mount Sinai, He gave to Moses the two tablets of the testimony, tablets of stone, written by the finger of Elohim.

Exo 33:11a And YAHWEH would speak to Moses face to face, as a man speaks to his friend.

Deu 5:4 YAHWEH talked with you face to face in the mountain out of the midst of the fire.


So, if your faith is a Bible-based faith, shouldn’t every believer be willing to examine, & TEST their faith, to determine whether it really is Bible-based ?


Have you ever wondered why Messiah Yahushua gave us at least three important warnings in Matt 24:4-5, Matt 7:21-23 & Matt 7:13 ? Shouldn’t the three warnings that Yahushua spoke about in these verses, “alarm us” ? If we paid careful attention to what He said, wouldn’t it alert us all, that we really need to do a self-examination of the things that we believe ?


Let’s check them out.


In Matt 24:4-5, we read :

Mat 24:4 And Jesus answered and said unto them, Take heed that no man deceive you. 

Mat 24:5 For many shall come in my name, saying, I am Christ; and shall deceive many. (KJV)


Perhaps the first thing we should notice, is that Yahushua is speaking to His disciples – He is not making a general statement to the Jewish community.


Q: In verse 4, Yahushua says, “take heed” - what does “take heed” mean ?

A:  I believe that He is telling His apostles, “I, Yahushua, am about to present to you a real danger”, meaning each of the  

     apostles needs to be on “full alert” as to what He is about to tell them. Surely, Yahushua would not tell them to be on “full

     alert”, unless there was a real & immediate danger ?


Well, before we get to the specific danger, let’s examine some important points in these verses.


The first thing to be aware of is, that the warning begins with “take heed that no man deceive you”, so the concept of “deception” is front & centre in this warning. I’ll have more to write about that later.


Q: What is the danger Yahushua is seriously alerting His apostles to ?

A:  I believe that verse 5 reveals the answer – “For many shall come in my name” saying,  I am Christ, & shall deceive many."


Notice it says “many” shall come in my name, & shall deceivemany”.


Q: How many people have you heard stand up & say that they were “Jesus” or “Christ” ?

A:  Google says 24 in the 20th century, & 5 in the 21st century


Clearly, these numbers are not “many”, so Matt 24:4 & 5 can’t be referring to these people, who actually stand up & say, “I am Jesus”, or “I am Christ”!


So perhaps we have misinterpreted part of verse 5. When Yahushua tells the apostles that “many shall come in My name”, it can’t be a reference to His actual name, Yahushua or Jesus, or His title as Messiah or Christ.


Q: So what did it mean to the original audience ?

A:  If it didn’t mean to “come in His personal name or title”, then it mostly likely means, they would “represent Him” or come in

      “His authority”.


How can we test to see if “representing Him” or “coming in His authority”, could be a correct understanding of the phrase, “for many shall come in My name” ?


If we look at the Book of Romans, specifically Rom 15:16, doesn’t Paul tell us that he was a “minister of Jesus Christ”, & that he “ministered the Gospel of Yahweh” ?


Rom 15:16 That I should be the minister of Jesus Christ to the Gentiles, ministering the gospel of God


In today’s understanding, isn’t it fair to say, that Christian ministers, pastors & evangelists, are “ministers of Jesus Christ”, & wouldn’t they claim to “represent Him”, and/or, are “working in His authority” ?


Let’s leave it at that for now.


When examining these two verses more carefully, I noticed that the word “Christ”, which comes from the Greek word, “Christos”, is not a proper or personal name, & therefore should have been translated, & not transliterated, as if it were a proper or personal name. Could this be an example of translator bias” ?


Q: So what is the meaning of the Greek word, “Christos” ?

A:  Strong’s Concordance & Thayer’s Lexicon tell us it means “anointed


So if we re-write the verse by inserting the correct meaning of Christos, don’t we get :


Mat 24:4 And Yahushua answered and said unto them, Take heed that no man deceive you. 

Mat 24:5 For many shall come in my name, saying, I am anointed; and shall deceive many


So it seems that Yahushua is warning His disciples about those who claim to be represent Him, & claim to be “anointed”, not that they are actually “Christ” ?


I haven’t been able to find a statistic, but during my lifetime, numerous Internet & denominational pastors, teachers & evangelists have claimed to be “anointed”. Would you agree ?


Could this be what Yahushua is warning His disciples about in Matt 24:4-5 ?


So, based on my investigation, could the following be a more accurate translation of Matt 24:4-5 ?


Mat 24:4 And Yahushua answered and said unto them, Take heed (be on full alert) that no man deceive you. 

Mat 24:5 For many shall come in my name, (representing Me or in My authority), saying, I am anointed; and shall deceive many


If we read down to Matt 24:11-12, we read of “false prophets” rising up, & deceiving many.

 

Mat 24:11 “And many false prophets shall rise up and lead many astray. 

Mat 24:12 “And because of the increase in lawlessness, the love of many shall become cold. 


Q: What is a false prophet ?

A:  Isn’t a false prophet an “imposter” who “speaks” ?


Wouldn’t Matt 24:11 read, “many false (an imposter) prophets (one who speaks) shall rise up & shall deceive many” ? Isn’t this a re-statement of    Matt 24:5 ?


Q: From Matt 24:12, what is going to cause the “love of many to wax cold” ?

A:  Doesn’t verse 12 tell us that it is lawlessness, which according to 1 John 3:4 is “the violation of the instruction (the Torah)", given in the Bible ?


Q: Why then are people violating the instruction (the Torah) given in the Bible ?

A:  Based on Yahushua’s warning, isn’t it because they got deceived by a false teacher (a false prophet or imposter), who said he represented Yahushua, & saying they was “anointed” – in doing this, the false prophet taught the people that they didn’t have to keep the Torah (law), & were therefore, “lawless” ?


So to summarise - in the last days, we need to be alarmed & alerted by carefully noticing what Yahushua said in Matt 24:4-5, namely, many imposters are going to stand up, claiming to represent Him, & claiming to beanointed” - they will deceive many, into believing that they no longer need to keep Yahweh’s Torah that is written in the Bible.


What is the second warning that Yahushua alerted His disciples & us to ?


In Matt 7:21-23, we read :


Mat 7:21 Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven. 

Mat 7:22 Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? 

Mat 7:23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity.(KJV)


If we are taking notice of the warnings that Yahushua gave, shouldn’t we be willing to TEST them, to see if they are Bible-based or not ?


Q: What is a prevalent doctrine being taught by denominations today ?

A:  Isn’t it that, “all you have to do is call Jesus, your Lord, & you’ll go to heaven” ?


Notice that Yahushua says something very different to Matt 7:21 !


Q: Who does Yahushua say will enter into the kingdom of heaven ?

A:  Yahushua says, “he that does the will of my Father” !


Q: How do we know what the Father’s will is ?

A:  He expresses it in His Word, specifically, His instructions – His Torah.


Q: Don’t we notice Matt 7:22, uses the word “many”, as we did in Matt 24:4-5 ?


Q: Won’t these “many” think that the faith that they have embraced all of their lives, was a  Bible-based faith, but doesn’t Yahushua say in Matt 7:23, that “many of them”, will be wrong, & He will say, “depart from Me, I never knew youyou who worked iniquity (lawlessness)” ?


Q: Based on Matt 7:22, won’t these “many” think that they are representing Yahushua in everything they do – won’t they think that just because they see miracles & signs, & just because they cast out demons, & do mighty works, they will think, based on those things (what they’ve experienced, & what they have been a part of), it assures them that their faith is Bible-based faith ?


Q: Based on what we have witnessed in the world today, won’t the "many" defend it with everything that they have ? But, based on what Yahushua says in Matt 7:22, on the day of judgment, the "many" will find out that they listened to an imposter, who told them that he was “anointed”, & convinced them, based on that “anointing”, to ignore what was written in the Bible, & therefore, they have strayed away from, & established a belief system, that isn’t based on what the Bible says ?


Isn’t Yahushua really saying – “many” will be deceived - that they are going to live deceived - that they will defend their deception during their lives, & will die deceived, & even at judgment, they are going to defend their deception ?


Aren’t they going to say to Yahushua, “we did all this in Your name, as Your representative, & in Your authority” ?


Q: Based on Matt 7:22-23, what will Yahushua then say to them after this ?

A:  He will say, “I will profess to them that I never knew you – depart from Me that work iniquity" (lawlessness).


Q: What law is Yahushua talking about ?

A:  Surely it can only be, the biblical TorahYahweh’s instructions for living a healthy, happy & successful life.


In Matt 7:21-23, isn’t Yahushua warning His apostles, & us, not to be deceived into embracing a faith that is not Bible-based, even though it will seem spiritual, & “many” will think that they are right – surely, the fact that it rejects the written Torah in the Bible is evidence that is not a Bible-based faith ?


There is third warning from Yahushua in Matt 7:13-14 – please read it carefully.


Mat 7:13 Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: 

Mat 7:14 Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it(KJV)


Can we please take a few minutes to analyse these verse ?


If there is a wide gate, doesn’t that mean that “many” go through it, & doesn’t v13 say that they are going on their way to destruction ?


Q: What does the Greek word, translated as “wide” mean ?

A:  Doesn’t it have the sense of “being fabricated, & pushed out”, in order to allow “many” to go through it ?


Q: Isn’t it true that because “the gate” is wide, the intention is, let’s not be so strict on who we let in – that everyone is welcome as they are – let’s not have any restrictions on who can be part of the fellowship ?

 

Q: Doesn’t the Greek word translated as “broad” mean spacious, & so that there is a lot of room for every belief, every ritual & every lifestylewe welcome, & love everyone, regardless of their lifestyle ? Isn’t this happening today ?


Q: Doesn’t Yahushua say that “the way to life is through the straight gate”, & “that way is narrow” ? Doesn’t that indicate that the way through this gate is quite small, & that it controls who can pass through, & how they are to pass through ? Clearly, you can’t enter just anywhere ?


Q: Isn’t the word translated as “narrow” indicating a “rut” or a “well-trodden path” ?


Q: In the “broad” way, aren’t people always coming up with new ways to express your faith, but in the way that leads to life, “the straight & narrow” way, there is a well-worn rut-like path that was put there before us, a path that we are to find – it leads to life ?


Q: Don’t we have to go through the straight & narrow gate to find the well-worn, rut-like path, & then walk in that narrow path ?


So based on Matt 7:13-14, shouldn’t our faith be a faith that is based on the old paths that are revealed to us through Yahweh’s Torah ?


I know that we really, really want to be right, to be correct, & it is one thing to think you are right, but shouldn’t we be willing to put our beliefs to a serious TEST ?


Surely it is true that, when we are deceived, we don’t know that we are deceived ? So if you might have been deceived by a person who said that they represented Yahushua, & that they were “anointed”, wouldn’t it be prudent & wise to TEST those beliefs ? If you are afraid to TEST your faith, then surely your faith isn’t worth having ?


Do we have any biblical evidence to support these ideas ?


Yes there is ! I have a story, which is a paraphrase of what is written in the Bible, 1Kings chapters, 12 & 13. I am asking you to read this story very carefully, & see if you can identify the lesson that it teaches. I believe that if you do this, you will know for a certainty, whether you have been deceived or not ?


The Story & its Lessons


Saul was the first king of Israel, of all twelve tribes - he died, and David became King. David died, and his son Solomon became King. Solomon died, and his son Rehoboam became king, but Rehoboam did not become king of all twelve tribes.


There was a rift, & the ten northern tribes weren't sure if they wanted Rehoboam to be king - they met with him, & they talked with him, but they didn't like the things he said, and so they revolted. They said, "now we’ll have no part with the house of David, Rehoboam is not our King", & so they anointed Jeroboam to be their king


With Jeroboam being the king, the ten northern tribes had a dilemma, and the dilemma was that the temple was in Jerusalem, which is in the southern kingdom, & all of the feasts of Yahweh were held in Jerusalem. Jeroboam feared that during the commanded feasts of Yahweh, the people would return to Jerusalem, & they would get so caught up in the beauty of these holy convocations, and the celebrations, that they would repent that they had rejected Rehoboam, and they'd want to return and unite the twelve tribes all back together again – Jeroboam feared that they'd kick him out from being king, or even kill him, so what he decided to do, was to create his own holy day (1 Kings 12:32).

 

Let’s take a careful note that :


Jeroboam created a holy day, that was different from the commanded, seven biblical feasts of Yahweh.

 

The next thing that Jeroboam did was, he created two golden calves - now listen carefully to what he said when he set up these two golden calves “whereupon the king took counsel and made two calves of gold, and he said unto them, it's too much for you to go up to Jerusalem - behold your Elohim, O Israel which brought you up out of the land of Egypt” (1Kings 12:28).


Let’s make our second careful note that :


Jeroboam told his people that they no longer had to keep the seven feasts established by Yahweh


What logic did Jeroboam use to convince the people that they no longer needed to keep Yahweh’s feasts ? Well, as we saw in 1 Kings 12:28, Jeroboam said “it is too much”, implying that Yahweh would never expect them to go back to Jerusalem keep all those feasts ! Jeroboam deceived the people, & convinced them that, they didn't have to keep Yahweh’s feasts anymore.


Notice in the same verse, what we see Jeroboam doing ! He's not telling them, “let's start worshipping a different elohim than they worship in Judah - he's telling them that they can worship Yahweh in their own way, not the way that Yahweh commanded."


Now for our careful note number three :


Jeroboam re-assigned new meaning to pagan images and rituals.


Shouldn’t we note that at no time do Jeroboam’s golden calves represent Yahweh ? These golden calves represented pagan deities, but Jeroboam re-assigns new meaning to this pagan image, and all the rituals involved with that pagan image.


Jeroboam reassigned new meaning to those golden calves, and told the people these calves now represent Yahweh, even though those castes had nothing to do with Yahweh - Jeroboam just said that they did. Somehow, the people seem to have forgotten about the “golden calf” rebellion at Mt Sinai, & its consequences !


So when the people came to worship those calves, & you really need to understand what was in their hearts ! They were not worshiping a pagan god - those calves represented in their hearts, Yahweh, because of what Jeroboam had taught them they were. They sincerely thought in their hearts, that they were worshiping Yahweh.


Well, it's important to note that Yahweh wasn't pleased with this - He wasn't impressed by this new direction that Jeroboam was leading the people, so Yahweh sent a prophet from Judah to confront Jeroboam. It was on a day that Jeroboam was at the altar that he had built, & he was burning incense when the prophet, a young man came into the city. We're not even told what the prophet’s name is, but the prophet came just as Jeroboam was standing there burning incense, & actingall spiritual”, in front of the people (1 Kings 13:1).


When, this prophet confronts Jeroboam – he, the prophet, cried against the altar in the words of Yahweh (1 Kings 13:2), and said “o altar thus saith Yahweh; behold a child shall be born into the house of David; Josiah by name and upon you shall he offer the priest of the high places that burn incense upon you and men's bones shall he burn upon you”.


The prophet continued, “and he gave a sign the same day saying, this is the sign which Yahweh hath spoken; behold the altar shall be rent and the ashes that are upon it shall be poured”.


Please check our fourth careful note :


This prophet represents those whose faith, is a Bible-based faith.

 

Again, what is written in the Bible, is the Word of Yahweh. This prophet’s faith is based on what Yahweh says, & he is doing what Yahweh had said. Don’t we want to know what Yahweh said, & don’t we want to do what He said we should do, no matter how difficult life is going to be - don’t we want a life, based on Yahweh's words ?


This prophet was not there to go along with the teachings of Jeroboam - he was not there to find out the newest instructions of the priest that Jeroboam had appointed - he wasn't there to participate with Jeroboam in his new feast, or to learn from Jeroboam how this golden calf could represent Yahweh. The prophet’s life and his actions are based on what Yahweh had said.


It is extremely important that we see the picture exactly as it is presented to us. Jeroboam had deceived his people into thinking that they can worship Yahweh, their way. Jeroboam had established his & his people’s own holy day - he had brought in pagan symbols, & he has reassigned new meaning to them, so that the people now think that it's okay to use those images as they seek to worship Yahweh.


When you confront someone for not keeping a commandment, or something about their belief, don’t they say “Yahweh knows my heart” ? Let me explain - these people are not seeking to worship a pagan deity - they have been told that this pagan thing now represents Yahweh, so in their heart, they would have said to the young Prophet, “we're here to worship Yahweh”.  


The point is you cannot participate in pagan activities, and say, & believe that is worship of Yahweh.


See the picture here - the “many” are following Jeroboam, while the young prophet stands by himself. What did Yahushua tell us ? Didn’t He say that “many” will be deceived ? Again, aren’t the “many” following Jeroboam ?


May I stress again, Yahweh sends a prophet to warn the people that they are being deceived by Jeroboam, and by the priests that he's hired - the prophet did not come in and participate, because his life is governed by what Yahweh has said - he cannot join in, and participate in the false holy day - he cannot join in, and seek to praise Yahweh through that golden calf, and he cannot burn incense at that altar !


Why - because his faith is a Bible-based faith - his faith is based on what Yahweh says, and he know that Yahweh forbad every bit of what Jeroboam & his people are doing. The prophet does what Yahweh says do - he represents “the few”.


Again, the prophet walks up to the altar where Jeroboam is burning incense, and speaks to the altar.

From his lofty position Jeroboam points at the prophet and says, “seize him”. At this point then, three things happened. One, men moved immediately to do what the king said, namely, to seize that Prophetsecond, the altar rent in two, and the ashes that were on it, poured out, & three, Jeroboam’s hand seized up - it locked in place as he tried to draw it back.


Jeroboam is trying to get his hand and arm to work normally, but they won't come. His intention was to have that prophet seized, & at the very least run out of town, possibly imprisoned, more than likely killed, but Jeroboam has got a problem – he can’t control his hand & arm. When the men bring the young prophet in front of him, Jeroboam said to the prophet – do you think you could pray for me, & ask Yahweh to fix my hand & arm. The young prophet prayed to Yahweh, and Yahweh released his arm & his hand.


Now, Jeroboam said thank you, and asks the young prophet to come home with him today. Jeroboam says, “I invite you to come & refresh yourself, and I want to give you a reward”. The prophet says, “I will not go to your home even if you promise me half of your house - I will not eat bread nor will I drink water in this place, and I will not return home the same way that I came” (1 Kings 13:7-8).


Please note - there were many people there, supposedly worshiping Yahweh. Jeroboam is the king - everybody there who heard what this young prophet just said to the King, thinks the young Prophet is  certifiably crazy. Who in the right mind would tell a king, no - who would refuse to go to the king’s house - who would refuse to be refreshed at the king’s house - who would refuse the king’s food - who would refuse to sit down and have dinner with the king, and why would you go home a different way ? The young prophet sounded crazy to everybody that heard him. The “many” thought they had to think that he must be part of some strange cult, to act in such a weird way, because there's not a one of them standing there, that would have said no, to what was the king was saying.


But the young Prophet wasn't crazy - instead his life & his faith were all based on the Word of Yahweh.


It's worth pausing here to note that sometimes when you are around the “manywho have been deceived, that you are going to be the strange one – the “many” are going to think you are really odd or weird. Why ? Because they are the “many” who are deceived, and you are part of the “few”, who are living your life & faith, based on Yahweh’s Word !


Back to our story.


The prophet boldly walks away, & heads back towards Judah on a different route just like he said he would, & as he had been instructed by Yahweh.


Now there is an old prophet in the northern kingdom who was not at the altar that day, but his sons were, and they came running home after witnessing this incident. They say to their father, the old prophet, “dad, you're not going believe what happened at church today – today this prophet from Judah came up & spoke a curse on the altar that king Jeroboam had built, and he, the prophet, did it while Jeroboam was burning incense - the prophet prophesied that the altar would split & the ashes would spill, & it happened just like he said it would. The king was angry & commanded that the prophet be seized, but then the King's hand went all crazy, & then the prophet prayed, and the king's hand was restored, and dad, this is the crazy part, the king invited this prophet to his house for a meal, and a reward, and the prophet said no”.


The old prophet asked his sons which way did the prophet go, and they told him, and the old prophet said "saddle me a donkey," and they did. The old prophet got on his donkey, & he took off in the direction they said, and soon he came upon that young prophet sitting under an oak tree. The old prophet asked him, “are you the man of Yahweh that came up from Judah”, and the young prophet said, “I am”.


The old prophet said "come home with me and eat bread". It was evident that this young man was tired and weary, & he was famished. He is sitting under an oak tree, & he's thirsty - he's hungry - he's fatigued. The old prophet says, "come home with me and eat bread", but this young man's life is governed by the Word of Yahweh, not by his needs or his circumstances - he doesn't live by bread alone, he lives by every word that proceeds out of the mouth of Yahweh. So he says to the old prophet that “I may not return with you, nor go in with you, neither will I eat bread nor drink water with you in this place, for it was said to me by the Word of Yahweh, ‘you shall eat no bread nor drink water there nor turn again to go by the way that you came’".


So again, the young prophet’s life, his actions, & his decisions are based on what Yahweh said, and that is the way of life that is the path of life - that's what keeps you safe ! The young man understands that he cannot be influenced by kings - he understands he cannot be influenced by the majority, the “many”, and he understands that he cannot be influenced by other prophets.


Then it happened that old prophet said to the young man, I'm a prophet too, just like you - I amanointed” - I'm here because I had an angel appear to me - the angel said “I’ve got a word for you from Yahweh. That angel said, I'm to bring you back to my house, and give you something to eat".


Now put yourself again in the young prophet’s position - he's hungry - he's thirsty - he's got a long way to go to get back home, & he's not so arrogant to believe that he's the only prophet that follows Yahweh. This old prophet said an angel appeared - that's a sign & a wonder - this prophet said that Yahweh said so.


No doubt the young prophet had start thinking, well this is awesome ! It makes sense. The young prophet could very well be thinking that “Yahweh was just testing me to see if I'd obey Him or not, and now that He knows I'll obey Him, surely He doesn't want me to walk all the way back home without something to eat, and something to drink, & surely He sent this prophet so that I could go to his house, not the wicked Jeroboam”. So he said, no, I'm going to go to the old prophet, the anointed one’s house, and I'll eat with him.


The young prophet shouted halleluyah, & went to the old prophet’s home. They sat down and talked about all the great things that Yahweh had done that day - they ate a meal, and while they're eating their meal, the Word of Yahweh came to the old prophet, and he cried unto the man of Yahweh that came up from Judah, and he said to him – “thus saith Yahweh, for as much as you have disobeyed the mouth of Yahweh, and have not kept the commandment which your Elohim commanded you, but came back, and you've eaten bread, and drunk water in this place, of which Yahweh did say unto you, eat no bread, and drink no water, your carcass shall not come into the burial place of your father - you'll never make it back home”.


Now, here is the thing :


1:  the old prophet lied about the angel,

2:  the old prophet lied about the message, and

3:  the old prophet looked that young prophet in the eye, and said “Yahweh said”, when Yahweh did not say.


The young prophet made one fatal mistake - many people get deceived because they make the very same mistake, this young man made.


Do you know what mistake that is ? I want you think on it, & let me finish the story.


The young man got up, & he left the old prophet’s house. He started home, but he didn't get very far - what happened - a lion killed him.


Let’s look carefully at the fifth note :


The old prophet represents those that Yahushua warned us about - those who would claim to represent him, & be “anointed”, and deceive “many.

 

So what mistake did that young prophet make, that moved his faith, from being a bible-based faith, to being a faith that led him to destruction ? What error, & what mistake did he make ?


The error that he made that leads “many” into the broad way that leads to destruction is this :


He was deceived into believing that Yahweh can say something, and then, alter what He said.

Let me write it again, he was deceived into believing that Yahweh can say something, and then, alter what He said - that is the deception, that leads to every other deception.


A person has to first be deceived there, before he can be deceived into believing the lies of Satan -they have to believe that Yahweh said something, and then can alter what He said !


Read what Yahweh wrote in Psalm 89:34 - “my covenant will I not break - nor alter the thing that's gone out of my lips”.


Read what Malachi wrote in Mal 3:6for I am Yahweh - I change not”.


The word translated as “change” in Mal 3:6, is the same word that was translated “alter” in Psalm 89:34, so Yahweh says that He will not change, & what comes out of his lips can’t be altered - He says I do not change, and what I say does not change !


How much more clear can Yahweh be ?

 

Contrast this young prophet that we've been talking about in 1 Kings chapters 12 & 13, with Peter in Acts 10. Peter, who was also hungry (Acts 10:10), saw a vision of unclean animals, and he heard a voice that said to him, “rise Peter, kill, & eat”. What did Peter do ? He refused to do it. Why did Peter refuse to “rise, kill and eat” when he has had a vision - he's seen the unclean things descending - he hears a voice that says “rise Peter, kill, and eat”. Why did Peter refuse to do that ?


Peter understood what this young prophet failed to understand  ! When Yahweh says something, He will never alter the thing that He said. Peter understood that Yahweh had said in Leviticus 11, “do not eat unclean animals because it is not food”, and so he understood in the vision that he was having that, he's hearing a voice, but he knew that that voice was not Yahweh's voice, or anybody that represented Yahweh, because of what he understood about Lev 11. Peter knew that the voice he heard in the vision, was not a voice that represented Yahweh in any way, & so he rejected it three times, saying “not so, I will not - nothing unclean has ever touched my lips”, & I am not starting today.


Why would Peter be so adamant about not responding to the voice in his vision ? Because he knew that when Yahweh says something, Yahweh will never alter what he saidYahweh will never change it ! That belief kept Peter grounded in his faith.


How can we all find the answers that we all need, when examining our own faith to see if it's a faith that is a Bible-based faith ?


Well, let's begin by simply applying a TEST to see if Yahweh does not change His word.


In Deut 4:2 & Deut 12:32, Yahweh said through Moses that we are not to add to, or take away from Yahweh’s Word. Apart from this meaning that Yahweh doesn’t change what He says, doesn’t adding to, and/or taking away from Yahweh’s Word, weaken it & therefore, change what Yahweh has said ?


What if our denomination creates a different holy day to the seven feasts of Yahweh, & we are told that in our hearts, we are thinking about Messiah Yahushua when we celebrate it ?


Let’s apply a TEST - does Yahweh alter the thing that comes out of his mouth ? Never !


Aaron tried to create a holy day in Exod 32:4-5, separate to the seven feasts of Yahweh – he told the people, it was “a feast to Yahweh” – Yahweh was extremely angry, & wanted to wipe out all of Israel for their disobedience, & start again just with Moses (Exod 32:10).

 

As we know, Jeroboam tried to create a holy day that was separate from the seven feasts that Yahweh had established - it caused the destruction of the ten tribes in the northern kingdom.


Aren’t men still doing it too – didn’t it take decades to instil Christmas into being an acceptable holy day in the Church 


It wasn't that long ago, a church wouldn't dare let you bring a seder into the sanctuary of a Church. Didn’t it take decades to instil this into the Christian faith, and the only way it got instilled into the Christian faith, was that people got deceived into believing that Yahweh has changed his mind about it ?


It actually took centuries to instil Easter into the Christian faitharen’t several denominations now working on adding Halloween and Valentine's day as well ?


It is relatively simple to TEST whether your faith is a Bible-based faith, by going to Yahweh’s Word, & comparing, what you are doing or not doing, with what Yahweh tells you to do or not do in His Word.


Today, many Christian denominations claim that they don't have to keep the seven feasts of Yahweh.


Let’s TEST this.


Q: Does Yahweh ever change what He says in Lev 23 ?

A:  If we really believe that Yahweh’s Word is the inspired (influenced), inerrant, unchanging, revealed and written word of Elohim, then based on Ps 89:34 & Mal 3:6, No !


Yahweh says in Lev 23, “these are my feasts”. So if you're going to worship Yahweh, guess what, they are “His” perpetual feasts ! Yahweh clearly said that we're to observe them, so if our faith is a Bible-based faith, that is, based on what Yahweh said, then isn’t it obvious, that we cannot claim that He changed his mind.


Suppose your denomination claims that you do not have to keep the Sabbath anymore, by making largely unsubstantiated statements, & the denomination’s representatives use the following reasoning. I have attempted to be fair by copying, and/or quoting two people who write that keeping the Sabbath is no longer required. My question - is this a Bible-based logic ?


Justin Taylor, from  https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/blogs/justin-taylor/schreiner-qa-is-the-sabbath-still-required-for-christians/ writes in part :  

 

"The Sabbath was given to Israel as a covenant sign, and Israel was commanded to rest on the seventh day. We see elsewhere in the Old Testament that covenants have signs, so that the sign of the Noahic covenant is the rainbow (Gen. 9:8–17) and the sign of the Abrahamic covenant is circumcision (Gen. 17). The paradigm for the Sabbath was God’s rest on the seventh day of creation (Gen. 2:1–3)". 


"I do not believe the Sabbath is required for believers now that the new covenant has arrived in the person of Jesus Christ"


I believe this quote from Justin Taylor is from Heb 12:24, which is one of only three verses in the Renewed Covenant (NT), where this phrase is used. The other two are in Heb 8:8-13, which is a direct quote from Jer 31:31-33. My understanding of what Mr Taylor writes, is that (a) he in making a statement (underlined), with no evidence or explanation, & (b) he doesn’t seem to know what  thenew covenantis ? If you simply read Heb 8:8-13, anyone can clearly see that it has absolutely nothing to do with Sabbath.


Another argument put forward to claim that you do not have to keep the Sabbath comes from the following website :


https://www.equip.org/article/should-we-keep-the-sabbath/


In it James Borland (JB) writes :


Can one say for sure that God has abrogated (done away with) the command to keep the Sabbath? Yes. In many respects God has changed His commands and laws


Borland claims that “one clear illustration of God’s changing laws regards the eating of meat.” He uses Gen 2:16-17 to claim that people before the flood ate a vegetarian diet, but that after the flood, God changed His mind, & said in Gen 9:3, that people could now eat meat”.


JB further claimed that at Mt Sinai, God further restricted the diet of theJews”. JB actually writes, “In Lev 11, God restricted the eating habits of the Jews, only of the Jews”. (Again, a statement made with absolutely no evidence).


Borland goes on to claim that “those Jewish dietary regulations were abolished (after the cross) – This is clearly taught in Peter’s vision (Acts 10:9-16 & 11:5-10), & in Paul’s epistles (Rom 14:2-3, Col 2:16 & 1 Tim 4:3-5)”. JB continues, “in a similar manner, the Sabbath is no longer binding on Christians, (Col 2:16). Christ has freed us from the law”.


JB writes further, & makes the statement, “Christ released us from the Sabbath. His finished work on the cross abolished the entire Mosaic law of ordinances, which includes the Sabbath commandment”.

(Once again, JB writes an unsubstantiated statement). JB writes much more, but I believe what he has written is enough to expose his mistakes & errors.


May I begin by writing that making statements without any evidence to support a faith, is NOT a Bible-based faith ! Wouldn’t you agree ?


In terms of Yahweh changing His laws from a vegetarian diet to one that included meat, I’m not sure that is so, but let’s assume it is. I don’t know about JB’s Elohim, but my Elohim is both logical & loving.


There are several possible reasons for this “supposed” change, but the one that is most obvious to me is that, after the flood, the earth would have been mostly barren & desolate. There may have been some vegetation, but probably not enough for the eight people to survive on for long. While Noah probably had some “potted” plants on the ark as well, they probably weren’t enough to sustain these people, & the clean & unclean animals for very long. Yahweh, my Elohim lovingly took care of both the people & the animals, by making the necessary eating of meat, permissible.

 

Now to the first of several “biblical” errors that JB made.


JB claimed that at Mt Sinai, Yahweh further restricted the diet of the “Jews”. This clearly is a serious error because Yahweh’s Word, in Exodus 12 & several other places, clearly tells us that “the Israelites, all twelve tribes”, were at Mt Sinai to be offered, & for them to accept, Yahweh’s covenant (Exod 19:5-6). The tribe of Judah, later called “Jews” in 2 Kings 16:6, was just one of these twelve tribes of Israel.


JB wrote that “In Lev 11, God restricted the eating habits of the Jews, only of the Jews”. Again, JB has made a serious biblical error. Lev 11:2 tells us, “Speak to the children of Israel”, again, all twelve tribes.


So based on these two biblical errors, JB’s faith can’t be a Bible-based faith !


James Borland later claims that “those Jewish dietary regulations were abolished (after the cross) – This is clearly taught in Peter’s vision (Acts 10:9-16 & 11:5-10), & in Paul’s epistles (Rom 14:2-3, Col 2:16 & 1 Tim 4:3-5)”. JB continues, “in a similar manner, the Sabbath is no longer binding on Christians (Col 2:16). Christ has freed us from the law”. (More statements made without specific evidence).


If we carefully examine Acts 10:9-16, it is obvious, as I pointed out earlier in this study, that Peter knew that Yahweh never changes what comes out of His lips (Ps 89:36), & so he wasn’t influenced by what was spoken to him in his vision. It seems obvious that JB has not carefully read Acts 10:9-16 & Acts 11:5-10).


JB also quotes Rom 14:2-3, verses that seem to deal with “not judging what someone eats”, BUT, in the correct CONTEXT, isn’t it referring to the level of someone’s faith ?


JB also quotes Col 2:16, this time referring to “judging others about “meat or drink, a holyday, a new moon or sabbath days”, But again, isn’t the CONTEXT that the only ones who are qualified to “judge”, are only those who really understand what Yahushua believed, & taught (the body of Messiah), not everyone else ?


Again, JB quotes a verse totally out of CONTEXT, selecting one aspect out of the several things mentioned (seducing spirits, doctrines of devils, lies of hypocrisy, a seared conscience) – doesn’t this strategy almost always results in error ?


Later in his article, JB writes, ”Paul clearly stated that Christ took this “handwriting of requirements” and “nailed it to the cross” (Col 2:14)” adding, “the result could not be clearer”.


Sadly, JB “misquoted” & “misunderstoodCol 2:14 – I’ll explain below. Col 2:14 actually reads :

 

Col 2:14 Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross; (KJV)

Col 2:14 and, by his mandates, he cancelled the legal contract of our sins, which existed against us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to His torture stake. (HRB)

Col 2:14  εξαλειψαςG1813 [G5660] HAVING BLOTTED OUT   τοG3588 THE   καθG2596 AGAINST   ημωνG2257 US  

 χειρογραφονG5498 HANDWRITING   τοιςG3588 IN THE   δογμασινG1378 DECREES,   οG3739 WHICH   ηνG2258 [G5713] WAS   υπεναντιονG5227 ADVERSE   ημινG2254 TO US,   καιG2532 ALSO   αυτοG846 IT   ηρκενG142 [G5758] HE HAS TAKEN   εκG1537 OUT OF   τουG3588 THE   μεσουG3319 MIDST,   προσηλωσαςG4338 [G5660] HAVING NAILED   αυτοG846 IT   τωG3588 TO THE   σταυρωG4716 CROSS;   


Q: What is the meaning of the Greek word, G5498χειρογραφον translated as “handwriting of requirements” that JB quoted 

(legal contract of our sins in the HRB) ?

A:  Strong's Concordance says it means – hand written, a manuscript, document or bond. Thayer says it means – a

     handwriting, what one has written by his own hand.

     It seems fairly clear that, in this context, it is referring to a handwritten document, as the JB tells us.

Q: What hand written document was in opposition to us, (was against us) ?

A:  To shed some more light on this phrase, “handwriting of requirements”, may I direct us to Matt 27:37 or Mark 15:26 ?    

Matt 27:37 And set up over his head his accusation written, THIS IS JESUS THE KING OF THE JEWS. 

Mar 15:26  And the superscription of his accusation was written over, THE KING OF THE JEWS. 


If our faith is a Bible-based faith, shouldn’t we always attempt to understand Yahweh’s Word by examining the cultural aspects & the meaning of words, at the time they were written. Shouldn’t we also allow Scripture to interpret Scripture ?


Q: Historically, what was the written charge (crime) against Yahushua (Jesus) in Matt 27:37 & Mark 15:26 ?

A:  In those days, when a criminal was executed, in this case by crucifixion, the charge against him was written down, & was placed above his head on the torture stake. It was an example of the “handwriting of requirement” against him (in opposition to him).


Q: So how does this information assist us in finding out what the “handwriting of requirements” that was in opposition to us (against us) in Col 2:14 is ?

A:  Rom 3:23 tells us that “for all have sinned and come short of the glory of God” (KJV), &  Rom 6:23 tells us that for the wages sin pays is death” (KJV). 

 

     Doesn’t that mean that, as a result of each person’s sin, each person’s sin/offense deserves death (eternal death) ?


     If this is so, then based on the culture & thinking of the people at the time Col 2:14 was penned, their “offenses” were “written” in a sense - there would be a “written chargeagainst them for “their crime, their sina description of the debt that each person owes, because they have sinned ?


     Doesn’t it make much more sense, that the “handwriting of requirements” of Col 2:14, was the written description of the crime we have committed against Yahweh, by our sinning ?

     Surely, it was this “handwriting of requirements”, the one that accused us of the sins we have committed, that “He took it out of the way, nailing it (the written charge for our sins),to his cross (KJV).


     Doesn’t this also mean that, if the “moral standards” was not taken out of the way by nailing them to the torture stake, then “moral standards”, including the Sabbath, must still exist, & therefore need to be kept.


James Borland, based on what he has written, has certainly believed lies ! Because he has believed lies, isn’t it true that he must have been “deceived” by someone, at some time ?


I am always amazed that Christians like James Borland can’t seem to read what is clearly written in Yahweh’s Word. This being the case, how can they claim that their faith is a Bible-based faith - are they so “married” to their man-imposed doctrine, that they don’t have “eyes to see”, or a “heart to want to do Yahweh’s will ?


If we examine Matt 5:17-19, aren’t we told very specifically, that :


1:  Yahushua said “do not think He has come to destroy the law (Torah) or the Prophets

2:  He came to “fulfil” (them). Here is the really, really clear statement from the mouth of Messiah Yahushua.

3:  Yahushua continues saying, “for verily I say unto you. Till heaven & earth pass, not one jot or tittle

     shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled

 

Mat 5:17 Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil. 

Mat 5:18 For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled. 

Mat 5:19 Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 


If we simply read what Yahushua says in these verses, how can this be any clearer ?


Those who rise up, and tell you that they are “anointed”, and that “they represent the Messiah”, and then tell us that Yahweh changed what He said, are seriously deceived and/or, are lying to you because Yahweh never changes what he says.


How can you know that somebody's deceived and/or is lying to you, when they tell you that you don't have to keep the Sabbath anymore - how can you know that somebody's deceived and/or lying to you, when they say, “well those feasts listed back there in Old Testament are for the Jews”, & because we aren’t Jews, we don't have to keep those anymore ? Again, how do you know that they're deceived and/or lying to you when they make these claims about any such subject ? Well, clearly, Ps 89:34 tells us that Yahweh will not alter any things that has gone out from His lips, & Mal 3:6, tells us that Yahweh doesn’t change.


So let me state it once again, if you believe that Yahweh alters what He says, & that He actually can change, then that's the deception, that leads to all deception. Wasn’t that what the serpent said to Eve in Genesis chapter 3 ?


From our story above, we know that Jeroboam reassigned meaning to pagan images & pagan rituals.


Let's apply the TEST to see if that is biblical-based & therefore, acceptable to Yahweh by checking  Deut 12:29-30 & Jer 10:2.

 

Deu 12:29 When the LORD thy God shall cut off the nations from before thee, whither thou goest to possess them, and thou succeedest them, and dwellest in their land; 

Deu 12:30 Take heed to thyself that thou be not snared by following them, after that they be destroyed from before thee; and that thou enquire not after their gods, saying, How did these nations serve their gods? even so will I do likewise. 

 

Jer 10:2 So says YAHWEH, Do not learn the way of the nations


So, based on Yahweh’s Word just quoted, anytime somebody says “yes, this was pagan, but I do it now in my heart for Yahweh", they have been deceived and/or, they've been lied to - they've been convinced into believing that they can reassign it another meaning, and worship Yahweh with it ! If your faith is a bible-based faith, then you cannot do it, because Yahweh never alters His Word, and in Jer 10:2,  He said, “do not learn the ways of the nations”.


There is nothing that any pagan has ever used to worship their elohim, (god), that Yahweh wants to be used to worship Him - you cannot reassign the meaning of Sunday worship - you cannot reassign the meaning of a decorated, evergreen tree - you cannot reassign the meaning of December 25th - you cannot reassign the meaning of the first Sunday after the first full moon, after the vernal equinox, which was dedicated to Ishtar the Babylonian fertility deity (Easter), and say that it now represents the resurrection if your faith is a Bible-based faith, you cannot do it !

 

If your faith is a Bible based faith then you do what Yahweh says, not what men say. I told you Jeroboam represents “religion” - he represents denominations - he represents those who have established their own Commandments, holy days and traditions.


People should examine their faith and see if their faith is based on “religion” - if their faith is based on a denomination’s traditions - if their faith is based on the commandments of mendo they keep the holy days established by men, or the holy days established by Yahweh - do they keep the commandments of men,  & tell their congregation,you don't have to keep the law”, do they obey man, or do they obey Yahweh. Do you believe the Bible is the Word of Yahweh, and if you do believe it's the Word of Yahweh, why are you ignoring,it,  & if you are, is it because some man told you that you could ?


The young prophet from Judah represents a faith that is a Bible based faith. What we see in him until he falls, is that when your faith is a Bible based faith, you're going look different, sound different, & act different - you're not going to fit in with the “many” - you're not going to fit in with a crowd - you will even sometimes look weird. People will think you are rude when you decline to participate in Christmas, when you turn down their bacon-wrapped filet mignon, but you're not trying to be rude, you're not trying to be weird, you're merely living your faith based on what Yahweh is said in the Word. You believe that it's really His Word, and it never changes, and that you should keep it.


Lastly, the old prophet represents those that Yahushua warned us about in Matt 24:4-5. They will claim to be “anointed”, but they will deceivemany”. They will be very convincing when they tell people to do what Yahweh said not to do, and to not do what Yahweh said to do !


Yahushua warned His disciples & us - He said “they're going to come say they’re 'anointed', & 'many' are going to be deceived, even as the young prophet was. Yahushua also warned us four times in Matt chapter 24 (verses 4,5 11 & 24), & again in Mark 12:5-6, & in Luke 21:8.


Paul warned us aboutnot being deceived”, at least seven times (Rom 7:11 & 16:18, 1 Cor 3:18 & 6:9, Eph 5:6, Gal 6:7, 2 Thes 2:3). John also warns us once in 1 John 3:7.


The spirit of deception is the strongest reason why Yahushua, Paul & John gave us those warnings !


If our faith is based on what Yahweh said, then we go by what is written, because all Scripture is breathed out by Yahweh. Is your faith really a Bible based faith - is it really based on what Yahweh said, or have you been deceived ?


If you have been deceived, then fix it while you can, because the path of deception is a broad way that leads to destruction - if you've ever been taught to ignore any part of the Bible - to believe what you believe, you have been, and you are being deceived,  & if you have to alter any part of the Bible, to believe what you believe, your faith can't be a Bible-based faith ! .


Can it be any plainer than this – again, if you have been, and you are being deceived,repent”, & fix it now, while there is still time, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.


What I am attempting to do is, to alert and alarm us all, about that strong delusion, that strong spirit of deception. I know this  because people can get fighting mad at you, and tell you "I worship Yahweh", and "I believe the Bible"  When you ask, do you keep the Sabbath - no; do you pig - yes; do you  eat shrimp - yes; do you keep the feasts -  no; & they say, but the Bible says I don't have to do that anymore, that is a deception that has been put on people, that began with a man claiming to represent the Messiah -  a man who said he was anointed, and who convinced people saying, "it's too much for you to have to do all of that". We're in a new dispensation, & you don't have to keep all that stuff anymore". I've been deceived, & so I TEST everything anyone says, to see if it is "Bible-based". I was no pleased at the time, but I am so glad that someone confronted me about some of the things that I had believed, & so thankful that Yahweh, in His mercy, pointed me to very carefully, read & study, His written Word.


I strongly encourage each person reading this, to very carefully TEST what they currently believe, so that they won't wind up on judgment day, with Yahushua saying, "depart from Me, I never knew you". I want to be confident that my faith is a Bible-based faith !



Followers of the Messiah - some thought-provoking questions for truth-seekers

About ten years ago, we came to the critical realisation that, we never wanted to "disbelieve" Yahweh's (God's) truth, and that at the same time, we never wanted to believe a lie! We are sure that most sincere, truth-seeking Christians have that same conviction. It was this realisation, that spurred us on to become serious Bible students, an endeavor that we truly enjoy & cherish. We are amazed how deep the Word of Elohim (God) is!


If you are a Christian, you may believe that:


1:  The Church "replaced" Israel, and in particular the Jews, and that grace has "replaced" the law (the Torah of the Old Testament), and


2:  You are "under grace", and "not under the law", & that "the law" has been done-way with.


If these are your beliefs, then we challenge you to HONESTLY address, and/or answer, ALL the following questions. If you cannot address and/or answer these questions, perhaps you can ask your pastor, minister, or priest? Either way, you must TRUTHFULLY answer these questions, and if you cannot, then we believe that you may been have been DECEIVED!


"When a man or woman is honestly mistaken and hears the truth, they will either quit being mistaken, or they will cease to be honest." Unknown. 


It is our desire that you the reader will find the following questions stimulating & interesting. 

If you would like to ask any questions, or need more information, please contact Peter at :

askseekknockandtest@gmail.com


What is your understanding and/or description of the Bible ?

Our Response to Question 1

We believe that the Bible (the Tanach & the Renewed Covenant known as the Old Testament & the New Testament, respectively) is the inspired (influenced), revealed, inerrant, unchanging, written Word of the Creator.

Some of it is the actual spoken & written word of Yahweh (God), and Yahushua (you may know Him as Jesus). Much of it is written by men who were guided, motivated, influenced and stimulated by Elohim (God) to write what they wrote.

Surely, it is only "inspired" in the original languages, & in the original context. There is no such thing as an "inspired" translation.

I believe that we must ALWAYS study Yahweh’s Word in the original CONTEXT (cultural, social, historical, linguistic and literary), since it was written TO the original audience, but was written FOR us.

    Isn't it true that,  Yahweh’s Word says what it says;
            not what I think it says,
                        not what I believe it says,
                                    not what I’d like it to say,
                                                not what others say it says, and
                                                            not necessarily what I’ve been taught that it says !  

Conclusion – If we want to read and “understand” what the Bible is really telling us, it is essential to :

1: compare the verse studied with several versions of the Bible (this is easily done using the excellent, free Bible software, e-Sword from http://www.e-sword.net/   

2: use several concordances/dictionaries to study the meanings of specific Hebrew words

What is Biblical TRUTH ?

Our Response to Question 2

Webster's 1828 Dictionary defines 'Truth' as "conformity to fact or reality; exact accordance with that which is, or has been, or shall be'.
Isn't this a person's, a man's, definition ?

Can we accept or trust a man's definition, for Yahweh's, His biblical TRUTH ? Shouldn't we refer to Yahweh's Word for HIS definition of His TRUTH ?

There are many scriptural verses that use the word, TRUTH. There are however, only a few that actually tell us what TRUTH is.

These verses are :

John 14:6, Ps 119:142, & Ps 119:151

Joh 14:6 Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the TRUTH, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.

Joh 17:17 Sanctify them through your TRUTH; your word is TRUTH.

Psa 119:142 Your righteousness is an everlasting righteousness, and your law (Torah) is the TRUTH.

Psa 119:151 Thou art near, O LORD; and all your commandments are TRUTH.

Psa 119:160 Your word is TRUE from the beginning: and every one of your righteous judgments endureth for ever.

Based on the above scriptures, isn't it correct & accurate to say :

Yahushua (Jesus) is the TRUTH
Yahweh's Word is TRUTH and is TRUE
Yahweh's Torah (law) is the TRUTH
All Yahweh's Commandments are TRUTH ?

When we read Matt 7:22-23, we see that Yahushua (Jesus) is extremely critical of a certain group of people. Have you ever carefully considered who this group of people could be, & why Yahushua says these seemingly "harsh" words to them ? Mat 7:22 Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in your name? and in your name have cast out devils? and in your name done many wonderful works ? Mat 7:23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, you that work iniquity. (KJV)

Our Response to Question 4

Can we eliminate the groups of people who do not prophesy, do not cast out devils, & do not do many wonderful works, in Yahushua's name ?
I'm thinking of atheists, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus, & so on. Do you agree ?

Isn't it reasonable to think that the only group of people who do these things are Christians ? Who else could they be ?

So why does Yahushua tell them, "I never knew you: depart from Me" ?
Doesn't He tell them the reason in verse 23, where He says, "ye that work iniquity" ?

What is "iniquity" ? If we check the Greek word translated as "iniquity" in the KJV, we find it is G458, anomia, which can mean illegality or violation of the law (law-less-ness).

What "law" is being violated by those who prophesy, cast out devils & do many wonderful works, in Yahushua's name ?

In the context of Yahushua's time, surely, it can only be, the written law of Moses (the first five books of the Bible) ?

These days, there are a lot of persuasive teachers around. Isn’t it true that many of these teachers are extremely convincing ? How then do you really know, that what you have read or listen to, or what you have been taught or believed, is true, accurate, and correct ?

Our Response to Question 3

Isn't it true that, the only way to really know whether the information we have been taught & have believed, or have read or heard, is true, accurate & correct, is to TEST it, by carefully examining ALL the evidence we can find about that information?

What is sin ?

Our Response to Question 5

Webster's 1828 Dictionary records that 'sin' is "the voluntary departure of a moral agent from a known rule of rectitude or duty, prescribed by God; any voluntary transgression of the divine law, or violation of a divine command; a wicked act; iniquity".

Let's compare this man-determined definition with three witnesses from Scripture .

1Jn 3:4 Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law.

Rom 7:7 What shall we say then? Is the law sin? God forbid. Nay, I had not known sin, but by the law: for I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet.

Rom 3:20  Therefore by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight: for by the law is the knowledge of sin.

Q: What is 'the law', mentioned by John & Paul in the above scriptures ?

A: Let's see what others write about 'the law', as used in these verses.

We need to do this because, there are at least 15 different uses of the Greek word, nomos, translated in the Renewed Covenant (NT) - refer to the list below.

www.bibleref.com writes that "Lawlessness was associated with those who broke the Law of Moses (the Torah), and were therefore sinners".

www.bibletools.org writes "a clear definition of sin: the attitude and practice of breaking God's laws."

Doesn't this evidence clearly show that SIN, is the breaking of Yahweh's (God's) laws, His Torah ?

Renewed Covenant uses of the Greek word, nomos, translated as 'law'.

1) The Law (Matt 5:17, Luke 10:26, John 7:49, Acts 6:13, and over 100 others
2) The Law and the Prophets (Luke 16:6, Acts 13:15)
3) The Law of YHWH (Luke 2:23, Romans 7:25; 8:7)
4) The Law of Moses (Luke 24:44)
5) The Law of Sin (Romans 7:23)
6) The Law of Sin and Death (Romans 8:2)
7) The Law of the Spirit of Life (Romans 8:2)
8) The Law of Faith (Romans 3:27)
9) The Law of Righteousness (Romans 9:31, 10:4)
10) The Law of Messiah (1 Corinthians 9:21)
11) The law of her husband (Rom 7:2)
12) The law of your fathers (Acts 22:3)
13) The law of the Jews (Acts 25:8)
14) The law of my mind (Acts 7:23)

While 1 John 3:4, Rom 7:2 & Gal 3:19 simply mentions ‘the law’, its context based on Deut 31:26, indicates that it, the book of the law (Torah), was placed outside the Ark of the Covenant.

Heb 7:11, 12, 28 also plainly refer to the Levitical Law whereby men were made high priests.

James 1:25 mentions the ‘perfect law of liberty’, while James 2:8 refers to the ‘royal law’.

Gal 5:3 and James 2:10 both mention the ‘whole law’.

What are the ten commandments, as determined by the Catholic Church ?

The ten commandments as are written at :
http://www.catholicity.com/catechism/the_ten_commandments.html,
are :
1: "I am the Lord your God you shall not have strange Gods before me"
(Ex 20:2-6, Deut 5:6-10)
2: "You shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain" (Ex 20:7-8,
Deut 5:11-12)
3: "Remember to keep holy the Lord's Day" (Ex 20:8-11, Deut 5:12-15)
4: "Honor your father and your mother" (Ex 20:12, Deut 5:16)
5: "You shall not kill" (Ex 20:13, Deut 5:17)
6: "You shall not commit adultery" (Ex 20:14, Deut 5:18)
7: "You shall not steal" (Ex 20:15, Deut 5:19)
8: "You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor" (Ex 20:16, Deut 5:20)
9: "You shall not covet your neighbor's wife" (Ex 20:17, Deut 5:21)
10:"You shall not covet your neighbor's goods" (Ex 20:17, Deut 5:21)

When we check Exod 20:2-6 in the Jerusalem Bible, (The Catholic Bible), it reads :

Exo 20:2 I am YAHWEH your God, who has brought you out from the land of Egypt, from the house of slavery.
Exo 20:3 You shall not have any other gods except me.
Exo 20:4 You shall not make a carved image or any likeness of anything in heaven or on earth beneath or in the waters under the earth;
Exo 20:5 you shall not bow to them, and you shall not serve them; for I am YAHWEH your God, am a jealous God, and I will punish the father's faults in the sons, the grandso
ns, and the great-grandsons,
Exo 20:6 to those that hate Me; but I show kindness to thousands of those who love me, and keep My commandments.


I understand that the first Catholic commandment is a combination of Exod 20:1 & Exod 20:2, & that that Exod 20:17 has been divided into two separate commandments.

Q: Why has the Catholic Church, as is written in catholicity.com, left Exod 20:4
out of its Ten Commandments ?
A: It seems to us, that verse 4 has been omitted, because the Catholic Church actually breaks this commandment by having statues of their various "saints" in most, if not all of their church buildings.

Q: Isn't this a violation of Deut 4:2 & Deut 12:32, which tell us we are not to add to, nor take way from, what is written in Yahweh's Word ?

In doing this, removing some of Yahweh's Word, isn't the Catholic Church deceiving its members, & in fact, has lied to them about what Yahweh's ten commandments are ?





When does the Catholic Church tell us is Messiah Yahushua's (Jesus') birthday ?

The website, http://www.catholic.org/national/national_story.php?id=22329, tells us that :
"Dec. 25 offered a date with a good theological basis that also would counter several pagan holidays. Although we don't know the final steps, in 336 A.D., the church at Rome officially observed the "birth day of Christ" Dec. 25."

Have you ever really examined this teaching ? Yahushua could not possibly have been born on December 25, since that is the middle of winter in Israel. The shepherds would not be in the fields then. Also back-tracking through Luke 1, the story of Elizabeth & Zachariah tells us that, Yahushua was most likely born around the biblical feast of Sukkot (September-ish, based on Lev 23:24-25).

Q: Why would the Catholic Church arrive at such a conclusion, when clearly, they had (and have), the ability to determine more accurately when Yahushua was born ?

Q: Are you aware, that December 25, was at the time of Constantine, a major pagan feast to "Sol Invictus", the sun god ?

Q: Isn't this a violation of Deut 4:2 and 12:32 - adding to the Word of Yahweh ? Despite what "catholic.org" writes, there doesn’t seem to be any theological basis for this conclusion !

Isn’t the above information about Yahushua’s birthday, as quoted by the Catholic Church, a LIE ?

The Catholic Church teaches "All interpretation (of Scripture) is subject to the Church and exegetes must help the Church form a firmer judgment". (http://www.catholicity.com) Is this teaching based on biblical principles ?

While we appreciate that in the past, the laity of the Catholic Church had almost no access to the Scriptures, to Yahweh's Word, we cannot make that statement today. With the invention of the printing press, and the today's Internet's resources, people have  easy access to many different versions of the Bible, including Hebrew & Greek Interlinears and dictionaries, in free software programs such as e-Sword.

To answer the question as to whether this teaching of the Catholic Church is biblical, there are at least three Renewed Covenant (NT) scriptures that explain what individuals are to do.

Acts 17:10-15 tells us about Paul's visit to Berea. In verse 11, it reads :

Acts 17:11   Here the Jews were more noble-minded than those in Thessalonica, and they welcomed the word very readily; every day they (the Bereans) studied the scriptures (the Tanach OT) to check whether it was true.

1 Thes 5:21 tells us to "test or prove all things" (We notice this verse is not in the Jersualem (Catholic) Bible - I wonder why it has been removed. It is in the New Jerusalem Bible though).

1 Thessalonians 5:21   test everything and hold on to what is good.

2 Tim 2:15, in the King James Version reads :

And study to present yourself approved to YAHWEH, a workman unashamed, rightly dividing the Word of Truth.

The Jerusalem Bible does not tell us this. It reads :

Do all you can to present yourself in front of God as a man who has come through his trials, and a man who has no cause to be ashamed.

This translation is NOT rendered from the Greek manuscript. We wonder why
not ?

Phil 2:12-13 & Matt 24:13 tell us that our salvation is a personal endeavour. Each person is responsible for his or her own salvation. Yes, the Catholic Church can assist, but it is each  individual who must work for their salvation.

Phil 2:12-13 tells us :

12 So, my dear friends, you have always been obedient; your obedience must not be limited to times when I am present. Now that I am absent it must be more in evidence, so work out your salvation in fear and trembling.  
13 It is God who, for his own generous purpose, gives you the intention and the powers to act.


Matt 24:13 tells us :

... the man who stands firm to the end will be saved

Isn't it true that, based on the above Scripture verses, this Catholic teaching is not based on biblical principles ? I wonder if you can explain why not ?

What does the Catholic Church teach on its "infallibility", & is this teaching, valid ?

https://www.catholic.org/encyclopedia/view.php?id=6099 makes the following statement about "Infallibility" :

"In general , exemption or immunity from liability to error or failure; in particular in theological usage, the supernatural prerogative by which the Church of Christ is, by a special Divine assistance, preserved from liability to error in her definitive dogmatic teaching regarding matters of faith and morals".

In doing this, doesn't the Catholic Church, ignore and/or contradict Scripture, which clearly states in Ps 89:34, that "Yahweh will not alter the thing that is gone out of His lips", & in Mal 3:6, that "Yahweh does not change".


Psa 89:34  My covenant will I not break, nor alter the thing that is gone out of my lips

Mal 3:6  For I am the LORD, I change not; 

Is the Catholic Church aware of the fact that many of its practices are of a pagan origin, & if so, why has the Catholic Church adopted such scripturally forbidden practices ?

Here is a direct quote from a book written by the Catholic Cardinal, John Henry Newman. In chapter 8 of his "Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine", published in 1878, Newman writes :
"The rulers of the Church from early times were prepared, should the occasion  arise, to adopt, to imitate, or to sanctify the existing rites and customs of the population, as well as the philosophy of the educated class. The use of temples and those dedicated to particular saints, and ornamented on occasion with branches of trees (wreaths), incense, lamps, candles, votive offerings on recovery from illness, holy water, holy days and seasons (the entire Church calendar), use of calendars, processions, blessings on the field, sacerdotal vestments, the ring in marriage, chants, the Kyrie Eleison - are all of Pagan origin, and sanctified by adoption into the Church".  (emphasis added)

Clearly, the Catholic Church is well aware of its pagan origins.

Even a cursory reading of Scripture will tell us that Yahweh "hates" unauthorized mixtures. On many occasions in His Word, He elects, divides and then separates. Examples include Gen 1:4, when He separated light and darkness, Lev 11:47 where He separates the clean from the unclean, and Gen 25:23 where Yahweh chose Jacob as His first-born, even though Esua was the first to be born of Jacob.

In Deut 8, Moses tells Israel what Yahweh requires of them. In Deut 8:11 Moses reminds Israel to keep Yahweh's commandments, judgments and statutes. In Deut 8:19, Moses tells the Israelites the consequences for "walking after other gods", namely, "you shall utterly perish". Deut 12:8 and Deut 12:30-31 tell us not to get involved with another's god in any way. As well, Deut 4:2 & 12:32 tell us we are not to add to, nor take away from the Word of Yahweh.

So, why has the Catholic Church adopted such scripturally forbidden practices ?
Could it be that the Catholic Church has "strayed" from the original teachings of the Bible, & of the Messiah, they claim to follow ? Is it possible that the Catholic Church bases its doctrines & beliefs on man-determined ideas, & not Yahweh's Word ? Doesn't this practice require urgent examination & questioning ?

If Catholics, according to www.catholic.com/magazine/articles/why-we-are-not-bound-by-everything-in-the-old-law, are not required to keep the Old Law, why did Messiah Yahushua, (1) send the ten lepers that He healed to the priests (Luke 17:14) ? (2) wear tassles/fringes on His outer garment (Matt 9:20) ? Aren't both these activities "Old Law" requirements, where (1) is dealt with in Lev 13:1-27, & (2) is mentioned in Num 15:38 - didn't Messiah Yahushua keep the "old Law" ?

Clearly, Messiah Yahushua guarded the whole of the "Old Law", the Torah, & kept all of it, that He was able to keep (He couldn't keep the priestly commands, nor the commands for women, for example).

In Matt 5:17-19, Messiah Yahushua explains His position on "the Law & the Prophets", where He says :

Mat 5:17 Do not imagine that I came to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I did not come to abolish, but to complete them.
Mat 5:18 I tell you solemnly, til heaven and earth disappear, not one dot or one little stroke, shall disappear from the Law until its purpose is achieved.
Mat 5:19 Therefore, the man who infringes even one of the least of these  commandments, and teaches others to do the same, will be considered least in the kingdom of Heaven, but the man who keeps them and teaches them, will be considered great in the kingdom of Heaven.

Further Comment
In Mat 5:17, the Greek word translated as "complete them" is pleroo. It means to fully teach, to verify, to fully preach or to cram full of meaning, to fill up, or to make full. It does not mean to "complete". The Hebrew word from which this comes is mala (see Gen 1:22), which clearly cannot mean "complete".

Mat 5:18 makes a very serious statement - "til heaven & earth pass away or disappear, not one dot (yod) or one little stroke shall disappear" ! The last time we looked, the earth was still here - it hasn't disappeared ! So doesn't that mean that ALL the Law (Yahweh's Torah) must still be here, & must still be kept. Clearly, the Catholic Church has been deceptive about this Scripture.

Why does the Catholic Church celebrate the 7th day Sabbath on Sunday, when there is no scriptural instruction to do so ?

The Catholic Church, from, http://www.catholicity.com/catechism/the_lord's_day.html, writes the following :
"The First and the Eighth 

Jesus rose "on the first day of the week" (Mk 16:2). This "first day" recalls the first creation. As an "eighth day," it symbolizes the new creation begun by Christ's Resurrection. For Christians, Sunday has become the first of all days, the Lord's Day. "We gather on the day of the sun, for it is the first day when God made the world; on this same day Jesus Christ our Savior rose from the dead" (St. Justin).

A New Hope - A New Day

Sunday replaces the Sabbath for Christians because Christ's Passover fulfills the truth of the Jewish Sabbath. The Old Law worship prepared for the mystery of Christ. "We have come to a new hope, no longer keeping the sabbath, but the Lord's Day" (St. Ignatius of Antioch).

Observing Sunday fulfills the moral command inscribed in man's heart to render public and regular worship to God "as a sign of his universal beneficence to all" (St. Thomas Aquinas). Sunday worship fulfills the Old Law by a weekly celebration of the Creator and Redeemer."

Some of the information provided in this quote IS NOT scripturally correct.

1) Mark 16:2 does not tell us that Yahushua rose "on the first day of the week", in fact, it doesn't even mention Yahushua.

Mark 16:1-2 When the sabbath (the 7th day Sabbath) was over, Mary of Magdala,             Mary the mother of James and Salome, bought spices with which to go and anoint             him. And very early in the morning on the first day of the week they went to the tomb,         just as the sun was rising.

Matt 28:1 gives us similar information.

Matt 28:1 After the Sabbath (the 7th day Sabbath), and towards dawn on the first day       of the week, Mary of Magdala and the other Mary, went to visit the sepulchre.

If we read each of these chapters further, in context, we notice that Yahushua was not seen until He is mentioned in Matt 28:9 and John 20:14-17.

Clearly, there is no scriptural evidence that Yahushua rose on the first day of the week.

2) The 7th day Sabbath is definitely not a Jewish Sabbath. Gen 2:2-3 refers to the 7th day of creation, while Exod 20:10 specifically calls the 7th day Sabbath, the Sabbath for Yahweh. Remember, we are told that in Deut 4:13 that Yahuah Himself, inscribed the ten sayings on the two tablets of stone. Changing something Yahuah has personally written
is a very serious thing.

Exod 20:10   but the seventh day is a sabbath for Yahweh your God.

If you examine much of Catholic doctrine & teaching, it has attempted to remove anything "Jewish", or more correctly, Hebraic.

3) The Catholic Church has "speculated" that Yahushua rose on the first day of the week. The Greek phrase used in Matt 28:1 and Mark 16:2 is "mia sabbaton" - it is correctly translated as "one of the sabbaths", not the first day of the week.

4) I won't go into it in detail here, but "the day of the sun" or pagan "SUN WORSHIP" is seen in many places in the Catholic Church (Justin quotes the day of the sun, the sun shaped halos, the shape of the communion host, the construction of the monstrance with its sunrays & a crescent moon, the solar wheel & the very large phallic tower in the Vatican.

If the Catholic Church is infallible, why has it changed several doctrines during my lifetime such as : The doctrine of indulgences – refer to http://catholic.org/tracts/myths-about-indulgences. The Latin Mass, Abstaining from eating meat on Fridays in Lent, Pre-Communion Fasting, Limbo, Purgatory, No salvation outside the Catholic Church

The Catholic Church states in, http://www.catholic.org/encyclopedia/view.php?id=6099, that :                                  
"the Church is infallible in her objective definitive teaching regarding faith and morals, not that believers are infallible in their subjective interpretation of her teaching".

How can this be so if during my lifetime, some 70 years, the Catholic Church has CHANGED its teaching on "indulgences, the Latin Mass, eating meat during Lent,
pre-Communion fasting, Limbo, purgatory, and no salvation outside the Catholic Church).

Prior to my lifetime, the Catholic Church has changed several practices, including "allowing married men to be priests, the releasing of religious from their vows, the current sign of the cross, 53 Catholic Doctrines not found in the Bible (http://www.bible.ca/catholic-flip-flops.htm), marriage to a non-Catholic was invalid until 1818 AD, withholding the communion cup from the laity from 1416 AD until the late 20th Century, the frequency of receiving communion changed from weekly to daily in about 500 AD, baptism by immersion was practised until 1311 AD, no infant baptism until the 4th Century, and no Pope was considered infallible until 1870 AD.

Why are Catholic priests, nuns & brothers required to take the vow of "obedience” ?

http://www.catholic.org/encyclopedia/view.php?id=8605 tells us that

"Religious obedience is that general submission which religious vow to God, and voluntarily promise to their superiors, in order to be directed by them in the ways of perfection according to the purpose and constitutions of their order."

While we are sure that the principle involved here is quite noble, and that it can lead to an individual becoming a better person, our experience of around 60 years as devout, practising Catholics tells us that, many Catholic clergy were far short of perfection. In fact, many were tyrannical bullies.

In terms of the vow of obedience, we have asked ourselves these questions :

Q1: Could this vow be a way to control those within the order ?

Q2: Could this vow be a way of controlling individuals who may disagree with various aspects of the Catholic Church, and/or the religious order to which they belong ?

Q3: Could this vow be a way of silencing individuals who may disagree with various aspects of the Catholic Church, and/or the religious order to which they belong ?

Followers of the Messiah - the Lessons

Introduction - The journey begins

I may have covered some of this in previous teachings, so I hope the revision will help.

Isn’t it true that we are all on a spiritual journey ? The following points are commonly experienced as we journey towards Yahweh’s Truth – please consider them in this lesson.

At some point on that journey, Yahweh disturbs our shalom, our peace ! You probably don’t know why, & most likely, you may sense that something is wrong, or that something is missing in your life, or both.

Once you are aware of this “uncomfortability”, you may begin to ask questions, & to seek answers. You do this in an attempt to restore your shalom.

To assist you with this attempt to restore your shalom, I have prepared a series of activities, (some with questions for you to answer, & others for you to read & digest), that hopefully, will guide you. I encourage you to either create a computer file for your responses, or write them in an exercise book. Writing a date can also be helpful when you examine your progress at some future time.

1:  Make a list of as many of your questions as you can – leave a space between them for any answers you may have found. Please focus on your own questions before you refer to the possible questions I have provided below.


Possible questions might include :

Q: What was it that caused me to be unsettled in Church, or why did I leave Church ?

Q: How well do I understand what I read in the Bible ?

Q: Why haven’t we been taught in my Church how to really study the Bible, instead of being told what verses mean by my pastor or minister ?

2:  Once we realised that our shalom (peace), has been seriously disturbed, we begin to Ask, Seek, Knock in an effort to restore our shalom. Verses like Matt 7:1-14, & Isa 55:1-11 may come to mind. 

~ Mat 7:1-14 “Ask and it shall be given you… knock & it will be opened to you

~ Isa 55:1-11 “Seek Yahweh while He is to be found…”

We might ask questions like :

Q: Who is “God” ?

Q: What is the Bible, & what does it tell us about God & His Messiah ?

Q: Why did God create the universe & us ?

Q: What does God want us to do & be ?

Q: How do I know, that what I’ve been taught & have believed is true ?

Q: What is the Creator’s name ? Are names important ?

Q: Who is the Messiah (Christ) ? Is the Messiah’s name Jesus ?

Q: Have we been taught what the Messiah believed & did ?

Q: When did the Church begin ?

Q: Who are God’s chosen people ?

Q: Where can I find a group to learn from, & fellowship with ?

Q: How can I know which group I should join ?

Depending on how much asking, seeking & knocking you have done so far, you may have considered several of these, or most likely, many questions of your own.

Write a list of any questions you may have considered so far on your journey, with any responses you may have found. It is perfectly OK, if you haven’t started this step yet.

3:  In this process of asking, seeking & knocking, it is important to realise that we have to discern what to let go of, & what to embrace.

We also need to understand that this is an expedition into Yahweh’s truth, one out of confusion into clarity. It can be very difficult without a guide, because we are going somewhere we haven’t been before. Hopefully, this series of lessons can lead you, with Yahweh’s Ruach, to where He wants you to be.

Please be aware of not falling for the lie, “the Ruach will teach me”, without remembering that He disturbed your peace in the first place, & it doesn’t mean that the Ruach will give you an instant download, with all the answers. There will be a lot of personal work to be done.

We need to realise that this procedure produces a lot of change, & that any kind of change is stressful.

We also come to realise that we were made to go through a process of knocking, & asking, seeking, & journeying, because it allows us to find others, who are also knocking, asking, seeking & journeying.

One very important question you may ask is, “who am I”, & this usually results into a search for your real identity (see later)

4:  It is about this point on our journey, that we personally come to understand, that the biblical names of the Creator, & His Messiah are very important.

Q: If you haven’t come to this understanding yet, I encourage you to ask, are names important, & why are the personal names of the Creator, & His Messiah, especially important ?

We may begin using Their Hebrew names – Yahweh is the heavenly Father’s name, yod-hey-vav-hey in Hebrew, translated as LORD, & Yahushua, is His Messiah’s Hebrew name. You may know Him as Jesus.

If you have arrived at this point on your journey, I encourage you to write down some personal comments on your attempts to use these very important Sacred names.

We realized that “God” was not a name, but a description, or a title

We may also start to appreciate, & understand more about our Saviour, Yahushua.     

Isn’t it true that Yahweh only made His covenant with one group of people ? Doesn’t Exod 19:3-6 tell us that this covenant was with Israel  ?

5: In this process of searching for Yahweh's truth, we usually start to evaluate a lot of things that you we need to add to our walk.

Isn’t it true that Father Yahweh is developing a “forever community”, where He wants us to be able to live with each other, & to support each other now, so that in the “forever community”, we will also be able to live with, & support each other.

Q: Is everyone you know going to be in that “forever kingdom” ?

Q: Would you like to live in the “forever kingdom”, with everyone you know ? Why or why not ?

6: At some stage, we come to appreciate that we are looking for, and desiring, “the TRUTH”. When we do this, our understanding of what TRUTH is, may be vague, & so we go searching Yahweh’s Word for answers.

A quick search using free software such as e-Sword, reveals that the Hebrew word translated as “truth” is emet, which can mean stability, certainty, truth or trustworthiness.

7:  As we are continue asking, seeking & knocking, we are beginning to recognize that we don’t know,  what we don’t know (stage 1 of learning anything) !

At this point, it is very important to realise that some of those people who are teaching, don’t understand that there are lots of things that they really don’t know – they really don’t know what needs to be re-learned.

~   We are making a “conscious” choice or decision to accept Yah as He is, over our own version of Him, which has been shaped by our personal preferences (self-sovereignty, cultural influences, “Babylon” influences, etc.)

~   We realize that this is not easy because of the battle that is taking place in our minds and hearts .

~   We accept that we must “LET” the mind of Yahushua be in us, (Phil 2:5), so that we can be transformed, and conformed to His image.

9:  So, how do we find YHWH’s Truth ?

1 John 2:4 explains :

The one who says “I know Him”, and does not guard His commandments, is a liar, and the TRUTH is not in him

Q: If we are to “know Him” (Messiah Yahushua), shouldn’t we, as 1 John 2:6 tells us, “WALK as He WALKED” ?

Q: Shouldn’t we live our lives, by doing what He, & the first century believers believe & did ?

Q: So what did Messiah Yahushua believe, & do ?

In order to find the answers to these questions, shouldn’t we search the Renewed Covenant Scriptures (NT), rather than simply rely on, & accept, what we have been taught in the Church ?

Did our denomination teach us how to really study YHWH’s Word, or did they teach us to come to their pastors, ministers or priests, their experts, for the answers to our questions ? Wasn’t this one of the reasons we stopped going to Church ?

     Very Important 

     Isn’t it true, that if we haven’t studied Yahweh’s Word for ourselves (in the original languages), then we have NO opinion ! This statement is saying that if we have not studied His Word, then we can’t have an opinion about that Word, because we really don’t know what it actually says. All we really know, is someone else’s opinion - in other words, our opinion is based on “hearsay” !

     Very Important Question – am I willing to accept the opinions of others, for my eternal salvation, & walk of faith ?

There is much, much more to learn, & I invite you to examine the next lesson in this series.

Followers of the Messiah - Foundational Beliefs

 Isn’t it true that a belief is anything that is accepted by a person as being true ?

If we examine our lives as children, I’m sure that you will agree that we learned those early beliefs, such as being well mannered, by being specifically taught by a parent, a teacher, or someone we see as being in authority. Another way of learning other early beliefs, is that we passively absorbed something we observed or experienced, such as a love of reading, after being read stories by a parent.

Q1:              What are some of your childhood beliefs ?           

Later in our lives, we consciously decided that we wanted to believe something – an example might be deciding that we love to travel.

Once we realise & decide that we want to have a closer relationship with our Heavenly Father, we consciously develop those spiritual beliefs that are most important. Some of the most important ones are written in the text box below.

 

 Established Principles of Scripture that Cannot be Contradicted by any Doctrine of Faith


1:  Yahweh is one, and is expressly manifested in many ways, and that in all these ways, He is the one True Elohim (God).

2:  Yahushua the Messiah was sent from Father Yahweh, and practiced the Torah of Elohim perfectly - He is the Son of Elohim, and the same image or reflection of the Father.

3:  Yahushua the Messiah came to Earth as the Word made flesh, and He kept Father Yahweh's instructions (Torah) faithfully & faultlessly.

4:  Yahweh created all things by the Word, and all creation is subject to the Word.

5:  Yahushua is the walking, talking, living, breathing Torah.

6:  Yahweh’s written Word, that is found only in the original languages, is His inspired, influenced, inerrant, unchanging, revealed Word.

7:  In those original languages, Yahweh’s written Word 

     ~ says what it says, 

     ~ not what I think it says, 

     ~ not what I believe it says, 

     ~ not what I’d like it to say, 

     ~ not what others say it says, and 

     ~ not necessarily what I’ve been taught that it says.

     There is no such things as an inspired translation of Yahweh’s Word.

 

 

Very Important Question  - how do I really know that, what I believe, what I have been taught, what I have seen or heard, is completely accurate, true & correct ?

 Isn’t it true that the only way I can really know this, is to check & test ALL the Evidence I can find ?

 Let’s do some basic checking, & testing of the above beliefs. The following questions are designed to assist you in this process. You are encouraged to write as much detail as you can, & write down any comments in a Notes section.

If you have e-Sword, some other Bible software, or can access biblehub.com, you should be able to search Yahweh’s Word for the following evidence. If not, look in the Index or Lectionary of a study Bible, or check out the hints provided below.

 Q1:              What verse is evidence that Yahweh is one (echad in Hebrew) ?            

Q2:              What are some of the ways that Yahweh is manifested in the first five books of the Bible ?

Q3:              What scriptural evidence is there that Yahushua is the Son of Elohim ?    

Q4:              Where can we find evidence that “the Word” created all things ?

Q5:              If we examine John 14:6, Ps 119:42 & 160, and John 1:14 carefully, what is each telling us, and what collectively are

                    we being told ?

Q6:              What evidence do we have for statement 5 ?

Q7:              Do you really agree with statements 6 & 7 ?

Q8:              What comments and/or additions would you like to add to the list of established

                   scriptural principles ?



HINTS


Q1 (Hint – Deut chapter 6);

Q2 (Hint – Gen 18, Exod 19 & 24, 34)

Q3 (Hint – Matt 14, Mark 15, Luke 4, John 11);

Q4 (John 1)

Q5 (Write what each verse is really telling us, & then, tie it all together)

Q6 (Refer to Q5)



Followers of the Messiah - How to TEST what has been said or written

 Please read the following list of important Scriptural principles carefully - these should be applied when studying YHWH’s Word.

 


Established Principles of Scripture that Cannot Be Contradicted By any Doctrine of Our Faith.


Our Creator gave mankind His written Word, with special emphasis on the first five books.


The Word contains all of Yahweh’s Torah (instructions), commands, judgments & statutes, for all people who choose to align their lives in faith to the Word of Elohim, not just to Israel, or the Jews (Leviticus 24:22).


It is wrong to add or take away from the Word of Elohim, as written in the first five books (Deuteronomy 4:2; 12:32)


Any prophet that is a true prophet will teach according to this Word of Elohim already given in the first five books, lest he be a false prophet (Deuteronomy 13)


The Messiah cannot have added to, or taken away from this Word of Elohim (Deut 4:2; 12:32), lest He be a false prophet as well (Deuteronomy 13).


This is also true for James, Peter, John, & Paul, or any other writings found in what we often call the Bible.

All writings must be consistent with this already established Word of Elohim.


Scriptures should never contradict one another.



Do you agree with the following questions ? Comment on them.


Q1:              Isn’t the purpose of any biblical study, to Know YHWH’s Truth ?


Q2:              Isn’t it true that the more Scripture we understand, the more the Ruach can help us apply it, & the more we apply it,

                    the closer we become to Yahweh ?


Q3:              What will you do, if you find out that discovered Truth comes into direct conflict with something that you currently

                    believe ?


Q4:              Do you agree with the following statement ? If we honestly seek Yahweh 's truth, and we are shown that we are in

                    error, we will either cease being honest, or we will change our belief to  repair the error.


                  Doesn’t James 4:17 explain it this way “Therefore, to one who knows the right thing to do and does not do it, to him it is

                  sin” ?


Q5:              Do you agree with the following statement ? If the truth does not offend you, then, you either don’t see it, or you

                     already agree with it ! If the Truth is doing its job, it will hurt temporarily, but  remember, the Truth heals what is

                      corrupt !



I am sure that you have heard or read teachings that seem to be very convincing ! In these teachings, the speaker or author usually makes statements that appear to be so persuasive, that you want to agree with what is being said or written.


Q6: How do you know that what is being spoken or written is in actual fact, accurate, true and/or correct ?


Q7: If you analyse the many teachings or sermons you have been exposed to, isn’t it true that it is reasonably easy, to present a

       very convincing sermon or teaching, that is either partially or completely inaccurate and/or incorrect ?


Very Important Question – How can we really KNOW whether a statement, a scripture verse interpretation, or even a version of a scripture verse itself, is accurate, true and/or correct ?


Answer – the only way we can really KNOW this is to TEST it in some way ! This testing process is the focus of this lesson.


If anyone quotes a verse, or asks you for your opinion about a verse, I strongly encourage you to TEST it, by checking to see if, what is said or written is scripturally accurate, using if possible, the strategies explained in previous teachings . 


As well, I encourage you to use the following information & questions to establish the correct context of a scripture verse or chapter.


As well as reading verses before and after the verse we are studying, we can further define the CONTEXT of a word or verse, by answering the following questions as they relate to the verse or chapter


Who wrote this book ? When was it written ?

Who was the original audience ? Who was it originally written to ?

Why was it written ?

What was their culture ?  What was their legal system ?

What was their religious background ?

What Hebrew idioms did they use ?

What did they already know about the subject ?

What future group does it affect, & how will they be affected ?


What is the context for Exod 20:7 ?

 

The original audience were the now free Israelite slaves from Egypt. It was written TO them, to remind them that they had been offered a Covenant with Yahweh, the one true Elohim, & that they had accepted Yahweh’s offer.


In this chapter & the next 3 chapters of Exodus, they are being reminded of what Yahweh requires of them.


After being in Egypt for about 215 years, probably between 150 & 180 years as “slaves” to Egypt’s Pharaohs, they had lost their identity, their land, their language, their independence, & their rituals. Yahweh wanted to build a kingdom - one based on a totally different foundation to the one, these now free Israelites, were used to.


As a result of being assimilated into Egypt, these now free Israelites, understood what being in covenant with a greater being meant – they had lived this way all of their lives. To some extent, they understood the legal aspect associated with it, namely, they were expected to do their part in this covenant with Yahweh.


In terms of their religious background, they were “Egyptian”. The Israelites knew all about the Egyptian culture, history, mythology, religion & cosmology. They understood & believed the same as the Egyptians did – they had an Egyptian world-view.


They probably knew something about Yahweh, based on stories & legends told to them by their forefathers, but, in practical terms, they knew almost nothing. It seems very unlikely that they trusted Moses at this point of their history.


In terms of future generations, we are told in the book of Deuteronomy, chapter 4 & verse 5:3, that Moses explained to the next generation, that Yahweh had cut a covenant not only with their forefathers, but with them (& us) also.


 

How to test a Renewed Covenant (RC) scripture (NT) verse ?


When we are studying a RC scripture verse, problems can arise because sometimes, there can be contextual confusion. To assist us with this difficulty, it is important that we ask ourselves four questions.


1:  Who are the groups involved in a conversation ?

2:  What is any debate over ?

3:  What is the correct definition of the words being used, according to the original authors & audience ?

4:  Does the interpretation, contradict any scriptures that are clearly understood in the first five books of the Bible ?


The Main Groups referred to in the RC


The Circumcision Party :

claimed that to be saved a person must be circumcised, keep the Torah of Moses, & keep all the traditions of the Elders


Cornelius, a believing gentile (Acts 10), took these steps to become a saved “Jew”


Jewish Gnostics :

1:  believed in a higher secret knowledge (kabala)

2:  believed that the human flesh was evil, & thus, the only way to be released from it was to indulge it & punish it through 

     self-mutilation

3:  some sects worshipped angels

4:  remained Jewish, but practised Judaism through their Gnostic adaptations & philosophy


Gentiles

1:  those that were not considered Jews or from the “House of Judah”

2:  comes from the Hebrew word, goyim, which means, “the nations”

3:  can also mean the 10 northern tribes or “the House of Israel”, that were disbursed into all the nations because of their disobedience to Yahweh’s Covenant


The Way – mentioned in Acts 24:14

1:  They believed in keeping the Torah of Yahweh

2:  They do not believe in keeping the “oral law” or “the Traditions” of the Jewish Elders, that were added to the law of Yahweh

3:  They believed that the Messiah that they were waiting for, was Yahushua of Nazareth, & that He paid the price that the Torah

      required for all those who broke it

4:  They strongly believed in being led by the Ruach & not allowing the other sects of Judaism to tell them how to do things.


The Constant DEBATE was      What does it take to be SAVED ?


Through much of Paul’s letters, this was the constant argument he was battling.


These other groups did not believe that Paul’s converts were “saved” because they were not converting in the “established Jewish” way, nor were they keeping the commandments, & traditions in the way that these other groups were.


How do we know that our current understanding of a scriptural word is accurate ?


There are quite a few Hebrew and Greek words that, when translated into English, are rather abstract in their meaning. This means that their meaning is not precise, not crystal clear, & usually depends on an individual’s interpretation. A list of such English words can include words like love, faith, truth, mercy, salvation, grace and worship, to name but a very small few. For this explanation, I will use the word, “worship”.


Many people use the phrase, “praise & worship” to describe the joyful singing, dancing, & raised arms gestures in reverence to Yahweh & Yahushua, that often proceeds a religious Christian service. A question we could test might be, is this joyful singing, dancing & raising of arms in reverence, what is meant by the Hebrew or Greek words that are translated from Yahweh’s Word as “worship” ?


Step 1          Begin by locating the first place that this translated word, “worship” is found in Yahweh’s Word.

                      In the KJV, it is first used in Gen 22:5


Gen 22:5 And Abraham said unto his young men, Abide ye here with the ass; and I and the lad will go yonder and worship, and come again to you.


Step 2          Locate a few verses where your test word, “worship” is used. In the KJV Bible, there are 102 verses that use this

                      word. For this example, I’ll choose Deut 8:19, Josh 5:14, Ps 5:7, Ps 66:4, Matt 2:2, Matt 4:10 &  John 4:23.


Step 3          Copy each verse, & insert the possible meaning before the test word, “worship”, & read it out loud.

                     Does your possible meaning, “sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence” make sense in each verse ? If it does,

                     your opinion has been supported, if not, then you need to search for a more appropriate meaning.


Deu 8:19 And it shall be, if you shall forget YAHWEH your Elohim, and walk after other gods, and serve them, and (sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence to) worship them, I testify against you today that you shall utterly perish

 

Jos 5:14 And He said, No, for I now come as the Captain (Sar) of the army of YAHWEH. And Joshua fell on his face to the earth and (sang joyfully, danced & raised arms in reverence) worshiped. And he said to Him, What does my Master speak to His slave ?

 

Psa 5:7 But I, in the plenty of Your grace, I will come into Your house. I will (sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence) worship in Your fear toward Your holy sanctuary, O YAHWEH

 

Psa 66:4 All the earth shall (sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence) worship You; and they sing to You; they shall praise Your name. Selah.

 

Mat 2:2 saying, where is He born King of the Jews? For we saw His star in the east and have come to (sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence) worship Him

 

Mat 4:10 Then Yahshua said to him, Go, Satan! For it has been written "You shall (sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence) worship YAHWEH your Elohim, and Him only shall you serve."

 

Joh 4:23 But an hour is coming, and now is, when the true worshipers will (sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence) worship the Father in spirit and in truth. For the Father also seeks such, the ones (singing joyfully, dancing & raising arms in reverence) worshiping Him.


Let’s try “bow down & pay homage” as another possible meaning.


Deu 8:19 And it shall be, if you shall forget YAHWEH your Elohim, and walk after other gods, and serve them, and (bow down & pay homage to) worship them, I testify against you today that you shall utterly perish

 

Jos 5:14 And He said, No, for I now come as the Captain (Sar) of the army of YAHWEH. And Joshua fell on his face to the earth and (bowed down & payed homage) worshiped. And he said to Him, What does my Master speak to His slave ?

 

Psa 5:7 But I, in the plenty of Your grace, I will come into Your house. I will (bow down & pay homage) worship in Your fear toward Your holy sanctuary, O YAHWEH

 

Psa 66:4 All the earth shall (bow down & pay homage) worship You; and they sing to You; they shall praise Your name. Selah.

 

Mat 2:2 saying, where is He born King of the Jews? For we saw His star in the east and have come to (bow down & pay homage) worship Him

 

Mat 4:10 Then Yahshua said to him, Go, Satan! For it has been written "You shall (bow down & pay homage) worship YAHWEH your Elohim, and Him only shall you serve."

 

Joh 4:23 But an hour is coming, and now is, when the true worshipers will (bow down & pay homage) worship the Father in spirit and in truth. For the Father also seeks such, the ones (bowing down & paying homageworshiping Him.

 

After reading each verse, ask yourself, which of the two possible meanings, “sing joyfully, dance & raise arms in reverence”, or “bow down & pay homage”, seems more appropriate ?


If you want to be very thorough, locate all the verses where this word, “worship” is used.


Other possible questions that could be examined in order to TEST what has been said and/or written


Test this by comparing several different translations, and if able, use a Hebrew-English or Greek-English translation, to examine each word for accuracy of meaning


1:  Are there any Hebrew or Greek idioms being used, & do I understand their meaning ?


     An idiom is an expression in a language which has a unique meaning which cannot be understood from the meanings of its

     parts. Examples in the English language are :

         to feel under the weather

         to have egg on your face

         to read between the lines

         to rain cats and dogs


     The Bible is no different, & it contains many idioms. Examples in Hebrew & Greek are :

    

Verse

Idiom

Meaning

Gen 4:6

face fallen

sad

Gen 24:60

possess gates

 capture cities

Deut 15:7

close hand

selfish

Ps 89:13

right hand

force

Matt 8:21

bury my father

collect my inheritance

Matt 16:19

bind and loose

to forbid and to allow

Luke 23:42

remember me

intercede for me

    


2:  Does what I am understanding Scripture to say, contract something else in Scripture ?


3:  Does what I am understanding Scripture to say, add to or take away from what is written in the first five books of Scripture ?


4:  What am I understanding Scripture to say ? What influences am I holding on to ?


5:  What reliable resources have I used to verify my understanding (I should use at least two) ?


6:  Am I looking at the verse with Western (Greek) mindset, or should I be using the Cultural Hebraic mindset ?


7: Does my current understanding of this Scripture take into account all the circumstances surrounding the situation described ?


8:  If I am able, have I used a Hebrew-English or Greek-English Interlinear translation, to examine each word for accuracy of

     meaning ?


9:  After considering all the above questions, what is my informed understanding of the verse in question ?


Exercises


A:  Apply the method described on page 4 above to the following ideas or terms


                   love, faith, truth, mercy, salvation, grace, covenant


B:  What do you think the following Hebrew & Greek idioms mean ?


     Gen 49:4                    unstable as water


     Exod 33:3                  a stiff-necked people


     Lev 13:45                   covering of lips


     Matt 16:6                   leaven of the Pharisees


     Mark 16:18                 take up a serpent


     Luke 22:31                  sift you as wheat


     John 11:32                 fell down at His feet


     Acts 2:42                    breaking bread


     1 Cor 3:2                     feed with milk


    


    



Additional Tools for Testing Everything 

(not an endorsement for nor an exhaustive list of resources available) 


Online Resources:


 http://biblegateway.com

 

 http://blueletterbible.org

 

 http://biblehub.com/


 http://www.biblestudytools.com/


 http://haktuvim.co.il


Excellent free Bible software    e-Sword.net


Followers of the Messiah - Foundational Spiritual Beliefs Part 2

 In Lesson 2, you were introduced to a few of the most important foundational spiritual beliefs.

I encourage you to test what you learned in Lesson 2 by completing the following revision questions. Refer back to Lesson 2 if necessary.

1:  How do we develop our belief systems ?

2:  What fundamental beliefs do you have about Yahweh ?

3:  What fundamental beliefs do you have about Yahushua ?

4:  What do you believe about Yahweh’s written Word ?

While it is common for those who are brand new to our “Messianic Israel” walk to already have most of the fundamental “beliefs” mentioned in Lesson 2, there are many new beliefs, practices & activities that they will encounter as they go forward, that they may not have encountered, or processed. Please DECIDE that you will not be overwhelmed by them – just go slowly by considering them carefully, one at a time !

It is often suggested by those who have been on this walk for quite a while, to not make the mistake that many of us have made. 

Let me explain. When we have had our shalom disturbed by Yahweh, & have decided to leave a previous denomination because we identified errors, or because something just didn’t “seem right”, it is better, but difficult, to put all our previous beliefs down, and pick them up, “one at a time”, rather than keep what we had, & examine each one as we proceed on our new journey. One person described it as having a "garage or backyard" sale. You put everything that you thought you believed out on the lawn, & pick them up for consideration, one by one.

I strongly advise brand new people to start with one belief, and examine it thoroughly, by asking :

A: What do I really believe about, say, Sabbath ?  I have provided one detailed example of how this might be done below.

I suggest that your answer be written down in as much detail as possible. When this has been completed, ask the next two very important questions :

B:  Why do I believe what I just wrote ?

C:    What evidence do I have for believing what I just wrote ?

In order to TEST if your belief is scripturally accurate, it is recommended that you do further research using a study Bible’s Index or Concordance, or if you can, access Bible software, such as e-Sword, or an online resource such as biblehub.com.

Again, I have provided an example of what you might do, & how you might do it below. It is not the only method, but it is a method that I have found easy to apply, & very useful.

What is Sabbath ?

Ask yourself as many questions as you can think of, & then answer or TEST them, as thoroughly as possible, by checking what Yahweh’s Word.

Where is Sabbath first mentioned in Scripture ?                         Exod 16:23

Which day is Yahweh’s Sabbath ?                                                  the 7th day

Where do we first encounter this 7th day ?                                   Gen 1:31-2:3

What do these verses tell us about the 7th day ?

     In Gen 1:31-2:3, we are told that Elohim blessed this seventh day, and set it apart from all the other days. He sanctified this

     day by ceasing (resting) from His work of creation.

Is this 7th day the same as the other 6 days of creation ?           

     It seems obvious, that the seventh day of creation was, and is different from every other day.

Which day of the week is the 7th day which day is Yahweh’s Sabbath ?    

     Saturday – from Friday sunset to Saturday sunset (Gen 1:5)

When is the next mention of this 7th day ?               It is not until Exod 16:21-30, about 2500 years later

Before we read about how the Israelites were instructed to keep the weekly Sabbath in Exod 16:21-30, were there any instructions given to previous generations, about how to keep this 7th day Sabbath ?

     No – there is only one general statement given about Abraham’s faithfulness in Gen 26:4-5

What instructions were given about keeping the 7th day Sabbath in Exodus 16 ?

     Exod 16:4 tells us that YHWH would test the Israelites, as to whether they would walk in His Torot (plural for Torah) or not.

     The Israelites were instructed :

     ~ to gather twice as much manna on the 6th day – there would be none on the 7th day (v22)

     ~ that the 7th day would be a rest, a Sabbath set apart to YHWH (v23)

     ~ that which they baked or cooked on the 6th day, would be left over for the 7th day (v23)

NB – The 7th day Sabbath was given BEFORE the Ten Words were spoken in Exod 20.

What other instructions are given about Yahweh’s Sabbath ?      

It may come as a surprise, but there are only a few instructions about how to keep Yahweh’s 7th day Sabbath. In the 1st five books of Scripture, there are eight specific instructions about how to keep Yahweh’s 7th day Sabbath. They are :

     Exod 20:8 tells us we are to remember the Sabbath, to set it apart or to sanctify it

     Exod 20:10 tells us to cease from work on the Sabbath – repeated in Exod 31:14-15

     Exod 20:10 also tells us to cause no one else to work on the Sabbath

     Exod 23:12 tells us to rest on the Sabbath – repeated in Lev 23:3

     Exod 35:3 tells us not to kindle A FIRE ON THE Sabbath day

     Lev 23:3 tells us we are to hold a set-apart gathering on the Sabbath

There is one clarification of these is given in Neh 10:31 & 15, where we are told not to buy or sell on Sabbath.

Isaiah 58:13-14 encourages us not to do things for our own pleasure on Sabbath.

I have provided a list of topics with questions below, that you can check. It might be a good idea to copy those you have not encountered, or dealt with each thoroughly, & place a tick next to those you have examined. Please do not be overwhelmed by the list – just take your time – ask for assistance – I would be pleased to answer any questions that you may have (if we can).

Please contact me, Peter,at      askseekknockandtest@gmail.com

     The 7th day Sabbath – why you need to keep it, when to keep it, what is required ?


     The Sacred Names – what they are, what they are not, why they are sacred ?


     Yahweh’s calendar – what are the main possibilities, what the evidence is for each possibility. This is a big topic - I have

     written a detailed study on this elsewhere on this website.

     What are the problems with each calendar possibility, where to find scriptural evidence about it ?


     Yahweh’s Torah instructions, commands, judgments, statutes – what Torah means - why it is different to commands,             

      judgments & statutes - why do we need to keep those parts of it that apply to each of us ?


     Yahweh’s food requirements – what they are, how to apply them ?

    

     Yahweh’s annual appointed times, His moedim – what each of them is - when are they to be kept - what is required for each

      of them ?


     What is the difference between Hebraic & Greek-Roman (Western) thinking ?


     How to test or prove what you read or hear in Scripture, or elsewhere ?


     Why is Israel important, & why should we be part of it ?    


     What are your Hebrew Roots ?


     Who are the Lost Tribes ? What are the Two Houses of Israel ?


     What are the main scriptural problems with Judaism ?


     What are the main scriptural problems with Christianity ?


     The difference between being saved from ignorance, being saved from the penalty of our sin, & being saved for eternity with

     Yahweh ?


     How to study Yahweh’s Word – the original languages ? (Refer to the several teachings elsewhere on this website)


     What are the four levels of Hebrew Understanding ?


     How to find the correct context of a scripture chapter or verse ? (Refer to the several teachings elsewhere on this website)


     What is the correct scriptural meaning of Renewed Covenant (NT) words & ideas including :

     Grace   Salvation   Redemption  Torah (law)   Mercy   Love   Adoption   Covenant   Faith      Scripture   Works   Assembly  

     Circumcision   Gnostic  Gentiles   Ruach (spirit)   Jews   Pharisees   Sadducees   Traditions of the elders   Disciples   Apostles      Leaven   Faithfulness   Righteousness   Truth     (there are many others) ?


     What are the problems with understanding Paul ?


     What is sin ?                         What is Repentance ?                         What is Mikvah ?


     What is biblical Covenant ?                               What is adoption in the Scriptures, & the Ancient World ?


     How to test whether someone is a false prophet ?


    There are other teachings that follow, which I pray, will be of assistance, & will guide you along the way. Again, please go slowly, & be as thorough as possible, about anything you choose to add to your belief system.


REMEMBER, what you believe will TOTALLY control your actions.


Please ask for assistance, & ask questions when you are not sure - we are here to help. Email Peter at :

askseekknockandtest@gmail.com


Followers of the Messiah - Introduction

The Biblical Calendar is probably one of the most contentious topics encountered by people who want to obey Yahweh's Torah.

The biblical calendar is specifically referred to only a few times in the Bible. I'll get to these verses in a later post. The purpose of the Biblical Calendar, I believe, is described in great detail, in Leviticus, chapter 23. There, we are told of Yahweh's moedim, HIS appointed times. These are the specific times, or appointments, that Yahweh wants to meet with His chosen people as a group

The Hebrew word, translated as "feasts" in most Bible versions, is this Hebrew word, moedim. In these posts, I will be using moed (singular) or moedim (plural), as there is another Hebrew word that specifically means "feast", namely, chag, & I want to avoid any confusion.

I believe that the reason for such contention is that, in our Messianic community, there are at least four main ways that groups understand, & keep the Biblical Calendar. I won't go into the details here, because I will be dealing with them in detail, in another post.

The biggest problem that I see with these different biblical calendars is that, because Yahweh has declared that He wants to meet with His people on certain, specific days, if we have different calendars, that means that, some, or all of us, will "miss" our appointment with Yahweh !

This group of studies is completely dedicated to examining some of the most challenging issues related to Yahweh’s calendar, as is used in the Bible. It proceeds with the assumption that you already believe that the whole Bible is the inspired Word of Yahweh, in the original languages, & in the original context, and is applicable to all believers who are Followers of the Messiah, today.

The goal of these studies is not to suggest that we have everything regarding this subject worked out - we know that we don't. We are simply sharing what we have discovered so far, which of course means that it could change at any time, after further study.

119 Ministries, in their presentation at : https://www.119ministries.com/teachings/video-teachings/detail/time-the-foundation-part-1/, describes the problem well.

These studies "will force us to take a position in a sea of controversy. This means that, by default not everyone will be happy with our results or conclusions. Many may be disappointed or perhaps even angry that we did not come to the same conclusions as them. At minimum, we hope our presentation at least offers understanding why we currently believe what we believe, at best, we hope that this teaching offers you clarity, resolve, and understanding when it comes to our Creator’s calendar".

There are basically four different perspectives on calculating the first month of a biblical year. The following short descriptions are not given in any intended order.

Method H – The Hillel II calculated calendar  (also called the Jewish calendar). This is the traditional rabbinical model which has been used since the fourth century, and its creation is usually credited to Hillel II. Most mainstream Jews, & many Messianic Israelites follow this method. It is a mathematical-type method.

The Hillel II calendar was originally developed after the Romans destroyed the Temple in Jerusalem in 70 AD. Without going into all the details, the Jewish dispersion, sometimes called the Diaspora, is the name given to the event when the Jewish people were exiled from ancient Israel, so that they had to settle in other parts of the world.

Because the Jews were dispersed across the world, Hillel II, the Nasi (president) of the last Jewish Sanhedrin, developed, & published a calculated calendar for all Jews throughout the world to use. The Jewish people sincerely wanted to observe Yahweh's moedim (feasts or appointed times), but because of their exile from their ancient homeland, Israel, they had a serious problem determining the biblical calendar. This was their solution.

This Jewish calendar uses a nineteen year pattern, and an astronomical cycle to calculate this calendar. It is perhaps the most popular method used, mostly because of tradition.

As a summary, this fixed calendar is a man-made, calculated calendar. Its start is based on the calculated conjunction for the 4th day of creation. Its days go from sunset to sunset - it has either 29 or 30 day months, & its years are either 12, or 13 months. It uses a 19 year cycle, & inserts leap years mechanically every 3,6,8,11, 14, 17 & 19 years.

This Hillel II calculated calendar, based on rabbinical tradition, adds days, & even postpones certain days. An example is that with their added rules & reasoning, Yom Kippur should not fall adjacent to Shabbat, because this would cause difficulties in coordinating a fast with Shabbat.

For more specific details on the Hillel II calculated calendar, please refer to :
http://www.jewfaq.org/calendar.htm

Method E - The Enoch calendar. This is probably the least popular method. It is derived from an extra-Biblical Book titled, the Book of Enoch, & uses the Book of Jubilees for additional support. This method exclusively utilizes the sun in calendric calculations.

The Enoch calendar is calculated using three steps.

STEP 1: They determine the Spring “equilux”, the day which has equal daylight and night. I believe that there is some debate on whether to use the Jerusalem Equilux as March 16th, or Astronomical Equinox as March 20th. This day is considered to be the last day of the year.

STEP 2: The following day, is the first day of the month, of the new year – I believe it must be a Wednesday, since Wednesday is the fourth day of a week, which correlates to the fourth day of creation, when the sun was created (Gen 1:14-19). Months 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, & 11 contain 30 days, while months 3, 6, 9, & 12 contain 31 days. This is a total of exactly 364 days per year.

STEP 3: The weekly Sabbath calculation begins on the 3rd day of the first month, with each successive Sabbath day falling on the 7th day from that. As the calendar is in transition from one year to the next, the Sabbath shifts the “non-days” are not formally included in the Sabbath count. This means that sometimes there can be a period of eight to nine days (evening and mornings) between a Sabbath during the annual transition, instead of the Biblical seven.

Method K – There is the Karaite Jewish Calendar, which relies heavily on the sighting of abib barley in Israel The abib barley is required for the First-fruits wave sheaf offering to Yahweh, soon after Passover. The Karaite Jews, and many Messianic Israelites utilize this method. It is a lunar/solar calendar that determines the start of the year based on the agricultural sign of the abib barley, and the first of the month is determined by means of sighting the first crescent of the moon,  
 
Method S - There is the method of using only the sun, moon, and stars, in conjunction with the abib barley as another witness. This calendar uses the sun to determine the day (yom in Hebrew), the conjunction moon determines the start of a month (chodesh in Hebrew), and the stars determine the start of the year (shaneh in Hebrew), with the second witness agreement found in the agricultural sign of the abib barley in Israel. All celestial timepieces are considered intentional, and useful in our Creator’s design with an Earthly agricultural sign as an additional witness.
Have you ever had the experience of being judged by someone, without them even listening to what you would like to say about a subject ? I have, and I am sure that you the reader has also. This experience has a title - it is called the principle of “Condemnation before Examination”. It has been said that the greatest form of ignorance is condemnation before examination.

Recently, I gave considerable thought as to whether I practice “condemnation before examination”, and had to admit that I had done so in the past. I receive many studies, or teachings on subjects I am interested in, and I now realise, I sometimes judge the content of the study, or teaching, without really examining it carefully. Once I came to this realisation, I decided to change my attitude, & now, will read, & examine, any study or teaching that I receive.

Another thought I had, was that when people send a study, or teaching to someone else, don't they have an expectation, that the other person will read, and “examine” it? 

Do you know what my experience is ? I have sent several, carefully prepared studies to different “messianic” leaders, and sadly, there is usually "no response", but when the rare individual does reply, it is clear, that they have not really read what I have written. It seems that all they want to do, sadly is, “justify what they already believe”.

I therefore, strongly encourage you the reader, to open your mind to what I have written, to place any preconceived ideas aside for now, and to allow this information to enter your mind for consideration. If you examine it, and can “prove” from Scripture that it is faulty, you are no worse off. All you have lost, is a little time. If some, or all of what you read is new “revelation” to you, your understanding of Yahweh’s word will have expanded.

Because there are at least, four main biblical calendars in use, isn't it blatantly obvious that, at least three, if not four, are in error ? Again, I ask the vital question, how can I really know that, what I have read & viewed about the Biblical Calendars, is accurate, true & correct ?

My answer to this question is that I like to TEST each candidate by examining the reasons each was originally developed, & then look at the problems associated with each method. By doing this, I believe it is possible to eliminate the unworthy & invalid biblical calendar contenders. 

May I begin - I'll be using "my" description for each calendar candidate ?

Method H – The Hillel II calculated calendar  (also called the Jewish calendar), uses a mathematical-type method to determine it.

It's rationale.

After the Roman destruction of the Temple in 70 AD, the Jews were exiled from Israel, & were forced to live in other parts of the world.

Because the Jewish people, sincerely wanted to observe Yahweh's moedim (feasts) in those places, Hillel II, the Nasi (president) of the last Jewish Sanhedrin, developed, & published a calculated calendar for all Jews throughout the world to use.

This Jewish calendar uses a nineteen year pattern, and an astronomical cycle, based on the sun, to calculate this calendar. It is perhaps the most popular method used, mostly because of tradition.

As a summary, this fixed calendar is a man-made, calculated calendar. Its start is based on the calculated conjunction for the 4th day of creation. Its days go from sunset to sunset - it has either 29 or 30 day months, & its years are either 12, or 13 months. It uses a 19 year cycle, & inserts leap years mechanically every 3,6,8,11, 14, 17 & 19 years.


Method E - The Enoch calendar exclusively uses the sun in its calendric calculations, & is derived from an extra-Biblical Book, titled, the Book of Enoch, & uses the Book of Jubilees for additional support.

Its rationale

Those who follow the Enoch Calendar, claim that it is shown in the first Book Of Enoch, chapter 37, and was given by the Angel Uriel (YahEl). They say that it is the original Priestly Calendar that was used in the Torah.

The Enoch Calendar is a 12-Month Solar Calendar having 364 days only, and proponents claim it was used by the antediluvian (pre-flood), patriarchs, and by Noah, Abraham, and Jacob. They further claim it was taught to Moses by the Angel Yah, and that it continued in effect through the second Temple period under Ezra and Nehemiah. They say that it was the official biblical calendar until the 2nd Century BCE, when King Antiochus IV Epiphanes ended the use of the Enoch Calendar, and forced the Israelite people (sons of Eber/Heber) to observe the Lunar Calendar.

Enoch calendar proponents assert that the Book of Jubilees preserved the Enoch Calendar.

These proponents claim that, based on Jubilees 2:2-3, the angels were created on Day One of the creation week, and the stars, sun and moon were created on Day Four of the creation week, and that the angels & stars, sun & moon are different creations, having different functions; i.e. many of the angels are responsible for "leading" the sun, stars, and moon through the heavenly portals to keep perfect timing over the earth by controlling light, darkness, seasons, weather, and sea levels, quoting Enoch 75:1, 80:1, 82:4-20. They also quote the Septuagint version of Job 38:7, as support.

Job 38:7 When the stars were made, all My angels praised Me with a loud voice.

I believe that another reason supporting the Enoch calendar is based on three verses in Genesis, chapters 7 & 8. They are Gen 7:11, Gen 8:3, Gen 8:4 & Gen 8:14. Their logic is that, since two periods of time are mentioned, the 17th day of the 2nd month (Gen 7:11), & the 17th day of the 7th month (Gen 8:4), & the time of 150 days in Gen 8:3 is given, that each month must be 30 days long (150/5 = 30).

Gen 7:11  In the six hundredth year of Noah's life, in the second month, the seventeenth day of the month, the same day were all the fountains of the great deep broken up, and the windows of heaven were opened. 
Gen 8:3  And the waters returned from off the earth continually: and after the end of the hundred and fifty days the waters were abated. 
Gen 8:4  And the ark rested in the seventh month, on the seventeenth day of the month, upon the mountains of Ararat.

Gen 8:14  And in the second month, on the seven and twentieth day of the month, was the earth dried. 

Method KThe Karaite Jewish Calendar relies on the following as supporting evidence.

1:   Exod 13:4, Exod 23:15, Exod 34:18 and Deut 16:1 all refer to the month in which the Israelites left Egypt as the month of "Abib". Therefore, for these proponents, "abib" is a very important descriptor as we shall see.

Exod 13:4 On this day you are going out, in the month Abib.

Exod 23:15 You shall keep the Feast of Unleavened Bread (you shall eat unleavened bread seven days, as I commanded you, at the time appointed in the month of Abib, for in it you came out of Egypt; none shall appear before Me empty); 

Exod 34:18 “The Feast of Unleavened Bread you shall keep. Seven days you shall eat unleavened bread, as I commanded you, in the appointed time of the month of Abib; for in the month of Abib you came out from Egypt.

Deu 16:1  Observe the month of Abib, and keep the passover unto the LORD thy God: for in the month of Abib the LORD thy God brought thee forth out of Egypt by night. 

2:   Abib indicates a stage in the development of the barley crops. This can be understood by reading Exodus 9:31-32 which describes the devastation caused by the plague of hail.

Exodus 9:31-32 "And the flax and the barley were smitten, because the barley was in the ear (Abib) and the flax was boiled  (Giv'ol)
And the wheat and the spelt were not smitten because they were dark (Afilot)."

These verses relate that the barley crops were destroyed by hail, while the wheat and spelt were not damaged. The reason that the barley was destroyed, and the wheat wasn't, is that the barley had reached the stage in its development called "abib", and as a result had become brittle enough to be damaged by the hail.

In contrast, the wheat and spelt were still early enough in their development, at a stage when they were flexible, and not susceptible to being damaged by hail.

3:  The "abib" barley theorists conduct “barley hunts” in Israel each year around the beginning of March. They have “experts” who go through the land of Israel searching for barley that is classified as “abib”. When sufficient “abib” barley is found throughout Israel, they declare that the barley in Israel is “abib.

4:  "Abib" Barley proponents also use Lev 2:14 for support. They claim that the firstfruits mentioned here can be brought as either “abib” barley parched in fire, or as crushed grain.

Lev 2:14  And if thou offer a meat offering of thy firstfruits unto Yahweh, thou shalt offer for the meat offering of thy firstfruits green ears of corn (abib), dried by the fire, even corn beaten out of full ears. 

5:  "Abib" barley theorists claim that Gen 1:14 supports their position, since the sun is needed to produce mature barley “at the appropriate time”. For them, the "abib" barley is the first indication of the approaching biblical new year.

Gen 1:14  And Elohim said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, (moedim), and for days, and years: 

Method S - This method uses only the sun, moon, and stars, (the lights of Gen 1:14), in conjunction with the abib barley as another witness. It claims that the biblical new year begins at the new moon conjunction, after the vernal equinox.

This group relies on the following evidence to support their claim :

1:   The “lights” mentioned in Gen 1:14 are the sun, the moon, and the stars. This is supported by Gen 1:16.

Method S proponents claim that the sun moves through all the constellations of stars each year in a systematic way. Based on Josephus' comment in, Antiquities of the Jews,  3:10:5, the sun was in the constellation of Aries at the time of the original Passover in Egypt.

Today, at Passover, the sun is in the constellation of Pisces, & returns back there at the beginning of the following “year”. The start of the biblical yearly cycle is signalled with the vernal equinox (around March 20 or 21st).

Gen 1:16  And God made two great lights; the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser  light to rule the night: he made the stars also. 

2:   Method S proponents claim that there is scriptural support from several verses that refer to the idea of "a year's end" in Exod 34:22, as well as "the year was expired" in 1 Ch 20:1 & 2 Ch 36:10, with "the end of the year" referred to in 2 Ch 24:23.




 In Exod 34:22 and 2 Ch 24:23, the Hebrew words translated as “at the year’s end” are Hebrew words “shaneh”, H 8141 and “tekufah”, H8622.
The appropriate information from Strong's Concordance is shown below :

I Ch 20:1 and 2 Ch 36:10 contain the Hebrew words H 8141 and H 8666 which are translated as “the year was expired”.

Method S theorists claim that this is scriptural evidence that the vernal equinox is significant - they say that the vernal equinox signals the start of the biblical new year.

3:   We know that, according to Lev 23:10, barley, the only crop ready for harvest around Passover,  is required for the first-fruits wave offering. Proponents of this Method, claim that the sun, when it returns to the constellation of Pisces at the start of the new biblical year, is in a perfect position to ripen the barley for this Yahweh commanded ceremony.

Method S differs from Method K, in that the positioning of the sun (the greater light of Gen 1:16) is the trigger for the start of the biblical new year, because that positioning of the sun, at the equinox, "ripens" the barley for harvest (a second witness).

Lev 23:10  Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto them, When ye be come into the land which I give unto you, and shall reap the harvest thereof, then ye shall bring a sheaf of the firstfruits of your harvest unto the priest: 

They claim that the biblical new year begins with the conjunction of the moon after the vernal equinox.

I'd like to now, list the problems that I have found with each of the above biblical calendar candidates, which will, hopefully, assist us in identifying the valid, & scripturally correct, Biblical Calendar.

Major Problems with the Hillel II calculated calendar.

A: This Hillel II calculated calendar, based on rabbinical tradition, adds days, & even postpones certain days. An example is that with their added rules & reasoning, Yom Kippur should not fall adjacent to Shabbat, because this would cause difficulties in coordinating a fast with Shabbat. There is no mention, anywhere in the Bible, of any postponements associated with Yahweh's biblical calendar.

Based on Deut 4:2 & Deut 12;32, no one has the authority "to add to, or take away" from Yahweh's Word, including His biblical calendar.

B: The Jews themselves, know & admit that, the Hillel II calculated calendar is not the calendar that was used prior to the Jewish dispersion, in 70 AD.

C: We know that the Jews have now been living in the promised land, Israel, for over 70 years, & with modern technology readily available, the original problem no longer exists. I have seen no evidence that the Jews of modern Israel are making any effort to restore the correct biblical calendar.

D:   While this calendar does rely on the sun for its operation, it totally overlooks the instructions of Gen 1:14-16, by ignoring the participation of the moon, & the stars.

E: There are several other problems that the following list details, but the five above, are the most serious.

~ It is purely a man made calculated calendar
~ There is no observation of the moon, nor the physical sighting of the required wave sheaf offering crop, barley (Lev 23:10)
~ The original start of this calendar is at conjunction on the 4th day of creation
~ Subsequent conjunctions are calculated using average synodic lunar month of 29.53 days
~ Molad (lunar conjunction)is presently 2 hours later than when instituted (based on Jerusalem time)
~ It can sometimes be 26-33 days in error from "abib" Barley
~ Postponements can cause month to begin 1 day after the sighted new moon
~ It is increasingly moving later into the seasons (currently 8 days later than when instituted)
~ It improperly dates Shavuot (Pentecost)

Based on these very serious violations of Scripture, I have to eliminate the Hillel II calculated calendar, as a valid candidate for Yahweh's Biblical Calendar.

Problems with the Enoch calendar

A:   While this Enoch calendar uses the sun & stars, it ignores the moon as a participant in determining a "biblical" calendar, thus overlooking the instructions of Gen 1:16 & Ps 104:19.

Gen 1:16  And God made two great lights; the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: he made the stars also. 

Psa 104:19  He appointed the moon for seasons (moedim): the sun knoweth his going down. 

B:   Many of the ideas mentioned in the Book of Enoch & the Book of Jubilees are not referenced in the official Bible. 

C: There is a debate within the Enoch calendar community about several details, such as whether to use the Jerusalem equilux (equal daylight & night), as March 16th, or astronomical equinox as March 20th.

D: Regardless of whether there are 365 or 366 “evening and mornings” between Spring equiluxes, or equinoxes, there is a adding of one or two “non days” in any given solar cycle. The reason for this is because the time from equilux to equilux, or equinox to equinox, in the Spring, is always 365 to 366 days, whereas the Enoch calendar is only allowed to have a strict 364 days. Thus, the accuracy of Enoch as a calendar, is already a mathematical impossibility.

E:   The logic of the 30 day months from Gen 7:11, Gen 8:3 & 4, seems convincing, but, if we use all the data found in Gen 7 & 8, it can be shown that, the year of Noah's flood was 385 days. If this is so, any idea of 30 day months, is impossible. Refer to Don Roth's website for details     https://www.biblicalcalendarproof.com/about/research 

F: There is nothing in all of the Bible that states that a month, or a year needs to be a certain time in length.

Based on the above problems with the Enoch calendar, I have to eliminate it, as a valid candidate for Yahweh's Biblical Calendar.

Problems with the Karaite Jewish Calendar

A:   How can anyone know the precise stage of maturity of the barley in that is described in Exod 9:31 - surely, this is an assumption ?

B:   There is sometimes disagreement about whether the barley is “abib” or not ? The method of determining whether the barley is abib" is very subjective. There are at least three scales against which the barley is measured in order to determine whether it is "abib" or not. They are the Zadok, Feekes and Haun scales.

C:   How did the Israelites know when to keep the Passover in the second year when they did not plant crops, nor could they view the barley in Israel ?

D:   Without this "abib" barley, how did the Israelites of Joshua’s day know when the Passover was, when they celebrated Passover after the 40 years in the wilderness ? For that matter, how did Noah know when months began, & when the next year started, without sighting "abib" barley ?

E:   How did the vast majority of exiles know when the barley in Israel was "abib", when they were not in the land of Israel for at least 2000 years ? The technology has only been available in recent times.

F:   Exod 23:15 tells us that no one is to come before Yahweh “empty-handed”. This is clearly saying all must bring a first fruits offering. Lev 23:10 also implies this. What happens when some of the land of Israel doesn’t satisfy the "abib" barley requirement, after all, not all the barley in Israel, "ripens" at the same time ?

 Exo 23:15  Thou shalt keep the feast of unleavened bread: (thou shalt eat unleavened bread seven days, as I commanded thee, in the time appointed of the month Abib; for in it thou camest out from Egypt: and none shall appear before me empty:) 

Lev 23:10  Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto them, When ye be come into the land which I give unto you, and shall reap the harvest thereof, then ye shall bring a sheaf of the firstfruits of your harvest unto the priest

 G:  The land promised by Yahweh went from the Nile River to the Euphrates River. Across such a large area, there are considerable differences of climate. Therefore, the "abib" sighting of the barley would be different in different geographical areas.

H  The barley mentioned in Exod 9:31 was in Egypt. My research of crops, tells me that the "abib" time in Egypt is at a different time to that of Israel. It can vary by several weeks.

I:    Moses did not ever go into the land of “Israel”. In fact, it is extremely unlikely that he knew anything about "abib" barley. Because Moses had lived in Egypt, he would have used Egyptian understanding for determining years and months, that is, by using the equinoxes, and the moon.

J:  "Abib" barley has no connection at all with the stars mentioned in Gen 1:14. Elohim said that the “lights” would be for “signs, seasons, days and years”.

K:  How can we know with certainty when the seventh plague, hail, struck (Exod 9:24) ?The "abib" barley Method relies on the idea that the time that the hail struck the barley, must have been quite close to the time when Yahweh spoke to Moses and Aaron in Exod 12:2, about the start of the biblical year.

Exo 9:24  So there was hail, and fire mingled with the hail, very grievous, such as there was none like it in all the land of Egypt since it became a nation. 

Based on the above reasons, I have some serious problems with accepting the Karaite Jewish calendar, as the Biblical Calendar.

Problems with Method S

A: Many claim that the ancient Israelites were unable to accurately determine the precise time of the vernal equinox.

B: Some say that the ancient Israelites were unable to calculate the timing of the moon's conjunction - that they didn't have the necessary knowledge or the skills.

C:   What happens when there is an “early” or a “late” Spring, and there are perhaps no first fruits to harvest for the first-fruits offering as described in Lev 23:10 ?

D: Many claim that there is really no scriptural reference to any "equinox" anywhere in the Bible.

E: Is there any evidence that the vernal equinox always precedes the barley being ready for harvest, so that the first-fruits wave offering can be made, just after Passover ?

Even though the above problems have been highlighted, I believe that this candidate is the most likely one as the authentic & valid, Biblical Calendar.

In the next post, namely, "The Start of the Biblical Year Study", I will be providing significant scriptural, & observational evidence that, I hope will add more clarity to what really is, Yahweh's Biblical Calendar.
When is the start of the Biblical Year ?

While I completely understand that there is a lot of emotion around the topic of Yahweh's Biblical Calendar, I believe that it is possible for open-minded believers, who really want to do Yahweh's will, His way, to very carefully consider all the evidence that is available, & figure out what Yahweh's Biblical calendar really is.

"Although it is true that we do not have a perfect Greek or Hebrew text, and although we do not have inspired, inerrant translations, with the help of modern scholarship of the languages, knowledge of OT and NT cultures, careful textual criticism and so forth, we have, with the help of the Ruach, at least as good access to understanding the original inspired Word of Elohim as the believers living in the first or second century". (Reliability of the Old Testament PowerPoint)

Can I please ask the reader to understand that, while I have made every effort to simplify it, the following information on how we start the biblical year, is both detailed, & quite long. For this reason, I strongly encourage my audience to read slowly & carefully through it, so that all the details can be understood. I believe that the effort involved will be worth it.


In order to arrive at the best answer the our study's question, it seems to me that we need to consider three groups of information, namely,

(a) scriptural verses that directly provide us with relevant information,
(b) pertinent information that must be gleaned from other than biblical sources, &
(c) information that is based on direct observation of Yahweh's creation.

Scripture verses that directly provide information 

1: Gen 1:14 and 16 are the first verses that provide specific information on our subject.

Gen 1:14 And God said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, (appointed times - moedim) and for days, and years


Gen 1:16  And God made two great lights; the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: he made the stars also. 


From these verses, it seems clear that :
a)  the lights (sun, moon & stars) separate the day from the night, & are for signs, appointed times (mo'edim), days and years, &
b) the sun rules the day, & the moon rules the night.

Q: Can we agree that the sun, moon & stars are involved in determining a biblical year, & that observation tells us that the sun follows a set pattern, as do the moon & stars. The sun determines a day as it appears to rise and set each day?

2:  Exod 12:2, Num 9:1-6, and Exod 40:2 give us information related to the start of the biblical year, and the second biblical year of the Exodus.

Exo 12:2 This month shall be unto you the beginning of months: it shall be the first month of the year to you.

Num 9:1 And Yahweh spake unto Moses in the wilderness of Sinai, in the first month of the second year after they were come out of the land of Egypt, saying,

Exo 40:2  On the first day of the first month shalt thou set up the tabernacle of the tent of the congregation. 


From Exod 12:1-2, we can see that Yahweh spoke to Moses & Aaron while they were in Egypt, & told them that the month indicated by Yahweh was the first month of His biblical year.

Num 9:1-6 tell us that the Israelites prepared the Passover in the first month of the second year in the wilderness of Sinai. Clearly, they either determined the start of the second year in the wilderness of Sinai using an undisclosed method, or they were again told about it by Yahweh.

Exod 40:2 tells us that the Israelites raised up the tent of the tabernacle on the first day of the first month. It seems likely that this was the start of the second year as well.

Both Exod 13:4 & Deut 16:1 refer to the month of “the aviv” (aviv means green ears). The month of "the aviv" seems to be significant in Yahweh's biblical calendar.

Exo 13:4  This day came ye out in the month the Aviv.

Deu 16:1  Observe the month of the Aviv, and keep the Passover unto Yahweh thy God: for in the month of the Aviv Yahweh thy God brought thee forth out of Egypt by night

Q: Can we agree that determining the start of a biblical year was at this time not determined by being in Israel, since the original Exodus took place in Egypt, and the second year started in the wilderness of Sinai.

3:  Ps 104:19a tells us that Yahweh made the moon for moedim (appointed times)

Psa 104:19a  He appointed the moon for seasons (
appointed times - moedim): 

Because Yahweh's "appointed times", His moedim are important for Yahweh's Calendar, I'd like to take a little time to examine the Hebrew term moed (moedim pl), if I might.

Gen 1:14 & Lev 23:2 & 4 also use the Hebrew term moed (moedim pl).

Gen 1:14 And Elohim said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, (appointed times - moedim) and for days, and years

Lev 23:2 Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto them, Concerning the feasts (
moed) of Yahweh, which ye shall proclaim to be holy convocations, even these are my feasts (moed).

Lev 23:4  These are the feasts (
moedim) of Yahweh, even holy convocations, which ye shall proclaim in their seasons (moedim). 


Q: Can we notice that the KJV sometimes translates moed & moedim as "feast(s)", & at other times as "seasons"?  Let's take a closer look at these Hebrew words as they are used in these verses.

The respective forms of the words whose root is “moed”, are shown below, with Strong’s, & Brown-Driver-Briggs (BDB) information below them. The verse where each is used is given in the top row. I have copied the exact Hebrew phrases, with their KJV translations. Please examine them carefully.



After examining the above verses in the contexts described, let’s consider the following questions.

Q: Can we agree that one of the reasons the lights were made (Gen 1:14), was “for moedim" (appointed times), & that the lesser light was to rule the night ?

Q: Since the first day of the first month begins the year, then can we agree that the moon must be involved because, Ps 104:19 tells us that "the moon is made for mo'edim"?

Since Yahweh's annual appointed times, His moedim, are determined by counting the days of a month, & since the moon is for moedim, can we assume that the moon determines the start of a biblical month, & the sun has no “direct role” in determining the annual mo'edim?

4:  Exod 12 deals with the original Passover, & the 7 days of Unleavened Bread. The mo'ed of First-Fruits occurs soon after Passover, & a first fruit offering of barley is required. Lev 23:10 tells us the Israelites must bring a sheaf of a grain crop (with specific features), for the first fruits wave offering.

Lev 23:10  Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto them, When ye be come into the land which I give unto you, and shall reap the harvest thereof, then ye shall bring a sheaf of the firstfruits of your harvest unto the priest: 


I hope that we can all agree that the time or season of the year, for the first fruits offering, Passover & the 7 days of Unleavened Bread, must all occur in the northern hemisphere's Spring time.

5:   Lev 2:1 & 7 & Lev 23:14 provide some information on the stage of development that the barley must be in, so that the first fruits offering can be made.

Lev 2:1 And when any will offer a meat offering unto Yahweh, his offering shall be of fine flour; and he shall pour oil upon it, and put frankincense thereon:

Lev 2:7  And if thy oblation be a meat offering baken in the fryingpan, it shall be made of fine flour with oil.

Lev 23:14  And ye shall eat neither bread, nor parched corn, nor green ears, (aviv) until the selfsame day that ye have brought an offering unto your God: it shall be a statute for ever throughout your generations in all your dwellings

Based on these scripture verses & logic, I believe that we can conclude :
a) The grain in Israel, for the first-fruits offering of Lev 23:10, was barley
b) Not all the barley in Israel will be at the required stage, at the same time. However, that which will be in the first fruits wave offering, must be mature enough so that fine flour can be made from it (Lev 2:1,7)
c) The first fruits grain cannot be eaten until the wave offering is made (Lev 23:14).

6: 1 Ch 27 tells us that there are 12 months in a biblical year, but It doesn't eliminate the possibility that there could be a 13th month.

Conclusions specifically based on Scripture

A: The sun, moon and the stars (constellations) are involved in determining the start of the biblical year. (Gen 1:14, 16)
B: The moon determines the start of the month (Ps 104:19)
C: The start of the biblical year of the Exodus was in the month Yahweh indicated to Moses & Aaron about the first Passover. (Exod 12:2) The Hebrews were in Egypt when these instructions were given.    
D: The month of “the aviv” is the month when the original Passover took place, & when the Israelites left Egypt. (Exod 13:4 & Deut 16:1)
E: Since the Exodus (Exod 12:2) took place from Egypt, & since the Israelites began the second year in the wilderness of Sinai, it seems reasonable to conclude that the start of the year is not determined from Israel.
F:  There are 12 months in a biblical year, unless the agricultural seasons are out of synch, (1 Ch 27), when a 13th month can be added.
G: The start of the Spring agricultural season is involved in determining the start of a biblical year, since the mo 'ed of the First Fruits requires an offering of mature barley from which fine flour can be made. This is to be made 2 - 3 weeks after the start of the biblical year (Exod 12, Lev 2:1, 7, Lev 23:10, 14)
H: While aviv barley is required for the First Fruits offering, aviv barley itself DOES NOT determine the start of the biblical year. Barley is in the aviv stage, as the result of the Spring agricultural season starting. The barley cannot be aviv UNTIL the earth is in the correct position on its path around the sun.

Scripture verses where non-biblical sources must be used to obtain information 

1: In Exod 9:31, we are told that as a result of the plague of hail, (Exod 9:22-25) the flax and the barley were struck by the hail, and so were severely damaged, or even destroyed. We are further told that the barley was aviv, (in the head), and in verse 32, we are told that the wheat & spelt were not smitten, because they were not ripe (they were late). Exod 10:15 confirms this devastation telling us that the locust plague was so severe that, "there remained not any green thing in the trees, or in the herbs of the field, through all the land of Egypt".

Exo 9:31  And the flax and the barley was smitten: for the barley was in the ear, (aviv) and the flax was bolled.
Exo 9:32 But the wheat and the spelt were not smitten: for they were not grown up.

Exo 10:15  For they covered the face of the whole earth, so that the land was darkened; and they did eat every herb of the land, and all the fruit of the trees which the hail had left: and there remained not any green thing in the trees, or in the herbs of the field, through all the land of Egypt.

Based on these verses, there was no barley to inspect, & so couldn't have used to determine the start of that biblical year.

I understand that some people strongly believe in searching for aviv barley as a trigger to start their biblical new year. Here is my list of reasons why I just as strongly disagree :

a: The jubilee years had no grain planting - so no planted or harvested barley
b: Noah knew the beginning of the year while the earth was covered with water - no barley
c: During the 40 years of wandering in the wilderness, Israel started its years without barley
e: The information given in Exod 9:31 describes the condition of barley in Egypt, not Israel.
f: It is not possible today to know about the stages of barley in Israel, while in the diaspora, without modern technology.

2: Exod 34:22 is often translated as follows.

Exo 34:22 And you shall observe a Feast of Weeks for yourself, the first-fruits of the harvest of wheat; also the Feast of Ingathering after the turn of the year (ha'shaneh tequpha't).

Q: What is the "turn of the year", & is it significant ?
A: The Hebrew term,  ha'shaneh' tequpha't, literally translated means "the year's revolution".
My explanation of its significance is a little complicated, so please bear with me as I attempt to explain it.

In Gen 1:14-19, we are told two important things.
Firstly, we are told in verse 14 that the “lights” (sun, moon & stars) are for moedim (appointed times). We are also told that the "lights" rule over the day & the night, dividing light from darkness (verse 18).

If we now look at Gen 8:22, we see a connection between the role of the “lights” of Gen 1:18 and the agricultural seasons. The “seed-time and  harvest, and summer and winter” of Gen 8:22, are, I believe, known today as the equinoxes & solstices.

Gen 1:14  And God said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, (moedim), and for days, and years:
Gen 1:15 And let them be for lights in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth: and it was so.
Gen 1:16 And God made two great lights; the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: he made the stars also.
Gen 1:17 And God set them in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth,
Gen 1:18 And to rule over the day and over the night, and to divide the light from the darkness: and God saw that it was good.


Gen 8:22 While the earth remains, seed-time and harvest, cold and heat, summer and winter, and day and night shall not cease.


If we now look at Job 38:31-33, we see another connection between “the stars” and the agricultural seasons. (I believe that Pleiades in the constellation of Orion was anciently used to help determine the time of Spring).

Job 38:31 Can you bind the bands of the Pleiades, or loosen the cords of Orion?
Job 38:32 Can you bring out the constellations in their season; or can you guide the Bear with its sons?
Job 38:33 Do you know the limits of the heavens; can you establish their rulership on the earth?


Q: Is this the similar time as is mentioned in Exod 23:16?
A:  Ex 23:16 describes the feast (chag) of Tabernacles as follows:

Exo 23:16 Also the Feast of Harvest, the first fruits of your labor, of what you sow in the field. Also the Feast of Ingathering, at the going out of the year (b'yatsa ha'shanah), at your gathering your work from the field.

The term b'yatsa ha'shanah, literally translated means, "at the going out of the year". I believe it refers to the fall equinox.

In summary, I believe that the following points are factual, based on scripture, observation, & logic.

1:
(a) The ancient Israelites would have been familiar with scripture, the first five books, and especially Genesis & Job
(b) They would have been familiar with the night sky (the moon, the main planets & stars, & their relative positions to the cardinal direction points), from after sunset until sunrise
(c) They would know that the sun determines a solar year, as it travels through a complete circuit of the constellations (stars)
(d) They would know that the sun, moon and stars are involved in determining the start of a biblical year
(e) They would know where the sun was each day, in relation to the two main cardinal points (East & West), and in relation to the major stars (constellations)
(f) They would know that the moon determines the start of a biblical month
(g) They would know that the sun is involved in determining a day
(h) They had the ability to record what they observed
(i) They were familiar with the timing of the agricultural seasons (summer, autumn, winter, spring)
(j) When in the land of Israel, they would know if the barley was ready for the First-Fruits wave offering, at the start of a biblical year.

2:  The heavenly signs rule over the earthly signs, (we must see signs in the heavens BEFORE we can use earthly signs, such as the aviv barley).

3: The sun signs rule over the moon signs. The illumination of the moon depends on the sun’s reflected light. The moon is still subject to the solar year, because without it, the moedim that are keyed to harvest & planting, will occur out of season. As long as the moedim stay in season, the moon is in charge. When it needs help to keep the moedim at the proper time, the sun takes over.
So both the sun & moon mark the biblical year.

Q:  How do we know when the moedim are out of season ?
A:  The First-Fruits offering of barley is not ready.

What can we deduce from the above information ?

The start of the biblical year must begin in the springtime, signalled by the vernal equinox, in the northern hemisphere.

Q: I believe that the vernal equinox is the trigger for the start of the biblical year, so what do we know about this equinox?

A: The vernal equinox is generally agreed to be the 21 March each year, when many, claim it is the day when there is equal daylight & equal nighttime. In reality, this only occurs at the equator.

If we TEST this, we encounter an obvious problem – this day of equal daylight & equal nighttime, will vary, depending where we live on the earth.
Example :
The day of equal daylight and darkness in Jerusalem is usually 16 March (Spring in the Northern Hemisphere), while in the Southern Hemisphere, the day of equal daylight and darkness in Sydney is 24 March.

Q: How did the ancient Israelites know when the day of the vernal equinox was?
A: My research shows that there are two methods that they could have used.

Method 1: This is based on scriptural and historical information

Again, we know from Gen 1:14-18 that the lights, (sun, moon & stars), are involved in determining the start of a biblical year.

Q: How can the stars tell them & us when the first month & the first day of a biblical year is?
A: My answer is a little involved, so again, please bear with me by going slowly.

Job 38:31–33 specifically mention a special group of stars. In this chapter, Yahweh asks Job a series of questions including the following :

Job 38:31 Can you bind the bands of the Pleiades, or loosen the cords of Orion?
Job 38:32 Can you bring out the constellations (mazzarah) in their season; or can you guide the Bear with its sons?

Job 38:33 Do you know the limits (ordinances) of the heavens; can you establish their rulership on the earth?


In case you are unaware, Orion is a common constellation that can be easily observed from Earth, and Pleiades is a cluster of several stars that are in that constellation - shown just above the blue arrow.


The Hebrew word translated as “constellations” is mazzarah, defined by Strong's Concordance as “the 12 signs of the Zodiac and their 36 associated constellations”.

In Job 38:31-33, please note the mention of various groups of stars (Orion, Pleiades, & the Great Bear), & how they relate to the ordinances of the heavens, & their rulership on the Earth. The fact that the aviv barley is an earthly sign, & Yahweh declares that the ordinances of the stars have dominion over the Earth, is quite revealing. Haven’t we also established that the aviv barley is caused by the position of the sun ? It seems clear that by understanding the heavenly bodies, we can then know when to expect the aviv barley. Could Job be revealing how the stars assist us in determining the Spring season?

Q: Is there a star pattern that can be observed around Spring and Fall (Autumn) ?
A: An observer of the night sky will be aware that there are definite patterns for each of these seasons. Stars rise in the East, and appear to “fall” into the Earth, as they move towards the West.
     

I’m not sure if there is a direct connection, but doesn’t Mark 13:24-25 specifically mention “the stars of heaven will be falling” on the Day of Yahweh?

Mar 13:24 But in those days, after that suffering, the sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give her light;
Mar 13:25 and the stars of the heaven will be falling, and the powers in the heavens will be shaken.


Q: One other notable thing happens twice a year – again, at the equator, the daytime and night time are equal at the Vernal and Autumnal equinoxes. Could this be significant ? Please read the follow statement by a physicist very carefully.

“Physicist Bill Welkner, using some information provided by Josephus, explains how easy it would be for ancient Israel to determine the first month of the year, which of course, as further evidenced by the aviv is when the season of Spring starts, noted by the Vernal Equinox. (From 119 Ministries, The Creator's Calendar).

   “In Moshe’s time, when the sun was in Aries at the Vernal Equinox, on March 21st, it was pretty close to Aldebaran (52 degrees, also within about 25 degrees of the Pleiades). As the sun is making its annual trek toward Vernal Equinox, it is moving daily along the ecliptic closer and closer to Aldebaran. (Almost exactly 3 weeks after Vernal Equinox, the sun and Aldebaran have the same ecliptic longitude.) So, what I am saying is this: In Moshe’s time, as the sun was approaching Vernal Equinox, each night just after sunset, one could watch Aldebaran and the Pleiades Setting in the evening sky. Each night, the Pleiades and then Aldebaran set earlier and earlier, such that, at the time of the Vernal Equinox, Aldebaran is just barely visible at Nautical Twilight, and the Pleiades is no longer visible at sunset! Thus, since on cannot see the stars “behind” the sun due to the sun’s brightness, Aldebaran and the Pleiades are the last notable signs and visible just before the Vernal Equinox. The Pleiades, being an open closter of fainter stars, disappearing in the glow of sunset first; then you start watching for Aldebaran. When, after sunset, just as the stars start becoming visible, you notice that Aldebaran is becoming very hard to spot, you know Vernal Equinox is near or has happened.” 


Josephus writes :

In the month of Nisan…the beginning of our year, on the 14th day of the lunar month, when the sun is in Aries, (for in this month it was that we were delivered from bondage under the Egyptians,) the law ordained that we should every year slay that sacrifice which I before told you we slew when we came out of Egypt, and which was called the Passover. (Josephus, Antiquities, 3:248)

Like Job, note how Bill specifically mentioned "Pleiades" and "Alderbaran", and how they relate to the ordinances of the heavens, and their dominion over the Earth, dictating the seasons.

The following three screen-shots show Alderbaran on 21 March 2013, at Jerusalem, New York and Sydney, respectively. I have included the constellation artwork to help compare the relative positions of Alderbaran at each of these locations.

Jerusalem 21 March 2013

New York 21 March 2013

Sydney 21 March 2013

Method 1: This is based on Science & Observation

During the year, the sun rises in an easterly direction, (not due east), and each day it moves either south or north (depending on the season). The following screen-shots from Stellarium free software, show how the sun rises in a different place each day. I have adjusted the usual settings in Stellarium by removing the atmosphere, so that the position of the sun can be more easily observed. These are “sunrise times”.

I have started with 2 February 2015, where the sun rises to the right (south-east) of the cardinal direction, East. Below that screen-shot, I have shown the day of the Vernal Equinox, 21 March. Notice that since the 2 February, the sun has moved to the left each day, and on this day of the Vernal Equinox, it is rising DUE East. To demonstrate that the sun continues to rise each day in a direction left of where it was on 2 February, I have included a screen-shot for the 21 April. The screen-shot under that shows the position of the sun on 21 June - the Summer solstice in the Northern Hemisphere. Then, there is a screen-shot for 21 July. Please notice that the sun has reversed its direction across the horizon, and is now moving to the right. When 21 September arrives, it will rise due East again (Fall Equinox), and when 21 December arrives, it will stop its journey to the right, and begin moving left the next day. Using observation alone, we can all know when the equinoxes & solstices happen, as I believe the ancient Hebrews did, in assisting them to determine the start of a biblical year. I hope this explanation is clear.

Southern Hemisphere (SYDNEY) Sunrise
Notice that the sun is right (south-east) of the cardinal direction - East
2 Feb 2015

Southern Hemisphere (SYDNEY) Sunrise
Notice that the sun is directly at the cardinal direction - East
21 March 2015        This is the day of the Vernal Equinox
It is the start of Spring in the Northern Hemisphere 
Southern Hemisphere (SYDNEY) Sunrise
Notice that the sun is left (north-east) of the cardinal direction - East
21 April 2015


Southern Hemisphere (SYDNEY) Sunrise
Notice that the sun is still left (north-east) of the cardinal direction - East
21 June 2015
This is the day of the Summer Solstice in the Northern Hemisphere.
After this day, the sun will start to move towards the East until the Fall equinox.


Additional Information


The above information on the day of equal daytime & darkness can be obtained by observation, but only if you are at the location indicated. So if a believer lives outside Israel, it would not have been possible to know this information accurately, 50 years ago. The information I have provided comes from :     http://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/astronomy.html?n=110&month=3&year=2014&obj=sun&afl=-11&day=1

Jospehus, in the above quote, is relating his astronomy as it existed at the time of the Exodus, some 1500 years before his time, and 3400+ years from our time – Not how the stars are positioned today.

Philo, another Jewish historian described this in the following way – it is quoted by Andrew Roth in “The Real Equinox Rule", p. 41-42

“Moses puts down the beginning of the vernal equinox as the 1st month of the year…for it is through the bounty of nature that the seeds which are sown to produce the necessary food of mankind are brought to perfection. (Philo, On Moses, 2:222)”

“This phrase “beginning of the vernal equinox” is a huge and critical clue for piecing the system together. Philo recognizes the importance of dating the start of the Hebrew Solar Year at the “beginning” of spring, because this will give a fixed point in time completely independent of the stars precessing backwards over time. It will never go out of date!

Therefore “beginning of vernal equinox” is understood as being the same as the when the sun begins to be in Aries.”

Then, going back to Josephus, we see the importance of the 14th day of that lunar month, which is the time of the full moon.

Putting it all together it means this: The New Moon nearest VE is Abib, and the first full moon of Aries is Passover ! “

This is strong evidence that the stars, sun and moon cycles are all part of the biblical calendar.

Andrew Roth, in his study, “The Real Equinox Rule”, goes into great detail to explain the above information. In summary, he concludes :

1:  The New Moon nearest the start of Spring, the Vernal Equinox, is ALWAYS the month of the aviv – it is the start of the biblical year.

2:  The earliest possible time for the New Moon would be March 7th, but it can be any time between 7th and April 4th.

I have used this information to determine the start of the biblical year, each year, since 2012. Refer to the “This is how we determine the start of a biblical year” posting.
 
This is how we determine the start of a biblical year

We use the following information as the basis for how we determine the start of a biblical year :

A: The lights (sun, moon & stars) are for signs, moedim, (appointed times), days and years (Gen 1:14).

B: The moon determines the start of the month (Ps 104:19)

C: The start of the biblical year of the Exodus was in the month Yahweh indicated to Moses & Aaron about the first Passover. (Exod 12:2) The Hebrews were in Egypt when these instructions were given.

D: The month of “the aviv” is the month when the original Passover took place, & when the Israelites left Egypt. (Exod 13:4 & Deut 16:1). The month of “the aviv” is the start of Spring in the Northern Hemisphere.

E: Since the Exodus (Exod 12:2) took place from Egypt, & since the Israelites began the second year in the wilderness of Sinai, it seems reasonable to conclude that the start of the year is not determined from Israel. While it is desirable to determine the start of the biblical year from Israel, based on this information, we can therefore apply these principles to our own locality.

F: There are 12 months in a biblical year, unless the agricultural seasons are out of synch, (1 Ch 27), when a 13th month can be added.

G: The start of the Spring agricultural season is involved in determining the start of a biblical year, since the mo 'ed of the First Fruits requires an offering of mature barley from which fine flour can be made. This is to be made 2-3 weeks after the start of the biblical year (Exod 12, Lev 2:1, 7, Lev 23:10, 14)

H: While aviv barley is required for the First Fruits offering, aviv barley itself DOES NOT determine the start of the biblical year. Barley is in the aviv stage, as the result of the Spring agricultural season starting. The barley cannot be aviv UNTIL the earth is in the correct position on its path around the sun.

I: The start of the biblical year must begin in the Northern Hemisphere springtime, signalled by the vernal equinox.

J: The heavenly signs rule over the earthly signs, meaning, we must see signs in the heavens BEFORE we can use earthly signs.

K: The sun signs rule over the moon signs. The moon is still subject to the solar year, because without it, Yahweh’s moedim that are keyed to harvest & planting, will occur out of season. As long as the moedim stay in season, the moon is in charge. When it needs help to keep the moedim at the proper time, the sun takes over. So the sun, stars & moon mark the biblical year.

We, based on the extensive work of Andrew Roth, use the following two rules, to determine the start of the biblical year. Below them, I will demonstrate how we use the Stellarium astronomical software to make the final decision.

1:  The New Moon nearest the start of Spring, the Vernal Equinox, is ALWAYS the month of the aviv – it is the start of the biblical year.

2: The earliest possible time for the New Moon would be March 7th, but it can be any time between 7th and April 4th.

Our Story

In 2012, after much study of Gen 1:14-16, we began the biblical new year with the conjunction moon on 23 March, 2012. We use the moon conjunction on, or after the vermal equinox.

Using Stellarium, on the day of the vernal equinox, the 23 March 2012, we know that the sun rose on the right hand side of the constellation PISCES, in the upper area. (I used the "no Atmosphere" feature of Stellarium to determine this). Note that the time was 8:31 am in the following screen-shots. The screen shots show the same time for the same day, with & without the constellation artwork.


23 March 2012 @ 8:31 am Constellations shown with lines & artwork


Clearly, we would not see this in the sky at 8:31 am, because (a) it would be complete daylight, and (b) there is no "artwork" to guide us.

The following screen-shot shows the same situation as the previous one, without the constellation artwork

23 March 2012 @ 8:31 am Constellations shown without the artwork

In order to use this information in a practical way, (as the ancients Israelites would have), we need to examine the Eastern sky, perhaps one hour BEFORE sunrise, and determine which stars are visible, & what are their positions relative to direct East, & the place the sun will rise at sunrise.

Here is a screen-shot on 23 March, 2012, the day of the vernal equinox, when the sunrise is about 7:10 am, & the sun rising just left of East. (the no Atmosphere feature is on to help us see clearly where the sun rises).


Let's turn the Atmosphere back on, and go backwards about 1 hour, & examine the position of the stars BEFORE sunrise. I've shown the constellations with their names & lines, so that we can better understand their positions relative to direct East. Below it, we have the same Eastern sky without labels. The un-named constellation left of East, in the second screen shot, above the white arrow is PEGASUS.



Explanation

1: This precise arrangement of stars, about one hour before sunrise, shows the morning sky of the new moon day, at the start of the biblical year 2012-2013.

2: If we use Stellarium to cycle through 12 lunar months, we can see whether this same morning sky arrangement is present to begin the biblical year, 2013-2014.

Below are two screen-shots, (with and without constellation labels), of the morning sky on the 13 March, 2013, the morning after the new moon conjunction, about one hour before sunrise. This would be the start of a possible 13th month.

13 March 2013 6:20 am
1 hour before SUNRISE with constellation labels


13 March 2013 6:20 am
1 hour before SUNRISE without constellation labels


Q:  Is this the start of the first month of the new biblical year, or do we need to add a 13th month ?

A: Let's see if we can TEST it.

Below are 2 screen-shots - one of the 1st biblical month of 2012 (23 March), and the other, a possible 1st month of the biblical year of 2013.

Let's examine them carefully to see if a 13th month is required.



Q: Are these stars (constellations) on the 13th March, 2013, in a similar pattern to where they were on 23 March 2012 ?
A: Clearly, the relative position of the constellations for the 13th  March 2013, is not the same as for 23 March 2012. The sun is much closer to Aquarius.

Q: What conclusion can be drawn ?
A: There is still a few days BEFORE the cycle of the year will be completed.

Q: Is this significant ?
A: I'm not sure - we need to check.

Q: If we fast-forward to 4 April, 2013, what do we notice ?
A: Let's look carefully at the screen shot.



If we carefully compare the morning sky of the 4th April 2013 with that of the 23rd March 2012, we see a very similar pattern. This confirms that the yearly cycle has been completed.

If we use modern technology, by adding the constellation lines & artwork, we can see that the sun is in a different place to what it was at the start of the biblical year in 2012.


Q: Can a new biblical year begin BEFORE the previous year's cycle has been completed ?
A: This is just a personal opinion.

Deut 22:9-11 tells us that we are not to sow divers seeds in a vineyard, nor are we to plow an ox with an ass, or wear a garment of divers sorts such as wool & linen. Matt 9:16-17 also tells us that we wouldn't put a new cloth on an old garment, nor would we put new wine in old bottles.

If you look carefully at the date above, March 13, 2013, you will notice that it is BEFORE the vernal equinox of March 21. That means that Spring has not quite arrived, & the barley needed for the first-fruits offering of Lev 23, would not be at the required stage of development.

Based on these ideas, I believe that we cannot begin a new biblical year until the old biblical year is completely finished.

The following chart shows the dates for the start of each biblical year from 2012 until 2020. I will now provide screen shots for each of those years from 31/3/2014 until 25/3/2020. Please compare the position of the sun in the constellation of PISCES.








When does the biblical month begin ?

I believe that it should be possible to gather together, believers who are willing to examine what Yahweh tells us about this matter. I encourage all readers to only seek Yahweh's Truth in this matter, & not be distracted by any traditions or biases.

Before I examine the two main possible methods for determining the start of a biblical month, I’d like to present some scientific facts about the moon. Please study them carefully, so that we all have the same understanding of how the moon moves in relation to the Earth.

The moon is a natural satellite of the Earth, whose average distance from the Earth is 384,467 km. Because the moon’s rotation is synchronised with its revolution around the Earth, the same side of the moon always faces the Earth.

The phases of the moon are the different ways the moon looks from Earth during the month. This happens because as the moon moves through space, different parts of it face the sun. The same phases of the moon happen again and again, & on an average, it takes about 29.5 days (about 697 hours) to complete one revolution around the earth.

NB – A primary reason for confusion between different Messianic groups in determining the start of a biblical month, is that we are scattered across the planet. We need to understand that the moon’s journey around Earth has nothing to do with the location of the observer, but rather, the moon’s position relative to the Earth and the Sun.

Q: Does the following statement seem logical to you, & do you agree with it ?
A: A new moon is not determined by those various locations “sighting” of a first crescent at their sunset, but rather occurs for the entire Earth at one time. The moon centers itself between the Sun and the Earth, & then begins to build the light of the first day (from the zero light of a conjunction). A careful examination of the following diagram should illustrate this principle.

Perhaps things will become clearer, if we carefully examine the following diagram, and perform the exercise below.


Exercise             
(From : http://www.fossilizedcustoms.com/moonpeople.html)

Picture yourself on the surface of the Earth, aligning your view of the moon from the dotted lines in the illustrations above. The moon will appear to you as the image in the outer ring. The circuit of the moon as it travels around the Earth is illustrated by the inner ring – this is not related to what the moon looks like from a specific locality.

The Earth is independently spinning, and people at various locations on the surface are arguing about what "day" of the moon it is, relative to their position, instead of the moon in its circuit. Regardless of where someone is, after 697 hours of time, the moon will return to its starting position between the Earth and the Sun. Where you happen to be on the sphere of the Earth, and what time it may be at your location, has nothing to do with when the moon reaches its zero-point.

Q: If you are a “first crescent” person, where would you be on Earth, on the above diagram to observe the very first crescent?
A: Clearly, you would be at some place just above the 0O dotted line.

Wouldn’t that place be different for every first crescent observer on Earth, since they would all be in different locations?

This is very confusing, & appears to conflict with 1 Cor 14:33, which tells us Yahweh that is NOT an Elohim of CONFUSION.

1Cor 14:33 For Yahweh is not (the author) of confusion

Basic Premise

Around the world, there are two main groups of people, who each currently begin their biblical month in different ways. Of these two main groups, there are those who begin their biblical month by sighting the first crescent of the moon, after the period of the “dark moon”, and those who begin their biblical month on the day of the conjunction, or on the day AFTER the moon’s conjunction.

Q: What does this tell us ?
A: It is obvious that at least one group is in error - both groups cannot be correct.

Personally, I only want to do Yahweh's will – I want to do things His way – I want to walk in all His ways (Deut 10:12), so if I am in one of the groups that is wrong, I want to know this, & I want to fix it. That's why I want to TEST all the evidence that is available, before I decide!

Deu 10:12  And now, Israel, what doth Yahweh your Elohim require of thee, but to fear Yahweh your Elohim, to walk in all his ways, and to love him, and to serve Yahweh your Elohim with all thy heart and with all thy soul,
Deu 10:13 To keep the commandments of Yahweh, and his statutes, which I command thee this day for thy good?


A famous person once said “there is only one really effective way to destroy truth – to assume that you already have it !” I don't want to make this same mistake, so again, I want to examine ALL the evidence I can find!

There are only two real possibilities or theories. Please remember & check, that there is relatively little, specific scriptural evidence that relates to the start of a biblical month, & there is even less detailed scriptural evidence related to the moon.

Let's begin our study by examining each theory separately. After this, we will consider the problems associated with each theory. Finally, I will analyse the information, & state MY conclusion based on that analysis.

I am presenting what I have studied, and what I have found. I encourage each of you to do your own analysis, & arrive at your own conclusion.


Theory 1 - The biblical month begins when the first crescent of the moon is observed after the period of the "dark moon".

What is the Evidence for Theory 1 ?

1:   A very important piece of evidence put forward to support this theory, is that, since Gen 1:14 tells us that the "lights" are for "signs", & so, we must see the moon, in order for it to be a sign.
Associated with this, is the idea that light must come from the “lights”, in order for it to be a sign, hence the visible first crescent theory.

Gen 1:14 And Elohim said, Let lights be in the expanse of the heavens, to divide between the day and the night. And let them be for signs and for (moedim) seasons, and for days and years.

2:   Ps 104:19 tells us Yahweh that made the moon for His moedim. These moedim can only be determined by knowing when the correct start of a biblical month is. This theory tells us that we must see the first crescent of the moon, in order for a biblical month to begin.

Psa 104:19  He appointed the moon for seasons (appointed times - moedim)


3:   Another piece of evidence relates to the actual meaning of the Hebrew word, chodesh, H2320, which is translated as new, or month, or new moon. Scriptural evidence often used as support for this idea includes : 1 Sam 20:5, 18; Ps 81:3, & Ezek 46:1. It is claimed that it is called the “new” moon because the first crescent moon is the first time the “re-newed” moon is sighted. Refer to the table for Strong’s & Brown-Driver-Briggs' definitions.


In terms of the statement, “the new moon is tomorrow”, (1 Sam 20:5), proponents of theory 1, claim that the day when David spoke these words must have been the 30th day of a month, & therefore,  tomorrow” must be the 1st day of a new month, (since a biblical month cannot have more than 30 days). 

 Rabbi Ed Nydle suggests from 1 Sam 20:5 & 18, that the New Moon at that time was a festival time. Amos 8:4-6 implies that it may have been observed as a "sabbath".


4: Others claim that 1 Sam 20:5 is evidence for the first crescent being used, by explaining that the term “tomorrow is the new moon” is used because there have been 2 days of darkness, so the next day will definitely be the day of the first crescent. Observation tells us that, at the moon's conjunction, the moon can be hidden for almost 1 to 3.5 days.

5: Further evidence quoted for support is historical in nature. The Talmud claims that the Sanhedrin relied on 2 witnesses to sight the first crescent, in order to determine the start of the biblical month. The 2 witnesses were apparently questioned carefully in order to be sure that what they claim to have seen, was the first crescent. The following quote from https://www.hebrew4christians.com/Holidays/Rosh_Chodesh/rosh_chodesh.html provides some details :

6:  Joe Dummond of www.sightedmoon.com explains a theory that uses the constellation Virgo and the work of E.L. Martin, with modern astronomical software, to show that the New Moon sightings had to be made using the “crescent” moon – he uses Rev 12:1-3. Mr Martin comes up with a time of  6.15 - 7.45 pm, September 11th, 3 BC, as the date of Yahushua's birth – this according to Mr Martin was Yom Teruah of that year. He further concludes that since this is the exact time of Yahushua's birth, then the only time when the sun can "clothe" the virgin, & the moon is at her feet (Rev 12:1), is when a crescent moon appears.

Rev 12:1 And a great sign was seen in the heavens, a woman having been clothed with the sun, and the moon was underneath her feet; and on her head a crown of twelve stars;
Rev 12:2 and having a babe in her womb. She cried, being in labor, and having birth pains to deliver.
Rev 12:3 And another sign was seen in the heavens. And, behold, a great red dragon having seven heads and ten horns! And on his heads were seven crowns


7: In 1 Kings 6:38, and 1 Kings 8:2,  there are two different Hebrew words translated as “month”. They are ירח, H3391, yerach, (month Bul), and חדשׁ , H2320, chodesh (eighth month). All the translations found, translated these two Hebrew words as “month”. This indicate that yerach and chodesh are interchangeable words.


Theory 2 - The biblical month begins on the biblical day of the moon’s conjunction, or on the first biblical day AFTER the moon's conjunction.

What is the Evidence for Theory 2 ?

The moon's conjunction is when the sun & moon are on the same side of the earth, & all three are in a straight line – it is a lunar eclipse. The conjunction itself, lasts but a moment ! The moon starts to give its light only a few minutes after conjunction, but because of the moon's closeness to the sun, it cannot be seen with the naked eye until the moon has at least 1.44% illumination – it can clearly be seen with the naked eye, if the moon’s illumination is 2% or greater. Note again, that the moon can be hidden at the time of conjunction for almost 1 to 3.5 days.


Although there is a lot of additional scientific information about the moon & its cycle, apart from the above information, I will only be using the scriptural & practical evidence that would be available to an ordinary ancient Israelite.

1:   This theory also uses Gen 1:14 as evidence. It agrees that the "lights" are for "signs", but claims a sign does not need to be seen, for it to be a sign. It asserts that “seeing a sign”, is a Greek-Roman way of thinking, not a Hebraic way to think.

Theory 2 quotes Heb 11:1, which gives a biblical definition for faith, as support.

Heb 11:1  Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. 


Theory 2 asks the question, if "faith is the substance of things being hoped, the evidence of things not having been seen", why does a sign need to be seen, to be experienced ? Doesn’t Heb 11:3 also support this ? Isn’t this is the Hebraic way of looking at this evidence ?

Heb 11:3  Through faith we understand that the worlds were framed by the word of God, so that things which are seen were not made of things which do appear. 

2: This theory also agrees that Ps 104:19 tells us that Yahweh made the moon for His moedim (His appointed times), & that they can only be determined by knowing when the correct start of the biblical month is.

3: If we carefully examine 1 Sam 20, specifically verses 5, 18, & 27 where the story of Jonathan, Saul's son, & David's is given, we can observe several important points.

 David knows king Saul wants to kill him, but Jonathan, doesn't believe it. They make a plan to test David's belief about Saul, and this is all described in 1 Sam 20. Verse 5 gives details of an important part of this plan. The plan involves David hiding away until the third evening after the time of 1 Sam 20:5. I have provided the HRB version.


1Sa 20:5 And David said to Jonathan, Behold, the new moon is tomorrow (chodesh). And sitting I should certainly sit with the king to eat. And you shall send me away, and I shall be hidden in the field until the third evening(HRB)

Q: In context, what does the statement "the new moon is tomorrow" tell us ?
A: A check of Strong’s Concordance & BDB (below) provide strong evidence that, in context, “tomorrow” is the appropriate translation. This is supported by the fact that at least 10 different translations I consulted, all translated it this way. Therefore, this phrase indicates that the day of the new moon is calculated in some way. This statement in repeated in 1 Sam 20:18.

Q: Why does David stay away until the third evening ?
A: There isn't a reason stated, but from the story, it seems likely that the Israelites of this period may have had a tradition of keeping a new moon feast for 3 days. (Rabbi Ed Nydle agrees).

Later I will give my detailed explanation for why this tradition was used.



1Sa 20:18  Then Jonathan said to David, Tomorrow is the new moon: and thou shalt be missed, because thy seat will be empty.

1 Sam 20:27 tells us that David didn't come to the new moon meal on either the first day or the second day, & king Saul asks why on the second night ?

1Sa 20:27  And it came to pass on the morrow, which was the second day of the month, that David's place was empty: and Saul said unto Jonathan his son, Wherefore cometh not the son of Jesse to meat, neither yesterday, nor to day? 


Verses 1 Sam 20:28-34 reveal to Jonathan that king Saul, his father, really wants to kill David.

Theory 2 proponents claim that at the time of 1 Sam 20, the Israelites had a tradition of keeping the start of the new moon as a feast for three days. They did this because, they wanted to observe the first crescent, in order to CONFIRM that the new moon had begin, knowing that it can take up to three days for the first crescent to be seen.

4:  Isa 13:9-10 tell us that on "the day of Yahweh", "the sun will be darkened (not totally dark) & the moon will not reflect its light".

Q:  Which day is considered to be "the day of Yahweh" ?
A: It is believed to be Yom Teruah, the day of Trumpets. Is 13:10c states that the moon shall not reflect its light. Yahushua also quotes this in Mark 13:24.

Isa 13:9  Behold, the day of Yahweh cometh, cruel both with wrath and fierce anger, to lay the land desolate: and he shall destroy the sinners thereof out of it.
Isa 13:10 For the stars of heaven and the constellations thereof shall not give their light: the sun shall be darkened in his going forth, and the moon shall not cause her light to shine
.

Mar 13:24  But in those days, after that tribulation, the sun shall be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light,

If the “day of Yahweh” is a Yom Teruah day, then according to the above scripture verses, it must be a day when the moon doesn’t give her light, and therefore, it must be a “dark moon” day. Isn’t this excellent evidence for a new moon day that depends on a conjunction start?

5:  
Q: What do we know about Yahweh that can assist us in determining the correct start to a biblical month ?
A:           
(i)   Yahweh is a very orderly Being

Everything that our Heavenly Father does has judicial order. Simply put, it is the order that He set out at creation of how things work, such as gravity. Yahweh’s judicial order sets precedent for our lives, and how we are to worship Him. So when looking at what constitutes a “new moon” according to Scripture, we will look at the precedents that He has set, since He does not change (Mal 3:6a)

Mal 3:6  For I am Yahweh, I change not
;

We see the precedent laid out at creation in that the things created did not come into being out of things that already appeared. The same way that the world started in darkness (Gen 1:2-3), and the day starts in darkness, and even life in the womb starts in darkness, the precedent set is that the month starts at conjunction, the exact time each month that the earth, the moon and the sun are lined up in perfect order.

Gen 1:2  And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters.
Gen 1:3 And God said, Let there be light: and there was light
.

(ii) Yahweh is perfect.

When you see a quarter moon, the month is ¼ over. When you see a full moon the month is half over. When you see a waning ¼ of a moon, the month is ¾ over, and when the moon is dark again at conjunction it is “resetting” the new month. Refer to the diagram from Andrew Roth below. This symmetry of the moon is evidence that Yahweh is perfect.


6: The evidence of a 30 A.D. crucifixion of Yahushua

Yahweh planned for His son Yahushua to be crucified on a Wednesday in 30 A.D. We know that Yahushua was not crucified on a Friday, as you cannot get three days and three nights in the grave from Friday afternoon until Sunday morning (Matt 12:38-40), but He was crucified midweek. Now if you go to the year He was crucified, 30 A.D., you can only come up with a midweek crucifixion if you start your month by conjunction, but if you are visibly sighting a crescent, you are back to a Friday crucifixion, which is impossible according to Scripture. There is ample historical evidence to clearly show a 30A.D. crucifixion.

Mat 12:38  Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.
Mat 12:39 But he answered and said unto them, An evil and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign; and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the prophet Jonas:
Mat 12:40 For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale's belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth
.

Other evidence to support a 30 AD crucifixion, interestingly, come from the Jerusalem Talmud. We read there that :

"Forty years before the destruction of the Temple, the western light went out, the crimson thread remained crimson, and the lot for the Lord always came up in the left hand. They would close the gates of the Temple by night and get up in the morning and find them wide open" (Jacob Neusner, The Yerushalmi, p.156-157). [the Temple was destroyed in 70 CE]

Another piece of evidence to support a 30 AD crucifixion, also comes from the Jerusalem Talmud. Jewish authorities acknowledge that for 40 years, until it destruction, the Temple doors swung open every night of their own accord. The leading Jewish authority of that time, Yohanan ben Zakkai, declared that this was a sign of impending doom, and that the Temple itself would be destroyed. We read :

''Said Rabban Yohanan Ben Zakkai to the Temple, 'O Temple, why do you frighten us? We know that you will end up destroyed. For it has been said, 'Open your doors, O Lebanon, that the fire may devour your cedars' '' (Zechariah 11:1)' (Sota 6:3).

A third piece of evidence to support a 30 AD crucifixion, is that every night for 40 years (over 12,500 nights in a row) the main lamp of the Temple lampstand (the menorah) went out of its own accord — no matter what attempts and precautions the priests took to safeguard against this event!

Earnest Martin states:

''In fact, we are told in the Talmud that at dusk the lamps that were unlit in the daytime (the middle four lamps remained unlit, while the two eastern lamps normally stayed lit during the day) were to be re-lit from the flames of the western lamp (which was a lamp that was supposed to stay lit all the time — it was like the 'eternal' flame that we see today in some national monuments) . . .
''This 'western lamp' was to be kept lit at all times. For that reason, the priests kept extra reservoirs of olive oil and other implements in ready supply to make sure that the 'western lamp' (under all circumstances) would stay lit. But what happened in the forty years from the very year Messiah said the physical Temple would be destroyed? Every night for forty years the western lamp went out, and this in spite of the priests each evening preparing in a special
way the western lamp so that it would remain constantly burning all night!
'' (The Significance of the Year CE 30, Ernest Martin, Research Update, April 1994, p.4).

Again, the odds against the lamp continually going out are astronomical. Something out of the ordinary was going on.

The ''light'' of the Menorah—representing contact with Yahweh, His Spirit, and His Presence was now removed. This special demonstration occurred starting with the crucifixion of the Messiah.

A fourth piece of evidence to support a 30 AD crucifixion, is that from 30 AD to 70 AD, the following documented event took place.

"and it has further been taught: ‘For forty years before the destruction of the Temple the thread of scarlet never turned white but it remained red.’" (Bavli Rosh Hashanah 31b).

The Jewish authorities have been unable to explain these 4 events, but they clearly point to something happening in 30 AD – we know that it was the crucifixion of the Messiah.

7:  
Q: Does a month starting in darkness make biblical sense ?  
A: The physical often teaches the spiritual. Remember, biblically, many things begin in darkness
~ creation itself began in darkness (Gen 1:2)
~ Job 12:22 says "He reveals mysteries from the darkness, and brings the deep darkness into light"
~ we start off our lives in darkness (in the womb)
~ our spiritual lives start off in complete darkness, & then light comes into our lives
~   John 12:46 tells us "I (Yahushua) have come as Light into the world, so that everyone who believes in Me will not remain in darkness".
~ doesn't Yahushua call our attention to certain periods in our lifetime - from "death" (darkness) to being reborn into light ?
~ 1 John 2:8 tells us "Again I write a new commandment to you which is true in Him and in you, because the darkness is passing away, and the true Light already shines"

Darkness is very important to Yahweh

~ The covenant with Abraham was made in darkness (Gen 15:12)

Gen 15:12  And when the sun was going down, a deep sleep fell upon Abram; and, lo, an horror of great darkness fell upon him
.

~ the passing over of the death angel took place during the night time (darkness) (Exod 12:12)

Exo 12:12  For I will pass through the land of Egypt this night, and will smite all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, both man and beast; and against all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgment: I am Yahweh
.

~ Yahweh dwells in darkness (Exod 20:21, 1 Kings 8:12, Ps 18:11)

Exo 20:21  And the people stood afar off, and Moses drew near unto the thick darkness where Yahweh was
.

1Ki 8:12  Then spake Solomon, Yahweh said that he would dwell in the thick darkness
.

Psa 18:11  He made darkness his secret place; his pavilion round about him were dark waters and thick clouds of the skies
.

The moon cycle begins in darkness, & moves into light in increasing steps.

8:  There is one scriptural verse that “appears” to deal with the new moon. It is Ps 81:3, & a common translation of it is :

Psa 81:3  Blow up the trumpet in the new moon, in the time appointed, on our solemn feast day
.

If we examine this Ps 81:3 in its original language, Hebrew, it can be translated as :


A closer examination of the Hebrew written in this verse reveals the following:


From the above information, there are two possible interpretations :

Option 1 Ps 81:3

  Blow  in month  shofar  in fullness or full moon  towards day  our feast

OR

Option 2 Ps 81:3

Blow   in month   shofar   in concealed moon   towards day   our feast

If we examine Option 1, we need to ask ourselves, is there ever a time when a shofar must be blown on a day of the fullness or full moon ?

We know there are two moedim that fall on the 15th of a Hebrew month, the day of a full moon. These are the feast of Unleavened Bread (15th of the 1st month), and the feast of Sukkot (15th of the 7th month).

Num 10:10 tells us that the two silver trumpets, H2689, are to be blown on "our solemn days (moedim)". A shofar is not a silver trumpet, and so,  fullness" or "full moon" are inappropriate meanings for Ps 81:3.

ba ke'se, H3677, comes from the root word, כסה kasah, H3680, (with the same Hebrew letters, but with different vowels) is widely understood to mean “cover, concealed, enveloped, shrouded, dark”.      

Now we need to check Option 2, to see if it fulfils all scriptural requirements.

Lev 23:24 refers to the first day of the 7th month, or the new moon day - it is called "the feast of trumpets". It tells us that it is a day when there will be "blowing of trumpets". The Hebrew word describing it, is H8643, teruah. Strong's Concordance tells us that this word means "clamour, acclamation, a battle cry, a clangor, an alarum". BDB tells us it means "alarm, signal, shout, sound of tempest, blast of war, alarm or joy". While this doesn't specifically mention the shofar, many translators have rendered this word as "blowing of trumpets". At the same time, the "feast of trumpets" is a "new moon" day, so the silver trumpet, H2689, chatsotsrah, is appropriate. However since it isn't mentioned, this time probably isn't a new moon day.

Without getting into a deeper discussion on the real meaning of this verse, it seems very clear, that this verse cannot be referring to a new moon that begins with a first crescent, because a full moon nor a covered moon is a crescent.

My research indicates that the most correct translation of Ps 81:3 is :

Ps 81:3 Blow the shofar in the month at the concealed moon towards the day of our feast
.

9:   Although this is historical evidence, it can be considered. Hillel the Elder (not Hillel II) was a Rabbi who lived just prior to Yahushua. In 10 BC, he re-instituted conjunction observance.

Refer to http://littleguyintheeye.wordpress.com/2009/09/06/biblical-calendar/. This source has been removed from the Internet, & I have been unable to confirm it elsewhere.

10: In the Andrew Roth study, “Philo & the New Moon”, where he quotes Philo at :      http://www.earlyjewishwritings.com/text/philo/book28.html.

It reads :

     XI. (41) "The 3rd (festival) is that which comes after the conjunction, which happens on the day of the new moon in each month”.

Clearly, Philo, a Jewish historian who wrote after Yahushua's time, considered that the start of the biblical month involved the conjunction.

11: In 2014, there was a blood moon on the 15th day of the 7th month, (Sukkot), based on a conjunction start.

Problems with each theory

The proponents of each theory claim their opponents have serious problems.

Let's examine these in an attempt to arrive at a correct decision about when a biblical month begins.

Theory 1 - the First Crescent Problems

1: In point 3 above, we read that the Hebrew word for "new moon" is H2320, chodesh. While it is true that chodesh is often translated as "new moon", it is NEVER translated as "new moon" in the Torah, the first 5 books of the Tanach. There, it is always translated as "new" or "month".

2:  1 Sam 20:5 & 18 tell us that "tomorrow is the new moon". Since it is an observable fact that, there can be 1-3 days before the first crescent of a new moon can be seen with the naked eye, it is IMPOSSIBLE to calculate precisely when it can be seen, unless the day indicated was, the 30th day of the biblical month. If this new moon day was determined by the first crescent, why did they apparently have a 3 day festival ? They wouldn’t need to confirm it further, since the first crescent was observed !

Q: Why would David need to wait until the 3rd day to meet with Jonathan ?
A: It seems very unlikely that 1 Sam 20:5 & 18 can be referring to a first crescent start to a new month !

Q: If the next day after 1 Sam 20:5 is determined by observing the first crescent, what possible reason would there be to :
(a) celebrate the new moon festival for 2 -3 days, &
(b) why would David be waiting until the third evening ?

3:  Earlier, it was claimed that the "day of Yahweh" would occur on a Yom Teruah day. Is 13:10 & Mark 13:24 both tell us that "the moon will not give her light". If this is so, it cannot possibly be referring to a first crescent start of a biblical month, since the moon will not give her light !

4: Amos 8:5 asks "when will the new moon have passed ?".

Q: If a new moon day is determined with a first crescent, why did they have to ask when the new moon would be over ?
A: Biblically, the day would be over when the sun went down, & they would not have to ask. But because they appear to have had a "tradition" of celebrating 3 days as a "feast" from conjunction to first crescent, the observation of the New Moon became longer than the actual day.

It may be in Amos 8:5, they were referring to the Day of trumpets - the only commanded "Shabbaton", שׁבתון that is a New Moon day (refer to Lev 24:24) !

Clearly, this cannot be referring to a new moon day starting with a first crescent.

NB – this Shabbaton, שׁבתון in Lev 23:24 is NOT a Shabbat Shabbaton,
שׁבת שׁבתון like the 7th day Sabbath of Lev 23:3.

Amo 8:5  Saying, When will the new moon be gone, that we may sell corn? and the sabbath, that we may set forth wheat, making the ephah small, and the shekel great, and falsifying the balances by deceit
?


Lev 23:24  Speak unto the children of Israel, saying, In the seventh month, in the first day of the month, shall ye have a sabbath, a memorial of blowing of trumpets, an holy convocation
.

5:  In order to examine a problem when a sighted, first crescent moon is used to begin a biblical month, I have created a hypothethical version of a typical moon cycle.

Legend                          
The row beginning with Day 28 represents a moon cycle based on a CONJUNCTION count.
The row beginning with Day 1 represents a moon cycle based on a SIGHTED CRESCENT count. The example shown represents a cycle where the sighted crescent is seen on the 2nd night after the day of the conjunction.

(NB - my research from the following sites shows that the shortest time for observing the first crescent moon with the naked eye is 15.5 hours after the actual conjunction. The maximum time between these two events is 3.5 days).
(Refer to http://aa.usno.navy.mil/faq/docs/crescent.php & http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_moon)

If we examine this information carefully, we notice a few irregularities about the sighted moon theory.
A: The start of the new month can be 1, 2 or 3 days after the actual conjunction.
B: This is a problem because the main visible phases of the moon (1st quarter, full moon and 3rd quarter) can vary for up to 3 days on different months. Yahweh is an Elohim who is perfect, & to my way of thinking, these irregular observable phenomena support a picture of an Elohim of confusion, not an Elohim of order (1 Cor 14:33a)

1Co 14:33a  For God is not the author of confusion
,

C: The day of the full moon, when it has 100.0% illumination, can NEVER be in the exact middle of a biblical month, based on the sighted moon theory.
D: In 2014, there was a blood moon, which can only be observed on the day when the moon is 100.0% illuminated. As mentioned earlier this occurred when the month began with the conjunction. Using the first crescent, their “full moon”, with 100.0% illumination, was 3 days later.


6: Yahweh didn’t tell the Hebrews to use the crescent moon to begin the first month while in Egypt. Some misinterpret the meaning of the Hebrew term translated as "observe" in Deut 16:1.

Deu 16:1  Observe the month of Aviv, and keep the passover unto Yahweh your Elohim: for in the month of Aviv Yahweh your Elohim brought thee forth out of Egypt by night
.

The Hebrew word translated as “observe” in the original Hebrew is Strong’s word #8104 “shawmar”, and does not mean to physically look at, but rather to keep, to guard and protect, to be aware of. It is the exact same word that is used in Deut 5:12, when we are told that we are observe the Sabbath day, and I don’t think anyone will argue that on the Sabbath we are not visibly sighting something to start the day, actually it is the very opposite, it is the absence of the sun that tells us that the Sabbath has started.

Deu 5:12  Keep 
(shawmar) the sabbath day to sanctify it, as the LORD thy God hath commanded thee.

In fact, just one chapter earlier in Deut 4:19, Yahweh commands the Hebrews not to look at or worship the sun, the moon and the stars.

Deu 4:19  And lest thou lift up thine eyes unto heaven, and when thou seest the sun, and the moon, and the stars, even all the host of heaven, shouldest be driven to worship them, and serve them, which the LORD thy God hath divided unto all nations under the whole heaven
.

Now do you honestly think that, in a region where people were worshipping the sun and moon and stars, and with the Israelites’ propensity to paganism with the golden calf, that Yahweh would really have them go every month out to sight a crescent moon? It would be like sending an alcoholic to watch a room full of whiskey, and telling him not to drink.

7: Many claim that the only way to properly keep the holy days correctly is to know the timing of the new moon from Jerusalem, thus using Jerusalem time. So before the last 50 years, how would anyone living in Europe or America know when the crescent moon was sighted in Jerusalem ? And if you go by a local sighting, you can have up three different days for a moed in a given area. Nowhere in Scripture does Yahweh ever command to visibly sight a crescent moon to start the month.

8:  One of the most convincing pieces of evidence is based on the work of E.L. Martin in his book, "The Star of Bethlehem - The Star that Astonished the World". As stated above, Mr Martin claims that Yahushua was born on September 11th, between 6:15 and 7:45 pm,  3 BC. The problem is, that Joe Dummond's sighted moon theory is based on this date.

Another respected scholar, Andrew Gabriel Roth, also deals with the same topic in his God's Learning Channel, program 3, “The Heavens Declare the Glory of Yahweh”. He presents very convincing evidence, and comes up with a date for Yahushua's birth as 13 September, 5 BCE. Clearly, they both cannot be correct & it is possible that they are both incorrect.

Mr Martin's conclusion is based on the idea that Yahushua was born on Yom Teruah, the feast of Trumpets, the new moon day of the 7th month. This clearly cannot be correct, since Luke 2:7 tells us "there was no room in the inn", indicating a time after the start of Sukkot (15th day of the 7th month).

The original web address for A.G.Roth's talk was :
http://www.glc.us.com/site/watch.php?program=28&video=202
which I believe has been removed, but I did have extensive notes & screen shots for the program, & was able to put together these ideas. The program was called, "The time of Messiah's birth" by Andrew Gabriel Roth.

9:  The crescent (saharon in Hebrew) only appears 3 times in the Tanach (Jud 8:21, 26 & Is 3:18) – each time, it is associated with paganism, & never is it compared to the new moon. The crescent  moon was used by the ancient world, but it was not Israel who used it - the worshippers of Diana (Artemis, Ishtar, Venus, & Asherah) used the crescent as her symbol, as do the Ishmaelites (and Islam) today.


10: The Babylonian Talmud, 02 Rosh 07, does have records of sighting the crescent as part of a new moon certification process, but it appears to have been originally done as a "backwards" marker - as a way to confirm that the conjunction new moon had begun. Again, I believe  1 Sam 20:5 supports this.

11: The Babylonian Talmud (03 Yomah 07) records that there were 300 high priests during the “years of the wicked”, a period of 420 years. They appear to have died on Yom Kippur because they went into the Holy of Holies, on the wrong day ! Andrew Roth claims that this stopped in 10 BC when Hillel the Elder (a Pharisee) corrected to calendar back to a conjunction start of the biblical month. We certainly know that Ananias & Caiaphas ruled as high priest for a number of years.

12: Andrew Roth further claims that Philo & Josephus agree about how the calendar of Hillel the Elder worked – it was based on the “dark moon”. Andrew Roth presents considerable evidence for the conjunction start of a month in the following (Philo & the New Moon by Andrew Roth;
http://www.earlyjewishwritings.com/text/philo/book28.html)

13: Yahushua never disagreed with the calendar of the Pharisees – in Matt 23:1-2, He says that the  Pharisees & not the Sadducees “sit in Moses’ seat”.

14:   A close examination of the following diagram that was used earlier, provides significant evidence against the 1st crescent sighting theory. As I wrote above, the Earth is independently spinning, and people at various locations on the surface are arguing about what "day" of the moon it is, relative from their position, instead of the moon in its circuit.

If you are a conjunction theory person, the start of any biblical month will always be on the 0o line, and after 687 hours of time, the moon will return to that same starting point, 0o.

If you are a first crescent theory person, the start of your biblical month will be somewhere between 0o and 45o. I have drawn a red line to simulate this.

Unlike the conjunction method, when the cycle of the moon is completed, it will almost always NOT return to this same starting position – it could be before that red line or after it ! This is because the moon can be hidden from vision for 15 hours to 3.5 days after the conjunction – the actual time of the conjunction itself affects when the first crescent will be visible. Clearly, the time between the sighted first crescent at the start of one month, and the sighting of the 1st crescent at the start of the following month, will almost never be 687 hours – it will vary every month ! Again, this chaotic situation is a reflection of an elohim of confusion, not one of order. Refer to the diagram below for more information.


15: As far as I am aware, there are THREE different ways that different sighted moon proponents claim to observe the first crescent. Many base their first crescent sighting on the time this crescent is first sighted in Jerusalem. Another group base their sighting based on the FIRST sighting of this crescent, anywhere in the world, and a third group base their sighting on when they sight it in the locality in which they live. My understanding is that the general group of first crescent observers are unable to agree on which of these is the most scriptural.

I will examine each position, & see what my conclusions are.

a:   Those who use the Jerusalem sighting

Q:   Does this seem logical when we know that Moses was not in Israel when Yahweh spoke to him in Exod 12:2 – he was in Egypt ? Wasn’t Moses in the wilderness of Sinai when Yahweh spoke to him about conducting a census on the first day of the second month of the second year, in Numbers chapter 1 ? Wasn’t Moses also in the wilderness of Sinai when Yahweh spoke to him about celebrating Passover in the first month of the second year, as described in Numbers chapter 9 ?

Q:   I live in eastern Australia, which is usually 7 hours ahead of Israel in terms of international time. If we are to keep the start of a biblical month based on Jerusalem time, what do I do when I often sight the first crescent 7 hours BEFORE they do in Jerusalem ?

Q:   Does it seem reasonable to use this method, which for most people in the world relies totally on technology, when such technology has only been available for the last 50 or so years ? How would people use this method for the centuries before that ?

Q:   A study of the books of Kings & of Samuel tell us that the Israelites didn’t start to live in Jerusalem for several hundred years after they entered the promised land. During this time, they celebrated  Yahweh's moedim (feasts) wherever the Tabernacle was. If this is so, doesn’t it seem logical that the place where Yahweh chooses to put His name is the issue, not Jerusalem itself ?

As a side-note, a brief examination of the few scriptures that mention “the place where Yahweh puts His name” (Deut 12:5, 12:11, 12:21, 14:23-24, 16:2 16:6, 16:11 & 26:2), all refer to the place where Israel is to bring their offerings – Passover, First-Fruits & others.

Although the annual moedim indirectly depend on the timing of biblical months, there is no mention of any determination of time.          

An Australian couple I know, who believed in keeping the first crescent, sighted in Jerusalem, said that they would keep Yom Teruah, the first day of the 7th month, on 24-25th September, 2014, based on Jerusalem time.

I decided to do some research by consulting :
www.timeanddate.com, www.iceinspace.com.au, http://moonsighting.com &
http://www.islamicmoon.com, for the latest expert information.

www.timeanddate.com informed me that Jerusalem is 7 hours BEHIND Newcastle (Australia) time. It also told me that the conjunction time for Jerusalem was 9:13 on 24 Sept, while        www.iceinspace.com.au, gave me the conjunction time for Newcastle as 16:13 on 24 Sept, 2014.

http://moonsighting.com is a good website for information about sighting the first crescent (even though it is Muslim based). It shows a map of the world which shows how the visibility of the first crescent is different in different locations around the world. A screen shot of their website details for 24 Sept, 2014 follows :


Again, for the month of Tishri, 2014, the conjunction will occur at Newcastle when it is 16:13, and at Jerusalem when it is 9:13 – each on the 24 Sept, 2014. Jerusalem is 7 hours behind Newcastle.

The following diagram summarises this information, where the secular calendars & the biblical days are compared. The vertical brown line indicates the local time of the conjunction in each place.

Scientists again tell us that at the moment of conjunction, the moon’s illumination is 0.0%, but begins to increase immediately after this moment. Expert observers claim that the first crescent cannot be seen with the naked eye less than 15 hours after the moment of the conjunction, and/or not when its illumination is less than 1.44%. Again, we are told that the period of time when the moon may not be seen varies from 15 hours to 3.5 days, depending on where you live. www.moonsighting.com provides a world map (above), that illustrates this phenomenon.

The Talmud claims that for these reasons, the moed of Trumpets (Yom Teruah), based on the first crescent method, is the “day that no one knows”. This certainly was true up until the last few years -  it can’t be determined in advance, (based on the first crescent method),  without the use of modern technology !


In the following 2 tables, I have summarised my personally collected & recorded data, based on www.iceinspace.com information & some direct observations. If you study it carefully, you will notice that the sighted first crescent almost always occurs after the day of the conjunction. Even though I have only provided this data for the biblical year, 2014, I have about 11 year’s worth of similar data that I have recorded most days during that time.



As a further consideration, I asked myself the following questions, & then attempted to provide honest answers :

Q:   Where was Moses when Yahweh told him about the start of the year in Exod 12:1-2 ?
A:   Wasn’t he in Egypt ?

Q:   Where was Moses when Yahweh spoke to him about conducting a census in Num chapter 1 – wasn’t it on the first day of the second month of the second year ?
A:   Num 1:1 tells us he was in the wilderness of Sinai

Q:   Where was Moses when Yahuah told him about celebrating the Passover in Num  chapter 9 – wasn’t it in the first month of the second year ?
A:   Num 9:1 tells us he was in the wilderness of Sinai

Q:   Where is Jerusalem ?
A:   It is in the northern part of Israel (Canaan at this time) ?

Q:   Does it seem logical to determine the start of a biblical month using Jerusalem time, when there are times when locations such as Newcastle NSW Australia, see the first crescent 7 hours BEFORE they can in Jerusalam ?

Q:   Wouldn’t this Jerusalem method of determining the start of a biblical month be confusing to someone who knows the above facts ? Is Yahweh an Elohim of confusion ?
A:   I would be very confused by this method. 1 Cor 14:33 tells us that Yahweh is NOT an Elohim of confusion.

I believe, based on the above evidence, that these believers are mistaken about when the biblical month of Tishri begins, & strongly urge them to re-examine the information.

b:   Those who use the FIRST sighting, anywhere in the world

Q: Again, does it seem logical and/or reasonable to use this method,
which for most people in the world relies MUST rely on the latest modern technology, when such technology has only been available for the last 50 or so years ? Once more, how would people use this method for the centuries before that ?

c:   Those who use their local sighting, wherever they live

It does seem reasonable, & logical to use this method, since this principle generally agrees with scripture. Moses was told by Yahweh to start his biblical month in Egypt, & Moses again started the second year, where he was in the wilderness of Sinai.

While method c appears to be reasonable, it seems to me that, if those who subscribe the first crescent theory can’t decide on which method to use, there is some confusion about it all.

16:  I have been making daily observations, & keeping records of the moon’s activities for over 11 years in the locality where I live. What I have noticed about the first crescent sightings, is that the percentage of illumination varies every time. Please examine the following table of the 2014 year’s observations. While this is a small sample, it is typical of readings taken during this time.


Q:  If we apply this data to the diagram of one moon monthly cycle above, what conclusions can be drawn ?
A:   It seems obvious to me that since, the percentages of illumination are different each time, that the time for each moon circuit based on this first crescent theory, WILL be DIFFERENT each & every month !!!  It will never be the consistent 687 hours that scientists have determined is the usual time for one circuit of the moon around the Earth.

Q:   Does this sound like the work of an Elohim of perfect order, or is it the work of an elohim of confusion ?

17: In point 7 above, it was stated that in 1 Kings 6:38 & 1 Kings 8:2, that the Hebrew words, yerach  & chodesh can be used interchangeably. If this verse is translated literally, shouldn’t it read ?

1 Kings 6:38  And in the eleventh year, in the moon Bul, the eighth month, the house was   finished as to all its parts, and according to all its plans. So he built it for seven years
.

I believe that, in Yahweh’s word, “every word” is significant, and so, these words are not interchangeable, but have been translated as if they are, either because, the translators are unable to know the difference between them, or there is translator bias of some sort.

18: In point 7 above, I made some comments on sighting the first crescent from Jerusalem. Over the last few years, I have recorded accurate observations twice daily, on the percentage illumination of the moon. I would like to examine  a period of six lunar months, as of 21/3/16, to demonstrate a further problem with the first crescent sighting of the new moon. I don’t have the data for Jerusalem, but I believe it is appropriate to apply the Australian data that I do have, to the Jerusalem situation.


If we examine the days between each successive sighting of the above lunar months, it is obvious that the number of days for each lunar month, based on the sighting of the first crescent, varies. In this small sample of six, consecutive lunar months, there are 29, 31, 31, 30, 30 & 29 days between the sighted crescent new moons.

Q:   If an average biblical month is 29.53 days, & it is generally accepted that a biblical month can be either 29 or 30 days, what happens when there are actually 31 days between consecutive sightings, as happened, twice in this six lunar month sample above?

To me, this is another significant problem with the sighted crescent new moon theory !

Problems with theory 2 - the Conjunction New Moon

The major problem with using the conjunction to determine the start of the new month is calculating WHEN the conjunction of the moon occurs. The opponents of this idea use this as the main reason for saying the ancient Hebrews didn’t have the knowledge or ability to calculate this exact point in the moon’s cycle.

My research of several years (with actual daily data) shows me that it was quite easy for ancient Hebrews to calculate the day of the new moon's conjunction.

Observational Method of Determining the New Moon

(This method relies solely on observation, in a similar way that I believe the ancient Hebrews probably used)

1:  Around the 27th or 28th day of a biblical lunar month, go outside about 30 minutes before sunrise, look towards the north-east, and see if the last moon crescent is visible. You should be able to easily see it if the amount of illumination is 2% or greater.

2:  If the crescent is visible, we must test this by checking the last crescent the very next morning. Usually, we will be unable to see the morning crescent because it is too small, and has been overshadowed by the much stronger rays of the sun. This is NOT the day of the Conjunction.

3:  Sometime during the next biblical day (sunset to sunset), the moon's conjunction will occur. We can't know when, from observation alone. I use www.iceinspace.com or www.timeanddate.com      to assist, but not determine the time of the actual conjunction.

4: The New Moon day begins just after sunset (the next biblical day). It is possible that there could be a first sliver sighting soon after sunset in the north-western sky, just above the horizon, but it is unlikely. We should check anyway.

5:  Just after sunset at the start of the next biblical day, we should check again for the first sliver in the north-west. If the first sliver is observed, that CONFIRMS that we have begun the New Moon day correctly.

6:  If there is no first sliver on the second night of the New Moon, we need to check again at the start of the third night. It should be visible !

NB  Again, the first crescent can take from one to three nights to be observed. Once observed, it confirms the correct start to a biblical month

The following table is not necessarily correct – it simply shows all the possibilities


This method gives at least a 90% record of calculating the correct day of the conjunction, according to my 11 years of data records.

The following table shows an example based on the 1st biblical month of 2014. The official conjunction time was 5:48 on 31/3/14

Please be patient with the following layout, as the tables I am providing are copies which do not fit well on the page space available.


NB - This method can be done, based solely on observation. Even though, I have added Internet data, it can be done without it. I believe this kind of method probably was used by the ancient Israelites.

The above method explains why the Israelites of 1 Sam 20, kept a 3 day new moon celebration.

The following table shows a typical month of daily illumination percentages.

The graph shows how those percentages change during a typical month. Note that the percentages are close together at the time of the conjunction, & at the full moon, but are wider apart between these times.


Again, I apologize for not being able to provide a more clear table.

NB – The timing of the first crescent depends on the precise timing of the conjunction.

Another problem with the Conjunction New Moon theory is which day is declared as the New Moon day. Is it (a) the day of the conjunction, or (b) is it the first biblical day after the conjunction ?

If inclusive reckoning is used to determine the New Moon day, that is, the day of the conjunction, the main problem is that we cannot know the precise timing of the conjunction WITHOUT modern technology, & Internet access.

The method above that uses the "hypothetical" version of a typical moon cycle points to the day of the conjunction, but we cannot know the precise timing, with any certainty.

Q:   If we are going to use “inclusive reckoning” to begin a new biblical month, namely, by using the "day of the conjunction", shouldn’t we also use it in all biblical situations – one example is Exod 12:18 ?

Exo 12:18  In the first month, on the fourteenth day of the month at even, ye shall eat unleavened bread, until the one and twentieth day of the month at even
.

If we use inclusive reckoning, then the first day of "unleavened bread", must be the 14th day of Aviv. Although I personally agree with this idea, this differs with the way that most people understand it.

A second possible problem with declaring the New Moon day as the day of the conjunction is that many, if not all of these New Moon days, contain part of the old month as well as part of the new month.

Q:   Does it seem logical and/or reasonable, that Yahweh would start His biblical months with part of a previous or old month ?
A:   I personally have a problem with beginning a new biblical month with part of the previous month.

Q:   Matt 9:17 & Luke 5:37 all make statements by Yahushua about not putting new wine in old wine skins. Does it seem logical that Yahweh would reverse this principle by determining the start of a biblical month, with part of an old month ?

Mat 9:17  Neither do men put new wine into old bottles: else the bottles break, and the wine runneth out, and the bottles perish: but they put new wine into new bottles, and both are preserved
.

Luk 5:37  And no man putteth new wine into old bottles; else the new wine will burst the bottles, and be spilled, and the bottles shall perish
.

In terms of the choice between declaring a new moon day as (a) the day of the conjunction, or (b) is it the first biblical day after the conjunction, my conclusion follows :

The above method, can be applied using observation alone. Ancient Israelites most likely only had observation & simply calculations. They had no accurate method of determining the precise timing of the conjunction. This method has a practical accuracy of at least 90%.

Since the inclusive reckoning method relies on knowing precisely when the conjunction is, the only way this can be done accurately, is using advanced calculations using a computer. This is totally impractical for an ancient Israelite.

Even though this point is significant, the fact that for this method, a new biblical month must begin with part of an old month, is a strong reason to not use this method.

The above observation method is the most practical way to determining the New Moon Day.

Which possibility was more likely used for determining the start of a biblical month :
(a) using the sighted first crescent or (b) using the conjunction

I ask you to do your own analysis of the information presented BEFORE scrolling down to read what I have concluded.









Based on the type, and amount of evidence presented above, it seems much more likely that a biblical month has a conjunction start, rather than a sighted first crescent start. I personally determine the start of a new biblical month, by going to the biblical day, AFTER, the day of the conjunction.

I hope this study has been of assistance to you. If you find any errors of logic and/or of scriptural interpretation, because I never want to believe a lie, or be in error about Yahweh's Calendar.

If you would like more information, or have any questions, please let me know. You can contact Peter at askseekknockandtest@gmail.com


Before I begin my study, I am going to provide a series of questions that I asked myself about being in Yahweh’s covenant. I hope they can be an important background for my audience, as you carefully examine what I am presenting – I have given my answers at the sixth part of this series..

Q: What is a biblical covenant ?
Q: Why would you want to be covenanted ?
Q: Which covenant should you be considering ?
Q: Are you covenanted ?
Q: With whom are you covenanted ?
Q: How do you know that you are covenanted ?
Q: What conditions do you need to fulfil, to be in this covenant ?
Q: What are the consequences for keeping the conditions of this covenant ?
Q: Can you break this covenant ?
Q: What are the consequences for breaking the conditions of this covenant ?
Q: What can you do when you break it ?
Q: Can you be covenanted with Yahweh & Yahushua if you are not :
(a) the physical seed of Abraham, and/or
(b) part of physical Israel, and/or
     (c) “adopted” into Israel as Ruth, a Moabitess, was (Ruth 4:11), and/or “grafted in”, as Paul indicates in Rom 11:17, 19, 23 & 24 ?

If you don't belong to one of these groups, aren’t you, as Paul writes in Eph 2:12, “excluded from the Commonwealth of Israel”, & therefore “strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, & without Yahweh in the world” ?

Q:  If you disagree with the implications of the previous question, what covenant do you think you are in, & what conditions are required to be in that covenant ? How do you really know what you have believed about this ?

If we are to really, really understand what Yahweh’s Word is telling us in the original context, & in the manner which the original authors intended it to be understood, wouldn’t it be a good idea to examine as much accurate information on the biblical, historical, social, geographical & cultural background of the text as is possible ?

Isn’t it true, that unless I consider ALL the evidence I find about a subject, in this case, “covenant”, how will I really know, if what I think I have found, & have been taught, or what I believe, or what I have seen, & read, or what I have heard, is true & correct ?

Isn’t it therefore logical, that we should investigate what “covenant” meant to those original audiences, rather than what we currently think it means?

In this study I intend to cover several subjects that I hope you will find interesting & helpful. They include :

What is a biblical covenant, with specific scriptural examples ?
 
What is covenant renewal in ancient Israel ?
 
What is the “new” covenant according to Scripture ?
 
What does an ancient marriage covenant look like, & how does it relate to the “new” covenant ?
 
A series of questions, with my personal answers, that are designed to address the title of this study, “Are You Really in Covenant with Yahweh (God) – How do you really know ?”


This is quite a long study, so I hope you can be patient, by reading through each of the next five parts of this series,  because I believe it contains information that is not widely known, and/or understood.
Welcome back !

Please note that I will be using the personal names of the Creator, and His Son – the Creator’s name is Yahweh, which I will abbreviate to YHWH, because there are other legitimate pronunciations for the Hebrew tetragrammaton, yod-hey-vav-hey, the heavenly Father's personal name, & Yahushua, whom you probably know as Jesus.

In this study I have quoted many scriptural verses to support what I have written, but, because some of the quotes are several verses in length, I may not have included all these. May I respectfully ask you to look these up for yourselves. The verses that I have included are from the Hebrew Roots Bible version.
 
The Facts

Because YHWH’s Word was written over a period of several thousand years, by many different authors, & in ancient languages, my personal observation is that I, and I’m guessing many others too, have in the past, been confused about several important biblical concepts, including the idea of “covenant”, & especially, “the new covenant” of the NT. While this confusion is a frustrating problem, I have found that a careful examination of the biblical, & the available ancient near East archeological data tells me a lot about this vitally important biblical concept.

My research has shown me that during the time of early biblical history, covenants existed to unify people with their kings & leaders, their gods, & with each other.

In the Bible, & the ancient near East :

1:  A covenant is an agreement, usually formal, between two or more parties, to do, or not do something that is specified. At a very basic level, a covenant is an oath-bound relationship between those two or more parties.

2:  A covenant is not the same as a promise, but a covenant can be made to strengthen the promises that are made.

3:  A biblical covenant between two or more parties usually has, at least a proposal, & an acceptance. In the Bible, a covenant often was ratified with a ritual, such as a sacrifice, & was regularly confirmed with a meal.

Several biblical covenants had signs and/or witnesses attached to them. Sometimes, possessions such as robes were exchanged.

4:  Most covenants have conditions, (the dos & don’t do’s), that must be followed by all parties.

Being in a covenant, & doing or not doing what the covenant requires, produces blessings.

Being a covenant, and breaking its requirements, results in serious consequences (curses).

5:  In ancient times, there were three basic types of covenant – Parity covenants, Suzerainty covenants, & Royal Grant covenants.
 
 Parity Covenants were made between individuals who had equal status.

Suzerainty Covenants were between a greater/stronger party (the Suzerain) & a weaker party (the Vassal). There were always conditions which were declared by the Suzerain, & agreed to by the vassal.

Royal Grant Covenants were between a stronger and a weaker party (a special kind of suzerainty covenant), where the rights of the vassal are protected, not those of the suzerain.

Biblical examples of these types of covenant

Parity Covenant Biblical Examples

In Gen 21:22-32, there is a parity covenant made between Abraham & Abimelech at Beersheba – the terms were set, oaths were taken, sheep & oxen were exchanged, & ewe lambs presented as witnesses to their covenant – they cut a covenant.

In Gen 31:44-54, there are details of Jacob’s covenant with Laban – a pillar of stones was raised as a memorial, oaths were sworn with YHWH as their witness, terms were set, a sacrifice was made, & a meal was shared.

Joshua made a covenant (league) with the Gibeonites, which is described in Joshua 9:6-16. Even though the Gibeonites lied about their origin and condition, Joshua honoured the covenant he made with them because he had sworn an oath.

1 Sam 18:3-4 tells us that David and Jonathan made a parity covenant with each other, in which Jonathan gave David his robe, his belt & sword. 2 Sam 9:7 & 21:7 describe how the covenant made between David & Jonathan still applied to Jonathan’s son, ever after Jonathan had been killed.

Suzerainty Covenant Biblical Examples

Again, a Suzerainty Covenant is one wherein a superior (a greater/stronger) individual, (the Suzerain), such as a king, made an agreement with one of his vassals (the weaker party). There were always conditions, made only by the Suzerain. Often, the Suzerainty Covenant used a legal system which included adoption - the suzerain (great king) adopts the people, & sometimes individuals of the vassal king.

Let me summarise a most important biblical Suzerainty Covenant between YHWH & Abram. It is sometimes called a Promise Covenant because YHWH proposed, or promised it. Eph 2:12 (above) makes reference to this promise covenant.

Gen 12:1 tells us of YHWH’s instruction (Torah) to Abram – it is the first part of YHWH’s proposal

Gen 12:1 And YAHWEH had said to Abram, Go out from your land and from your kindred, and  from your father's house, to the land which I will show you.

Gen 12:2-3 gives us details of YHWH’s promise/proposal
 
Gen 12:2 And I will make of you a great nation. And I will bless you and make your name great; and you will be a blessing.
Gen 12:3 And I will bless those who bless you, and curse the one despising you. And in you all families of the earth shall be blessed.

Gen 12:4 tells us Abram accepted this proposal by doing what YHWH instructed.

Gen 12:4 And Abram went out, even as YAHWEH had spoken to him. And Lot went with him. And Abram was a son of seventy five years when he departed from Haran.

There is no mention of brith, the Hebrew word translated as “covenant” in this chapter.

Gen 15:1 was a declaration/promise from YHWH directly to Abram.
 
Gen 15:1 After these things the Word of YAHWEH came to Abram in a vision, saying, Do not fearAbram; I am a shield to you, your reward will increase greatly.

Gen 15:2-3  & 8 tell us of Abram’s request for a guarantee of YHWH’s promise of his inheritance

Gen 15:2 And Abram said, Adonai YAHWEH, what will You give to me? I am going childless and the son of the inheritance of my house is Eleazar of Damascus?
Gen 15:3 And Abram said, Behold! You have given no seed to me; and lo, the son of my house is inheriting of me!
 
Gen 15:8 And he said, Adonai (LORD) YAHWEH, by what shall I know that I shall inherit it?

Gen15:4-5 gives us YHWH’s promise/proposal

Gen 15:4 And, behold, the word of the LORD came unto him, saying, This shall not be thine heir; but he that shall come forth out of thine own bowels shall be thine heir
Gen 15:5 And he brought him forth abroad, and said, Look now toward heaven, and tell the stars, if thou be able to number them: and he said unto him, So shall thy seed be

Gen 15:6 shows us how Abram accepted YHWH’s proposal by believing what He (YHWH) promised, as was expressed by Abram’s obedient actions.

Gen 15:6 And he believed in the LORD; and he counted it to him for righteousness
 
Gen 15:9-12 & 17 give details of the blood ratification (another aspect of some covenants) of YHWH’s covenant with Abram & his seed, as a result of Abram asking for a guarantee. As a consequence of this, there was now a death penalty, a condition, for any breach of this covenant.

Details of this will be provided below.

Gen 15:9 And he said unto him, Take me an heifer of three years old, and a she goat of three years old, and a ram of three years old, and a turtledove, and a young pigeon. 
Gen 15:10 And he took unto him all these, and divided them in the midst, and laid each piece one against another: but the birds divided he not. 
Gen 15:11 And when the fowls came down upon the carcases, Abram drove them away. 
Gen 15:12 And when the sun was going down, a deep sleep fell upon Abram; and, lo, an horror of great darkness fell upon him
 
Gen 15:17 And it came to pass, that, when the sun went down, and it was dark, behold a smoking furnace, and a burning lamp that passed between those pieces

Q: Doesn’t Gen 15:18 tell us that YHWH says He cut a covenant (brith) with Abram ?

Gen 15:18 In the same day Yahweh made (cut) a covenant with Abram, saying, Unto thy seed have I given this land, from the river of Egypt unto the great river, the river Euphrates: 
 
Q: How could YHWH have cut a covenant with Abram, when Abram was in a deep sleep ?
A:  In Gen 15:17, we see two entities – a smoking furnace and a lighted lamp. Who are these entities ? Was Abram a party to this covenant ?

We know that Yahushua is called the “light of the world” in John 8:12 & John 9:5 – is it not reasonable to assume that a pre-incarnated Yahushua was this “lighted lamp” of Gen 15:17, & Father YHWH was the “smoking furnace” ?

Joh 8:12 Therefore Yahushua (Jesus) spoke to them again, saying, “I am the light of the worldHe who follows Me shall by no means walk in darkness, but possess the light of life.”
 
Joh 9:5 “While I am in the world, I am the light of the world.” 
 
Q: What two things are signified by walking between the sacrificed animal pieces  ?
A:  
1: Agreement to keep the covenant being made, and
2: Suffering the same consequences as the dead animals, if either or both parties ever broke that covenant ?

Isn’t is probably that Yahushua, the “lighted lamp”, was Abram’s substitute, his proxy, since Abram was in a “deep sleep” ?

If this is correct, then wasn’t Yahushua willing to take on Himself the death penalty for Abram and his descendants, IF they broke this Gen 15 covenant !

Surely, Jer 31:32 is the empirical proof that declares the descendants of Abraham, the Israelites of the Exodus, as participants of this Abrahamic covenant !

Jer 31:32 not according to the covenant that I cut with their fathers in the day I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt (which covenant of Mine they broke, although I was to be a husband to them, says YAHWEH).

Isn’t this a major reason as to why Yahushua took upon Himself the “death penalty” for the party that broke the covenant, when He was crucified ?

Comment

Please note carefully – you may not have ever read, or heard what I am about to explain, so please choose to have an open mind when reading, & considering it.

Yahushua stood in as Abram's, (later Abraham), & his descendants’ proxy, their substitute. These descendants broke the Promise Covenant, which was renewed with the Mt Sinai covenant of Exod 19:5-6, with the golden calf sin, & were guilty. Yahushua, who had freely accepted their death position, was now responsible, and had to die in their (our) place.

The Gen 15 covenant was YHWH’s insurance to Abraham (at Abram’s request), that YHWH’s Promise was good. The Promise Covenant was “damaged” when Abraham’s descendants broke the Exod 19:5-6, covenant. That covenant break enacted the ‘death position’. Remember though, that in YHWH’s case, it also gave Him the legal right to send His ‘goél’, kinsman redeemer, (Yahushua), in their place (Lev 25:25-26, Ruth 3:9 & 12,& Ruth 4:14).
 
Exo 19:5 And now if listening you will listen to My voice, and will keep My covenant, you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations, for all the earth is Mine.
Exo 19:6 And you shall become a kingdom of priests for Me, a holy nation. These are the words which you shall speak to the sons of Israel.

Lev 25:25 If your brother has become poor and has sold his property, then his kinsman redeemer shall come, and he shall redeem the thing sold by his brother.
Lev 25:26 But when a man has no kinsman redeemer to him, and his own hand has reached out, and he has enough for its redemption,
 
Rth 3:9 And he said, Who are you? And she said, I am your handmaid Ruth, and you shall spread your skirt over your handmaid, for you are a kinsman redeemer.
 
Rth 3:12 And now, surely it is true that I am a kinsman redeemer. But there also is a redeemer closer to you than I.
 
Rth 4:14 And the women said to Naomi, Blessed be YAHWEH, who has not left you this day without a kinsman-redeemer; and may his name be called in Israel.

Yahushua then had the unique covenant standing & position, to die for all parties concerned. Yahushua qualified for this, because He was sinless, & therefore was, a perfect sacrifice.

YHWH wants desperately to extend salvation to all. YHWH is LOVE, but He is also the supreme Law Giver, & the ultimate Law Keeper. Therefore, He has to extend salvation in a legal way, a way that will not violate His Love, His justice, His mercy, His law, His covenant, or His oath !

Yahushua died the death for the adulterous bride (Israel), the rebellious son (the Lost Tribes), for the sins of the world, & for breaking the Gen 15 covenant, (all as the spotless lamb of YHWH).

Although the descendants of Abraham (Israel) broke the Gen 15 Covenant, & the Exod 19:5-6 Covenant, (to be discussed later), YHWH didn’t break it. He will still keep His side of the covenant.

Abrahamic Promise/Oath/Covenant 3 – YHWH’s third promise covenant was declared with His own oath

In Gen 22:16-18, YHWH declares that He (YHWH) HAD sworn by Himself, on account of Abraham not withholding his only son, Isaac, & because Abraham listened to YHWH’s voice. YHWH says He (YHWH) will bless Abraham, & multiply his (Abraham’s) seed as the stars of the heavens, & as the sand of the shores, & that his seed (Abraham’s) would possess the gate of YHWH’s enemies.

Gen 22:18 tells us that in Abraham’s seed, all the nations of the earth shall be blessed.

Gen 22:16 And He said, I have sworn by Myself, declares YAHWEH, that on account of this thing you have done, and have not withheld your son, your only son,
Gen 22:17 that blessing I will bless you, and multiplying I will multiply your seed as the stars of the heavens, and as the sand which is on the lip of the sea. And your Seed shall possess the gate of His enemies.
Gen 22:18 And in your Seed shall all the nations of the earth be blessed, because you have listened to My voice.

Gen 22:17-18 seem to refer back to the promise of an inheritance that YHWH made to Abram in Gen 12:2-3, and in Gen 15:5. This was the oath referred to in Gen 26:3 – “I will cause to rise MY OATH which I swore to your father Abraham”.
 
Gen 26:3 Stay in this land, and I will be with you and bless you, for to you and to your seed I will give all these lands. And I will cause to rise My oath which I swore to your father Abraham.

This Promise/Oath/Covenant was unconditional, since YHWH swore it by Himself.

Even though the Hebrew word, brith is not mentioned, clearly, if YHWH makes an oath with Himself, that would be an unconditional ‘royal grant’ covenant !


Let’s now examine possibly, the most important biblical covenant, YHWH’s covenant, that He calls, “My covenant”, that is often referred to as “the covenant”. It is proposed in Exod 19:5-6, and was only ever made with one nation, Israel.

Exo 19:5 And now IF listening you will listen to My voice, and will keep My covenant, you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations, for all the earth is Mine.
Exo 19:6 And you shall become a kingdom OF priests for Me, a holy nation. These are the words which you shall speak to the sons of Israel.(HRB)

From these & following verses, these aspects of covenant are expressed :

Proposal :    “IF listening, you will listen to My voice, & will keep My covenant”

Acceptance :    “all YHWH has spoken we will do” (Exod 19:8, 24:3 & 7)

Blessings :   “you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations; … a kingdom OF priests for Me, a holy nation”

Consequences : not stated here but are clearly applicable (see Exod 32 & Deut 28 for the consequences when this covenant was broken)
 
Exo 19:8 And all the people answered together and said, All which YAHWEH has spoken we will do. And Moses brought back the words of the people to YAHWEH.
 
Exo 24:3 And Moses came and told all the words of YAHWEH to the people, and all the judgments. And all the people answered with one voice and said, We will do all the Words which YAHWEH has spoken.
  
Exo 24:7 And he took the book of the covenant, and read in the ears of the people. And they said, We will do all that YAHWEH has spoken, and we will hear.

Perhaps a paraphrased version of YHWH’s covenant is :

If you Israel, do all that I say, namely, listen to My voice, keep My Torah, My commandments, My statutes, & My judgements, then I (YHWH) will take care of everything else (I will bless you, protect you, provide for you, keep you safe, & show you how to become more & more like Me).

NB – This Mt Sinai covenant, that YHWH calls “My covenant”, was offered only to Israel. The Israelites had the choice to either accept it, or reject it – they decided to accept it, three times.

The conditions of YHWH’s covenant were set by Him – it was, & is a Suzerainty Covenant, where YHWH is the “supreme” suzerain, & Israel is the vassal. This covenant was offered after the Israelites had witnessed YHWH’s powerful actions in Egypt.
What is the “New Covenant”, mentioned in Matt 26:28, Mark 14:24, Luke 22:20, 1 Cor 11:25, 2 Cor 3:6, & Heb 8:8-11?
    
Mat 26:28 For this represents My blood of the New Covenant which concerning many is being poured out for remission of sins.
 
Mar 14:24 And He said to them, This is My blood, that of the New Covenant, which is poured out concerning many.
  
Luk 22:20 And in like manner the cup, after having supped, saying, This cup is the New Covenant in My blood, which is being shed for your sakes.

1Co 11:25 In the same way the cup also, after supping, saying, this cup is the New Covenant in My blood, each time you drink it, do this in remembrance of Me. 

 
2Co 3:6 who also made us able ministers of the New Covenant, not of the letter, but of the Spirit. For the letter of the Torah (law) punishes with death, but the Spirit makes alive
 
Heb 8:8 For finding fault with them, He said to them, "Behold, days are coming, says YAHWEH, and I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah;
Heb 8:9 not according to the covenant which I made with their fathers in the day of My taking hold of their hand to lead them out of the land of Egypt; because they did not continue in My covenant, and I rejected them, says YAHWEH.
Heb 8:10 Because this is the covenant which I will covenant with the house of Israel after those days, says YAHWEH, I will give My Laws into their mind, and I will write them on their hearts, and I will be their Elohim, and they shall be My people."
Heb 8:11 And they shall no more teach each one their neighbor, and each one his brother, saying, Know YAHWEH; because all shall know Me, from the least of them to their great ones.
   
Q:  Is this “covenant”, mentioned in the above verses, a “new” covenant?
A:  No – based on my research, I believe it is nothing more than a renewal of the relationship covenant between YHWH, & His chosen nation, Israel. What is “new” about it is that, with Messiah Yahushua as its head, the “original” covenant can now be applied in such a way, that it will be perfectly kept. Heb 8:8-13, quoting Jer 31:31-34, explains that “YHWH will put His Torah in their minds, & will write it on their hearts”. We are told in Heb 12:24 that Yahushua is the mediator of this “new” covenant.

Jer 31:31 Behold, the days come, says YAHWEH, that I will cut a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah,

Jer 31:32 not according to the covenant that I cut with their fathers in the day I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt (which covenant of Mine they broke, although I was to be a husband to them, says YAHWEH).
Jer 31:33 But this shall be the covenant that I will cut with the house of Israel: After those days, declares YAHWEH, I will put My Torah in their minds, and I will write it on their hearts; and I will be their Elohim, and they shall be My people.
Jer 31:34 And they shall no longer each man teach his neighbor, and each man his brother, saying, Know YAHWEH. For they shall all know Me, from the least of them even to the greatest of them, declares YAHWEH
 
Heb 12:24 and to Yahshua the Mediator of a new covenant, and to the sprinkling of His blood, which speaks better things than Abel did.

I strongly believe that in each case where “new” is the translation, it should be translated as “renew”, as it can apply to a “new moon”, or more accurately, a "renewed” moon.
 
If we read Deut 4, & specifically verses 30-31, we see a reference to a future covenant. For context, please start in verse 27, where YHWH says He will scatter Israel, because they broke His Exod 19:5-6 covenant. In verse 29, YHWH tells us (Israel), that “if we seek Him with all our heart & being, we will find Him”. Deut 4:30-31 reads :

Deu 4:30 in your distress, when all these things have found you, in the latter days, then you shall return to YAHWEH your Elohim, and shall listen to His voice.
Deu 4:31 For YAHWEH your El is a merciful Elohim. He will not forsake you, nor destroy you, nor forget the covenant of your fathers which He swore to them.

Isn’t returning to YHWH, & listening to His voice, a direct reference to His Exod 19:5-6 covenant ?

Exo 19:5 And now if listening you will listen to My voice, and will keep My covenant, you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations, for all the earth is Mine.
Exo 19:6 And you shall become a kingdom of priests for Me, a holy nation. These are the words which you shall speak to the sons of Israel.

Doesn’t Deut 4:31 tell us that YHWH will not forget “His” (Exod 19:5-6) Covenant ?

Yes, we (Israel) broke “the Exod 19:5-6” Covenant, & so a “new one” is needed, BUT, again, according to Jer 31:31-34 & Heb 8:8-13, it will be the same as the Exod 19:5-6 covenant, but this time, because it will be written on our minds & hearts, we will keep it.

Q: Is this “new covenant” offered to followers of Yahushua, or to everyone ?
A:  I believe it is only offered to the followers of Yahushua

Q: Is this “new covenant” about a new relationship between YHWH & Christians which was mediated by Yahushua (Heb 12:24), & is about being “saved by grace through faith” (Eph 2:5 & 8) ?

Eph 2:5 even when we were dead in our sins, He made us alive together with Messiah by whose grace we are saved;
 
Eph 2:8 For by grace you are saved, through faith, and this is not of yourselves; it is the gift of YAHWEH;

A:  While it is true that we are “saved by grace through faith”, which is a free gift (Eph 2:8), the question needs to be asked, what are we saved for ? I believe that Scripture is clear that we are saved from the death penalty of our sin, so that we can serve YHWH.

Don’t we serve YHWH by “obeying” His voice ?

Don’t we “obey YHWH”, by keeping His Torah ?

Isn’t the biblical language of love, “obedience” ?

So no, when I read my Bible in the original languages, & in the original context, I don’t find any scriptural evidence of a new relationship between YHWH & any other group, other than Israel !

Q: Do these followers of Yahushua need to decide that they will accept this “new covenant” ?
A:  Absolutely – they have to make that choice

Q: What are the conditions attached to YHWH’s offer ?
A:  YHWH offers His “renewed” Covenant, by asking the followers of Yahushua, as He did the original Israelites, “if listening, you will listen to My voice, & will keep My covenant” (Exod 19:5)

Without any doubt, all the original Torah, commandments, statutes & judgments, are still in place, & those who accept YHWH’s & Yahushua’s proposal, must keep those parts of it that apply to them. Remember, no one can keep all the parts of it since, some parts are for the high priest, some for priests, some for Levites, some for men, some for women, some for farmers & some of it is for everyone. Those who do accept YHWH’s offer, must “guard” the whole Torah (Deut 5:1), & do all of it that specifically applies to them.
 
Deu 5:1 And Moses called to all Israel and said to them, Hear, Israel, the statutes and the judgments which I speak in your ears today. And you shall learn them, and be on guard to do them.

Q: What are the blessings that go with this “new covenant” ?
A:  They are the same as the original ones, stated in Exod 19:5-6. There is a list of blessings also given in Deut 28:1-14.

you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations; … a kingdom OF priests for Me,   a holy nation

Q: What are the consequences for breaking this “new” covenant ?
A:  Because YHWH will put all His Torah in the minds of those who accept this “new” covenant, & will write it on their hearts, those who accept it will not want to break it - there do not appear to be any negative consequences, only positive ones.

Q: Has the “new” covenant been established ?
A:  Unfortunately, the “new” covenant may have been offered, but, since Jer 31:31 & Heb 8:8, each tell us that this “new” covenant will be made with the house of Israel (Ephraim), AND with the house of Judah (Jews), who will be re-united as the whole house of Israel, (Jer 31:33 & Heb 8:10), as yet, this clearly hasn’t happened – these verses seem to be telling us that it will not be until these two houses are re-united that, YHWH’s Torah will be “written on their hearts”. So until, then, all the consequences for breaking YHWH’s covenant, still apply, once we have accepted His proposal.

Q: What happens those who do not accept YHWH’s “new” covenant proposal ?
A:  I believe that they will be influenced positively by those keeping YHWH’s covenant – they will then want to belong to the “new” covenant group, & will be taught what they need to do by that “new” covenant group.

Have you ever noticed that in YHWH Word, there is “Covenant language”?

Above, I wrote that the Suzerain often “adopts” a Vassal’s people, & sometimes individuals. If we look in Gen 48, we read about a scene where Jacob “adopts” Joseph’s two sons, Ephraim & Manasseh.

In the Renewed Covenant Scriptures (NT), there are many language references to adoption of groups & individuals by YHWH.

We read the term “adoption” in Rom 8:15 & 23, 9:4, Gal 4:5, & Eph 1:5.
We read the term “sons of God”, in John 1:12. Rom 8:14, 19, Gal 4:4-5, Phil 2:15, Heb 2:10 & Heb 12:7-8, & 1 Jam 3:1-2.

In Rom 8:15 & 8:17, Gal 3:29, Tit 3:7, Heb 1:14, 6:17, 11:9, Jam 2:5, & 1 Pet 3:7, we see the term “heirs”.

Many of today’s believers in Messiah Yahushua, do not understand that YHWH’s Mt Sinai covenant (Exod 19:5-6), with His specially chosen nation, Israel, was an ancient marriage type covenant.

I encourage you to continue reading, & studying the next part of this series that follows.
Covenant Renewal in Ancient Israel
 
My research indicates that “covenant renewal” is not well understood, especially as it applies to Messiah Yahushua. For this reason, I am attempting to explain what I have been shown as well as I can.

There is quite a bit of “covenant renewal” taking place in Scripture, but it isn’t “spelt out” with descriptive detail, in other words, it doesn’t actually mention “covenant renewal”. In YHWH’s Word, when concepts are well known to the original audiences, they are often not described as such.

Because we are so far removed from the original audience’s understanding of “covenant renewal”, it will be necessary to “add more detail”, to what is written in the biblical text. I hope you can be patient, & open minded with me, as I attempt to do this.

Perhaps the first question we should attempt to answer is, why would someone want to “renew a covenant” ?

While I will attempt to explain this in detail with examples below, I have found that there are four main reasons why a covenant would be “renewed” from time to time.

In ancient Israel & the near East, covenants were “renewed” when :

A:  a covenant is broken                          or

B:   the previous mediator/leader was about to die. The renewal was done to ensure continued, & absolute allegiance to the covenant,    or

C:   there was a new generation,            or

D:   something in a covenant, needed to be “updated”, but not changed.

Again, I am asking you to please be patient with me as I attempt to “put flesh”, so to speak, on these perhaps not so obvious “bones”.

Above, I explained the Abrahamic “covenant of pieces”, as described in Gen 15. In Gen 15:18, we are told that “YHWH cut a covenant with Abram”, that involved his (Abram’s) seed.

Gen 15:18 In that day YAHWEH cut a covenant with Abram, saying, I have given this land to your seed, from the river of Egypt to the great river, the river Euphrates,

In Gen 17:21, YHWH prophesies to Abraham & us, that He (YHWH), will establish His covenant with as yet unborn, Isaac.
Gen 17:21 And I will establish My covenant with Isaac, whom Sarah shall bear to you at this set apart time next year.

In Gen 28:13, we have a reference to YHWH telling Jacob that, He (YHWH), will give the land Jacob is lying on, to him (Jacob), & his seed. There is no specific mention of covenant.
 
Gen 28:13 And, behold, YAHWEH stood above it and said, I am YAHWEH the Elohim of your father Abraham, and the Elohim of Isaac; the land on which you are lying, I will give it to you and to your seed.

In Lev 26:42, YHWH says that He will remember the covenants that He made with Jacob, Isaac & Abraham.
 
Lev 26:42 then I will remember My covenant with Jacob, and also My covenant with Isaac, and shall also remember My covenant with Abraham, and I shall remember the land.

Q: Which covenants are being referred to in Gen 17:21, Gen 28:13, & Lev 26:42 ?
A:  Again, while we aren’t specifically told, I believe that we need to be aware that, the covenant made to Isaac & to Jacob, was the same covenant that YHWH made with Abram in Gen 15.

Q: Are we told anything about YHWH’s Gen 15 covenant being “renewed” with Isaac & Jacob ?
A:  No – but we need to realise that the original audience clearly understood that the Abram Gen 15 covenant was passed on to first Isaac, & then Jacob, & that it was therefore, “renewed” with Isaac, & then with Jacob.

I hope that is clear.

While there are quite a few “covenant renewals” referred to in YHWH’s Word, I do not intend to examine all of them. I hope that I can cover the main ones, & that as my audience reads the Bible, the incidences of other “covenant renewals” will become more obvious.

Again, I believe that, as well as the Abrahamic covenant, the next most important biblical covenant mentioned in Scripture, occurs in Exodus 19:5-6, which I will copy below. As mentioned above, YHWH calls it, “MY covenant” (if necessary, please re-read it now).

Exo 19:5 And now if listening you will listen to My voice, and will keep My covenant, you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations, for all the earth is Mine.
Exo 19:6 And you shall become a kingdom of priests for Me, a holy nation. These are the words which you shall speak to the sons of Israel.

I am asking my audience to again, please be patient, as this next section is a quite long. It will deal with what I believe is a most important covenant in the Bible, & I hope to explain how it is “passed on”, in several “covenant renewal” situations.

I’d like to begin by copying, & examining the significant verses of Exod 24:3-11. As you read through it, please notice that I have written in red, some important, & significant phrases. Please consider them carefully.

Exo 24:3 And Moses came and told all the words of YAHWEH to the people, and all the judgments. And all the people answered with one voice and said, We will do all the Words which YAHWEH has spokenThis is the OATH declaration
Exo 24:4 And Moses wrote all the Words of YAHWEH. And he rose early in the morning and built an altar below the mountain and twelve memorial pillars for the twelve tribes of Israel

The requirements of the covenant, in v7, are written in the “book of the Covenant

Exo 24:5 And he sent young men of the sons of Israel. And they offered up burnt offerings, and offered sacrifices of bulls, peace offerings to YAHWEH.   A sacrifice was offered
Exo 24:6 And Moses took half of the blood, and he put it in basins. And he sprinkled half of the blood on the altarThis is the blood element
Exo 24:7 And he took the book of the covenant, and read in the ears of the people. And they said, We will do all that YAHWEH has spoken, and we will hearThis is the OATH declaration, repeated
Exo 24:8 And Moses took the blood and sprinkled on the people, and said, Behold, the blood of the covenant which YAHWEH has cut with you concerning these words. This is also the blood element
Exo 24:9 And Moses and Aaron went up with Nadab and Abihu, and seventy from the elders of Israel.
Exo 24:10 And they saw the Elohim of Israel. And under His feet was as the work of a pavement of sapphire, and as the heavens for clearness.
Exo 24:11 And He did not stretch out His hand to the nobles of the sons of Israel. And they saw Elohim, and they ate and drank. (HRB)   This is the covenant confirming meal.


While this section of verses refers specifically to Exodus, chapters 19 to 23, & the Mt Sinai covenant, that YHWH calls, “My covenant”, it could also be seen as a detailed example of a “covenant renewal” of the Abrahamic covenant, since this covenant is being made with the seed of Abraham, namely, Jacob’s 12 tribes.

But for now, I’d like to look at the Mt Sinai covenant as an original covenant. Please notice that it has all these parts :
 
A: a proposal (Exod 19:5-6),
  
Exo 19:5 And now if listening you will listen to My voice, and will keep My covenant, you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations, for all the earth is Mine.
Exo 19:6 And you shall become a kingdom of priests for Me, a holy nation. These are the words which you shall speak to the sons of Israel.
 
B: an acceptance, which I believe would have been declared with an Oath     (Exod 19:8, Exod 24:3 & 7)
 
Exo 19:8 And all the people answered together and said, All which YAHWEH has spoken we will do. And Moses brought back the words of the people to YAHWEH.
 
Exo 24:3 And Moses came and told all the words of YAHWEH to the people, and all the judgments. And all the people answered with one voice and said, We will do all the Words which YAHWEH has spoken.
 
Exo 24:7 And he took the book of the covenant, and read in the ears of the people. And they said, We will do all that YAHWEH has spoken, and we will hear.
 
C:  the conditions for being the YHWH’s covenant (Exod 19:5-6 & Exod chapters 19 to 23)

D: a list of blessings for keeping it (Exod 19:5-6)
  
Exo 19:5 And now if listening you will listen to My voice, and will keep My covenant, you shall become a special treasure to Me above all the nations, for all the earth is Mine.
Exo 19:6 And you shall become a kingdom of priests for Me, a holy nation. These are the words which you shall speak to the sons of Israel.
 
E:  the specific requirements were written in a book (Exod 24:4)
 
Exo 24:4 And Moses wrote all the Words of YAHWEH. And he rose early in the morning and built an altar below the mountain and twelve memorial pillars for the twelve tribes of Israel.

F:  the conditions of the covenant were read to those who accepted the covenant (Exod 24:7)

Exo 24:7 And he took the book of the covenant, and read in the ears of the people. And they said, We will do all that YAHWEH has spoken, and we will hear.
 
G: consequences for breaking it (see Exod 32 & Deut 28 for the curses when this covenant was, & is broken)

H:  blood ratification (Exod 24:6 & 8)

Exo 24:6 And Moses took half of the blood, and he put it in basins. And he sprinkled half of the  blood on the altar.
 
Exo 24:8 And Moses took the blood and sprinkled on the people, and said, Behold, the blood of the covenant which YAHWEH has cut with you concerning these words
 
I:   a covenant confirming meal (Exod 24:11
 
Exo 24:11 And He did not stretch out His hand to the nobles of the sons of Israel. And they saw Elohim, and they ate and drank.
 
If we look at the story of what happened after YHWH’s covenant with Israel had been proposed & accepted, we notice that :

A:  Moses is instructed to go up the mountain to be with YHWH, where He (YHWH), will give Moses, tablets of stone, the Torah, and the commandments which YHWH has written (Exod 24:12). Moses is gone for 40 days & 40 nights (Exod 34:28)
 
Exo 24:12 And YAHWEH said to Moses, Come up to Me to the mountain, and be there. And I will give to you the tablets of stone, and the Torah, and the commandments which I have written, to teach them.
     
Exo 34:28 And he was there with YAHWEH forty days and forty nights; he did not eat bread and  he did not drink water. And He wrote on the tablets the words of the covenant, the Ten Words.

B:  Previously, Moses had gone up & down the mountain four times – whenever YHWH spoke to Moses, it was on the mountain. These are the trips up & down the mountain

     UP - Exod 19:3, DOWN – Exod 19:7;
     UP – Exod 19:8, DOWN – Exod 19:14
     UP – Exod 19:20, DOWN – Exod 19:25
     UP – Exod 24:1, DOWN – Exod 24:3

Please notice that they were short trips, probably less than one day each.

Exo 19:3 And Moses went up to Elohim. And YAHWEH called to him from the mountain, saying, You shall say this to the house of Jacob, and tell it to the sons of Israel.

 
Exo 19:7 And Moses came (down) and called the elders of the people. And he put all these words before them which YAHWEH commanded him.

Exo 19:8 And all the people answered together and said, All which YAHWEH has spoken we will do. And Moses brought back the words of the people to YAHWEH.

 
Exo 19:14 And Moses went from the mountain to the people. And he sanctified the people, and they washed their clothes.
 
Exo 19:20 And YAHWEH came down on the mountain of Sinai, to the top of the mountain; and YAHWEH called Moses to the top of the mountain, and Moses went up.
 
Exo 19:25 And Moses went down to the people and spoke to them.
 
Exo 24:1 And He said to Moses, Come up to YAHWEH, you and Aaron, Nadab, and Abihu, and seventy from the elders of Israel. And bow yourselves from a distance.
 
Exo 24:3 And Moses came (down) and told all the words of YAHWEH to the people, and all the judgments. And all the people answered with one voice and said, We will do all the Words which YAHWEH has spoken.

C:  When the people hadn’t seen Moses for about 40 days, Exod 32:1 tells us the Israelites concluded that perhaps something must have happened to him, after all, his previous trips, up & down the mountain, were short ones.

Exo 32:1 And the people saw that Moses delayed to come down from the mountain. And the people gathered to Aaron. And they said to him, Rise up, make for us gods who may go before our face. As for this Moses, the man who brought us up from the land of Egypt, we do not know what has become of him.

D: After coming to this conclusion, they came to Aaron, Moses’ second-in-command, with this problem (Exod 32:1). Aaron decided, probably based on his experience of how to worship the gods of Egypt, to ask the people for their rings of gold (Exod 32:2). From this gold, Aaron formed it into a casted calf, & he also built an altar before it (Exod 32:4-5).

Please note, that Aaron said in Exod 32:5, they would have “a feast to YHWH tomorrow”. I believe that they were sincerely going to have a “feast to YHWH tomorrow”, but it would be based on the way that the Egyptians worshipped their gods.

Exo 32:2 And Aaron said to them, Break off the rings of gold which are in the ears of your wives, your sons and your daughters; and bring them to me.
Exo 32:3 And all the people broke off the rings of gold in their ears, and they brought to Aaron.      
Exo 32:4 And he took them from their hand and formed it with an engraving tool. And he made it a casted calf. And they said, These are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt.
Exo 32:5 And Aaron saw, and he built an altar before it. And Aaron called and said, A feast to YAHWEH tomorrow.
 
E:  When YHWH saw this, He (YHWH), commanded Moses to go down & “deal” with the idolatrous Israelites (Exod 32:7-8).

Exo 32:7 And YAHWEH spoke to Moses, Come, go down, for your people whom you caused to go up from Egypt are corrupted;
Exo 32:8 they have quickly turned off from the way which I commanded them; they have made for themselves a casted calf and have bowed to it, and have sacrificed to it. And they have said, These are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt.
 
F:  When YHWH tells Moses that He (YHWH), is going to “consume” them (Israel), (Exod 32:10), Moses prays before the face of YHWH saying :
 
Exo 32:10 And now leave Me alone that My anger may glow against them, that I may consume them. And I will make you a great nation.

Moses then says : 

1: “why O YHWH does You anger glow against Your people whom You caused to go up from the land of Egypt with great power, & with a mighty hand” (Exod 32:11). Clearly, YHWH does not want to be worshipped in ways that other gods are worshipped.
2: “that the Egyptians would then say that, YHWH caused them (Israel) to go up, to kill them in the mountains(Exod 32:12)
3: “Remember what You (YHWH) swore by Himself to Abraham, Isaac & Israel” (Exod 32:13).

 YHWH was moved to pity Israel (Exod 32:14).
 
G: Moses goes down with the stone tablets written on both sides, the work of Elohim, & throws them (the tablets) from his (Moses’) hands & breaks them (Exod 32:19). Moses takes the golden calf, burned it with fire, & grounds it until it is fine, & scatters it on the water, & makes the Israelites drink it (Exod 32:20).

Exo 32:19 And it happened, as he came near to the camp and saw the calf and dances, the anger of Moses glowed. And he threw the tablets from his hands, and he broke them below the mountain.
Exo 32:20 And he took the calf which they had made and burned it with fire and ground it until it was fine, then he scattered it on the face of the water. And he made the sons of Israel to drink it.

H:  Aaron makes excuses for his part (Exod 32:22-24)

Exo 32:22 And Aaron said, Let not the anger of my lord glow. You know the people that it is in evil.

Exo 32:23 And they said to me, Make for us gods who may go before us; as for Moses, the man who caused us to go up from the land of Egypt, we do not know what has become of him.
Exo 32:24 And I said to them, Whoever has gold, let them break off. And they gave to me, and I cast it into the fire, and this calf came out.
 
I:   Moses asks who was for YHWH, & the Levites join him. Moses tells them to kill the offenders, & about 3000 are killed (Exod 32:26-28).

Exo 32:26 And Moses stood in the gate of the camp and said, Who is for YAHWEH? Come to me! And all the sons of Levi assembled to him.
Exo 32:27 And he said to them, So says YAHWEH, Elohim of Israel, each one put his sword on his thigh; pass to and fro from gate to gate in the camp, and each one kill his brother, and each one his neighbor, and each one his kindred.
Exo 32:28 And the sons of Levi did according to the word of Moses. And about three thousand men of the people fell on that day.

J:  YHWH punishes the Israelites for their rebellion with a plague (Exod 32:35).

Clearly, the golden calf rebellion was a breach of YHWH’s covenant – the Israelites had “broken” the covenant within about 40 days, after agreeing to it, three times, (Exod 34:28)

Exo 32:35 And YAHWEH plagued the people because they made the calf, which Aaron made.

 If a covenant is broken, it can be “renewed”, provided the Suzerain agrees.

I believe that this is what happened in Exod 34, where YHWH instructs Moses to :

1: cut two tablets of stone (Exod 34:1)

Exo 34:1 And YAHWEH said to Moses, Cut out for yourself two tablets of stone, like the formerAnd I will write on the tablets the words which were on the former tablet, which you broke.

YHWH also says :

2:  He (YHWH) will write on the two tablets, the words of the former tablets which Moses broke (Exod 34:1)

3:  for Moses to come up to the mountain on his own (Exod 34:3)

At their meeting, we are told several very important characteristics of YHWH :

4:YAHWEH! YAHWEH Elohim! Merciful and gracious, slow to anger, and great in goodness and truth, keeping mercy for thousands, forgiving iniquity and transgression and sin, and not leaving entirely unpunished, visiting the iniquity of fathers on sons, and on sons of sons, to the third and to the fourth generation” (Exod 34:6-7)

Moses asks YHWH to forgive Israel’s iniquity & sin, & take them again, (us) as a possession (Exod 34:9)

Exo 34:9 And he said, If now I have found favor in Your eyes, O YAHWEH, please let my Adonai go in our midst, for it is a stiffnecked people; and You forgive our iniquity and our sin, and take us as a possession.

YHWH says “And He said, Behold, I am cutting a covenant; I will do wonderful things before all your people which not have been done in all the earth, and among all nations. And all the people in whose midst you are shall see the work of YAHWEH, for that which I am about to do is awesome” (Exod 34:10)

Exo 34:10 And He said, Behold, I am cutting a covenant; I will do wonderful things before all your people which not have been done in all the earth, and among all nations. And all the people in whose midst you are shall see the work of YAHWEH, for that which I am about to do is awesome.

YHWH gives details of the commands He requires for being in this “renewed” covenant (Exod 34:11-26)

YHWH instructs Moses to write the words YHWH spoke because on those words, YHWH cut this “renewed” covenant with Moses & Israel (Exod 34:27)

Exo 34:27 And YAHWEH said to Moses, Write these words for yourself, for on the mouth of these words I will cut a covenant with you and with Israel.

YHWH wrote on the tablets the words of the covenant, the ten words (Exod 34:28)
 
Exo 34:28 And he was there with YAHWEH forty days and forty nights; he did not eat bread and he did not drink  ater. And He (YHWH) wrote on the tablets the words of the covenant, the Ten Words.

 A covenant can be “renewed” just before a leader, with whom the covenant was made, is about to die.

Here are three examples in Scripture where we are shown that, just before a leader dies, he holds a “covenant renewal” type ceremony.

Moses appoints Joshua as his replacement
 
There are two passages in Scripture where we are told about Moses appointing Joshua as his successor. They occur in Num 27:18-23 & Deut 31:7-13.

We read in Num 27:18-23 that Moses is appointing Joshua as his replacement, but we are not told that it is related to the “renewal” of any covenant – I believe that this is not written down in the biblical text, because the original audience, the Israelites who left Egypt, knew exactly what was going on. I personally, have confidence that this series of verses, is describing details of this “covenant renewal” process.

If we examine the whole book of Deuteronomy, I believe it is a “covenant renewal” of the Mt Sinai covenant document. The title Deuteronomy, derived from Greek, means a “copy,” or a “repetition,” of the law, which is further evidence that it being a “covenant renewal”.

It can be shown that the Book of Deuteronomy can be outlined as follows :

1. Preamble (1:1-5).

2. Historical prologue (1:6-4:49).

3. Stipulations (5-26).

4. Curses and Blessings or Covenant Ratification (27-30).

5. Succession Arrangements or Covenant Continuity, in which are included the invocation of witnesses and directions for the disposition and public reading of the treaty (31-34).

In Deut 31:7-13, Moses is encouraging Joshua (Vs7-8), & in verse 9, we are told that Moses wrote “this Torah”, the conditions for YHWH’s Mt Sinai covenant with Israel. In verses 10-11, Moses commands Israel to proclaim this Torah before all Israel – in the ancient “covenant renewal” process, the original conditions were revisited periodically, as we see in these verses.

In Joshua 8:30-35, we see a ceremony conducted by the new leader of Israel, Joshua, where Joshua builds an altar to YHWH, the Elohim of Israel, referencing the Torah given to Moses, & it being read to Israel.

If we look at what is called “the Shema”, in Deut 6:4-9, I believe that this is giving an oath, a declaration of absolute loyalty, & obedience to YHWH.

Deu 6:4 Hear, O Israel, YAHWEH our Elohim is YAHWEH echad.      (the oath)
Deu 6:5 And you shall love YAHWEH your Elohim with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your might.
Deu 6:6 And these Words which I am commanding you today shall be on your heart.
Deu 6:7 And you shall diligently teach them to your sons, and shall speak of them as you sit in your house, and as you walk in the way, and as you are lying down, and as you are rising up.
Deu 6:8 And you shall bind them for a sign on your hand; and they shall be for frontlets between your eyes.
Deu 6:9 And you shall write them on the doorposts of your house, and on your gates.

If we carefully consider Deut 10:12-13, I believe that this tells us clearly, in two verses, what YHWH clearly expects of all those who are in His covenant. I strongly encourage you to read it very carefully.

Deu 10:12 And now, Israel, what has YAHWEH your Elohim requiring of you, except to fear YAHWEH your Elohim, to walk in all His ways, and to love Him, and to serve YAHWEH your Elohim with all your heart, and with all your soul;
Deu 10:13 to keep the commandments of YAHWEH, and His statutes which I am commanding you today, for your good.  (HRB)

Joshua appoints Israel’s elders, its heads, judges & officers, as his replacement

In Joshua chapter 24, we have another “covenant renewal” ceremony, where Joshua who is about to die, passes the responsibility for keeping YHWH’s Mt Sinai covenant, on to Israel’s elders, its heads, judges & officers.

Messiah Yahushua conducts a “covenant renewal” ceremony
 
Have you considered that the “Last Supper” was a “covenant renewal” ceremony that Yahushua makes reference to in Matt 26:28, Mark 14:24, & Luke 22:20 ?
 
Mat 26:28 For this represents My blood of the New Covenant which concerning many is being poured out for remission of sins.
 
Mar 14:24 And He said to them, This is My blood, that of the New Covenant, which is poured out concerning many.
 
Luk 22:20 And in like manner the cup, after having supped, saying, This cup is the New Covenant in My blood, which is being shed for your sakes.

Doesn’t YHWH’s covenant need to “renewed”, because Yahushua His covenant mediator, is about to die ?

Let’s look at the “covenant renewal” activities, & notice the “covenant renewal” language.

In Matt 26:26-29, Mark 14:22-25 & Luke 22:14-20, we read :

1:  that Yahushua was having a “covenant renewal” meal with His 12 apostles, as part of their Passover memorial meal, in accordance with YHWH's Exod 12:14 command

2:  what Yahushua did during this meal
~ that He proposed the “new” covenant, when He offered His apostles, who would be the “covenant renewal” replacements, wine & bread

3:  that they each part-took of the wine, & the bread, as an acceptance of this new responsibility

NB – As an aside issue, have you ever noticed that in Gen 14:18, Melchizedek brought “bread & wine”, to share with Abraham. I strongly believe that this was ancient custom, obviously even before this Gen 14:18 event, that Messiah Yahushua performed with His disciples at His last Passover meal. It wasn’t anything new – its just that it hadn’t been written about before, because it was such a common event for this first century audience.

Gen 14:18 And Melchizedek, king of Salem, brought out bread and wine; and he was the priest of the most High El (El Elyone).

After the apostles had accepted this new responsibility, in John 14:15, Yahushua says, “if you love Me, keep My commandments”, a clear reference to the conditions for being in this “new” covenant. Isn’t “loving”, the expression for being faithful & loyal, & by being absolutely obedient to the covenant requirements ?

Joh 14:15 If you love Me, keep My commandments.

If this is a “covenant renewal” ceremony, then surely, the original covenant conditions would apply, & not be something “new” & “different” !

I have more to tell about this “new” covenant below in the section, What is the “new” covenant.

What happens when there is a new generation ?

After the original generation of Israelites, namely, those who had lived in Egypt, had all died (Num 26:65 & Num 32:11-12), the Mt Sinai covenant needed to be “renewed”. Again, please recall that the word, “Deuteronomy”, means “copy” or “repetition”, of the (Torah) law. As stated earlier, it can be shown that the whole book of Deuteronomy is a “covenant renewal” document.
 
Num 26:65 For YAHWEH had said to them, they shall surely die in the wilderness, and not a man of them should be left except Caleb the son of Jephunneh, and Joshua the son of Nun.
 
Num 32:11 Surely none of the men that came up out of Egypt, from twenty years old and upward, shall see the land which I swore to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob because they have not wholly followed Me;
Num 32:12 except Caleb the son of Jephunneh, the Kenezite, and Joshua the son of Nun, for they have fully followed YAHWEH.

If we examine Deuteronomy chapter 5, we read that Moses reminds the next generation of Israelites of the covenant that was made at Mt Sinai, (Horeb) (Deut 5:2). Moses explains that YHWH cut this covenant with them, as well as their fathers (Deut 5:3). He goes on to explain many of the original details, & in verse 33, Moses commands “You shall walk in all the ways which YAHWEH your Elohim has commanded you, so that you may live, and that good may be to you, and you may prolong your days in the land which you will possess”. Isn’t walking in all YHWH’s ways, truly a matter of life & death ?
 
Deu 5:2 YAHWEH your Elohim cut a covenant with us in Horeb.
Deu 5:3 YAHWEH did not cut this covenant with our fathers, but with us, even us, these here today, all of us alive.
    
In the remaining chapters of Deuteronomy, they & we are given many details about YHWH, & of His covenant with Israel, but the point we need to understand is that, even though it is not spelt out clearly, this whole book is really a “covenant renewal” document, for this new generation of Israelites.

Updating a covenant, not changing it, when the circumstances change
 
Perhaps the most difficult to understand & accept, reason, to “renew a covenant”, is to “update”, but not change, a covenant, when the original circumstances change. Please read what I am writing very carefully, & try to avoid jumping to any conclusion, until you have read my explanation. I’ll do my best to explain this as well as I can.

I’ll be using just one example to hopefully explain this principle.

If we compare one thing in the Book of Leviticus with a similar thing in the Book of Deuteronomy, we notice that one detail has been “updated”.

Remember that, when we read Leviticus, we need to recall that the Israelites were in the wilderness, & their tribal camps surrounded the Tabernacle (details are in Num chapter 2)– they lived in close proximity to the Tabernacle Altar.

Lev 17:3-6 tell us that while in the wilderness, if a man wanted to slaughter an animal, he was to take it to the Altar – in other words, YHWH was “invited” to such a celebration.
 
Lev 17:3 Any man of the house of Israel who kills an ox, or lamb, or goat, in the camp, or who kills at the outside of the camp,
Lev 17:4 and has not brought it in to the door of the tent of meeting as an offering to YAHWEH, before the tabernacle of YAHWEH, blood shall be imputed to that man; he has shed blood. And that man shall be cut off from the midst of his people;
Lev 17:5 so that the sons of Israel shall bring in their sacrifices which they are sacrificing in the open field to the door of the tent of meeting, to the priest, and sacrifice them for sacrifices of peace offerings to YAHWEH.
Lev 17:6 And the priest shall sprinkle the blood on the altar of YAHWEH, at the door of the tent of meeting, and shall burn the fat as incense for a soothing fragrance to YAHWEH.

Based on these verses, the Israelites were to :

1:  bring their sacrifices (ox, lamb or goat) to the door of the tent of meeting,

2:  sacrifice them as peace offerings to YHWH, &

3:  the priest shall sprinkle the blood on the altar of YHWH.

Q: Why would YHWH command this ?
A:  I’m sure there are other reasons, but in the wilderness, we know that the Israelites had very recently left Egypt & its pagan influences, such as offering sacrifices to idols, & so perhaps, YHWH decreed that they needed to bring their sacrifices to Him in the Tabernacle, to avoid any temptation to revert back to their previous pagan practices, after all, YHWH is a jealous El (Exod 20:5).
 
Exo 20:5 you shall not bow to them, and you shall not serve them; for I am YAHWEH your Elohima jealous El, visiting the iniquity of fathers on sons, on the third and on the fourth generation, to those that hate Me;

In Deut 12:13-16, we read :

Deu 12:13 Take heed to yourself that you not offer your burnt offerings in every place that you see;
Deu 12:14 but in the place which YAHWEH shall choose in one of your tribes (Jerusalem), there you shall offer your burnt offerings, and there you shall do all that I command.
Deu 12:15 Only with all the desire of your soul you shall sacrifice and shall eat meat within all your gates according to the blessing of YAHWEH your Elohim which He has given you; the unclean one and the clean one may eat of it, as of the gazelle and as of the hart.
Deu 12:16 Only, you shall not eat the blood; you shall pour it (the blood) as water on the earth.

Here, the Israelites were to :

1:  bring their burnt offerings to the place where YHWH shall choose

2:  eat the meat within all their gates, &

3:  pour the blood onto the earth.

Notice that their situation was different when they were in the land – while in the wilderness, they had practiced bringing their slaughtered animals to the Tabernacle Altar for 40 years. Now that they are in the promised land, their circumstances were different, but we still have the same principle operating there.

YHWH now instructs them, since their situation is different, that they do not have to make the journey to the Tabernacle Altar as He did while they were in the wilderness - now He requires them to pour the blood out on the ground like water.

Please note that the only one with authority to “update” a covenant is the Suzerain, in this case, YHWH !

Q: Why was that ?
A:  Because the blood was actually what makes it a sacrifice – sprinkling it on the Altar was the main sacrificial act. So now, this was replaced by pouring the blood out on the ground.

This “updating” isn’t something like, you don’t have to keep the Sabbath - it is applying the principle of a command, to the “updated” condition. I hope that is clear.
So, my friends, based on all the above information & conditions about covenant, I wonder if you will now consider your answers to these “Are You Covenanted Challenge” questions ? .

Q: What is a biblical covenant ?
Q: Why would you want to be covenanted ?
Q: Which covenant should you be considering ?
Q: Are you covenanted ?
Q: With whom are you covenanted ?
Q: How do you know that you are covenanted ?
Q: What conditions do you need to fulfil, to be in this covenant ?
Q: What are the consequences for keeping the conditions of this covenant ?
Q: Can you break this covenant ?
Q: What are the consequences for breaking the conditions of this covenant ?
Q: What can you do when you break it ?
Q: Can you be covenanted with Yahweh & Yahushua if you are not :
     (a) the physical seed of Abraham, and/or
     (b) part of physical Israel, and/or
     (c) “adopted” into Israel as Ruth, a Moabitess, was (Ruth 4:11), and/or “grafted in”, as Paul indicates in Rom 11:17, 19, 23 & 24 ?

If you aren’t part of one of these groups, aren’t you, as Paul writes in Eph 2:12,excluded from the Commonwealth of Israel”, & therefore “strangers from the covenants of promise", having no hope, & without YHWH in the world” ?

Q:  If you disagree with the implications of the previous question, what covenant do you think you are in, & what conditions are required to be in that covenant ? How do you really know what you have believed about this ?

I will now give my answers to these questions, & if you haven’t already answered them, I invite you to do the same. I’d be very interested in reading what you have written in your answers.





Q: What is a biblical covenant ?
A:  A covenant is an agreement, usually formal, between two or more parties, to do, or not do something that is specified. At a very basic level, a covenant is an oath-bound relationship between those two or more parties.

Q: Why would you want to be covenanted ?
A:  My response is a bit long, so please be patient as you read it.

My research tells me that, without a doubt, YHWH, the supreme being, & creator of all there is, exists. That research further concludes that Yahushua is His Son, & His Messiah.

I am absolutely convinced that I see direct evidence of YHWH as the creator, everywhere in His creation. Again, my research shows me that the Bible, YHWH’s Word, is His inspired (influenced), inerrant, unchanging, revealed and written word, but only in the original languages, & only in the original intended context. I believe that what YHWH has written in His Word is absolutely true & correct – there are no mistakes, no errors, or no contradictions !

In that inspired, written Word, YHWH tells us through Moses many crucial, & important things. In the original context, we are told in Deut 29:9 that “in guarding /keeping the words of the covenant (the Torah), to do them, that we shall prosper in all that we do”. Do you understand what I just wrote ? Guarding/keeping & doing the words of the covenant (the Torah), results in me prospering in all that I do – WOW ! I can’t understand why anyone would not want that blessing.

We are also told that the in Deut 30:11 that the Torah is not too difficult for you, & that it is not too far off, that Moses sets before Israel, the Word of YHWH, (again, His Torah), which is good & gives life in Deut 30:15, & in Deut 30:19, Israel is told to choose life, (by guarding & doing YHWH’s Torah). I really want this life.

Paul tells us in Rom 7:12 that the Torah is holy, & in 1 Tim 1:8 he says the Torah is good, while in Gal 5:26 tells us that the Torah is perfect.

How much evidence do we need ?

Rev 21:12 tells us that the New Jerusalem will have 12 gates, on which are written the names of the 12 tribes of Israel. Surely this means that in order to get into this great city, & be part of YHWH's kingdom, you must be a member of one of the 12 tribes of Israel. I really want to be in YHWH’s kingdom. Rev 22:14 explains that the qualification for admission to this New Jerusalem, the kingdom of YHWH is, “doing the commandments” of YHWH, His Torah, His Covenant requirements.

Mal 3:6 tells us that YHWH Himself says, “I change not”, For all the above, & for the reason that YHWH never changes what He has decreed that we need to do to have life, why would I not want to keep all the Torah that I can, & why wouldn’t I want to be covenanted with my Creator, YHWH, & His Son, Yahushua ?

May I add a summary of what I have found out from a careful reading of YHWH’s Word, about His Torah ?

The Scriptures reveal that the Torah is much more than a list of dos and don’ts, as many people have been led to believe it to be.

The Torah defines what sin (1 John 3:4) and righteousness are (Ps 119:172).

The Torah shows us what YHWH expects from those who are in YHWH's covenant (Deut 10:12–13).

The Torah convicts man of sin or lawlessness, and brings us to Yahushua, by way of the cross (Gal 3:24).

The Torah brings temporal and spiritual rewards; life and blessing when followed; curses when disobeyed (Deut 28; Matt 5:19).

Obeying the Torah helps deepen a loving and intimate relationship with Yahushua, and helps us to abide in Him (John 14:151 John 2:3-6).

Obeying the Torah helps us to stay spiritually pure (1 John 3:3-6).

Obeying the Torah protects us from the influence of the devil (1 John 3:8).

The Torah provides a framework for divine justice or judgment (Deut 17:11; John 12:48Heb 4:12 cp. Rev 1:16; 2:16; 18:1521).

The Torah forms the basis for the jurisprudence system of civil government (Deut 17:11).

The Torah is heaven’s revelation of divine grace. It reveals how sinful man can be reconciled to a righteous Elohim; it reveals the path of redemption or salvation from slavery to sin through the idea of substitutionary sacrifice. This all points to Yahushua the Messiah, the Redeemer or Saviour of the world.

The Torah reveals the concept of covenant between YHWH and man involving YHWH’s chosen people—the nation of Israel.

The Torah will guide and keep us on the path of righteousness and lead us into YHWH’s everlasting kingdom and spiritual divine family. It acts as a protective guardrail to keep us on the road leading to eternal life. It keeps man from falling into the spiritual ditches or off the spiritual cliff along the side of the road of life.

The Torah is our light in a dark world; the answer to life’s questions and dilemmas (Ps 119:99, 105Prov 6:23).

Through Yahushua the Living Torah, the Torah helps us to become the person that YHWH wants to live with forever. It prepares us to be the spiritual bride of Yahushua (Rev 19:7–8).

Obeying the Torah brings us eternal rewards (not eternal life, which is by grace through faith alone), [Eph. 2:8], in the world to come (Matt. 5:19).

Obeying the Torah-Word of YHWH helps to perfect Yahushua’s love in us (1 John 3:6).

Again, I’m not sure how many reasons a person would need to want to be in covenant with their heavenly Father, YHWH, & His son, Yahushua, but clearly for me, the above list is overwhelming ! Why anyone would not want all these blessings, & benefits, is beyond my comprehension !!

Q: Which covenant should you be considering ?
A:  Because I am a “Follower of the Messiah”, I want to be in covenant with Him - His name is Yahushua, & with His Father, YHWH. As I explained above, because Yahushua, YHWH’s mediator, was about to die, it was necessary to “renew” the Exod 19:5-6 covenant. Heb 8:8 & 13, & Heb 12:24 quote Jer 31:31-34. That is the covenant I want to be part of.

Q: Are you covenanted ?
A:  I believe that I am covenanted, because I decided to be covenanted, & I accepted YHWH’s Exod 19:5-6 proposal, & Messiah Yahushua’s invitation at His last Passover meal. In accepting this covenant, I also accepted the conditions that YHWH required. I am very aware of my decision, including its blessings & consequences.

Q: With whom are you covenanted ?
A:  I am in covenant with YHWH, & Messiah Yahushua

Q: How do you know that you are covenanted ?
A:  I believe that I know I am covenanted with YHWH & Messiah Yahushua because :

1:   by accepting Yahushua as my Master & Saviour, & confessing that YHWH raised Him from the dead, & repenting of my sins, (Rom 10:9-10), I am grafted into Israel (Rom 11:11-24).

Rom 10:9 Because if you confess the Master Yahshua with your mouth, and believe in your heart that YAHWEH raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.
Rom 10:10 For the heart which believes in Him shall be declared righteous, and the mouth that confesses Him shall live.

2:   I am now part of Israel, I am qualified to accept YHWH’s Exod 19:5-6 covenant proposal, including all the conditions, namely, listening to YHWH’s voice & keeping His Torah, commandments, statutes & judgments.

3:   when I was “mikvahed” (baptized) in the name of Messiah Yahushua for the remission of my sins (Acts 2:38), I made several conscious decisions, which I verbally stated in front of witnesses, namely,

A:   I realised that being mikvahed in the name of Messiah Yahushua was a status change. I decided to, & was changed from “tamei” (biblically unclean) to “tahor” (biblically clean)

B:   I decided to bury the “old man” in me, (Eph 4:22), coming out of the water to walk in “newness of life” (Rom 6:4), by now keeping all of YHWH’s Torah that I can.

 Eph 4:22 Lay aside all your former practices and put off the old man, having been degenerate with deceitful lusts,
 Rom 6:4 Therefore, we were buried with Him through baptism into death that as Messiah was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, so also we should walk in newness of life.

C:   I verbally & mentally renounced the kingdoms of the world, of satan, & of my own self-sovereignty

D:   I chose to be a citizen in the kingdom of YHWH

E:   I chose to submit myself completely to the ruler-ship & authority of YHWH

F:   I made a commitment to take on all the responsibilities of being a citizen of the kingdom of YHWH, & to strive to live by Torah, YHWH’s teachings & instructions

G:   I requested that YHWH annul any, & all previous agreements with any, & all other organisations & authorities, that I had made, that conflict with Him

H:   I choose to take on myself the precious names of Yahweh, & Yahushua, & commit to walk out my life in such a way as to bring these sacred names, glory & honour, & not shame.

Act 2:38 And Peter said to them, Repent and be baptized, each of you in the name of Messiah Yahshua  for the forgiveness of sins, that you may receive the gift of the Spirit of Holiness.

4:   since being in YHWH's, & Messiah Yahushua’s covenant, I have experienced many of YHWH’s blessings, His protection & provision, & I believe that I have become, & am continuing to become, more & more like Him.

Q: What conditions do you need to fulfil, to be in this covenant ?
A:  I am now listening to YHWH’s voice, & keeping His Torah commandments, statutes & judgments.

Q: What are the consequences for keeping the conditions of this covenant ?
A:  Again, since being in YHWH's, & Messiah Yahushua’s covenant, I have experienced YHWH’s blessings, His protection & provision, & I believe that I have become more & more like Yahushua.

Q: Can you break this covenant ?
A:  I can break this covenant by sinning, by transgressing YHWH’s Torah, even though it is my fervent desire, not to do so.

Q: What are the consequences for breaking the conditions of this covenant ?
A:  When I sin by not keeping all of YHWH’s Torah that I can, I lose the covering of Messiah Yahushua’s precious saving blood that I had previously accepted – I am not covered, & therefore, unless I sincerely repent of my sin, I will suffer “eternal death”, the consequence of my sinning.

Q: What can you do when you break it ?
A:  Once I am aware that I have broken YHWH’s covenant by sinning, I can sincerely repent, deciding to return to YHWH’s Torah, when once again, I am covered by Messiah Yahushua’s precious saving blood.

Q: Can you be covenanted with YHWH & Yahushua if you are not 
(a) the physical seed of Abraham and/or 
(b) part of physical Israel, and/or 
(c) “adopted” into Israel as Ruth, a Moabitess was (Ruth 4:11), and/or “grafted in”, as Paul indicates in Rom 11:17, 19, 23 & 24

If you aren’t part of one of these groups, aren’t you, as Paul writes in Eph 2:12, “excluded from the Commonwealth of Israel”, & therefore “strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, & without YHWH in the world

Ruth 4:11 And all the people who were in the gate and the elders, said, We are witnesses. May YAHWEH make the woman who is coming into your house to be as Rachel and as Leah, both of whom built the house of Israel. And may you do worthily in Ephratah, and proclaim the Name in Bethlehem.

Rom 11:17 But if some of the branches were broken off, and you, being a wild olive tree were grafted in among them, and became a sharer of the root and the fatness of the olive tree,
Rom 11:18 do not boast against the branches. But if you do boast, it is not you that bears the root, but the root bears you.
Rom 11:19 You will say then, The branches were broken off that I might be grafted in.
Rom 11:20 Well! For unbelief they were broken off. And you stand by faith. Do not be high minded, but fear.
Rom 11:21 For if YAHWEH did not spare the natural branches, fear that it may be He will not spare you either.
Rom 11:22 Behold, then, the kindness and severity of YAHWEH: On those having fallen, severity. But on you kindness, if you continue in the kindness. Otherwise, you will also be cut off.
Rom 11:23 And those also, if they do not continue in unbelief, will be grafted in. For YAHWEH is able to graft them in again.
Rom 11:24 For if you were cut out of the natural wild olive tree, and against nature were grafted into a good olive tree, how much more these being according to nature will be grafted into their own olive tree?

A:  May I begin by stating that I am not intentionally attacking the beliefs of any Christian. All I am doing is using logic, & reasoning, in interpreting what we are told in the Bible. Essentially, all I am writing is what the Bible says.

In Eph 3:6, Paul writes that “the gentiles” can be co-heirs, united in the same body, & partakers together in the promise in Messiah through the Gospel”. So clearly, if gentiles (non-Israelites) are “adopted in”, or are “grafted in” to Israel (Rom 11), they can be participants in YHWH’s covenant.

Please note that I am not referring to the current nation of Israel in the middle East – I am referring to biblical Israel.

However, unless gentiles are “grafted in”, or “adopted” by Israel, AND, unless they accept YHWH’s, & Messiah Yahushua’s covenant proposal conditions, I believe that, based on Eph 2:12, which I have copied again so that you can read it once more, they CANNOT be participants in YHWH’s covenant. I really believe that this is a very serious, “salvation” issue.


I believe that we need to examine the idea of "salvation" form another perspective.

Q: Do you believe that, based on Rom 11, that you are “grafted in” to the olive tree, namely, Israel ?

Q: Again, do you believe that, based on Eph 1:5, that you, as a gentile, have been adopted into YHWH’s family ?

If your answers to the above two questions is "yes", then please consider the next few questions.

Q: If these beliefs are true, does it seem logical, & reasonable to think that YHWH would bring truth to the world through His Messiah & the apostles, and that He would then adopt “gentile”, believers in Messiah Yahushua, into YHWH’s family, and then tell the new children that they don't have to do what He had the original children do?

Q: Do you believe that YHWH would say to the Jews, who are part of His original family, Israel, throw all that nasty stuff away that you all have been doing up till now – you know, all My Torah instructions, commandments, statutes, ordinances & judgments, that I gave you, so that you would have life – it’s all been bondage, & really horrible? I knew when I gave them to you, that you  wouldn't be able to do it – sorry, but thank you for trying !

Q: Do you really think that YHWH would say to the Jews, again who are part of His original family, Israel, I still need you all to follow My instructions, & keep My commandments, statutes, ordinances & judgments, but these new children I'm adopting, they don't have to - I'm going let them live free of all of that, & live in whatever way that they were used to living before I adopted them?

Q: Does it make any logical sense that YHWH say to the goy (gentiles), that He is adopting, come into My house - be my children, & meet my other children. I require a lot of them that I'll never require of you, but welcome to the family? Isn’t that totally illogical?

Q: Doesn’t Eph 2:19 tell us that “now therefore you are no more strangers and foreigners but fellow-citizens with the Saints and of the household of Yahweh”?

Doesn’t that mean that we have become citizens in an established nation, and we have become children in an established family? Doesn’t that therefore mean that we are therefore, subject to the laws of that nation, and that we have to live by the rules of the family we've been adopted into?

Never was it written that the Gentiles would just get to start their own division of Yahweh's worshipers. Never was it written that the Gentiles would have a different citizenship and live in a different house.


We are citizens and an established nation we are children in an established family, & as such we are to rejoice, & we are to learn.


Eph 2:12excluded from the Commonwealth of Israel”, & therefore “strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, & without YHWH in the world” ?

I am sure that many Christians will claim to be in a “new” covenant, & they probably are in some covenant, but, unless they do what YHWH’s covenant says they need to do, they cannot be in YHWH’s Covenant.

What if the doctrine Christians have been taught, & have believed about being in YHWH's, & Yahushua’s new covenant, is wrong ?

                  
The problem sadly as I see it, is that most Christians, seem to be totally “unaware” of what is required of them, in order to be participants in YHWH’s, & Yahushua’s “renewed covenant” !

If you see any errors in my interpretation of Scripture, and/or any errors of logic, I would be very interested in any feedback (positive & negative), comments and/or questions that you may have.


Please do not hesitate, if you would like to discuss this further, or if there are any questions.

Please send them to          askseekknockandtest@gmail.com    using the subject           COVENANT


I pray for YHWH’s blessings to you & yours, in Messiah Yahushua’s precious name
Today in modern society, the bride is “the star of the show” in marriage ceremonies – she is the focus – she does all the planning. In biblical times, this was not the way that it was.

We often hear the phrase, “the bride of Christ (Messiah)”, & if we are the “bride of Messiah”, we need to know, & understand what our role is, & what is our groom’s role ! We know that Messiah will be faithful to fulfil all the requirements of the groom.

Let’s see how this worked in ancient times.

The first step in an ancient marriage covenant, including a first century wedding, was the betrothal.

The main parts of the betrothal were :

1:  Usually, the man would see a woman, a virgin, he wanted to marry, & he would ask his father to be involved.

2:  The man, with his father, would come to the village, & meet with the woman’s father. At this meeting, the man would explain to the woman’s father what he would offer - how he would take care of her – what he would provide – this would be the proposal for the wedding covenant.

3:  If the woman’s father was happy with these details, he would accept the wedding covenant for his daughter.

4:  The woman’s father would then talk to his daughter, explaining details about the future groom – that her future groom comes from a good family, & how he would take care of her.

The 2nd step in an ancient marriage was to negotiate the price of the bride – the bride price.

It wasn’t enough to establish a covenant, now the man had to make an offer that would show how much he loved this woman, & how much he wanted to marry her – he would make the best offer he could. Once this was established, they moved to the next stage.

A 3rd step in an ancient marriage involved the woman’s father talking to her, & explaining the latest details – the father would say - I have accepted the covenant – all is prepared – we agree on the price.

Then his daughter would prepare a meal for her future husband – of course, the man would be formally invited.

The future groom would knock at the door of his future bride’s home – on hearing this, the woman would go to the door, & open it a little – they couldn’t see each other - she’d then go back to the table where the meal would be eaten – she’d wait there.

Only when the door was opened, would the man come in – they would see each other officially for the first time - they would sit down together, & eat a meal.

Next, the man would pour a glass of wine for the woman – he then offers her the cup – if she drank the wine, the wedding was sealed – the marriage  covenant was ratified - they were legally married, or “betrothed”, although the marriage had not been consummated. She would pass the cup back to him, & he would drink from it.

A 4th step involves the future groom leaving his future bride, & going back to his father’s house – there he begins to prepare a home for his bride – it would take at least one year.

When the home was built, & set up, the future groom’s friends would come up & ask him, “when are you going back to get your bride – everything is ready ?”

In those days, it wasn’t up to the son to make this decision – he didn’t have the authority to choose the day he would go back to get his bride – only his father had the authority – when asked when he would go back to get his bride, the son would reply to his friends question, “I don’t know the time, the hour, or the day, you must ask my father”.

Finally, as a 5th step,  the father would give his blessing -  the groom & his friends would go back to the village where the woman lived with her father - when he got to the village, he would sound the shofar – the woman would hear the sound of the shofar – she had to be ready because she didn’t know exactly when he was coming – when she heard the shofar, she would get up & look – she would see her beloved – when it was confirmed that she was ready, the village gate would be opened – the groom would go into the village – he & his bride would meet half-way - he would then take her back to her father’s house where they’d have the wedding supper together.

During the ancient wedding ceremony, the person conducting it, would incorporate a covenant of salt, as mentioned in Num 18:19. In ancient times, when two people wanted to enter a covenant of loyalty, especially a marriage, each would bring a small pouch of salt, they would recite the details of the covenant, exchange salt from one pouch to the other, and then shake the pouches. The symbolism is powerful. The only way their marriage covenant could possibly be broken is, for each to individually retrieve their own grains of salt, which is impossible.

We can now look at how all this is related to being “the bride of Messiah” – there are several parallels we can notice.

Let’s begin by focusing on Yahushua at His last Passover – He says something to the effect in Matt 26:28, Mark 14:24, Luke 22:20, & quoted in 2 Cor 3:6,  “I have come to establish a new covenant with you”.

In Luke 22:20, Yahushua says “this is the new covenant in my blood which is shed for you” – this was the price He was willing to pay.

In John 15:13, Yahushua says “greater love than this has no one, that anyone should lay down his life for his friends”. Again, a reference to the price He was willing to pay for us, His bride.

So Yahushua, just like in the first century wedding, came to establish a covenant, & offered to pay the bride price (the highest price, His life).

We see another step in Rev 3:20 – Yahushua says “behold, I stand at the door & I knock, & if anyone hears my voice, I will come in & sup with them”.

Think back to Yahushua at His latest Passover - He pours the wine, & says each of you “take this cup & drink of it” (Matt 26:27-29, Luke 22:17)

Q: Why did Yahushua do that ?
A:  Because the groom had to offer the bride the cup.

In doing this, the betrothal between the groom (Yahushua), & the bride (us) began.

In John 14:2, Yahushua says
In My Father’s house there are many dwelling places; if it were not so, I would have told you. I go to prepare a place for you”.

Yahushua our Bridegroom, gives to us all His wonderful promises - He promises :
~   to prepare a place for us (John 14:2)
~   to never leave or forsake us (Heb 13:5)
~   to heal us (Luke 4:18)
~   to protect us (Luke 4:10)

Q: When did Yahushua drink the cup ?
A:  In the garden, (Matt 26:39-42), Yahushua says He has to drink the cup, & then pay the price.

When the apostles asked Him when He would restore the kingdom, He gave a good wedding covenant answer – “I don’t know, the angels in heaven don’t know, only the Father knows”.

Aren’t we told in 1Thes 4:16-17, “He (Messiah) will descend from on high, sound the shofar, & those who are alive will be caught up to meet Him”.

I’m sure there are other parallels, but these will suffice for this study.
In this section, I will be adding a series of articles on different subjects. I pray that they will be both interesting, & helpful.

Our Belief Systems

I’d like to begin by defining what a belief is. There are many slightly different definitions of what a belief is, but for simplicity, I’m going to use yourdictionary.com’s definition. It says :

a belief is anything that is accepted by a person as true.

I hope we can we all agree on that "working" definition.
 
Every person has a unique belief system.
Our belief system is composed of a vast array of different beliefs (things that we accept as being true), that include survival beliefs, health beliefs, career beliefs, social beliefs, cultural beliefs, financial beliefs and religious beliefs, to name but a few. The question I want to investigate is “how did each person develop his/her own unique belief system”?

If you examine your own life, I am confident that you will find that the vast majority of your beliefs were developed when you were a small child. You learned many of them in your family environment, and, if you are younger than my generation, you also learned some of them in child-care facilities of various kinds. You learned them in schools, and in religions facilities, such as churches. Perhaps one of the most influential sources of your beliefs was television. 


An example of one possible belief might be, that your parents believed that being well-mannered was important. In this case, you were taught to be well-mannered. Without your parents specifically telling you to believe that “nice manners are important”, that idea was absorbed into your belief system. You were not aware of it becoming a belief for you, and you certainly did not question its validity. This was what I shall call “formal” belief development.


I propose that this formal belief development process happens to all of us with the vast majority of the things that we believe as adults.

A summary of this process might look like this :
1    A parent has a specific belief at either a conscious or subconscious level
2    The parent instructs the child about this belief
3    The parent reinforces this belief
4    The child “absorbs” this belief into their belief system

This same process occurred whether we were at home, in child-care, in school, in church, or while watching television.

With each belief that is absorbed into our belief system, there is an “intensity” that accompanies it. We may believe in something “passionately”, “moderately” or “sparingly”. 

There are other beliefs that we developed as children, that were not “formally” learned as in the above example. For instance, in my family, my grandparents “argued” a lot with each other. As far as I remember, we never discussed arguing in my family, but somehow, through a process of “osmosis”, arguing, or what I call “discussion”, became something that I have always done. If I disagree with something, I will often express that opinion. During the expression of that opinion, I am usually very “passionate”. However, I don’t usually “take offence” when someone disagrees with me. When the discussion is over, I don’t hold grudges or bad feelings for the other person – I just say to them “you can believe that if you like”. For most of my life I have “argued”, believing that I was right (and therefore, the other person was wrong). I am not like that now ! I still discuss many things passionately, but I now have an open mind to most things, and am willing to consider any reasonable information. After all, I could be wrong.

This “informal” belief development process could go like this :

1   A person (child-care person, teacher, minister, TV presenter, authority figure) might say something that catches the child’s attention, for example, “it is fun to travel”
2   The child might think about it briefly, but then forgets it
3   This or a similar idea may come up somewhere else – the idea is reinforced
4   Over a period of time, the idea is “absorbed” into the child’s belief system

I believe many, many of our beliefs were formed in these two ways. They were ideas that were absorbed somehow from family, teachers, religious ministers, friends, authority figures and television. As mentioned earlier, the impact of television at an early age cannot be exaggerated. Perhaps the most important point to make about this childhood belief development, is that, at that age we are very impressionable. We sometimes develop “irrational” beliefs as well as contradictory ones.

Of course, there are some areas about which we may not have established a belief. These most likely are areas that we have not yet experienced.

A theory about the establishment of a person's Belief System.


I am suggesting strongly the following “theory” about a person’s belief system.

1   The vast majority of any person’s belief system, is developed in the above ways, as a child.
2   Most adults go through their entire lives, without ever asking questions such as :
     ~   What do I really believe about . . . . . . ?
     ~   Why do I believe this ?
     ~   Is this belief valid ?
     ~   Does this belief help me to be successful ?
3   Our actions or behaviours are strongly controlled by what we deeply believe.
4   The vast majority of our actions operate at an automatic level. We don’t need to think about them, we just do them (most of the time). They are habitual.

I know you may not want to believe this, but sometimes, we have been believed LIES !
 What are some lies your have believed ? What is the truth about that lie ? Do any of these “ring a bell” ?
Lie - Santa is coming tonight               
Truth - He’s a fictional character made up to make small children feel good
Lie - Flying in an aeroplane is dangerous
Truth – Flying in an aeroplane is statistically a very safe form of transport
Lie – Captain Cook discovered Australia
Truth – Australia was visited by several groups before Captain Cook came
Lie – Electricity is dangerous
Truth – The careless use of electricity is dangerous
Lie - Money is the root of all evil
Truth – The love of money is the root of all evil
Lie - Work is boring
Truth – Work is a privilege, a joy
Lie – I’m not very smart; I can’t do things
Truth – I am highly intelligent; I can do anything if I work at it
Lie – Messiah Yahushua was born on December 25th
Truth – Messiah Yahushua was definitely not born on the 25th December. He was probably born during the feast of Sukkot (September/October)

How do we react when we realized we have believed a lie ?
In his book, “Fossized Customs”, Lew White says “When something believed-in, is exposed as being false or a lie, a reaction is aroused. How an individual reacts depends on how well-equipped they are, and the degree to which they want to believe the falsehood.

Dresden James wrote, “A truth’s initial commotion is directly proportional to how deeply the lie was believed. It wasn’t the world being round that agitated people, but that the world wasn’t flat. When a well-packaged web of lies has been sold gradually to the masses over generations, the truth will seem utterly preposterous, and its speaker a raving lunatic”.

From a personal point of view, when I discovered that, many of the foundations of my faith (I was a devout Roman Catholic for 63 years), were not rocks of truth, but as Todd Bennett describes in his series “Walk in the Light”, “rather the sands of lies, deception, corruption, tradition and paganism, I went into shock. I was in grief, and experienced its the various stages (denial, guilt, anger, hope and acceptance). I spent many, many hours attempting to “prove” that the counter-statements I had been confronted with, were false. When I could not, I experienced great pain and grief. It was a very painful time for me !

Why did I feel that way ? My understanding of what happened, is that when my deep-seeded beliefs were threatened with rival information, I “reacted” with all the stages of grief mentioned above. It is very difficult to convince someone who has deep-seeded beliefs about something that they are mistaken. They usually get very defensive, and will not even entertain the “threatening idea”, in any way. Their “reactions” are often “irrational”.

A personal example of a lie I believed, and how believing that lie affected my life
I am currently 77 years old. For most of those years, it never occurred to me to ask the deeper questions about important beliefs. I’d like to share with you an experience that totally changed my life. When I have a live audience, I tell the detailed version of this story. For now, I’ll give the abbreviated version.

When I was about 6 years of age, I had an experience with a teacher who asked me to read aloud in class. I was embarrassed because I couldn’t read as well as my classmates, and for 34 years, I had the strong belief that “I don’t like reading”. It wasn’t that I couldn’t read, my problem was that I read very slowly, and was unsure of the pronunciation of many words.

This belief, that “I don’t like reading”, had a great negative affect on my life. I was shy and lacking in self-confidence. I often felt embarrassed, and looking back, I know I was socially quite immature until I was about 40 years old.

At this time, I met a teacher who spent one hour teaching me how to “speed read”. To my amazement, my reading speed trebled after that one hour experience.

When I examined the “speed reading” method I had been taught, I realised that my problem was not that “I don’t like reading”, it was that I didn’t know the specific skills that I could use, to increase my reading speed ! I had believed a lie !

With this new information, I was able to correct the deep-seeded belief, that I don’t like reading, by creating a new belief, that I had consciously decided with my adult mind, which empowered me to become an avid reader ever since.

Changing False and Unproductive Beliefs
Soon after this, I became interested in the fascinating topic, “how does the human mind work”, and that led me to realise that I could change any belief I had, to something that I wanted to believe.

During the next few years, I systematically examined many of my previous beliefs about things like food, money, relationships, and career, with my adult mind. It was a very interesting and productive exercise. I strongly encourage each person to do the same. I believe it will be an exciting adventure for you, and that you will find a real peace when you consciously decide “what it is you really want to believe”.

Since then, I have made many conscious decisions concerning my “spiritual” walk, and my life in the world in general. 
They are things like :
+ Someone knows a great way to do everything (I don’t need to discover how to do everything I want to know, right from the beginning, or by trail and error)
+ While I pay close attention to what I am listening to or reading, I don’t accept or believe what anyone tells me, until I check it out. I “TEST it” as 1Thes 5:21 says. I apply this principle to any and every person, teacher or Rabbi. They are human – they can make mistakes.
Why do I do this - I never want to be deceived again !
+ The Bible, in its original language, is the inspired, revealed, written word of Yahweh. I check all teachings against that source, using several Bible versions and language tools such as Strong’s Concordance, to make sure that what I believe is as accurate as possible.
+ I want to do Yahweh’s will.
+ I am very vary or cautious of the “traditions of men”. They may be helpful, and even worthwhile, but they are not Yahweh’s commandments !

My advice to each of you is :
Be very careful what you believe ! It will totally control everything you do !

Deception
The “enemy” (satan), does not want us to know the true meaning of Yahweh’s Word, and so he has done many things throughout history to “deceive” mankind. There are many verses in Scripture about deception and being deceived – even Yahushua (Jesus) warns us about it.
The following scriptural verses contain some of these warnings :
Mat 24:4  And Yahushua answered and said unto them, Take heed that no man deceive you.

Matt 24:24 For false messiahs and false prophets shall arise, and they shall show great signs and wonders, so as to lead astray (deceive), if possible, even the chosen ones.(Some versions use “the elect”)
 Luke 21:8 Yahushua replied: "Watch out that you are not deceived. For many will come in my name, claiming, 'I am he,' and, 'The time is near.' Do not follow them.
Paul the apostle also comments several times about being deceived. In Ephes 4:14 he says :
so that we should no longer be children, tossed and borne about by every wind of teaching, by the trickery of men (by deception), in cleverness, unto the craftiness of leading astray
In 2 Thes 2;3, he says :
Let no one deceive you in any way, because the falling away is to come first, and the man of lawlessnes1 is to be revealed, the son of destruction
So we must be very careful – because we want to know what Yahweh’s Word really says. We must TEST everything we read or hear, by checking it against the original language of the Scriptures, so that we will not be deceived ! We must also ask Yahweh to only reveal His truth.
For a more detailed information about deceptions, please check out my studies elsewhere in this website called "How can I know if I've been deceived", & "Is your faith a "Bible-based" faith".

Truth

One of my biggest “hang-ups” is to do with a common use of that word “Truth”. How many times have you heard someone say “This is THE Truth”, or “G-d told me", or "the Holy Spirit spoke to me”, or “a word came to me” ! For me, the most disturbing statement is “we have the truth”, implying that no one else does ! How can the estimated 40 000 Christian denominations each claim that "they have the Truth"? 
I’m very, very careful about this. When I stand before Yahweh for my judgment, I don’t want Him to say to me “What was it, that you said, "I said", about such and such ?”
I have been told, and it probably is true, that in ancient Israel, all the prophets of old came before the elders and spoke their message. Every word of their message was written down, and later checked to see if they were true or false prophets. If we look at Amos 1:1, we see an example of this.
Amo 1:1  The words of Amos, who was among the herdmen of Tekoa, which he saw concerning Israel in the days of Uzziah king of Judah, and in the days of Jeroboam the son of Joash king of Israel, two years before the earthquake
Q: How could it have been two years before the earthquake ? 
A: It must have been recorded in some way.
I wonder if that had been done with all the modern-day prophets, how many would be shown to be true prophets ?

Important Note  
It is my reality, that we have all believed lies. How and why we have done this, is the subject of another study. I strongly urge you to develop an open, but critical mind, so that you can receive only Yahweh’s truth, but not be deceived by the enemy.
The story of Galileo Galilei in 1633 explains why. 
Galileo, the famous Italian scientist, was delivered before the Roman Inquisition to be tried on charges of heresy. He was denounced, according to a formal statement, "for holding as true the false doctrine . . . that the sun is the centre of the world, and immovable, and that the earth moves!" The statement went on to read that "the proposition that the sun is the centre of the world, and does not move from its place is absurd, and... heretical, because it is expressly contrary to the Holy Scripture!" Galileo was found guilty, and forced to renounce his views. He was sentenced to a life of imprisonment.
We all know now, that Galileo was correct, but clearly, wrong beliefs (lies) at the time, were believed by influential people. (Careful study will show you that the Bible says no such thing about the solar system). The belief systems of the Roman Church were threatened, and so, they needed to take action that supported their deep-seeded beliefs. As a result, Galileo suffered a severe injustice. The Roman Catholic Church finally pardoned him in 1992 !


What should we do to avoid being deceived ?
My research tells me that there is such a massive mixture of Yahweh’s Truth and paganism in the religious world. It is therefore vital that we realize, that there will be some beliefs we have, that are liesthat we have been deceived ! Again, we need to ask Yahweh for His truth, and we must to do our own study. Remember what Paul says in his second letter to Timothy
2 Tim 2:15 Study to show yourself approved unto Yahweh, a workman does not need to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.
What does the term “truth” really mean ?
I believe it is very important to always define terms by using Yahweh’s definitions. I get a bit nervous when people define terms such as these in a 21st century manner. 
If we go to the Scriptures, we find Yahweh’s definition for the term “truth”
                  
Ps 119:142, tells us : Your righteousness is righteousness forever, And Your Torah is truth.

In John 14:6, Yahushua said : I am the Way, and the Truth, and the Life. No one comes to the Father except                 through Me.”

1 John 5:6 says : And it is the Spirit who bears witness, because the Spirit is the Truth
 
So when we talk about “truth”, we are referring to Yahushua - the Living Torah, the Spirit of Yahweh, and Yahweh’s Torah – the Father’s loving teachings, instructions, commands and ordinances.
 
We must be humble before Yahweh, realizing that He is our source of everything we receive. We must “TEST all things”, including everything we currently believe is true, to see if we really do have Yahweh’s Truth !

It is very important that we be open to any new revelation Yahweh might give us – we must be teachable, and not arrogant, believing we have “the truth”. Of course, we must also be discerning, and so “TEST all things”. The apostle Paul speaks about this in Romans 12: 2 which says :
Rom 12:2 And do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you prove what is that good and well-pleasing and perfect desire of Elohim.


What Spiritual beliefs do I have ?
Over the last few years, I have studied the Word of Yahweh very intently. I have read and listened to, the whole of the Bible at several times, during that period. I have read the teachings of the main Messianic teachers and others, and have arrived at the following conclusions. I’d be very interested in hearing whether you agree with me or not, and if not, why !

Author’s Conclusions

1: In terms of our spiritual beliefs, there are “relatively” few things, about which, we can be absolutely certain !
2: The rest of our beliefs are what I call theories. These “beliefs” are possible explanations of ideas or events. We can’t be absolutely certain that they are true !
To explain what I mean, I will give three examples of beliefs about which I am absolutely certain, & three examples of "theories".
My three examples of absolutely certain beliefs are :
A: There is a Creator of all that there is
B: Yahushua is Yahweh's Messiah
C: There are two houses of Israel

Three examples of theories that I have are :
~   The Creator’s name is pronounced as Yahweh
~   The New Moon is determined by the “mulad”, the dark moon
~   Yahushua was born on the feast of Sukkot

One of the big problems we have in the “messianic” community is to do with the group of beliefs that I call "theories". We often disagree about things like “how to pronounce the Creator’s name”, or "when does the biblical year begin". Again, These are what I call "theories" – it is not a belief about which we can be absolutely certain.

As I said before, a theory is simply a possible explanation of an idea or event. A strong theory will have a lot of evidence, and that evidence will be sound. A weaker theory will have a lesser amount of evidence, and that evidence will not be as strong. In the end, we need to ask for the heavenly Father’s guidance, search His Scriptures in their original languages, to see what He says about something, weigh up the evidence, and then, make an intelligent decision. I believe that once we agree on this, we won’t get so emotional about our “theories”. I realise that I am “human”, and that I may not have all the evidence, and that my reasoning may be flawed, but I am always open for someone to “correct” any error I may have.

With this in mind, if you believe I am in error, I ask you to please show me from Scripture, where my error is.


Two Essential Spiritual Beliefs

If I am not sure about a person’s belief in say, creation, I usually ask a person “do you believe that there is a Creator of all that there is, or not”. If the answer is no, I ask them why they have that belief. From where I stand, it takes much, much more “faith” to believe that there is no Creator; that somehow all there is “just came to be” (the Big Bang theory is often quoted). For me, the belief in a Creator is the first “essential” belief any person can have.

The next question I ask a person once they have agreed that there is a Creator, is “what do they believe the Bible is ?” I don’t know if you have spent very much time with this question, but I believe it is vital. My answer to that question is that the Bible, in its original language, is the inspired, revealed, written Word of the Creator ! The Bible, the Creator’s instruction manual, is my “absolute authority” for any spiritual belief I have. Remember, there is no such thing as an “inspired translation” !
For much more detail on this, please refer to my series, "How to Study Scriptures", elsewhere on this website.

Why are the original languages of the Bible so important ?
If we are to understand as accurately as possible, Yahweh's Word, we must comprehend the original meaning of words used, as well as their original context,  and we must appreciate and understand the idiomatic expressions of those languages. If we fail to do this, we will almost certainly “misinterpret” what Yahweh’s word says. I believe this is what satan wants. He doesn’t want us to really know what Yahweh’s Word says. As a teacher, I often told my students the following :        

+   Wrong information ALWAYS gives us the wrong answer !
+   Incomplete information USUALLY gives us the wrong answer !
+   Only complete and accurate information can give us the correct answer !
Do you agree ?

Summary Conclusions
+   Each person has a unique belief system
+   The vast majority of a person’s beliefs are formed (often by “osmosis”) as very small children
+   Most people never ever question specifically what their beliefs are, why they have those beliefs, or whether their beliefs are valid, wanted or useful
+   All people have believed lies – we have all been deceived
+   Many of the actions or behaviours of a person are determined by their core belief system
+   Most people, most of the time, behave automatically, without testing their beliefs
+   Many people have believed the lie, that they are not intelligent enough to study and reason for themselves. They believe the lie, that only more educated people like priests, other religious ministers, and academics can really understand Yahweh's Word
+   Be very careful what you believe
+   Know why you believe something
+   A person can “change” her/his mind (beliefs) in a thoughtful way
+   Yahweh defines His “truth” in Ps 119:142, which says :
            Your righteousness is righteousness forever, And Your Torah is truth.
+   There is a vast mixture of Yahweh’s truth and paganism
+   There is a lot of theology, that I call “theory”. A theory is a possible explanation of an event. Strong theories have lots of robust, supporting evidence; weak theories have only lesser supporting evidence
+   There is a Creator of all that there is
+   The Bible, in its original languages, is the inspired, revealed and written Word of Yahweh. It is the Creator’s instruction manual, for how He wants us to live successful lives
+   We must use the original languages of the Bible, in the original context, and understand the true meanings of words and idioms, if we are to accurately interpret Yahweh’s Word
+   There is no such things as an inspired translation of the Bible
+   I am cautious about “the traditions of men”. While I realize that many traditions are good, I believe they are useful provided they line up with Yahweh’s Word. I always want to know if any action we do is a “command from Yahweh” or “a tradition of man”. We may do traditions but we MUST do Yahweh’s commands
+   Faith is “belief in action”. Faith is a gift – it must be received !
+   I must be open to receive new revelation from Yahweh, and I must not assume that my previous beliefs are absolutely true. We must “renew our mind”. I must “test” all spiritual beliefs by checking them against Yahweh’s Word – the Bible. I never ever want to be deceived about Yahweh’s Word
+   We all have a different belief system – it contains a mixture of Yahweh’s Truth and pagan influences. Be gentle with those who do not believe exactly what you believe. For whatever reason, Yahweh has created things this way

What will we do with this information ?
I realize that there is a lot of information here, and that it will take time for you to “digest” it. I will never ask you to “replace” your understanding of Yahweh’s Word for mine, but I do ask you to think very carefully about what I have written.

When I first realized all this, I made some careful, thought-out, conscious decisions. I ask you to consider what I have done, and if you agree with the above conclusions, I encourage you to decide now to adopt some or all of them as well.

1   I pray to Yahweh everyday, to ask Him to release to me only His truth, and to withhold anything that is not of Him
2   I choose to have an open teachable but discerning mind
3   I listen respectfully to, and read carefully what others say and write, but DO NOT BELIEVE them, until you have tested it against Yahweh’s Word, as it is written in its original language.
I am very wary of the “traditions of man”
4   I read Yahweh’s Word everyday – I suggest you do this in some systematic way
5   I study to show myself approved, but am guided by Yahweh's Ruach, His Holy Spirit,  to study the work of any person who some of Yahweh’s Truth (NB - there is a vast mixture of truth and paganism)
6   I search diligently to find more and more of Yahweh’s Truth
7   I find like-minded believers to communicate with – remember, we are each in a different place on our journey, so be patient and gentle with each other.

I’d like to thank you for reading this teaching, and I pray that it will be a blessing to you. Remember, I believe what I have written is correct, but please do not believe what I have written. Check it out for yourself. I’d be interested in any feedback, positive or negative. You can contact me at    askseekknockandtest@gmail.com

May Yahweh continue to bless you and expand your understanding of His Word.
Shalom.

Home Study Exercise
I encourage each person to do what I did, and examine each major belief you have about the Creator and His Word. If you would like some assistance with this, you might like to use the information provided in the Appendix.

Appendix
Use the follow questions as starters to the study of your belief system

Is there a Creator ? Who is the Creator (God) ?
Why did He create the universe and us ?
What is His name ? What do I know about Him ?
Are names important ?
What is the Bible ? Why are there so many different versions ?
Who are the “Old Testament characters such as Adam and Eve, Noah, Abram, Moses, David, and so on ?
Who are the chosen people of Yahweh ? What were they chosen for ?
What did Yahweh ask them to do?
Why did He ask them to do those things ?
What are the Ten Commandments ?
What does Yahweh want us to do ?
What is the Sabbath day and what are we to do on it ?
Who is the Messiah ? What is His name ?
Who were the Messiah’s parents ? Where did He live ?
What was He taught ?
Who were His apostles ? Who were the first century believers ?
What did the Messiah live and teach ?
Why was He so upset with the Pharisees ? Who was Paul ?
What is righteousness ? What is salvation ? What is the kingdom ?
What is the “good news” of the kingdom ?
Who are Messianic believers ?
What are the two houses of Israel ?
The list goes on and on !!!

Perhaps one of the most important questions that we can truthfully ask
ourselves is :

"How do we really, really know, that what we believe about these, & other spiritual questions, is accurate, correct & true ?"
What is salvation – Are you Saved?
 Earlier on in this website, I have touched on several very important beliefs, but for me, knowing what I believe for “salvation” is absolutely essential work. If I don’t know what I need to believe, (and do) to be saved, then all the rest of what I do is useless.
This blog will cover a few different aspects of salvation, & it is my hope & prayer, that they will be both interesting, & helpful.

Let’s begin with some important definitions that I hope we can agree upon.
 Salvation is the preservation from, or deliverance from harm, ruin or loss, as a consequence of sin - it was made available to all through the death, burial & resurrection of Messiah Yahushua.
Faith is our acceptance of this truth, & our complete trust, reliance, & confidence in the salvation provided by Messiah Yahushua
Works are the things we do, the actions we take, that demonstrate our faith, or lack of faith, in the salvation provided by Yahushua
Grace before YHWH calls you is unmerited favour. After YHWH calls you out, & your ears & eyes are opened, then "grace" is definitely merited. "Grace" is the power of YHWH, in & for you.
Isn't it true that Salvation, Faith & Works have always been the foundation of our relationship with our Creator, and the basis for the covenant He makes with his people?
It is your Faith that determines what you do, in response to the salvation that was provided to you by Yahushua.
It is your Works that demonstrate your faith.
Isn’t it true that we are going to be judged according to our works, & how they demonstrate our faith in the salvation provided by Yahushua?
If you think carefully about it after studying the Bible, isn’t it true that salvation was, & is provided, that is, made available TO ALL, by grace, because it is a desire of YHWH? We did nothing to cause YHWH to make Salvation available to everyone that ever lived !
Again, if we study what we are told about salvation in YHWH’s Word, don’t we find that it is faith, or belief alone, that determines whether or not, we get to have Salvation that was freely provided, or made available to us, by grace (Eph 2:8)?
 Eph 2:8 For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of YHWH
At the same time, again, isn’t it your “works” that demonstrates your faith? Aren’t your “works” the visible demonstration of your faith? Doesn’t James tell us in Jam 2:20 & 26, that, “faith without works, is DEAD”.
So yes, you are 100% saved by faith, but there’s a relationship that we need to understand between salvation, faith, & works.

Background Information 
If we refer to Exod 6:6, we see that YHWH will bring Israel out from under the burdens of Egypt, (He saved them), & will deliver them from slavery – YHWH redeemed them with an outstretched arm, & with great judgments.
Q: Why will YHWH bring Israel out from their burdens, deliver them from their slavery, & redeem them ?
A: So that they will have the freedom to walk the path of YHWH’s Torah.

Q: Wasn’t YHWH’s original plan back in the garden, always about creating a group of special people who He would spend eternity with ?

Q: Does it seem logical, or reasonable, that YHWH would simply provide, or make available to everyone, “salvation by faith through grace”, and not expect that those who receive that gift of salvation, should measure up to some standard that YHWH would set ? Would you want to spend eternity with people who just want to do their thing, & not conform to certain requirements that are set by YHWH ?

Q: Do you believe that, based on Rom 11, that you are “grafted in” to the olive tree, namely, Israel ? Let's assume that you do.

Q: Do you believe that, based on Eph 1:5, that you, as a gentile, have been adopted into YHWH’s family ?
Eph 1:5  Having predestinated us unto the adoption of children by Messiah Yahushua to himself, according to the good pleasure of his will,

Q: If these beliefs are true, does it seem logical, & reasonable to think that YHWH would bring His truth to the world through His Messiah & apostles, and that He would then adopt “gentile”, believers in Messiah Yahushua, into YHWH’s family, and tell the new children that they don't have to do what He had the original children do?

Q: Do you believe that YHWH would say to the Jews, who are part of the olive tree, Israel, to throw all that nasty stuff away, that they all have been doing up till now - you know, all My Torah instructions, commandments, statutes, ordinances & judgments, that I gave you, so that you would have life – would YHWH say to them "it’s all been bondage, & really horrible"? Would YHWH say, "I knew when I gave them to you, that you  wouldn't be able to do it – sorry, but thank you for trying" ?

Q: Do you really think that YHWH would say to the Jews, "I still need you all to follow My instructions, & keep My commandments, statutes, ordinances & judgments, but these new children I'm adopting, they don't have to - I'm going let them live free of all of that, & live in whatever way that they were used to living before I adopted them"?

Q: Does it make any logical sense that YHWH would say to the goy (gentiles), that He is adopting, "come into My house - be my children, & meet my other children. I require a lot of them that I'll never require of you, but welcome to the family"? Isn’t that totally illogical?

Q: Doesn’t Eph 2:19 tell us that “now therefore you are no more strangers and foreigners but fellow-citizens with the Saints and of the household of Yahweh” ? Doesn’t that means that we have become citizens in an established nation, and we have become children in an established family? Doesn’t that therefore mean that we are therefore, subject to the laws of that nation, and that we have to live by the rules of the family we've been adopted into?

Never was it written that the Gentiles would just get to start their own division of Yahweh's worshipers. Not ever was it written that the Gentiles would have a different citizenship, & live in a different house.

Aren’t we told quite the opposite in Eph 4:4-6 ?

Eph 4:4 There is one body, and one Spirit, even as ye are called in one hope of your calling;
Eph 4:5 One Master, one faith, one baptism,
Eph 4:6 One Elohim and Father of ALL, who is above all, and through all, and in you all
.

Q: How can people worship YHWH, when they won’t listen to His voice, & be obedient to what He commands?

Q: Doesn’t Deut 8:2 tell us that YHWH caused the Israelites to go 40 years in the wilderness, to humble them, & test them, in order for Him to know what was in their hearts, & to see if they would keep His commandments or not ?

Deu 8:2 And you shall remember all the way which YAHWEH your Elohim has caused you to go these forty years in the wilderness, in order to humble you, to try (test) you, to know that which is in your heart, whether you will keep His commandments or not.

Q: Again, it is clear that YHWH provides, or makes available to everyone, His free gift of Salvation by faith through grace, but wouldn’t He also want to apply this Deut 8:2 set of criteria, to see which people qualify to spend eternity with Him ?
How does the Bible define "salvation" ?
If we do a search of the Bible, we find that in Gen 49:18, the first mention of the Hebrew word, Yahushua, translated as salvation – it can mean deliverance, salvation, victory, & freedom. Did you get that? The name of our Saviour, Yahushua in the Hebrew, means deliverance, salvation, victory, & freedom.
 Gen 49:18 I have waited for thy salvation,(Yahushua), YHWH
 
Q: What do we need to have "salvation" from ?
A:  We need "salvation", Yahushua, to pay the eternal death penalty for us breaking YHWH’s Torah, for sinning – Rom 6:23 tells us that “the wages of sin is death
Luke 1:77 tells us that Yahushua will give a knowledge of salvation by the removing of their sins.
When we accept the free gift of salvation by faith through grace, that is offered to all, aren’t we given the key that opens the door into YHWH’s kingdom, where those who enter, will spend eternity with Him ? 
Q: If according to Rom 10:9, we accept Yahushua as our saviour & confess Him with our mouths, & believe in our hearts that YHWH raised Him from the dead, then aren’t we set free from sin’s penalty, that is, eternal death, & aren’t we given that key to the door of YHWH’s kingdom (so to speak)?

I will be returning to some of these ideas later, but for now, I’d like to share with you, an analogy, that seems to demonstrate what “salvation” is.

In this analogy, which I first heard described by Rabbi Steve Berkson of MTOI, can you imagine that as you walking through life, you are on a wide, winding path or road. There are many others also walking on this path.

At some point in your life, you discover, or realise that you need a “Saviour”. It is at this time, that the wide, twisting path divides into two paths, one which is still quite wide & winding, while the other path is quite narrow, & is straight.

You can’t see it, but you know that the narrow, straight path, goes from where you are now, to a door that leads into YHWH’s kingdom.

This narrow, straight path is covered by the shed blood of Yahushuaa blood canopy that covers you, while you are on the path.

As you walk along this path, the things that you do, like keeping Sabbath & how you actually keep it, what you eat, how you treat each other, & so on, are called in Hebrew, your halachah.

While you are walking on this path, & you are doing your halachah, the path eventually leads to that door – Rabbi Steve Berkson explains that this halachah is called “your” righteousness. Your righteousness gets you from where you are, to the door.

You can’t make it all the way to the door by yourself – you’ll need the Father to help you, & you’ll need Messiah Yahushua, & His Ruach (Holy Spirit), to lead & guide you – they will be supporting you, holding your hand if you like, but, you have to walk it out !

When you get to the door, it is locked. Because of you sin, you are still stained, even though you have been cleaned, & have been walking in righteousness. The only thing that can get the stain out, is the shed blood of Messiah Yahushua, which can be applied to you as you are walking, but its ultimate fulfillment can only be applied to you at the door. That is why His righteousness is imputed to you, so that you can be a pure white, spotless, bride, to enter into the kingdom.

Until you get to the door, there is no need for the ultimate fulfillment of Messiah Yahushua’s blood – there is however, a need for His shed blood for forgiveness, for restoration, & for relationship with Him & the Father.

To the left & right as you are walking, is every horrible, & every tempting thing, to scare you off the path, or to lure you off the path ­– only what is good for you in on that path. Even though now, you understand intellectually that the stuff off the path is not good, you are still attracted to it – in your heart, you are drawn to it

When you step off the path, you also step out from under the coveringbeing uncovered is the most dangerous place you can be – there you are on your own – you have no protection, & no support.

If you get off the path, you have to do “teshuva”, a Hebrew word that means that you have to repent of the sins that took you off the path, turn around, get back on the path, & keep walking in righteousness..

Again, your righteousness, (works of Torah), only gets you to the door

Yahushua’s righteousness must be applied to you, to “unlock the door” to YHWH’s kingdom

Remember, when you get to the door, you may be clean, but you are still stained. A shirt with a red wine stain can be washed, so that it is clean, but still stained.

You can be washed clean by Messiah Yahushua’s blood, every time you sin, but you are still stained until the His righteousness is applied to you.

Isn’t it true that this application of Yahushua's righteousness, doesn’t happen, until you get to the door ?

You need to do what you need to do, to get to the door ! YHWH will hold your hand, so to speak, until you get to the door, but, you have to do the work !

Salvation is of the Jews
There are two verses that many find difficult to really understand. They are in John 4:22, where Messiah Yahushua says, “Salvation is of the Jews”, & Rom 3:1, where Paul says, “What advantage then hath the Jews?” I hope my explanation below will assist in understanding the importance of these two verses.

Let’s begin by taking a look at John 4, & examining the context of John 4:22.

In John 4:4-18, we have the story of Yahushua’s encounter with a Samaritan woman. Yahushua stops at a well for a drink of water – it is called Jacob’s well because v5 tells us that it is near a parcel of ground that Jacob gave to his son, Joseph. Yahushua asks this woman to give Him a drink. In v9, the woman points out to Yahushua that “Jews have no dealings with the Samaritans”. Yahushua responds in v10 saying, “If thou knewest the gift of Yahweh, and who it is that saith to thee, Give me to drink; thou wouldest have asked of him, and he would have given thee living water”  .

Yahushua explains to this Samaritan woman that, the water that He would give her would mean that she’d never thirst; that it would spring up into everlasting life (v14). The woman replies in v15, “give me this water, that I thirst not”. Yahushua tells her to call her husband (v16), & she replies in v17, that she has no husband. Yahushua then tells her she’s had five husbands, but the one she has now, isn’t her husband (v18).

It is at this point, v19, that the Samaritan woman says, “I perceive thou art a prophet”, & adds in v20, ”Our fathers worshipped in this mountain; and ye say, that in Jerusalem is the place where men ought to worship”.

Yahushua then says to the woman in v21, “Woman, believe me, the hour cometh, when ye shall neither in this mountain, nor yet at Jerusalem, worship the Father”. Yahushua adds in v22, “Ye worship ye know not what: we (the Jews), know what we worship: for salvation is of the Jews.

The questions that every person reading this chapter could, & perhaps should ask at this point, are :
a: why did Yahushua tell her that she worshipped what she didn’t know, &
b: why did He say that “we” (the Jews), know what we worship, &
c: why did He say that “salvation is of the Jews” ?

In order to really understand the answers to these three questions, we’ll need to revisit some of the history of Israel, from the time just after king Solomon’s death. I hope a summary of the relevant events from 1 Kings 14 & 16, & 2 Kings 17, will suffice.

1 Kings 14:21 – we are told that Rehoboam, the son of Solomon reigned in Judah

1 Kings 14:30there was a war between Rehoboam, the king of the northern kingdom of Israel, & Jeroboam, the king of the southern kingdom of Israel.

1 Kings 16:22Omri became king of Israel, & he bought the hill Samaria (1 Kings 16:24).

2 Kings 17:6 – quite some time later, Assyria captured Samaria, & took the Israelites captive into their Assyrian lands (about 722-720 BCE).

2 Kings 17:24Samaria was then resettled with Babylonians, who were then known as Samaritans.

2 Kings 17:25These Samaritans didn’t fear YHWH, because they didn’t know who He was – note that YHWH sent lions among these Samaritans – this frightened them – reports of this came to the king of Assyria

2 Kings 17:26 – the Samaritans believed that “elohim” were connected to a geographic area, & this "Samaritan" elohim, who sent the lions, wasn't happy with them

2 Kings 17:27to solve the lion problem, the king of Assyria sent one Israelite priest to teach the Samaritans, the “manner of the elohim of that land”, whom they believed was YHWH

NB – recall from 1 Kings 12:31, that it was Jeroboam’s practice to make “priests” of the “lowest of the people”. Because the time of 2 Kings 17 is almost 200 hundred years later, the standard of Jeroboam type priests, would very likely, be much worse than when he first created priests - the priest's knowledge of YHWH almost certainly would be contaminated, & not scriptural.

Remember also that Israel was given to the Assryians because they transgressed YHWH’s law, (2 Kings 17:7), meaning that they didn’t really know how to keep YHWH’s laws. This one priest probably did a very poor job of educating the Samaritans about YHWH’s ways ! This led to the Samaritans “mingling in” pagan practices with what they had been taught about YHWH.

2 Kings 17:29 – tells us the Samaritans made “elohim” of their own, whom they worshipped, as well as what they had been taught about YHWH

2 Kings 17:33the Samaritans feared YHWH, but also served their own gods. Their religious system was one that “blended some of the truth of YHWH”, with “outright paganism”.

2 Kings 17:34 – this is a summary statement that tells us that the Samaritans “didn’t fear YHWH, nor did they keep His statutes or ordinances, after the Torah & commandments that YHWH gave to Israel

2 Kings 17:35 – explains that YHWH made a covenant with Israel, & told them, the Israelites, not to fearother elohim”, “nor bow down to them, nor serve them, nor sacrifice to them”.

2 Kings 17:41 – records that these nations of Samaritans, including their children & their children’s children, “feared YHWH”, AND served their graven imagesthey mingled, & contaminated their worship of YHWH

Q: Wasn’t this the reason that YHWH scattered both the northern & southern kingdoms of Israel, many years earlier (2 Kings 17:7)?

In summary then, if you practise, or participate in any pagan based ritual, then clearly, you do not keep Torah, & you do not “fear YHWH” – it is impossible tofear YHWH”, AND mingle, & contaminate the worship of YHWH with practices from any other deity.

So now, let’s get back to the woman at the well in John 4.

The first thing we need to understand is that this Samaritan woman is a Gentile, NOT an Israelite. She has been taught a contaminated form of worship.

She likes to talk as though she’s connected to Israel – in John 4:12, she asks Yahushua is He greater than “our” Father, Jacob, who gave them the well ? In v20, she says our” fathers worshipped in this mountain (of Samaria)

You might recall that “worship in the mountains of Samaria” was set up by Jeroboam (1 Kings 12:25-33). At that time, we are told they worshipped two golden calves as “Elohim”, claiming that they were worshipping YHWH. The Samaritan woman is claiming to have a heritage to the ancient kings of Israel that set this up.

In John 4:25, she says “I know that Messiah cometh, which is called Christ: when he is come, he will tell us all things”. She knows enough to know that “a messiah is to come”.

Again, we know that she had gentile origins, so how is it that she knows about a messiah, how can she claim this connection to Jacob, & that the ancient Israelite kings were part of her heritage ?

In 2 Kings 17:34, we are told that, “Unto this day they (the Samaritans), do after the former manners: they fear not the LORD, neither do they after their statutes, or after their ordinances, or after the law and commandment which the LORD commanded the children of Jacob, whom he named Israel

These Samaritans, who haven’t feared YHWH, & haven’t followed His statutes or ordinances, have taken their pagan rituals, & dedicated them to YHWH. We know that YHWH didn’t accept them when the northern tribes of Israel did this, not did He accept them when the southern tribes did the same. YHWH, certainly, isn’t going to accept them from the Samaritans.

Q: So, why did Yahushua tell the Samaritan woman in John 4:22, that she “worshipped what she knew not” ?
A: Because He knew about 2 Kings 17, as well as the history of the Samaritans since their arrival, as Babylonians, hundreds of years before. Yahushua knew that their ancient traditions affected what they knew, & practised now.

Yahushua knew that the Samaritans had been taught that they could take their previous pagan rituals, & dedicate them to YHWH, believing that YHWH would accept them.

Q: Isn’t this what most of Christianity has done for almost 1900 years ? Since emperor Constantine in the fourth century AD, most devout, sincere Christians have unknowingly, taken pagan rituals, & dedicated them to YHWH, believing, whole-heartedly, that YHWH would accept them.

Three common examples come to mind - celebrating the 7th day Sabbath of Exod 20:8, on Sundays, originally called “Dies Solis”, the pagan day of the sun; celebrating the birth of Yahushua on December 25th, the birthday of the pagan god of agriculture, Saturn; & celebrating the Messiah’s resurrection on “Easter” Sunday, the first Sunday after the first full moon, following the spring equinox - the name “Easter” is derived from “Eostre”, originally a Saxon word, denoting a goddess of the Saxons, in honour of whom sacrifices were offered about the time of the Passover - this day is really connected to the worship of the ancient pagan deities, Tammuz and Ishtar.

Isn’t it true that whatever a pagan ritual came out of the Roman Church, (of which I was a devout, practising, believing member for 63 years), the Roman Church didn’t try to convert the people from it, they just “baptised” that ritual, & said that they were doing it for Jesus or God ?

Very sadly, the vast majority of well-meaning, sincere, believing Christians have no idea about any of this. They are exactly like the Samaritan woman at the well in John 4, of whom Yahushua says, she “worshipped what she knew not”. Do you think that YHWH will accept, “contaminated & mingled” worship? Based on what happened to the northern & southern kingdoms of Israel in ancient times, & what Yahushua told the Samaritan woman in John 4, definitely NOT!

Aren’t these sins of Christianity, the same sins as the sins of the northern & southern kingdoms of Israel in ancient times, & of the Samaritans ?

Clearly, when we look at our world today, there is no “fear of YHWH” ! A person cannot truthfully say that they “fear YHWH”, & ignore what He says ! You can’t say that you “fear YHWH”, & ignore what He says about the 7th day Sabbath, about the eating of “clean” food, about keeping His moedim (appointed times), or about keeping any Torah instruction, or command that applies to that person!

Surely, the “fear of YHWH” is always evidenced by obedience to His instructions, commands, statutes, ordinances & judgments.

Can we know for sure, if our worship of YHWH is pure, or is it contaminated ? Let’s look at what Messiah Yahushua said about it.

Again, in John 4:22, Yahushua said, “salvation is of the Jews”! If you don’t know, or understand what this means, then isn’t your worship probably contaminated ?

Again, Yahushua said, “we know what we worship, for, salvation is of the Jews”. Notice He did not say that “if you believe in Me, & say this prayer, you will be saved”! Yahushua wanted her to know that He knew, that what she, & her people, believed & practised, would not save her, or them!

What does “salvation is of the Jews” mean? 
Doesn’t Paul explain it well in Romans 3 ?
Rom 3:1 What advantage then hath the Jew? or what profit is there of circumcision? 
Rom 3:2 Much every way: chiefly, because that unto them (the Israelites, including the Jews), were committed the oracles (the spoken thingsof YHWH

Didn’t YHWH commit the oracles (the words that He spoke), to the Israelites, which in the first century, would have been the Jewish people ?

At that time, the Jews were the guardians, & protectors of YHWH’s Word, the very utterances of YHWH, that He spoke to Moses. To do this, again, the Jews have endured hatred, & hardship.

Messiah Yahushua in John 4:22 is saying that “salvation comes out from the Jews”, & so, if you want to know about “salvation", you need to go, & look at the oracles that the Jews were entrusted with – if you want to know how to be rescued, & thus be saved, then you need to go, & look at the utterances, & instructions that YHWH gave to them through Moses.

If you have been taught of a “salvation” that is not based on the oracles of YHWH, then, based on what Messiah Yahushua said in John 4:22, it isn’t YHWH’s salvation.
 
The really sad thing is that, before YHWH disturbed the peace of my wife & myself, & showed our family how He really wants to be worshipped, we were worshipping all right, but like the Samaritan woman of John 4, we didn’t know who we were worshipping. We “believed“ that we were worshipping YHWH, but in fact, we were unknowingly, worshipping pagan deities like Ishtar, or Tammuz, or even demons. Why were we doing this? Because our Christian Church never taught us, YHWH’s Torah.

If we had been taught what the Jews had been given, namely, YHWH’s spoken Word through Moses, we would have known better – we would not to have had steeples, or Easter Sunday services, or egg hunts, or celebrations on the 25th of December, or Sunday sabbaths.

If we contrast what some pastors, evangelists, & Sunday school teachers are saying to their congregations, with what Yahushua said, aren’t these pastors, evangelists & Sunday school teachers saying “just believe in your heart, & call on the name of Jesus, & you will be saved”, while Messiah Yahushua said, “salvation is of the Jews”.

Based on this information, don’t many people have a false hope about salvation because they know little about Torah, & they miss-read what Paul writes. In Rom 10:5, Paul writes that “Moses describes the righteousness which is of the Torah, & that man who does those things, shall live by them”.

Isn’t it true that most people read Rom 10:13, believing that the name of “the Lord” is Jesus ? Is this correct?

Rom 10:13  For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.

Rom 10:13 is actually a quote from Joel 2:32, which reads :
Joel 2:32 And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord (YHWH) shall be delivered (saved).

Is “Jesus” the name of YHWH ? Based on Rom 10:13, is it possible to be "saved" in the name of Jesus ( a name that didn't exist until the 15th century, AD) ? Check out how the 1611 KJV Bible writes the name of the Messiah - there was no "J" in English until 1524.
Mat 1:1  The booke of the generation of Iesus Christ, the sonne of Dauid, the sonne of Abraham

Is the “once saved always saved” doctrine, scripturally correct ?           
 
Can we take some time to look at a concept that I believe, is at the heart of, & is a root cause of much of the rebellion, that we see throughout the scriptures by those who claim to be followers of YHWH and Yahushua, as well as by many people today?

If we look at the idea of being “saved”, isn’t it true that how we perceive salvation, & being “saved”, are powerful underlying factors in the decisions, & choices we make, both the good ones & the rebellious/foolish ones?

Let's consider the following points carefully.

Q: Rom 3:24 tells us that "Being justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Messiah Yahushua". Does this mean, that once you are “in Messiah Yahushua”, you automatically are in YHWH’s kingdom ?

Again, according to Exod 6:6, YHWH was going to bring, or save Israel out from the burdens of Egypt, & would deliver them from slavery – we read that He would redeem them with an outstretched arm, & with great judgments.

Q: Don’t we know that Exod 14:30 tells us that Israel was “saved” by YHWH !
Exo 14:30  Thus YHWH saved Israel that day out of the hand of the Egyptians; and Israel saw the Egyptians dead upon the sea shore.

Q: Did Israel ever need to be saved "again" ?
A: Absolutely - they needed to be “saved” over & over. If we check the following sample of situations, don’t we find that Israel needed to be saved again & again – Num 10;9, Deut 33:29, Judg 2:16, 1 Sam 14:23, 1 Ch 11:14.

It seems very likely that Israel thought that they “were saved” when they were delivered from slavery, from bondage, from Egypt, after celebrating YHWH’s Passover, but history, & the above verses, show that they were wrong?

Let’s now examine several verses in the Renewed Covenant scriptures (NT), that also apply here?
 
Q: Doesn’t John 15:1-9 use the word "abide" or “stay”, in reference to being in Messiah, ten times (v4, v5, v6, v7, v10)  ? Doesn’t this imply that if you can abide or stay, then clearly, you can also choose to leave ?

Q: Isn’t it reasonable to assume that the people referred to in Matt 7:21-23, sincerely believed that they were “IN Messiah Yahushua”, & that they were saved ? Why were they rejected ?
A: Doesn't v23 tell us that they "worked iniquity", meaning that they were not keeping YHWH’s Torah, & so again, according to v23, Master Yahushua declared that He never knew them ?    
 
Mat 7:21 Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven. 
Mat 7:22 Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? 
Mat 7:23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity

Q: Doesn’t Paul tell us in Phil 2:12, to work out our salvation with fear & trembling ? Does that sound like once saved, always saved  ? Isn’t this verse telling us that being saved is an on-going process ?

If you have a “once saved, always saved”, belief, how do you explain why Messiah Yahushua says in Matt 10:22, “the one who endures to the END, shall be saved ?

Again, isn’t Messiah Yahushua telling us here that "being saved" is an on-going process, that isn’t completed until "the end" ?

Let’s now consider the person, Judas Iscariot.
Did he believe in Messiah Yahushua at some point ? Yes
Did he always believe this ? No – Judas betrayed Yahushua
Was he saved simply because he believed Yahushua was the Messiah at some point ? We don’t know if he was saved, but we do know that his original belief didn’t save him.

Does it seem logical, or reasonable, that YHWH would simply provide, or make available to everyone, “salvation by faith through grace”, and not expect that those who receive that gift of salvation, to measure up to some standard that YHWH would set ? Would you want to spend eternity with people who just want to do their thing, & not conform to certain requirements, set by YHWH ?

A final thoughts

If we carefully read Rom 7:7, don't we find that Paul is telling his audience that the only way that he knew that he had sinned, was by reading, & knowing the law (YHWH's Torah) ?

Rom 7:7 What shall we say then? Is the law sin? God forbid. Nay, I had not known sin, but by the law: for I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet.

Can I please ask my audience a few very important questions ?

Q: Do you realise that you have broken the law ?
A: Based on Rom 7:7 & 1 John 3:4, unless you check out “the law”, how can you know that you have broken it, namely, that you have sinned?

1Jn 3:4 Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law.
 
I’m sure that you realise that there was a penalty paid for your disobedience, your breaking of YHWH's law – your sinning – Messiah Yahushua died for your's & my sins.

Q: Are you now going to walk out that “law” like it doesn’t matter anymore, knowing that it was your transgression of the law, that put my Saviour to death ?

A: Surely, we need to understand, & appreciate the “very, very high price that was paid” for those sins, & now decide to fully walk that salvation out – rather than just saying, this is going to be done, I’m just going to do it.

If you want to understand “salvation”, don't you need to really understand that you have “transgressed” the law, & how far you have fallen. Isn't true salvation about getting on your knees after seeing how far you have fallen, & begging the heavenly Father’s forgiveness, & then deciding to keep all of the "law of YHWH", that applies to you ?
Introduction

Before I get into the detailed possible scenarios for the original Passover, I'd like to share with you some information about why there might be confusion over this subject.

Have you ever stopped to consider how incomprehensible, satan’s powers of deception really are ?


Have you ever noticed that just 57 verses into YHWH’s Word, we are given a very deep insight into just how skilled satan is at deception ?

I’m sure you can recall that :

in the first two chapters of YHWH’s Word, we are told about how wonderful, powerful, & magnificent the Creator is.

We read that Adam & Eve are created in a perfect paradise, where they were in an incredibly intimate, & wonderful relationship with that Creator, & were given dominion over it all.

Under those perfect conditions & circumstances, can you imagine that it would be possible that Eve could be deceived into not believing what her Creator had said to them ?

Yet, that is exactly what happened !

To awaken us to how skilled satan is at deceiving people, let’s remember that satan went into that place of perfection, to a woman who had intimate knowledge, and a relationship with YHWH, the Creator, and deceived her into believing she ought to disobey what YHWH had said !

Isn’t that unbelievably, powerful deception ?

We are told in Genesis 3 that “the serpent was cunning above every beast of the field which YAHWEH Elohim had made”. The Hebrew word translated as “cunning” is H7, arum, which, according to Strong’s & BDB, can mean subtle, shrewd, crafty, sly, & cunning.

Interestingly, the English word, “cunning”, means “to be very skilled at achieving a goal by means of deception”.

Isn’t Genesis 3 really warning us that this serpent, this beast, (satan), is the most skilled deceiver ever to exist ?

Let me write that another way.

YHWH’s Word tells us right there in the beginning, that there is a very powerful spiritual entity at work, satan, who wants to deceive us, & we're told that he is more skilled at doing that, than any living being.

We are told that his craft hinges on his ability to get people to question, & then to reject, the things that YHWH said.

We are told exactly how much success he had, & we see in Genesis 3 that his very first attempt to do this, did not fail.

Again, satan went into that perfect environment - he went to a woman who had a very intimate relationship with YHWH, & was very aware of
what YHWH had said
- satan set out to deceive the woman into
committing an act of disobedience in the very beginning of our Bible.

Isn’t it true, that satan is so skilled & powerful as a deceiver, that he has gotten many Christians to believe that Messiah Yahushua would want them to disobey what YHWH, His Father, said ?

In my teaching on “is your faith a Bible-based faith ?”, I examined Matt 7:21-23 & Matt 24:4-5, showing that Messiah Yahushua prophesied that “many” people would be deceived.

If we read Mark 13:22-23, aren’t we told that “even the elect could be led astray, & be deceived" ?

If satan has continued deceiving people throughout the centuries using this same method, why do some of us think we are immuned ? Shouldn't we be combating any possible deception by continually TESTING all things (1 Thes 5:21) ?

What I am about to present is a TEST of the possible scenarios for the original Passover.

Detailed Possible Scenarios for the Original Passover

There are two main belief systems that relate to the keeping of the original Passover. To assess which belief system is scripturally correct, I will present two possible scenarios, thus TESTING each scripturally.

The first scenario involves keeping Passover by starting at the beginning of the 14th of Aviv – soon after sunset.

The second way involves celebrating Passover from around 3 pm on the 14th of Aviv, and continuing on into the 15th of Aviv.

By comparing these scenarios, we should be able to ascertain which is more scripturally accurate.

Could I strongly encourage the reader to "put aside", what they think they know about Passover, based on the Renewed Covenant Scriptures (NT), & focus only on the original Passover Scriptures ?

This first scenario relies on the idea that “between the evenings” means from sunset to dark at the start of Day 14. The times are hypothetical to see if this idea would fit in with the specific Scriptures. They are based on real times in Cairo, Egypt. Sunset is about 6 p.m. The days indicated are for the month of the Aviv. Please take as much times as you need, to very carefully examine all the details in each row.


This second scenario relies on the idea that “between the evenings” means from 3 pm until sunset on the afternoon of Day 14. The times are hypothetical to see if this idea would fit in with the specific Scriptures. They are based on real times in Cairo, Egypt. The days indicated are for the month of the Aviv.


Analysis of the Two Possible Scenarios concerning the Passover Event

There appears to be only minor problems with the first scenario.

One is that in Exod 12:11, the Israelites were told "to eat the Passover lamb with their belt fastened, their sandals on their feet and with their staff in hand – to eat it in haste". If they didn’t leave until almost 20 hours later, why were they told this ?

A possible answer is that they knew that they were not to do any work on the 1st day of Unleavened Bread, the 14th of Aviv.

Another possible reason is that they knew they were leaving, but they didn’t know exactly when – after all, they had to have Pharaoh’s permission to leave.

A third possible problem with this scenario is that it doesn’t seem to fit the timing of Messiah Yahushua’s death as the Passover Lamb (3 pm). He did die on the 14th Day of Aviv, though not at the exact time that the Passover lamb was slaughtered on the original day of Passover. For many people, this is unacceptable, since they say, the Messiah must fulfil every detail of prophesy. If we check Exod 12:14, we are told that the day, the 14th day of Aviv, was to be a memorial, not a re-enactment.

Exo 12:14  And this day shall be unto you for a memorial; and ye shall keep it a feast to the LORD throughout your generations; ye shall keep it a feast by an ordinance for ever
.

One study makes the point that the Jews, before and during Yahushua’s time on earth, had no idea of any connection between the original Passover lamb, and the death of the Messiah. Keith Hunt claims that there is no scripture in the Tanach connecting these two events. Indeed the only scripture verse about a slaughtered lamb in the Tanach, that I could find was Isaiah 53:7. The Messiah is only described as the Passover once in the Apostolic Writings (1 Cor 5:7).

Isa 53:7 He was oppressed, and he was afflicted, yet he opened not his mouth: he is brought as a lamb to the slaughter, and as a sheep before her shearers is dumb, so he openeth not his mouth.

1Co 5:7  Purge out therefore the old leaven, that ye may be a new lump, as ye are unleavened. For even Messiah our passover is sacrificed for us
:

I believes that Messiah Yahushua celebrated the Passover on the evening at the beginning of the14th day of Aviv, on the day He died. It seems logic that He would have gotten it right.

If we look at Exodus 12:50-51, we notice that there appears to be a contradiction about the day the Hebrews left Egypt. This is the same issue I dealt with in Exod 12:17.

Exod 12:50-51 And all the children of Israel did as Yahweh commanded Moses and Aharon, so they did. And it came to be on that same day that YHWH brought the children of Yisra’ĕl out of the land of Mitsrayim according to their divisions.

A possible explanation is that Pharaoh freed the Hebrews after midnight on the 14th day of Aviv, & even though they didn’t leave Rameses until the 15th day, they were free to do so. Remember also that it would take a considerable amount of time for the Israelites to travel from Goshen to Rameses.

Scenario two has problems that are more concerning.

A major problem here is that if the Israelites left on the 15th day of Aviv, the day many interpret as the first day of the festival of Unleavened Bread. In doing so, they would be breaking the direct command (Exod 12:16), not to do any manner of work, that YHWH gave the Israelites just a few days before.

Exo 12:16  And in the first day there shall be an holy convocation, and in the seventh day there shall be an holy convocation to you; no manner of work shall be done in them, save that which every man must eat, that only may be done of you
.

Another problem with scenario two is that some of the specific events described in the scriptures cannot fit into the possible time-frame that would have needed to occur.

Exodus 12:8 tells us that the Passover lamb had to be eaten, the night it was roasted, and this cannot happen with scenario two.

Exod 12:8 ‘And they shall eat the flesh on that night, roasted in fire – with Unleavened bread and with bitter herbs they shall eat it.

A similar problem occurs when we attempt to match the leaving from Egypt with the timing stated in Numbers 33:3, that is, during the night of the 15th day of Aviv (Deut 16:1). This timing just won’t fit the scriptural details of scenario two.

Num 33:3  And they departed from Rameses in the first month, on the fifteenth day of the first month; on the morrow after the passover the children of Israel went out with an high hand in the sight of all the Egyptians.

Deu 16:1  Observe the month of the Abib, and keep the passover unto the LORD thy God: for in the month of the Abib; YHWH Your Elohim brought thee forth out of Egypt by night
.

If the above scenario is correct, I believe the following summary of points, have to be true.

1: We have to believe that "between the evenings", beyn ha’everim, must mean "from 3 pm until sunset".

2: If "between the evenings" is a time from 3 pm until sunset, then we also must believe that Pharaoh, who's heart was hardened at least four times because of the plagues that YHWH had sent upon Egypt, decided to give the Israelites "the afternoon" off from their slavery, namely, the 14th day of Aviv, so that they could "slaughter the Passover animals", & roast them, from 3 pm to sunset.

3: If we compare the HRB of Lev 23:5, with the Greek Septuagint, we notice that the Greek word, translated as "evening" in the Septuagint is G2073, hespera.

Lev 23:5  In the fourteenth day of the first month between the evenings is YHWH's passover
. (HRB)
If we check Strong's Concordance & Thayer's Lexicon, we see that clearly, from these two witnesses, G2073, hespera, means “evening”.

If we now look at Matt 14, there appear to be two “evenings” in the one scenario.

Mat 14:15 And when it was evening, his disciples came to him, saying, This is a desert place, and the time is now past; send the multitude away, that they may go into the villages, and buy themselves victuals.

Mat 14:23  And when he had sent the multitudes away, he went up into a mountain apart to pray: and when the evening was come, he was there alone
.

If we check the APB+ translation of Matt 14:15, please notice that the Greek word, translated as "evening" is G3798, opsios. I have copied Strong's & Thayer's definitions below.



Based on this information, isn’t it now obvious that the “evening” in the verse 15 is probably referring to the “afternoon”, while the “evening” in verse 23 is referring to a  later time such as “evening” or “night” ?

Some supporters of the interpretation of "between the evenings" meaning from "3 pm until sunset" claim that, for the Jews of Israel, as native speakers of Hebrew, this term, beyn ha’everim, means "afternoon".

While I would not question the validity of that statement with the current Jews of Israel, if “between the evenings” meant “from 3 pm until sunset”, back when the Torah was written, why does the Septuagint use G2073 in Lev 23:5 & elsewhere, when there is a perfectly good Greek word, G3798, that can be translated as “afternoon ?

Doesn't it seem likely that the translators of the Septuagint, understood that “between the evenings” to mean, “from sunset to dark”, & not “from 3 pm until sunset"?

4: We must ignore several scriptural verses as being translation errors.
~ In Exod 12:8, we must impose the interpretation of the phrase “that night” to mean the next night.
~ In Deut 16:1, we must translate “by night” as meaning during the daylight.

5: We must expect that, either YHWH gave one command, & then changed His mind, as in the case of Exod 12:16, or the Israelites disobeyed YHWH by working on a day He proclaimed a few days earlier as a “non-work” day.

We know for sure, that the Israelites left Rameses on the 15th day of Aviv, (Num 33:3) whether it was during the night time, or during the daylight hours (Deut 16:1 says at night). In travelling out of Egypt, they certainly did “work of some manner”. So that means, (a) they disobeyed YHWH’s command of Exod 12:16 to do “no manner of work”, on the first day of the seven days of unleavened bread, or (b) the 15th day is NOT the first day of the seven days of unleavened bread.

Num 33:3  And they departed from Rameses in the first month, on the fifteenth day of the first month; on the morrow after the passover the children of Israel went out with an high hand in the sight of all the Egyptians
.

6: I mentioned this point briefly in the scenario chart above, but, because I strongly believe that most people seem to ignore it, I'd like to elaborate on it here.

We are told in several verses that the Israelites lived in Goshen, Egypt (Gen 45:10, 46:34, 47:6, & Exod 8:22). We know from Num 33:3, that they left Rameses on the 15th day of Aviv.

That means that when Pharaoh ordered them out of Egypt, they had to travel from where, at least 2 million of them lived in Goshen, to get to Rameses.

We don't know precisely where these places are, but I do know that it would have taken quite some time for these 2 million people to travel from Goshen to Rameses with their families, possessions, plunder, & animals.

This scenario does not allow for significant event.

Conclusion

Based on what the Scripture verses tell us, all the practical aspects involved, & the above information, I strongly believe that Scenario one, is the only real possible scenario.

What do you think ?


Because this topic is the cause of a lot of confusion, I have decided to examine it by presenting a balanced study that uses equal weights & measures (Lev 19). Because I do not want to be deceived, I will be quoting YHWH's Word often.

I realise that this process is quite complicated, and I may not have answers to every question - I may not even have all the questions. I might not have covered all the possibilities. If you find any errors in logic, or any omissions or any corrections, please let me know, at askseekknockand test@gmail.com & I will address them.

In order to arrive at a correct conclusion, I will attempt to present :

(a) a statement of the two main scenarios with regard to the meal eaten on the evening before Messiah Yahushua was crucified

(b) a statement of the command to keep Passover

(c) the evidence for each scenario

(d) the problems with each scenario

(e) the subsequent beliefs associated with each scenario, and

(f) my conclusion.

Some of the time, I will simply make statements or comments, while at other times, I will ask, and attempt to answer questions in order to add clarity to my understanding.

I'd like to strongly encourage you the reader, to be involved in this study process. While it is my intention to present accurate information, I will be recording "my" verdict about each piece of evidence presented, but I ask you to think about, & perhaps record "your" comments & verdict, as well. I plan to assess the strength of the evidence in my verdict, & hope that you can do the same.

Limitations for this study

While I have access to several tools, such as e-Sword, concordances & etymological books, where I can examine Hebrew & Greek words for possible meanings, and can check the various forms of these words, my knowledge of Hebrew & Greek grammar is limited - I call myself an "advanced" beginner. I will therefore, do the best that I can to examine, and explain my reasoning & understanding of the scripture verses, I will be referring to, hopefully in their correct context.

The two main scenarios commonly practised are :

A: Messiah Yahushua ate the Passover meal on the evening at the start of the 14th of Aviv, &

B: Messiah Yahushua did not eat the Passover meal, but instead ate a practice sedar to teach His disciples (This assumes an evening to evening determination of a day).

Background Information

The full description of the original Passover event is given in Exodus 12.

1:  Exod 12:14 states the command about keeping the Passover -it is to kept as a memorial.

Exo 12:14  And this day shall be unto you for a memorial; and ye shall keep it a feast to YHWH throughout your generations; ye shall keep it a feast by an ordinance for ever
.

Q: Which day is to be a memorial ?
A: Based on Exod 12, it must be the 14th day of Aviv, since it is the last day mentioned previously in this chapter (Exod 12:6). There are several other scriptures that state that the Israelites kept, and/or killed the Passover on the 14th day of Aviv (Num 9:5, 2 Ch 30:15, Erza 6:19, Ezek 45:21)

2:  There are some other commands directly related to Passover.

a) Exod 23:14-17 tells us that Passover along with Shavuot, & Tabernacles are to be kept as pilgrimage feasts each year. Deut 16:16 adds a little more detail by explaining that all males are to do this in the place YHWH chooses.

Exo 23:14  Three times thou shalt keep a feast unto me in the year.
Exo 23:15 Thou shalt keep the feast of unleavened bread: (thou shalt eat unleavened bread seven days, as I commanded thee, in the time appointed of the month Abib; for in it thou camest out from Egypt: and none shall appear befo
re me empty:)
Exo 23:16  And the feast of harvest, the firstfruits of thy labours, which thou hast sown in the field: and the feast of ingathering, which is in the end of the year, when thou hast gathered in thy labours out of the field.
Exo 23:17 Three times in the year all thy males shall appear before YHWH your Elohim
.

Deu 16:16  Three times in a year shall all thy males appear before YHWH your Elohim in the place which he shall choose; in the feast of unleavened bread, and in the feast of weeks, and in the feast of tabernacles: and they shall not appear before YHWH empty
:

b) Deut 16:1-2 tells us we are to observe the month of the Aviv, & keep the Passover

Deu 16:1  Observe the month of the Abib, and keep the passover unto YHWH Your Elohim for in the month of the Abib YHWH Your Elohim brought thee forth out of Egypt by night.
Deu 16:2 Thou shalt therefore sacrifice the passover unto YHWH Your Elohim, of the flock and the herd, in the place which YHWH shall choose to place his name there
.

c) Deut 16:5-7 tells us we may not sacrifice the Passover lamb within our gates (our towns), but at the place YHWH chooses. We are reminded to do this at even, ba erev, at the going down of the sun, at the time Israel came out of Egypt.

Deu 16:5  Thou mayest not sacrifice the passover within any of thy gates, which YHWH Your Elohim giveth thee:
Deu 16:6 But at the place which YHWH Your Elohim shall choose to place his name in, there thou shalt sacrifice the passover at even, at the going down of the sun, at the season that thou camest forth out of Egypt.
Deu 16:7 And thou shalt roast and eat it in the place which YHWH Your Elohim shall choose: and thou shalt turn in the morning, and go unto thy tents
.

d) Exod 12:43-49 tell us details about who can part-take of the Passover. The Hebrew word translated as "stranger" is nekar, & means a non-Israelite passing through the nation of Israel, but not living with them. A foreigner is a non-Israelite person dwelling with the nation of Israel. The "stranger" in v48, is a ger - a non-Israelite who is wanting to become a legal Israelite citizen - he is studying, in preparation for becoming a full-time Israelite, sometimes called a proselyte.

Exo 12:43  And YHWH said unto Moses and Aaron, This is the ordinance of the passover: There shall no stranger eat thereof:
Exo 12:44 But every man's servant that is bought for money, when thou hast circumcised him, then shall he eat thereof.
Exo 12:45 A foreigner and an hired servant shall not eat thereof.
Exo 12:46 In one house shall it be eaten; thou shalt not carry forth ought of the flesh abroad out of the house; neither shall ye break a bone thereof.
Exo 12:47 All the congregat
ion of Israel shall keep it.
Exo 12:48  And when a stranger 
(ger) shall sojourn with thee, and will keep the passover to YHWH, let all his males be circumcised, and then let him come near and keep it; and he shall be as one that is born in the land: for no uncircumcised person shall eat thereof.
Exo 12:49 One law shall be to him that is homeborn, and unto the stranger that sojourneth among you
.

Q: Where does YHWH choose to place His name ?
A: I believe that before the Temple was built in Jerusalem, it was where ever the Tabernacle was located. 2 Kings 21:4 tells us that when the Temple was built, it was Jerusalem.
       
2Ki 21:4 And he built altars in the house of YAHWEH, of which YAHWEH had said, In Jerusalem I will put My name
.

Q: What does "observe the month the Aviv" mean ?
A:  Some would say it means determining when the barley is "aviv", by "looking" at it.
The Hebrew word translated as "observe" is the word, shamar, which can mean to guard, protect, hedge, attend to, or keep.
Therefore it could also simply mean "celebrate Passover in the first month of the year", at the time when the barley is Aviv.

Q: What does Deut 16:5 mean - it is translated as above ?
A: I'm not sure. The Hebrew word translated as "within any" is "echad", which can mean "united, one, first, each or every". When combined with verse 6, perhaps it is saying "the Tabernacle" at this time, & then later, "the Temple" in Jerusalem. The CJB translates it as follows :

Deu 16:5  You may not sacrifice the Pesach offering in just any of the towns that Adonai your God is giving you
.

I am inclined to think that this may be a better translations, since the Hebrew word translated as "gates", H8179, sha'ar, is probably referring to the city or town gates, not the "gates" of a specific house.

Evidence that supports Scenario 1 - Messiah Yahushua is eating the Passover meal

1:  Matt 26:17-21, Mark 14:12-18, & Luke 22:7-20 each describe the preparation, & eating of the Passover by Yahushua & His disciples. Please note that the words in brackets are NOT in the original manuscript.

Mat 26:17  Now the first 
(day) of the (feast of) unleavened bread the disciples came to Yahushua, saying unto him, Where wilt thou that we prepare for thee to eat the passover?
Mat 26:18 And he said, Go into the city to such a man, and say unto him, The Master saith, My time is at hand; I will keep the passover at thy house with my disciples.
Mat 26:19 And the disciples did as Yahushua had appointed them; and they made ready the passover.
Mat 26:20 Now when the even was come, he sat down with the twelve.
Mat 26:21 And as they did eat, he said, Verily I say unto you, that one of you shall betray me
.

Mar 14:12 And the first day of unleavened bread, when they killed the passover, his disciples said unto him, Where wilt thou that we go and prepare that thou mayest eat the passover?
Mar 14:13 And he sendeth forth two of his disciples, and saith unto them, Go ye into the city, and there shall meet you a man bearing a pitcher of water: follow him.
Mar 14:14 And wheresoever he shall go in, say ye to the goodman of the house, The Master saith, Where is the guest chamber, where I shall eat the passover with my disciples?
Mar 14:15 And he will shew you a large upper room furnished and prepared: there make ready for us.
Mar 14:16 And his disciples went forth, and came into the city, and found as he had said unto them: and they made ready the passover.
Mar 14:17 And in the evening he cometh with the twelve.
Mar 14:18 And as they sat and did eat, Yahushua said, Verily I say unto you, One of you which eateth with me shall betray me
.

Luk 22:7  Then came the day of unleavened bread, when the passover must be killed.
Luk 22:8 And he sent Peter and John, saying, Go and prepare us the passover, that we may eat.
Luk 22:9 And they said unto him, Where wilt thou that we prepare?
Luk 22:10 And he said unto them, Behold, when ye are entered into the city, there shall a man meet you, bearing a pitcher of water; follow him into the house where he entereth in.
Luk 22:11 And ye shall say unto the goodman of the house, The Master saith unto thee, Where is the guest chamber, where I shall eat the passover with my disciples?
Luk 22:12 And he shall shew you a large upper room furnished: there make ready.
Luk 22:13 And they went, and found as he had said unto them: and they made ready the passover.
Luk 22:14 And when the hour was come, he sat down, and the twelve apostles with him.
Luk 22:15 And he said unto them, With desire I have desired to eat this passover with you before I suffer:
Luk 22:16 For I say unto you, I will not any more eat thereof, until it be fulfilled in the kingdom of YHWH.
Luk 22:17 And he took the cup, and gave thanks, and said, Take this, and divide it among yourselves:
Luk 22:18 For I say unto you, I will not drink of the fruit of the vine, until the kingdom of God shall come.
Luk 22:19 And he took bread, and gave thanks, and brake it, and gave unto them, saying, This is my body which is given for you: this do in remembrance of me.
Luk 22:20 Likewise also the cup after supper, saying, This cup is the new testament in my blood, which is shed for you
.

a) Matt 26:17, Mark 14:12, & Luke 22:8 each make reference to "preparing to eat the Passover".

In Matt 26:17, the Greek word translated as "prepare" is hetoimazo, G2090, ἑτοιμάζω. Strong's Concordance claims that it means "prepare". Mark 14:12 & Luke 22:8 use the same word. The Greek word, ετοιμασωμεν , is the form of G2090 in Matt 26:17, while ετοιμασατε , is used in Luke 22:8. While I do not understand these differences, I know they are grammatically different.

Q: What did they prepare ?
A: All three sources tell us "the Passover"

Q: What is the Passover ?
A: Strong's Concordance tells us that the Greek word translated as "Passover" is G3957. The concordance says it means the Passover (the meal, the day, the festival or the special sacrifices connected with it). In this context, it may mean the meal, the day, or the festival. Since we are told later in each chapter that they are eating a meal, clearly it means preparing for the meal.

VERDICT - I believe this is very strong scriptural evidence that the apostles intended to prepare for an actual Passover memorial meal.

b) Matt 26:19 & Mark 14:16 tell us that the disciples did as Yahushua had told  them - they made ready (prepared) the Passover. Again, the Greek word translated as "made ready" is the Greek word G2090.

Mat 26:19 And the disciples did as Jesus had appointed them; and they made ready the passover.

Mar 14:16  And his disciples went forth, and came into the city, and found as he had said unto them: and they made ready the passover
.

VERDICT - I believe this is strong scriptural evidence that they went, & prepared a Passover memorial  meal.

c) Matt 26:21 & Mark 14:22 each use the expression "as they did eat". G2068 is the Greek word translated as "did eat". Clearly they were eating a meal.

Mat 26:21 And as they did eat, he said, Verily I say unto you, that one of you shall betray me.

Mar 14:22  And as they did eat, Jesus took bread, and blessed, and brake it, and gave to them, and said, Take, eat: this is my body
.

Matt 26:2 1 & Mark 14:18 read "as they did eat". Clearly, "when even was come" translated from G3798, ὄψίος  op'-see-os, (meaning late, afternoon, evening or nightfall), refers to evening or nightfall since it is likely that they had begun preparing things (Matt 26:19, Mark 14:16 & Luke 22:8) at the start of the 14th of Aviv.

Q:  What did they eat ?
A: Since there are several references to the Passover, it must be the Passover meal - bread & the fruit of the vine are specifically mentioned.

VERDICT - I believe this is strong supporting evidence that they ate the Passover memorial meal.

2: There is not one scripture that says, or implies that the Passover was kept on the 15th Aviv. In fact, there are several scriptures that tell us that the Passover was kept on the 14th of Aviv (Num 9:5, Josh 5:10, & Ezra 6:19).

Num 9:5 And they kept the passover on the fourteenth day of the first month at even in the wilderness of Sinai: according to all that the LORD commanded Moses, so did the children of Israel.

Jos 5:10 And the children of Israel encamped in Gilgal, and kept the passover on the fourteenth day of the month at even in the plains of Jericho.

Ezr 6:19  And the children of the captivity kept the passover upon the fourteenth day of the first month
.

VERDICT - I believe this is strong implied evidence that they prepared, & then ate the Passover memorial meal.

3: There are several verses that state that the day the Passover lambs are killed is the day of Unleavened Bread. (Mark 14:1 tells us the Passover & Unleavened Bread are the same day;

Mar 14:1  After two days was the
 (feast of) the passover, and of unleavened bread: and the chief priests and the scribes sought how they might take him by craft, and put him to death.

Clearly, this cannot be saying that the "feast" of Unleavened Bread is the same as the day of Passover, since the 15th of Aviv is the "feast of unleavened Bread" (Lev 23:6). Note "feast of" is added, & isn't in the original manuscript.

Matt 26:17 tells us the first of unleavened bread was the day they asked about preparing the Passover; Mark 14:12 tells us that the first day of unleavened bread was when the Passover was killed; Luke 22:7 agrees). If you check Exod 12:18, I believe this also supports the idea that the 14th of Aviv, Passover, is the first day of unleavened bread.

VERDICT - I believe this is strong scriptural evidence that they day Yahushua & the apostles prepared, & ate the Passover memorial meal, & the day Yahushua was crucified, was the first day of Unleavened Bread.

4: Matt 26:28, Mark 14:24 & Luke 22:20 all use the expression "blood or cup of the new convenant which IS shed for many". Most, if not all translations use this present tense expression, "which IS shed", implying that Yahushua's blood is already shed. It is almost as if, as soon as Judas leaves, the process of Him dying begins, & so in just a few hours, in reality, His blood will begin to be literally shed.

VERDICT - I believe this is fairly strong scriptural evidence this the meal at which this phrase was spoken was the Passover meal (part of which was certainly a covenant confirming meal).

5:  Evidence from Mark 14:12-15

Mar 14:12  And the first day of unleavened bread, when they killed the passover, his disciples said unto him, Where wilt thou that we go and prepare that thou mayest eat the passover?
Mar 14:13 And he sendeth forth two of his disciples, and saith unto them, Go ye into the city, and there shall meet you a man bearing a pitcher of water: follow him.
Mar 14:14 And wheresoever he shall go in, say ye to the goodman of the house, The Master saith, Where is the guestchamber, where I shall eat the passover with my disciples?
Mar 14:15 And he will shew you a large upper room furnished and prepared: there make ready for us
.

Q: Why are we given the detail of the water carrier of verse 13 ?
A:  It could be telling us that he was an Essene, since only women, or slaves carried water at this time in Israel's history.

Q: What can we infer about the "goodman of the house" in verse 14 ?
A:  
1: "goodman of the house" simply means "head of the house"
2: He had the upper room "furnished & prepared" (verse 15)
3: He used the same calendar as Yahushua, since there is no mention of any other time
4: Since the water carrier may have been an Essene, so may the "goodman" have been an Essene

Q: If the upper room was furnished, & prepared (v15), what can we infer?
A:  The room had been cleared of "leaven", & set up for the apostles & Yahushua to use to celebrate a Passover meal.

Q: If this is so, what preparations, would the two disciples need to do so that Yahushua could "eat the Passover" (v12) ?
A:  Probably preparing the Passover lamb, & getting the other Passover meal materials (bitter herbs, unleaven bread, wine)

VERDICT - this is fairly strong to strong evidence that Yahushua used a different calendar to the Pharisees & Sadducees
- it is strong evidence to support the claim that Yahushua kept the biblical Passover, the night before He died.

6: Luke 22:15 tells us that Yahushua says that He "greatly" desires to eat this Passover with them BEFORE He suffers.

Luk 22:15 And He said to them, I have greatly desired that I eat this Passover with you before I suffer.

Q: What is the immediate context for Yahushua making this statement ?
A:  This statement is made after verse 13 where we are told that "they prepared the Passover".
Verse 14 tells us "when the hour came, He reclined, & the 12 apostles were with Him". Perhaps we can assume that this statement is the first recorded words Yahushua says to His apostles at the prepared Passover meal.

Q: Some claim that Yahushua, who died at 3pm on the 14th of Aviv, cannot have eaten a Passover meal on the evening before He died, when He in fact, is that Passover lamb. Is this claim supported by this verse ?
A:  While we can't be absolutely certain, this verse certainly indicates that Yahushua wants to eat this Passover meal with His apostles BEFORE He suffers. Even though, "it is not spelled out in words of one syllable", and even though verse 16 tells us that He will not eat it again until it is fulfilled in YHWH's kingdom, verses 17-20 give details of Yahushua sharing unleavened bread & wine with His apostles. Verse 19 tells us that Yahushua is keeping this as a memorial (possibly quoting Exod 12:14).

Q: If Luke 22:15 doesn't mean what it reads, what else could it mean ?
A: Yahushua is not a liar, so I take Him at what He says !

VERDICT - this verse is strong evidence that Yahushua ate a Passover meal.

Evidence that supports Scenario 2 - Yahushua is not eating a Passover meal

Those who believe that Yahushua did not eat a Passover meal have several reasons for believing this. These are :

1:   Proponents believe that, based on 1 Cor 5:7, Yahushua is the Passover lamb.

1Co 5:7  Purge out therefore the old leaven, that ye may be a new lump, as ye are unleavened. For even Messiah our passover is sacrificed for us
:

VERDICT - Even though, this is the only verse that I can find, that specifically points to Messiah Yahushua as "our Passover", I believe this is reasonable scriptural evidence.

2: Proponents believe that, based on Matt 27:46-50, Yahushua died at the ninth hour, namely, 3 pm, & claim that this ties in with a "between the evenings" understanding of 3 pm to sunset, the same time they claim the original Passover lambs were killed, on the 14th of Aviv.

VERDICT - I believe that, based on their understanding that, this is good scriptural evidence that implies that Yahushua was the Passover lamb.

3: Proponents also cite the following scriptures as evidence. They do this by claiming that the Greek word, G4413, can in this instance mean "before". They use Strong's explanation as evidence. Using this logic, they claim that these verses should read :

Matt 26:17 "before the first of unleavened bread, the disciples came to Jesus said unto him where wilt thou that we prepare for thee to eat the passover"          and
Mark 14:12 "before the first day of unleavened bread when they killed the passover, his disciples said unto him, where wilt thou that we go and prepare that thou mayest eat the passover"
.

For comparison, here are the KJV translations of these verses :

Mat 26:17 Now the first day (of the feast) of unleavened bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying unto him, Where wilt thou that we prepare for thee to eat the passover?

Mar 14:12  And the first day of unleavened bread, when they killed the passover, his disciples said unto him, Where wilt thou that we go and prepare that thou mayest eat the passover
?

The Greek word translated as "first" is G4413, protos. Strong's Concordance explains it as follows :

G4413     Strong's      πρῶτος                 prōtos
Contracted superlative of G4253; foremost (in time, place, order or importance): - before, beginning, best, chief (-est), first (of all), former.

G4253   Strong's     πρό             pro
A primary preposition; “fore”, that is, in front of, prior (figuratively superior) to. In compounds it retains the same significations: - above, ago, before, or ever. In compounds it retains the same significations.

VERDICT - I'm not sure this is supporting evidence for either scenario. If this preparation was done at the start of the 14th of Aviv, then the idea of "before" is irrelevant. Either way, it is implied evidence, not direct scriptural evidence

4: Proponents claim that "the preparation" referred to in these verses is simply the getting ready of everything for the Passover meal. This includes cleaning the house of leaven, getting all the food & other materials, and the taking care of the Passover lamb. They claim that the apostles are preparing things for a Passover meal at the start of the 15th of Aviv.

VERDICT
- I believe this is only implied evidence - its strength is fair.

5:  Proponents claim that the bread used at the "last super" was not unleavened bread, & so it could not have been a Passover meal. In Matt 26:26, we are told Yahushua took "bread". The claim is that when we examine this word, G740, using Strong's Concordance, we are told that it refers to "leavened" bread.

Mat 26:26  And as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and blessed it, and brake it, and gave it to the disciples, and said, Take, eat; this is my body
.

G740    Strong's           ἄρτος                artos
From G142; bread (as raised) or a loaf: - (shew-) bread, loaf.

G142    Strong's           αἴρω                  airō
A primary verb; to lift; by implication to take up or away; figuratively to raise (the voice), keep in suspense (the mind); specifically to sail away (that is, weigh anchor); by Hebraism (compare [H5375]) to expiate sin: - away with, bear (up), carry, lift up, loose, make to doubt, put away, remove, take (away, up).

VERDICT - While this evidence appears to be convincing, I believe this is poor supporting evidence. My latest research seems to indicate that there is no word for "unleavened bread", so the word G740 is used to indicate any bread at all. "Unleavened" is only ever used when referring to the "feast" of Unleavened Bread.

6: Proponents claim that it is unscriptural to eat the Passover meal before the Passover lamb is killed, and so it cannot have been the Passover meal.

VERDICT - I believe this is only fair supporting implied evidence.

7: Proponents claim that it can't be the Passover meal, since the disciples thought Judas was going to buy for the feast, quoting, John 13:29. They assert that it is against Torah to do so on a moed & chag (feast).

Joh 13:29  For some 
(of them) thought, because Judas had the bag, that Jesus had said unto him, Buy (those things) that we have need of against the feast; or, that he should give something to the poor.

One line of thought is that Passover is the night beginning the 14th, and the Feast of Unleavened Bread begins on the 15th. So, if Yahushua & the disciples were eating Passover the night of the 14th, it would have been possible for Judas to buy something for the Feast of Unleavened bread that would begin the following night.

VERDICT - I believe this is fairly strong supporting evidence against the scenario, which claims this is the first day of Unleavened Bread.

8: Some claim that Matthew was originally written in Hebrew, & then translated into Greek. They then argue that, if we are going to understand what Matthew really says, we must translate the Greek back into Hebrew, & analyse it from that perspective.

VERDICT - While I have often used this strategy, I'm not sure how anyone would do this, & I'm not sure this is evidence at all.

9: Others claim that there is no mention of 'the original exodus' in any of the gospels. In several places in the Tanach, we are told to remember the time the Israelites were set free from the slavery of Egypt.

VERDICT - I'm not sure that this is evidence that can be used for this discussion.

10: Proponents also claim that Yahushua & the apostles went out of the house after eating, an action that was forbidden for the original Passover (Exod 12:22).

VERDICT - I believe this is fair supporting evidence against scenario 1. My understanding of Exod 12:22 is that a command given there, was for that group of people, at that time.

11: I believe the most Jews kept the pharisaic Passover that is mentioned in John 18:28, & indirectly in John 19:31. The pharisaic method is :
(1) kill the Passover lambs at 3 pm on the 14th of Aviv,
(2) prepare the Passover lamb for the Passover meal (still on the 14th),
(3) eat it at the start of the 15th of Aviv.
Believers in scenario 2, use the preparation for the Passover idea (John 9:14) as evidence as well.

VERDICT - this seems like good evidence if the pharisaic method is correct.

12: Many quote Col 2:16-17, which they claim, is a statement  saying that the "moedim" of Lev 23, had been "shadow-pictures" of things to come. They argue that Yahushua has fulfilled the first three moedim, that is, He is the Passover lamb, He is the Unleavened Bread, and He is the First Fruits. Heb 10:1 gives us a similar.message.

Col 2:16  Let no man therefore judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of an holyday, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days:
Col 2:17 Which are a shadow of things to come; but the body is of Christ.

Heb 10:1  For the law having a shadow of good things to come, and not the very image of the things, can never with those sacrifices which they offered year by year continually make the comers thereunto perfect.
 

VERDICT - I believe this is fair evidence.

Problems with scenario 1 - Yahushua is eating a Passover meal

1:  Again, in point (5) in the evidence for scenario 2, we see in several scriptures such as Matt 26:26, the Greek word translated as "bread", is G740. Strong's Concordance tells us this word, artos, means bread or loaf. It comes from G142, airo, which means to lift, take up, raise, keep in suspense or sail away.

The claim is that when we examine this word, G740, using Strong's Concordance, we are told that it refers to "leavened" bread, & therefore, this meal cannot be a Passover meal.

Mat 26:26  And as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and blessed it, and brake it, and gave it to the disciples, and said, Take, eat; this is my body
.

Rebuttal :        
A careful search of the Renewed Covenant, will show that the only Greek word ever used for "bread" is artos, G740. The Greek word, azumos, G106, is translated as unleavened,  but "bread" is always added by the translators. "azumos" is only ever used when referring to the "feast" or "day" of unleavened bread. If artos refers only to leavened bread, & the road to Emmaus event of Luke 24:30 was during the 7 days of Unleavened Bread, why were Yahushua & the two disciples eating "bread", artos in the Greek?

Luk 24:30  And it came to pass, as he sat at meat with them, he took bread, (artosand blessed it, and brake, and gave to them
.

We also see artos being used as the Greek word for the "showbread" in the Temple, which was also unleavened bread. (Matt 12:3-4 & Heb 9:2).

Mat 12:3  But he said unto them, Have ye not read what David did, when he was an hungred, and they that were with him;
Mat 12:4 How he entered into the house of YHWH, and did eat the shewbread,  
(artos) which was not lawful for him to eat, neither for them which were with him, but only for the priests?

Heb 9:2  For there was a tabernacle made; the first, wherein was the candlestick, and the table, and the shewbread (artos); which is called the sanctuary
.

How do we know the showbread was unleavened? It is mentioned in a number of places including the Talmud, & by the Jewish Historian Josephus, but more importantly, it is mentioned in the Torah, in Exod 29:23.

Exo 29:23  And one loaf of bread, and one cake of oiled bread, and one wafer out of the basket of the unleavened bread that is before YHWH:

Therefore, any claim that the use of the word artos always refers to "leavened bread" is clearly an error - you cannot conclude that they ate leavened bread at the Last Supper. Clearly, this is not evidence against Scenario 1.

VERDICT - this claim is not evidence.

2: It is unscriptural to eat a Passover meal before the Passover lamb is killed.

Rebuttal : 
This may appear to be correct.

However, if we refer to Exod 12:14, we are told specifically, that Passover is to be kept as a "memorial", implying that we do not need to totally re-create the original scenario.

We also need to consider the following.

Matt 26:28, Mark 14:24 & Luke 22:20 all use the expression "blood or cup of the new convenant which IS shed for many". Most, if not all translations use this present tense expression, implying that Yahushua's blood is already shed. It is almost as if, as soon as Judas leaves, the process of Him dying begins, & so in just a few hours, in reality, His blood will begin to be shed.

VERDICT - I believe the original command has precedence over what men may have done. Is the timing of the killing of the Passover lambs a man-made decision ? Perhaps this idea has some worth !      

3: When we examine scriptures such as John 18:28, clearly they are referring to two passovers. Proponents of scenario 2, use this second passover as evidence that Yahushua's "last supper" was not a passover meal.

Joh 18:28  Then led they Jesus from Caiaphas unto the hall of judgment: and it was early; and they themselves went not into the judgment hall, lest they should be defiled; but that they might eat the passover
.

If we check John 6:4 & John 7:2, we notice that a reference to "passover a feast of the Jews", & "the Jews feast of Tabernacles", respectively. THis is strange because Lev 23:4 calls them, "the feasts of YHWH". They are not, "feasts of the Jews".

I believe because John is the only writer who uses this description, that these "feasts of the Jews" are actually, feasts that have been determined by the pharisaic Jews, as opposed to when the "feasts" of YHWH should be held. Why else would John describe them this way?

The time of day in this verse may have been 5 - 6 am on the 14th of Aviv. Clearly, this is referring to the eating of the Passover AFTER Yahushua is crucified. If Yahushua celebrated the Passover the night before, this is clearly a second Passover. This is the time, the modern day Jews keep their Passover today.

Rebuttal :        
Here no rebuttal is required since it seems clear that there were two Passovers being kept. The following sources support this.

Encyclopaedia Judaica on page 690 tells us that :
"The feast of Passover consists of two parts: The Passover ceremony and the Feast of Unleavened Bread. Originally both parts existed separately; but at the beginning of the Exile they were combined".

Eerdman's Dictionary of the Bible p.1076
"Before a.d. 70, the Jews followed Sadduccian reckoning which regulated the Temple services. Afterwards, the Pharisaic system became the norm. It is apparent in John 18:28, that the calendar kept by the Jewish leaders & the one used by Yahushua & His disciples were not the same, as Passover was celebrated on different days".

VERDICT - I believe that the scriptural evidence highlighting the "feasts of the Jews", rather than the feasts of YHWH, is extremely strong evidence to support scenario 1 - Yahushua ate a Passover meal.

4:  Earlier in this study, it is claimed that the meal eaten by Yahushua & His disciples can't be a Passover meal since the disciples thought Judas was going to buy for the feast, quoting, John 13:29. They claim it is against Torah to buy & sell so on a moed.

Joh 13:29  For some of them thought, because Judas had the bag, that Jesus had said unto him, Buy those things that we have need of against the feast; or, that he should give something to the poor
.

Rebuttal :
This needs to be considered further because I currently, believe that the first day of unleavened bread is the 14th of Aviv - the day of the Passover, when unleavened bread is eaten.

If I am mistaken, & the 14th of Aviv is not the first day of Unleavened Bread, then there is no problem with what the apostles thought Judas was doing.

VERDICT - this could be strong evidence for secenario 2.

5: John 13:1-2 clearly reads in the KJV, "before" the Passover - it uses G4253, pro. If this is so, then it was clearly before the feast of Passover that Yahushua ate a meal with his disciples and washed their feet, & therefore cannot be a passover meal.

Joh 13:1  Now before the feast of the passover, when Jesus knew that his hour was come that he should depart out of this world unto the Father, having loved his own which were in the world, he loved them unto the end.
Joh 13:2 And supper being ended, the devil having now put into the heart of Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, to betray him
;

G4253   Strong's           πρό         pro
A primary preposition; “fore”, that is, in front of, prior (figuratively superior) to. In compounds it retains the same significations: - above, ago, before, or ever. In compounds it retains the same significations.

Rebuttal :        
One possibility is that verse one is not connected with verse two. If we examine John 12:1, it speaks of "the Passover", while here, it definitely says "the feast of the Passover".

Joh 12:1  Then Jesus six days before the passover came to Bethany, where Lazarus was which had been dead, whom he raised from the dead
.

Q: Why are they different ?
A:   There must be a difference otherwise they would use the same phrase.
In John 13:2, the Greek word translated as "being ended" is G1096, ginomai. It can mean to become into being, to arise, be made, or possibly finished. A search of its use in e-Sword results in 456 verses where it is used. Only once out of 456 different translations is "being ended" used. Could this be that the translators do not really know what its meaning is here. Verse 26 tells us that Yahushua had not "ended" His meal since He "dipped the sop & gave it to Judas". The ABP+ Bible says John 13:2 reads, "and supper taking place", while the CJB reads "They were at supper". I believe these are more accurate translations.

VERDICT - It seems to me that the KJV+ translation is not completely accurate.

6: There no mention of the Passover lamb being eaten.

Yes, the word "lamb" is not mentioned explicitly, but it is implied. The Gospels tell us the disciples were "preparing the Passover", which implies they were preparing the lamb for Passover. So, when it says they went to prepare "the Passover", shouldn't this be understood that they were preparing the Passover lamb. The text even tells us it was on the day the Passover was supposed to be killed. (Luke 22:7-13)

So, on the day the Passover lamb is to be killed, Yahushua told His disciples to prepare the Passover so He can eat it with them.

Q:
What were they preparing?
A: They were preparing the Passover lamb for supper. Aren't we told in Mark 14:22-23, that "as they did eat" Yahushua took the bread and wine, so, what meal did they eat? Surely, they weren't only eating bread and wine, - they had a Passover meal, which would have included a lamb and bitter herbs. Why would the disciples say in Matt 26:17 " Where wilt thou that we prepare for thee to eat the passover?", if He really wasn't going to eat a Passover with them?

Mar 14:22 And as they did eat, Jesus took bread, and blessed, and brake it, and gave to them, and said, Take, eat: this is my body.
Mar 14:23 And he took the cup, and when he had given thanks, he gave it to them: and they all drank of it
.

Rebuttal : 
Perhaps there was no Passover lamb mentioned because the people reading these letters knew that the Passover lamb was so much a part of the Passover meal, that it was not necessary to mention it.

VERDICT - Perhaps this should be given some consideration.

7:  There is no mention of the exodus from Egypt

Rebuttal :        
Perhaps this is because the people reading these letters knew that the telling of the Exodus story is so much a part of a Passover meal, that it was not necessary to mention it.

VERDICT - Perhaps this should be given some consideration.

Problems with scenario 2 - Yahushua did not eat the Passover meal.

While I do not want to offend anyone, I do want to be honest, & I do want to examine all things, & I certainly want to find YHWH's truth.

Many people strongly believe that Yahushua the Messiah is the Passover lamb, & as such, must fulfill all the requirements of the original Passover lambs. This is their major focus.

My question then is, could it be possible that some of these folks have "flavoured" their interpretation of all the Passover scriptures, so that their strong belief in Yahushua as the Passover lamb will not be threatened ?

Please, please decide to have an open mind as you read on, so that we can find YHWH's truth about this matter.

1: While it cannot be denied that Yahushua the Messiah is referred to as our Passover in 1 Cor 5:7, I believe that His death was for several reasons including :
~ the sin of the world (John 1:29), Israel
~ the adulterous bride (to bring back the lost sheep of the house of Israel - note that Yahuhsua was sold for 30 pieces of silver - the price of a woman) (Matt 26:38-40 & Luke 22:41-43)
~ closely connected to this is the fact that Yahushua also died for all those who broke the Mt Sinai Covenant (Exod 32).
~ He died for the elder son (Judah), and others).
~ John 1:29 tells us He was the "lamb of Elohim", who takes away the sin of the world. This title is repeated in John 1:36. It seems to me that this is a reference to a "sin" offering - for the sins of the world.

Joh 1:29 The next day John seeth Jesus coming unto him, and saith, Behold the Lamb of YHWH, which taketh away the sin of the world.

Joh 1:36  And looking upon Jesus as he walked, he saith, Behold the Lamb of YHWH
!

The original Passover sacrifice was NOT a sin offering. Please note that in 1 Cor 5:7, Yahushua is referred to as our "Passover", not our Passover lamb  -  "lamb" is implied. Also note, that this is the only witness in Scripture that I can find which directly connects Yahushua as being the Passover lamb. There is no such connection the Tanach.

Q:   Don't Deut 17:6 & 19:15 tells us we need at least two witnesses to establish a matter, & that one witness isn't enough ?

Deu 17:6 At the mouth of two witnesses, or three witnesses, shall he that is worthy of death be put to death; but at the mouth of one witness he shall not be put to death.

Deu 19:15  One witness shall not rise up against a man for any iniquity, or for any sin, in any sin that he sinneth: at the mouth of two witnesses, or at the mouth of three witnesses, shall the matter be established
.

Q: Based on these two verses, how then can we use 1 Cor 5:7, one scriptural witness,  to claim that Yahushua is the Passover lamb ?
A:   If we do, we are going against Torah - so I believe, it must mean something else.

Isn't it true that, the context of this verse, based on the metaphor of "leaven", is about removing sin from our lives? Perhaps the statement that "Messiah our passover is sacrificed for us", is more evidence to support this idea. I am not sure!

At the same time, the statement about Yahushua dying for the sin of the world also has a problem, because Lev 4:14 tells us the sin offering for the congregation is a bullock, while Lev 4:27-28 tells us the sin offering for a person is a female goat.

Heb 9:11-28 compares the sacrifice of Yahushua's death & shedding of His blood,  with the sacrifices  offered by the high priest, according to the Torah of Moses. Verse 28 tells us Yahushua the Messiah was offered to bear the sins of many, so clearly, His death was a sin offering.

Rebuttal :        
The original Passover lamb was a shadow-picture of the Messiah. Both referred to the first-born son. The original Passover lamb's blood was used as a way of freeing the Hebrews from their slavery in Egypt. The blood of Yahushua the Messiah was used to free people from the penalty of their sins.

Again, while many claim, quoting  the principle of Deut 17:6, that we need at least two witnesses to establish a matter, from my study, 1 Cor 5:7, is the only specific reference to Yahushua being the Passover (lamb).

VERDICT - If the principle of Deut 17:6 is applied, this the strength of this evidence must be minimal.

2: I believe, & I have searched carefully, that there is no scripture in the Tanach that specifically connects the Messiah with the Passover lamb. To explain this further let's examine one scenario, and ask some questions.

Rebuttal :

Can we examine this idea by imagining that you were a Jew who lived in Israel, just before Yahushua was born.

Q: What would you know about Passover from the Tanach ?
A:   You have been told from your birth that the annual keeping of Passover was to remember how YHWH saved, & then delivered Israel on the 14th of Aviv from the bondage of slavery in Egypt. You would have observed the Passover & heard the story of Exodus 12 & 13 many times.

Q: What have you never heard, or read at home or at synogogue?
A:   You have never been told, or read that the Passover lamb that was slaughtered on the 14th of Aviv was to represent the Messiah. You were never told that this Passover lamb is a picture of the coming Messiah - a  representation of His death.

Q: Is the death of the Messiah mentioned in the Tanach ?
A:    It is "kind of" mentioned, but not in any specific or obvious words. It is shrouded in language that was not clear to most people. Ps 22 and Is 53 are the usual scriptures quoted by those who believe this scenario. Ps 22 doesn't mention a lamb at all, while Is 53:7 simply reads "he is brought as a lamb to the slaughter".

To illustrate this lack of understanding, let's recall the story of the Ethiopian eunich in Acts 8. He was reading Isaiah 53. When Phillip asked him if he understood what it meant, his answer was no !

Q:   Did the Jews of Yahushua's day have an expectation that the Messiah would come, & deliver them from the Romans ?
A:    Yes, I believe so. Acts 1:6 tells us the disciples asked Yahushua if He was going to restore the kingdom of Israel.

Act 1:6  When they therefore were come together, they asked of him, saying, Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel
?

Q: Do you think that if the Messiah was the Passover lamb, then it would be common knowledge ? Wouldn't it have been talked about by the rabbis ?
A:    I believe so.

Q: Did the Pharisees & scribes know that Yahushua claimed to be the Messiah?
A:    Yes. In Matt 26:63, the high priest asks Him straight out "whether thou be the Messiah, the son of Elohim ?". The high priest would not have asked him this, if Yahushua hadn't claimed to be the Messiah.  

Q:    If the Pharisees & scribes had known that the coming Messiah would be slain as the Passover lamb, would they have killed Messiah Yahushua on the 14th of Aviv ?
A:     No, in fact because they hated him, I believe that they would have done everything in their power to make sure that he WASN'T killed on the 14th of Aviv.

Q: Did the disciples of Yahushua ever ask him "we know that you are the Passover lamb who will be slain for the sins of the world on the 14th of the first month, so will it be this year ?".
A: No. They had no clue about this. They never thought that He would be betrayed, or killed, even though  He told them that He was going to be betrayed & be killed.

Q: John 1:1-11 refer to "the Word"& "the Light", as references to Messiah Yahushua. Verse 11 specifically tells us, that the Messiah came to His own people, and THEY didn't receive Him. Who were His own people ?
A: His own people were Israel, part of whom were the Jews of His time.

Q: Why didn't they receive Him ?
A: Some realised He was the Messiah, but because the Pharisees had "added to, & taken away" from YHWH's written Word, most didn't. I don't believe they knew He would be the Passover lamb because there is no scripture connecting the two concepts. As stated earlier, there is one verse (1 Cor 5:7), that directly refers to Yahushua the Messiah as the Passover (lamb).

Based on the above questions & answers, it seems very clear that the Jews of Yahushua's day saw no scriptural connection between the coming Messiah and Yahushua, as being the Passover lamb.

VERDICT - This is very strong evidence against the idea that the major purpose of Yahushua's death was as the Passover lamb. However, I am not sure how important this is, with relation to His eating or not eating the Passover meal.

3: Based on Exod 12:5, the original Passover lamb had to be a one year old male, without blemish.

Exo 12:5  Your lamb shall be without blemish, a male of the first year: ye shall take it out from the sheep, or from the goats
:

It had to be slaughtered "between the evenings", roasted by fire & eaten with unleavened bread & bitter herbs. Any not eaten Passover lamb, had to be burnt in the morning. The door-posts had to be sprinkled with the blood of the lamb.

Yahushua wasn't one year old, he was without blemish, but He certainly wasn't eaten, and He certainly was not burnt. If He was the Passover lamb, & we know several other of the original conditions were not met, (the door-posts had to be sprinkled with the blood of the lamb), why is the timing of the killing of the Passover lambs important. Again, Exod 12:14 tells us Passover is to be a memorial, not a re-enactment.

Rebuttal:
Again, the original Passover lamb was a shadow-picture of the Messiah. Both referred to the first-born son. The original Passover lamb's blood was used as a way of freeing the Hebrews from their slavery in Egypt. The blood of Yahushua the Messiah was used to free people from the penalty of their sins.

The other aspects of the original Passover (being eaten, burning the remains) are not as relevant here.

Q: If any subsequent celebrations of Passover were to be memorials, why is the so-called "precise" timing so important?
A: I have no answer.

VERDICT - The points made in 3, are relevant. This is strong evidence against the idea that the major purpose of Yahushua's death was as the Passover lamb. However, I am not sure how important this is, with regard to His eating, or not eating the Passover meal.

4: Proponents of scenario 2 claim that in some specific scriptures, such as Mark 14:12, words like G4413, protos, have been mistranslated. They claim it should read "before". My understanding of Greek is quite limited, but I have been told that Greek is a very precise language with very strict grammar rules. If this is so, why wouldn't the writer's of these texts have used a perfectly clear word such as G4253, pro, which means "in front of".

Mar 14:12  And the first day of unleavened bread, when they killed the passover, his disciples said unto him, Where wilt thou that we go and prepare that thou mayest eat the passover?
 

Rebuttal :

My logic tells me that this is a translation error - the KJV translation does not appear to match the other facts presented in the gospels of Matthew, Mark & Luke. However, I can't think of any reason why G4253, pro, wasn't used.

VERDICT - If I accept that this is a translation error, and accept that it should read "before the first day of Unleavened Bread/Passover", this evidence is irrelevant.

5: Proponents use the argument about "leavened bread" to support their belief. Clearly, the information provided for point 1 of Problems with Scenario 1 above applies here.

VERDICT  - This is no evidence at all.

6: The biggest problem with this scenario related to the many scriptures that refer to "preparing to eat the Passover", "the actual eating of a meal", and "the specific mention of Passover".

Rebuttal :
The usual explanation of these involves what is called a "rabbi's tish or tisch".

Wikipedia.com claims that a rabbi's tish was held the night before the real Passover meal - it was like a "practice" for the real thing. If this is so, eating "leavened" bread is not a problem, nor is "buying & selling". The preparation mentioned involves cleaning the house of leaven, obtaining all the materials needed, getting the Passover lamb ready. The "eating" is simply eating like an ordinary meal.

Questions for the Rebuttal 
Q: Why would a rabbi's tish be necessary since the only people who seem to be at the meal were the 12 apostles, & they would have had two previous Passovers with Yahushua?

Q: If this is a rabbi's tish, why isn't it specifically stated ?

Q: Why is there a constant reference to making ready, & eating "the Passover", if it was not a real "passover meal"?

Q:  Did any preparing occur at the start of the 14th of Aviv, such as cleaning the house of leaven ? If so, wouldn't it be difficult to do a good job when it is getting dark ?

Q: How do you explain away the 26 verses of Matt 26:17-21, Mark 14:12-18, and Luke 22:7-20, that specifically mention "passover", preparation for passover", & "eating passover"

VERDICT - I believe this is only fair evidence.

7: John 19:42 tells us that the day Yahushua died was preparation day for Passover. It seems very possible that some preparing took place during the daylight part of the 13th of Aviv, not on the 14th of  Aviv, the day He died.

Q: Doesn't this contradict the idea that the 14th of Aviv, the day of the Passover was the day of preparation ?
A: It does to my way of thinking. Don't Mark 15:42, Luke 23:54 each mention "preparation day" as it refers to the Sabbath? In John 19:14, it is in reference to the Passover.

Joh 19:42 There laid they Jesus therefore because of the Jews' preparation day; for the sepulchre was nigh at hand.

Mar 15:42 And now when the even was come, because it was the preparation, that is, the day before the sabbath,

Luk 23:54 And that day was the preparation, and the sabbath drew on
.

Q: Does this mean that the preparation of the Passover is the same as the preparation of the Sabbath, & is Passover also a Sabbath ?
A: Firstly, there is no specific mention of any preparation day in the Tanach. The only scripture that refers to "preparing" anything connected with the Passover is in Exod 16:5, where it specifically relates to preparing the manna on the sixth day.

Exo 16:5  And it shall come to pass, that on the sixth day they shall prepare that which they bring in; and it shall be twice as much as they gather daily
.

I believe that over time, this may have been expanded to include the whole of the day before a Sabbath - it became their tradition.

With regard to the stated question, it has been proposed that "preparation for the Passover", simply means preparing for the Passover meal (cleaning the house of leaven, roasting the Passover lamb, obtaining all the other materials), while preparation of the Sabbath means, doing all the things necessary so that there would be no work done on the Sabbath day itself.

Rebuttal :

At the moment, I have no rebuttal for the first part of 7. In terms of the second part of 7, again, I say that it is a tradition (a good tradition), which expanded the original statement in Exod 16:5. (It almost sounds like something from the oral Torah).

VERDICT - I believe this is reasonable evidence.

8: Both Col 2:17 states that the moedim (new moons & Sabbaths)  are "a shadow"  of things to come ! Since these were written after Yahushua had died, then these verses must be referring to a future time, not to the time Yahushua lived, died and was resurrected.

Col 2:17 Which are a shadow of things to come; but the body is of Christ.

Rebuttal : I don't have one

VERDICT : I'm not sure what this is evidence for.

Problems for scenarios 1 and 2.

1: How is it that the day of Unleavened Bread is the day the Passover is killed, as mentioned in Luke 22:7 ?

Luk 22:7  Then came the day of unleavened bread, when the passover must be killed
.

Response :

Possibilities

1: I believe that Exod 12:18 tells us that the first day of unleavened bread is the 14th of Aviv. The reason this is true is that, no matter how or when "at even", ba'erev, is determined, (whether at the beginning of the 14th day from sunset to dark, OR, from 3 pm until sunset), it is some part of the 14th day of Aviv, making it the first day of the 7 days of unleavened bread. Luke 22:7 simply confirms this.

Exo 12:18  In the first (month), on the fourteenth day of the month at even, ye shall eat unleavened bread, until the one and twentieth day of the month at even.

2: I have read (somewhere), that in Yahushua's time, the term "Passover", & "Unleavened Bread" were used synonymously. I cannot comment on whether this is true or not. But this appears to be something a little different. This is saying the "day of Unleavened Bread" (the 15th of Aviv - Lev 23:6) is the day the Passover lambs were killed.

In reference to Matt 26:17, Clarke comments :
"As the feast of unleavened bread did not begin till the day after the passover, the fifteenth day of the month, Lev_23:5, Lev_23:6; Num_28:16, Num_28:17, this could not have been, properly, the first day of that feast; but as the Jews began to eat unleavened bread on the fourteenth, Exo_12:18, this day was often termed the first of unleavened bread. The evangelists use it in this sense, and call even the paschal day by this name".

3:  In context, Luke 22:7 appears to be referring to the daytime portion of the 13th of Aviv. How can this be the day of Unleavened Bread and/or the day the Passover is killed ?

Response :

In the past, I have believed that the day the apostles asked Yahushua where He wanted the Passover meal to be prepared were the afternoon of the 13th of Aviv. Recently, I have re-examined this idea & decided that it is actually the start (sunset) of the 14th of Aviv. In doing this, several problems are resolved.

Evidence Summary

I have included the following "summaries" as a possible way to evaluate the evidences & problems. Please note that the values given are my estimates only.

Scenario 1 - Messiah Yahushua did eat a Passover Meal

1:  Matt 26:17-21, Mark 14:12-18, & Luke 22:7-20 each describe the preparation, & eating of the Passover
Very Strong Evidence        (9/10)

2:  Matt 26:19 & Mark 14:16 tells u that the disciples did as Yahushua had told them - they made ready (prepared) the Passover
Strong Evidence        (8/10)

3: Matt 26:21 & Mark 14:22 each use the expression "as they did eat". G2068 is the Greek word translated as "did eat". Clearly they were eating a meal.
Strong Evidence        (8/10)

4: There is not one scripture verse that says or implies that the Passover was kept on the 15th Aviv. In fact, there are several scriptures that tell us that the Passover was kept on the 14th of Aviv.
Very Strong Evidence        (9/10)

Problems Summary

ALeaven Bread was used
       Very Poor Evidence   (0/10)

B:  Unscriptural to eat a Passover meal BEFORE a Passover Lamb is killed
     Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

C: Two Passovers
     Very Poor Evidence     (0/10)  Very Strong evidence for Scenario 1

D: Perhaps Judas went to buy for the feast
    Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

E: John 13:1-2 appears to a meal eaten before the Passover day
    Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

F: No mention of a Passover lamb being eaten
     Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

G: No mention of the exodus from Egypt
     Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

Scenario 2 - Messiah Yahushua did not eat a Passover Meal

1: Yahushua was the Passover lamb of 1 Cor 5:7
     Fair Evidence     (5/10)

2: Yahushua died at the same time as the Passover lambs were killed
    Good Evidence     (7/10)

3: Some words mistranslated such as G4413
    Very Poor Evidence     (0/10)

4: Preparation means cleaning a house of leaven, getting food & materials ready, taking care of a Passover lamb
    Fair Evidence     (5/10)

5: Leavened Bread used
    Very Poor Evidence     (0/10)

6: Unscriptural to eat a Passover meal before the Passover lambs are killed
    Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

7: Perhaps Judas went to buy for the feast
    Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

8: because the gospel of Matthew was written in Hebrew, perhaps we should translate the Greek back into Hebrew
    Very Poor Evidence     (0/10)

9: No mention of the exodus from Egypt
    Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

10: Yahushua & the apostles left their house - prohibited for the original Passover
     Only Fair Evidence     (3/10)

Problems Summary

A: 1 Cor 5:7 tells us that Yahushua is the Passover lamb
     Only one witness (5/10)

B: No scripture that specifically connects the Messiah & the Passover Lamb
    Strong Evidence     (9/10)

C: Yahushua doesn't match several original Passover lamb features
     Good Evidence     (7/10)

D: Some words mistranslated such as G4413
     Very Poor Evidence     (0/10)

E: Leavened Bread used
      Very Poor Evidence     (0/10)

F: It was a rabbi's tish
    Only Fair Evidence     (5/10)

G: If preparation day is the 14th of Aviv, why did some preparation happen on the 13th of Aviv
     Only Fair Evidence     (4/10)

Concluding Thoughts

Backdrop

The Jews of Yahushua's day had been under the domination of the Romans for quite some time. Even though they may not have been slaves, they certainly felt oppressed by them & wanted them out of their land.

The Tanach promised Israel a Messiah, who would be their king (1 Sam 2:10), and who would reign on David's throne (1 Ch 17:12-13). He would come & save his people (Is 35:4). However, there was no specific scripture that claimed that he would be the Passover lamb.

Scenario 1 - Yahushua ate the Passover meal.

The case for scenario 1 relies heavily on scriptural evidence. The scriptural evidence provided by the Renewed Covenant, (Matt 26:17-21, Mark 14:12-18, & Luke 22:7-20) describing the events leading up to, and including the meal, is detailed and significant.

The scriptural evidence given to us in the Tanach (Exod 12 and especially Exod 12:14, Exod 23:14-15, & Deut 16:1-7) is quite clear, and explains how the Israelites were to keep the Passover. Exod 12:14, Lev 23:5 & several other verses, tell us that the Passover is to be kept or observed on the 14th of Aviv.

There does not appear to be any evidence that the events of scenario 1 contravened any of the Passover commands given in the Tanach (Exod 12, specifically verse 14, Lev 23:5, & Deut 16:1-7)

The arguments put forward to discredit scenario 1 are generally weak, & can usually be explained in a satisfactory manner.

Author's Comments

I have studied Passover several times & from different perspectives. I want to quickly re-state, & re-examine the key points that I had previously made, to see if they still apply.

1:   The meaning of "erev" and " beyn ha-erevim" are crucial to my understanding.  
~     beyn ha-erevim, "between the evenings" refers to a period of time, not a precise moment in time. In one context, it can possibly refer to a time between sunset & complete darkness (Exod 12:6), while in another context, it can possibly refer to a time before sunset (Exod 29:38-39).
~ erev, "evening" refers to a time when there is a "mixture" of light & "darkness" that is, when the daylight is plunging into night. In scripture, I believe it is mostly defining the moment immediately after the sun sets - when the sun falls completely below the horizon (Deut 16:6). Possibly, it can refer to a time before sunset.
Conclusion - context is therefore vital to my understanding !

2: The scenario for the original Passover, & Yahushua's Passover which seems to best fit with all the scriptures, is for beyn ha-erevim to mean between sunset & complete darkness.

3: If beyn ha-erevim means something else, then the following problems need to be explained or ignored :
~ why would slaves be given time off from their work to slaughter their Passover lamb at 3pm ?
(Exod 1:14 tells us the Hebrew's lives were made bitter with hard bondage [work])
~ when did the Hebrews get from where they lived in Goshen (Exod 8:22) to Rameses (Exod 12:37 & Num 33:3) ?
~ why would the writers of the Renewed Covenant give some many verses that specifically relate to a Passover meal (Matt 26:17-21, Mark 14:12-18, & Luke 22:7-20), if it was not really a Passover meal ?

Scenario 2 - Yahushua did not eat the Passover meal.

The case for scenario 2 relies heavily on circumstantial evidence. It's key premise is 1 Cor 5:7, which tells us that Yahushua is our Passover. Scenario 2 uses the logic that, if Yahushua was the Passover "lamb", then He had to die at the same time as the Passover lambs were being killed, that is, at about 3 pm on the afternoon of the 14th of Aviv (Mark 15:34 & Luke 23:44-46). This by-the-way relies heavily on the belief that, beyn ha-erevim, "between the evenings", must mean "3 pm to sunset".

The logic continues - if the Passover lambs were killed at 3 pm on the afternoon of the 14th of Aviv, then the meal on the evening before, at the start of the 14th, could not have been the Passover meal, since it is unscriptural to eat the Passover lamb before it is killed.

If this is true, they reason that this logic must also apply to the original Passover. Since the Passover lambs of Yahushua's day were killed at 3 pm, then the original Passover lambs must also have been killed at 3 pm.

Therefore, beyn ha-erevim must mean from midday until sunset (despite the fact that this time violates the original meaning of the word, erev, & implies that the original Israelite slaves were dismissed from their work during the afternoon of the 14th of Aviv).

This case also presents the following evidence. It claims :
1: some Greek words are mistranslated, for example, G4413,
2: the meaning of "prepare" in Matt 26:17, Mark 14:12, & Luke 22:8 refers to a variety of tasks, including cleaning the house of leaven, obtaining all the food & other materials & taking care of the lamb to be slaughtered. It does not only just refer to the preparations for the meal,
3: the Greek word for bread means only "leavened" bread,
4: there is no mention of the original exodus,
5: there is no mention that any Passover lamb was eaten at the meal, and
6: the actual meal being eaten was a rabbi's tish, not a Passover meal.

The arguments put forward to discredit scenario 2 are much more solid than those against scenario 1. For example, the fact that there is no specific scripture connecting the Messiah with the Passover lamb is very significant.

The reality that Yahushua did not have at least two of the characteristics of the original Passover lamb (He was not one year old, & wasn't burnt) is also important. The argument of the rabbi's tish, explaining away many specific verses of scripture is interesting, but is very circumstantial. If it is true, we must ignore 26 verses of scripture (Matt 26:17-21, Mark 14:12-18 & Luke 22:7-9) that directly mention a "Passover meal". The statement about the "leavened" bread is incorrect.

The logic explained above is based on the idea that Yahushua died mainly as our Passover lamb, & as the "first-born" of the Father delivers us from the slavery of our sins, in the same way the original Passover lamb indirectly delivered Israel from their physical slavery. Note again - the Passover lamb was not a sin-offering !

Scenario 2 seems to ignore the fact that, the main stated purpose of Yahushua's life was to die for the sin of the world (John 1:29, 36, Heb 9:28), & to die so that the penalty of that sin would be covered for all people.
The other evidence presented in (1)-(6), again, is largely circumstantial. To my way of thinking, scriptural evidence far out-weighs circumstantial evidence.

The arguments against scenario 2 are to my mind, quite significant.

Author's Conclusion

Based on the evidence presented for both scenarios, I must conclude that Yahushua did eat the Passover meal at the start of the 14th of Aviv.




Recently, I looked at the subject of FORGIVENESS, & even though I thought I knew a lot about it, I discovered that there were very important aspects of it that I hadn’t seen before.

May I share them with you now ?

Before I begin, I'd like to acknowledge the work of Rabbi Steve Berkson, of Messianic Torah Observant Israel for his videos on this subject. You can access these videos at   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIyIlt1JXKo&t=87s

While I agree with many of Rabbi Steve's ideas, I do not agree with them all, & as usual, I strongly encourage the reader, who wishes to view his, or any other person's videos, to TEST what is being said, before, taking any information into their belief system.

As we live our lives, I believe that we experience three different relationships - with ourselves, with others, & with YHWH.

During our lives, sometimes we are offended. We get upset, & suffer hurt & pain, when someone else, “trespasses” against us. At that time, we were made to feel embarrassment, & ashamed, we felt rejected, & of less worth. The degree of that hurt & pain, varied from horrific to just being upset.

WHAT IS TRESPASSING ?

The “trespassing” that caused the offense, happened when someone infringed, overstepped, or crossed a boundary that we have, without permission. Sometimes the “trespassing” was deliberate, while at other times it was unintentional, & done in complete ignorance. In actual fact, the trespassing can be real, or perceived, but either way, unpleasant, negative emotions are experienced.

When we have been offended by someone trespassing against us, don’t we have two choices – don’t we always have choices ? We can choose to forgive the trespass, or we can choose not to forgive it.

WHAT IS FORGIVENESS ?

Forgiveness is something you do, when someone has trespassed against you.

It is a releasing of all resentments against the one who trespassed against you, & letting go of the desire to punish them for doing it.

It is excusing a person for a fault, or to overlook an offense.

Forgiveness is necessary for you to be “healed”, so that you can move forward.
When you forgive, you personally pardon the offense, & the offender, & you release them from further punishment or debt – this happens from your point of view. This does not involve them.

That doesn’t mean you are releasing them from YHWH’s decision to punish them.

The first thing we need to realise is that “forgiveness, or unforgiveness affects you”, not the offender. When you forgive, you release hurt, anger, & negative emotions. Your forgiveness doesn’t have anything to do with what the other person does.


Forgiveness starts with deciding to let go of the situation, releasing it, & then saying, “I forgive you” (within yourself, & not personally to the offender).

All “trespasses” must be forgiven, by everyone, always ! If you don’t “forgive”, it WILL hurt YOU.

When you deal with forgiveness, you stop the hurt & pain, & the negative emotions, that resulted from you being offended by someone trespassing against you – it will stop the offense from affecting your future.
 
Forgiveness is essential for your present, & future peace ! We must forgive, if we really want to be free !

Letting go of the negative emotion, that was stimulated by the trespass, through forgiveness, has the benefit that it no longer damages, infringes, or impedes your forward progress through life. It won’t affect your future relationships.

By the way, the “letting go” will involve some kind of grief – if it was a very serious trespass, the grieving will take longer, & you could need counselling.

So, when we forgive the person who has trespassed against us, we experience three on-going, extremely important benefits :

1: on-going peace,
2: the ability to have healthy, present & future relationships, and
3: freedom

Most people don’t realise it, but if you don’t deal with forgiveness, it will “leak” into your future life by “popping up” at the most inopportune moment, & it never goes away.

By the way, the “popping up” doesn’t have to be with the same person – it can happen with a person who demonstrates similar behaviours to the original person who trespassed against you. Because you didn’t deal with it by “forgiving”, the ugliness can “pop” back up, at any time.

The “popping up” problems include, ongoing negative emotions, lack of on-going peace, & freedom, explained & unexplained resentments, & destructive relationships – all of these lead to depression. When I am in a negative emotional state as a result of someone trespassing against me, I am unable to understand what true justice is.

When you objectively think about the benefits of “forgiving” a trespass, compared to the on-going problems associated with “unforgiveness”, isn’t it a “no-brainer” decision, as to what will be your choice ?

By the way, forgiving someone for their trespassing, does not mean that you “forget” what happened, so that you are now vulnerable to it happening again. It is very important that you have the “information” about what happened, without hanging on to the negative emotions. That way, if at any time in the future, something happens that looks “a little similar to the original situation”, it will alert you to be on your guard, so that you can recognise that it was a problem in the past.

Again, forgiveness is something we must all do, every time there has been a trespass, & remember, there is nothing anyone can do to you, that you can’t forgive !

WHAT CAN HAPPEN ONCE YOU HAVE FORGIVEN A TRESPASS !

Another point we need to realise is that, forgiveness doesn’t include reconciliation. Forgiveness however, is absolutely essential, IF, “we desire” any of the future possible steps of resolution, reconciliation, & restoration.

RESOLUTION

Often you may desire reconciliation, & restoration, but each situation will depend on you, & the other person working together towards a mutual agreed resolution. Resolution is a firm decision between you & the offender, to do or not do something, but it can only happen, AFTER forgiveness. Resolution settles the trespass.

Resolution involves a relationship change, because “I want the offender to stop trespassing against me, & acting in a more appropriate way”.

REPENTANCE

Repentance is part of the resolution process. When I repent, I ask for forgiveness – I say that I want to make it right – I say I wish had never done it, & that I would reverse it if I can !


Repentance is apologising by sincerely saying, “I did it, & I am sorry for doing it”. By sincerely apologising, you express genuine remorse, regret & ownership for doing what you did.

When repenting, you might say something like, “I really wish I hadn't done it, and if I could go back and undo it I would, but I can't – I will make every effort to fix the damage that I caused – I will never ever do it again.

When you add forgiveness, & resolution together, it provides a platform potentially for reconciliation & restoration. If a situation has been forgiven, & the necessary compensation & resolution is made, then & only then, can there be reconciliation and/or restoration.

Forgiveness, & resolution need to happen, but they begin with just ourselves.

Reconciliation

You may desire reconciliation, & restoration, but again, each will depend on you & the other person working together towards a mutual agreed resolution.

Forgiveness, reconciliation, & restoration are three separate steps.


Reconciliation is the situation in which two people restore, or recreate a previous relationship that was damaged by one person’s trespass – it is the end of any estrangement.

Again, reconciliation can only result after forgiveness & restoration have happened – it is a process.

Reconciliation is optional – it can be a new relationship, especially if the previous relationship was a bad one – it can result from a desired relationship for both. If the “offending” relationship was horrible, you may never, ever want to reconcile with the one who trespassed against you, & that is OK !

Resolution & reconciliation can only come through a repentance process ! This must start with again, owning what you did; genuinely regretting it – there must be emotional, from the heart regret – with tears type apology

Very few people who are approached in this way, can refuse such an apology.

If I trespass against you, & I wish to reconcile with you, you will want a repentance type process to happen. Again, you’ll want to know that I am sorry for what I did, that I plan never to do it again with all the effort I can muster - you're going to want to know that I wish I could undo it if I could - you're going to want to know all of that as far as being able to reconcile, but none of it is necessary for forgiveness.

A very important point is that each person must have the ability to communicate precisely what each one needs for the reconciliation to happen. If you want to be reconciled, you must figure out what you need to resolve the trespass.

Examples

What you did made me feel unsafe. Well, what do you need to make you feel safe ?

Well what you did made me feel insecure. Well what do you need so that you will feel secure ?

Reconciliation isn’t evidence of forgiveness – people have reconciled, but haven’t forgiven the other.

The steps of resolution, reconciliation & restoration are freely available, but none of them can happen until you do step 1, forgiveness.


By the way, again, a consequence of the trespass may be that there is no reconciliation !

Restoration is optional, AFTER forgiveness – it is the action of returning something to a former place or condition. If the previous relationship wasn’t good, then restoration isn’t what you are looking for.

Unless you want to experience all the disadvantages that unforgiveness brings, ALL trespasses must be forgiven, no matter what the other person does.

Forgiveness needs to be done by everyone, all the time. It doesn’t have any requirement beyond “you”.

One Last Thought

Have you or someone dear to you, ever suffered from mental illness and/or depression ? Could it be that one factor that significantly contributes to that mental illness and/or depression is “unforgiveness” ? I strongly believe it is !

WELCOME

Elsewhere on this website, there is a study called, "The Journey", where I provided details of where you might be in your "spiritual" walk.

In this study, which was originally put together by Rabbi Rob Miller, I want to attempt to explain details about "who you really are", in other words, your "IDENTITY".

Before we get started with it, there are a few things I think we need to go over to make your learning experience the most enlightening it can be.

By now I am sure that you will have noticed that again, in place of the word “GOD” or “LORD”, I have used the personal proper name of our Heavenly Father – Yahweh , יהוה (read from right to left). Known as the Tetragrammaton, meaning “four letters,” His Name is represented by our English YHWH, which I frequently use. Transliterating the Creator’s Name into English, I believe that you would pronounce it properly as YahOOOeh, or “Yahweh.” It was the only name used prior to 800 BCE.

The Name “Yahweh” has been known for over 5700 years, & is written 6,823 times in the so-called Old Testament alone.

Again, in the place of the word “God”, I use the proper Hebrew word “Elohim,” plural form of the word Eloah, understood to denote the single deity of Israel. We know this because singular verbs and adjectives are used in the Hebrew text when the particular meaning of the deity of Israel (a singular) is intended.

In Exod 3:15, we have :

Elohim also said to Moses, ‘Say to the Israelites, “Yahweh, the Elohim of your fathersthe Elohim of Abraham, the Elohim of Isaac and the Elohim of Jacob—has sent me to you.” This is my name forever, the name by which I am to be remembered from generation to generation.’”

Likewise, speaking about Yahweh’s only begotten son, I use the Hebrew name ישׁועת “Yahushua”, instead of the name “Jesus.” The Name Yahushua means, “Yahweh is salvation.” When translating the Messiah’s name into English, instead of Jesus, it should have been Joshua.

Matt 1:21 should read :
“She will give birth to a son, and you are to give him the name Yahushua, because he will save his people from their sins.


This practice will assist in liberating you from deep-seated bias, as well as allowing you to view the Sacred Scriptures as a Hebrew book, not a Western book.

In this study, I will be providing many original slides that Rabbi Miller prepared for his presentation, "Mistaken Identity", together with comments & questions that I will add. May I please ask you, the reader, to carefully read the important details provided in those slides.


Q: I wonder how many of you can identify a life point in time when your life changed?
A: This message changed my life! When I found out who I was, it totally changed everything for me!


Do you feel like this ?

Or perhaps you feel like this ?



I know many people are unaware of it, but we are really in a CRISIS!


Doesn't the fact that this book is such a best seller, that at least 38 million people :

~ have no idea what their purpose in life is ?

~ who they are ?

~ where they are going ?

Q: Would you agree that it is very important to :

1: know who you are . . . THEN,

2: Learn what your mission is  . . . THEN,

You'll be able to read the signs !


WHO do you say ISRAEL is Today ?

  • The JEWS
  • A Trouble Maker in the Middle East
  • Jacob of the Tanach (OT)
  • The Church
  • The Christians

Common Beliefs :

1: The JEWS are the CHOSEN PEOPLE of the Scriptures

2: The Torah (law) was given to the JEWS

3: The feasts in the Tanach (OT) that Messiah Yahushua, & His DISCIPLES kept, were JEWISH feasts

Do you know that BEHIND every myth is the TRUTH waiting to be told ?



Q
: How many Tribes were at Mount Sinai to receive the Torah (law)?
A: ALL 12 tribes, & the mixed multitudes

Q: How many Tribes were JEWISH ?
A: One Tribe - Judah

The Twelve Tribes of ISRAEL

Manasseh                      Asher

Naphtali                          Zebulun

Issachar                          Gad

Ephraim                           Dan

Benjamin                         Reubin

Simeon                            Judah

Don't we know where JUDAH (the JEWS) is now ?

WHERE are all the other Tribes ?

Recently, the world has been caught up in a story of a mystical bloodline, & how this affects world history & religion.

The assertions of these authors are erroneous at the least, & heretical at its worst.


There is however, a sacred bloodline that is flowing through the veins of most people today - the ABRAHAMIC Bloodline.


This I believe, is the greatest "cover-up" in human history !

The following blessings are promised to Abram, (later Abraham), by YHWH - it is later called the ABRAHAMIC Covenant.

Gen 12:2  And I will make of thee a great nation, and I will bless thee, and make thy name great; and thou shalt be a blessing:
Gen 12:3 And I will bless them that bless thee, and curse him that curseth thee: and in thee shall all families of the earth be blessed
.


To actualise the Abrahamic Covenant in Abram's mind, YHWH creates a ceremony recorded in Gen 15 to indicate this promise covenant.

YHWH commanded Abram to divide animals into two pieces. Then YHWH causes a smoking furnace & a burning lamp, to pass between the pieces, binding the covenant.


If we apply this information to Gen 12:2-3, it would read as follows :

Gen 12:2  And I (YHWH) will make of thee (Abram) a great nation, and I will bless thee, and make thy name great; and thou shalt be a blessing:
Gen 12:3 And I will bless them that bless thee, and curse him that curseth thee: and in thee shall all families of the earth be mixed or grafted in
.

Gen 28:14 will also read as follows :

Gen 28:14  And thy seed shall be as the dust of the earth, and thou shalt spread abroad to the west, and to the east, and to the north, and to the south: and in thee and in thy seed shall all the families of the earth be mixed or grafted in












S T A R S


So by the END of DAYS, the majority of the people on Earth will be
ABRAHAM's SEED !





Rom 3:1-2 “What advantage, then, is there in being a Jew, or what value is there in circumcision? Much in every way
!

Primarily, the Jews have been entrusted with the very words of Yahweh (Torah).

Rom 3:3-4 What if some 
(of Israel) were unfaithful? Will their unfaithfulness nullify the Faith of Yahweh? Not at all! Let Yahweh be true, and every human being a liar.

Joh 4:19  The woman (acting like a Gentile) saith unto him, Sir, I perceive that thou art a prophet.
Joh 4:20 Our fathers (10 Northern tribes) worshipped in this mountain (Mount of Blessing) ; and ye say, that in Jerusalem is the place where men ought to worship (at the Temple)..
Joh 4:21 Yahushua saith unto her, Woman, believe me, the hour cometh, when ye shall neither in this mountain, nor yet at Jerusalem, worship the Father.
Joh 4:22 Ye worship ye know not what: we know what we worship: 
for salvation is of the Jews.
Joh 4:23 But the hour cometh, and now is, when the true worshippers shall worship the Father in spirit and in 
Truth: for the Father seeketh such to worship him.
Joh 4:24 God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in 
Truth.

Have you ever examined the following several scriptural verses that tell us about YHWH's TRUTH ? I encourage you to ponder them very carefully.

Joh 14:6 Yahushua saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.

Psa 119:142 
(YHWH) Thy righteousness is an everlasting righteousness, and thy Torah (law) is the truth.

Psa 119:160
 (YHWH) Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth for ever.

Joh 17:17 Sanctify them through thy truth
: (YHWH) thy word is truth.

Psa 33:4 For the word of YHWH is right; and all his works are done in truth.

Psa 119:151 Thou art near, YHWH; and all thy 
(YHWH) commandments are truth.


Jacob Blesses Joseph : Ephraim & Manasseh

Gen 48:19  And his father refused, and said, I know it, my son, I know it: he also shall become a people, and he also shall be great: but truly his younger brother (Ephraim) shall be greater than he (Manasseh), and his seed shall become a multitude of nations.



Q: Did you notice the sequence of blessings ?
A:  It went from Abraham to Isaac to Jacob to Ephraim

Ephraim, who carried the double portion blessing of the HOUSE of ISRAEL, was to be a MULTITUDE of NATIONS - a bunch of out-of-covenant people !


In Gen 47, we are told that Jacob's family moved from Canaan (the Promised Land), & settled in Egypt.



In 1 Cor 10:1-4, Paul adds his perspective :

1Co 10:1  Moreover, brethren, I would not that ye should be ignorant, how that all our fathers were under the cloud, and all passed through the sea;
1Co 10:2 And were all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea;
1Co 10:3 And did all eat the same spiritual meat;
1Co 10:4 And did all drink the same spiritual drink: for they drank of that spiritual Rock that followed them: and that Rock was Messiah
.


YHWH took Jacob's family from Canaan (the Promised Land) to Egypt, & then back to the Promised Land.

Isn't it true that, since we were children many of us have been taught that the Old Testament was OLD, and the New Testament was NEW!

It plants in our minds that the so-called Old Testament doesn’t have any value!

Are you aware that about 78% of the so-called Old Testament hasn’t even happened yet - so how can it be OLD?

I believe that there are over 500 verses of the so-called New Testament, that quoted from the so-called Old Testament - so how can it be NEW?

All the stories, whether it be Adam & Chavah (Eve) leaving the Garden, or Israel leaving the Promise Land, are always about, GOOD versus EVIL. It’s the same STORY RESTORATION!!!!!

If you put on your "Prophesy" hat, then :


So, what do you think might be the Most AMAZING Prophesy ?

Let me explain.

Standing at the Jordan River, YHWH says through Moses to Israel in Deut 28:15 & 64 :

“…if you do not obey Yahweh your Elohim and do not carefully follow all His commands and decrees I am giving you today, all these curses will come on you and overtake you…Then Yahweh will scatter you among all nations, from one end of the earth to the other. There you will worship other gods—gods of wood and stone, which neither you nor your ancestors have known.


Did you get it ?

If we do not obey YHWH, & carefully follow ALL His commands & decrees, THEN, He will scatter us among the nations !

In Deut 29:1, 14-15, & 30:1-3, YHWH made this COVENANT - please read it carefully.

These are the terms of the covenant Yahweh commanded Moses to make with the Israelites in Moab, in addition to the covenant He had made with them at Horeb… I am making this covenant, with its oath, not only with you who are standing here with us today in the presence of Yahweh our Elohim but also with those who are not here today… When all these blessings and curses I have set before you come on you and you take them to heart wherever Yahweh your Elohim disperses you among the nations,  and when you and your children return to Yahweh your Elohim and obey Him with all your heart and with all your soul according to everything I command you today, then Yahweh your Elohim will restore your inheritance and have compassion on you and gather you again from all the nations where He scattered you.

Did you see it - YHWH promised with an oath, that He will "gather" Israel from all the nations where He scattered them !

Let's go through some history.

In the book of Judges, we have a time when "Judges" oversaw Israel.

In Jud 17:6, we are told :

In those days there was no king in Israel, but every man did that which was right in his own eyes.”

Then, we have the time of the Kings - Saul, David & Solomon.

1 Sam 8:4-5 reads :

So all the elders of Israel gathered together and came to Samuel at Ramah. They said to him, ‘You are old, and your sons do not follow your ways; now appoint a king to lead us, such as all the other nations have.

Saul, David & Solomon governed the 12 Tribes of Israel UNTIL ....



1 Kings 11:34-39 provides more details

I will not take the whole kingdom out of Solomon’s hand; I have made him ruler all the days of his life for the sake of David my servant, whom I chose and who obeyed my commands and decrees. I will take the kingdom from his son’s hands and give you ten tribes. I will give one tribe (Judah) to his son (Rehoboam) so that David my servant may always have a lamp before me in Jerusalem, the city where I chose to put my Name. However, as for you, I will take you, and you will rule over all that your heart desires; you will be king over Israel. If you do whatever I command you and walk in obedience to me and do what is right in my eyes by obeying my decrees and commands, as David my servant did, I will be with you. I will build you a dynasty as enduring as the one I built for David and will give Israel to you. I will humble David’s descendants because of this, but not forever.’”

Why did YHWH say this ?

1Ki 11:33  Because that they have forsaken me, and have worshipped Ashtoreth the goddess of the Zidonians, Chemosh the god of the Moabites, and Milcom the god of the children of Ammon, and have not walked in my ways, to do (that which) is right in mine eyes, and to (keep) my statutes and my judgments, as (did) David his father
.




The Ultimate SIN

Exod 20:3, 5 You shall have no other gods before Me… for I Yahweh your Elohim, am a jealous Elohim…

The Kingdom of ISRAEL

1Ki 12:16  So when all Israel saw that the king hearkened not unto them, the people answered the king, saying, What portion have we in David? neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse: to your tents, O Israel: now see to thine own house, David. So Israel departed unto their tents
.

Then the UNION is DISSOLVED !

What was the Sin of JEROBOAM ?

2 Kings 17:21 tells us that "Jeroboam enticed Israel away from following Yahweh and caused them to commit a great sin, while 2 Chron 11:15 says, “…he appointed for himself priests for the high places, for the demons, and the calf idols which he had made.




Do we know WHO many of the Gentiles are ??



Again in Deut 29:1, 14-15, & 30:1-3, YHWH made this COVENANT - please read it carefully.

These are the terms of the covenant Yahweh commanded Moses to make with the Israelites in Moab, in addition to the covenant He had made with them at Horeb… I am making this covenant, with its oath, not only with you who are standing here with us today in the presence of Yahweh our Elohim but also with those who are not here today… When all these blessings and curses I have set before you come on you and you take them to heart wherever Yahweh your Elohim disperses you among the nations,  and when you and your children return to Yahweh your Elohim and obey Him with all your heart and with all your soul according to everything I command you today, then Yahweh your Elohim will restore your inheritance and have compassion on you and gather you again from all the nations where He scattered you.

YHWH promised with an oath, that He will "gather" Israel from all the nations where He scattered them, when the children of Israel return to YHWH !

In Jer 31:31 to 34, we have the "new", or "renewed" covenant, that was promised AFTER the northern & southern kingdoms, rebelled against the Mt Sinai covenant, & the Moab covenant.

Jer 31:31  Behold, the days come, saith YHWH, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah:
Jer 31:32 Not according to the covenant that I made with their fathers in the day that I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt; which my covenant they brake, although I was an husband unto them, saith YHWH:

Jer 31:33 But this shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel; After those days, saith YHWH, I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts; and will be their Elohim, and they shall be my people.
Jer 31:34 And they shall teach no more every man his neighbour, and every man his brother, saying, Know YHWH: for they shall all know me, from the least of them unto the greatest of them, saith YHWH: for I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more
.

Note what Ezek 37:15-23 tell us :

Eze 37:15 The word of YHWH came again unto me, saying,
Eze 37:16 Moreover, thou son of man, take thee one stick, and write upon it, For Judah, and for the children of Israel his companions: then take another stick, and write upon it, For Joseph, the stick of Ephraim, and for all the house of Israel his companions:
Eze 37:17 And join them one to another into one stick; and they shall become one in thine hand.
Eze 37:18 And when the children of thy people shall speak unto thee, saying, Wilt thou not shew us what thou meanest by these?
Eze 37:19 Say unto them, Thus saith YHWH your Elohim; Behold, I will take the stick of Joseph, which is in the hand of Ephraim, and the tribes of Israel his fellows, and will put them with him, even with the stick of Judah, and make them one stick, and they shall be one in mine hand.
Eze 37:20 And the sticks whereon thou writest shall be in thine hand before their eyes.
Eze 37:21 And say unto them, Thus saith YHWH your Elohim; Behold, I will take the children of Israel from among the heathen, whither they be gone, and will gather them on every side, and bring them into their own land:
Eze 37:22 And I will make them one nation in the land upon the mountains of Israel; and one king shall be king to them all: and they shall be no more two nations, neither shall they be divided into two kingdoms any more at all:
Eze 37:23 Neither shall they defile themselves any more with their idols, nor with their detestable things, nor with any of their transgressions: but I will save them out of all their dwelling places, wherein they have sinned, and will cleanse them: so shall they be my people, and I will be their Elohim
.

We are told in Eph 2:14-18 :

For [Messiah] Himself is our peace, who has made the two groups one and has destroyed the barrier, the dividing wall, by removing in his flesh the hostility for the Torah, with its commands and regulations. His purpose was to create in himself one new humanity (the Commonwealth of Israel – the Kingdom of Yahweh) out of the two (Israel & Judah) , thus making peace, and in one body to reconcile both of them to Yahweh through the gallows, by which He put to death their hostility. He came and preached peace to you who were far away (Diaspora)  and peace to those who were near (in Judea). For through Him we both have access to the Father by one Spirit.

Luke 19:9-10 tell us :

Yahushua said to him, ‘Today salvation has come to this house, because this man, too, is a son of Abraham. For the Son of Man came to seek and to save what was lost.


The Ministry of the Apostles

Mat 10:5  These twelve Jesus sent forth, and commanded them, saying, Go not into the way of the Gentiles, and into any city of the Samaritans enter ye not:
Mat 10:6 But go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.
Mat 10:7 And as ye go, preach, saying, The kingdom of heaven is at hand
.

WHO are the SHEEP ?

John 10:3-4, 7The one who enters by the gate is the shepherd of the sheep. The watchman opens the gate for him, and the sheep listen to his voice. He calls his own sheep by name and leads them out. When he has brought out all his own, he goes on ahead of them, and his sheep follow him because they know his voice… Therefore Yahushua said again, “I tell you the truth, I am the gate for the sheep
.”







Did you get that - "god is not YHWH's name !

Hos 8:10, 12 records :

“Although they have hired themselves among the nations, I will now gather them together.  They will begin to waste away under the oppression of the mighty ruler…I wrote for them the many things of My Torah, but they regarded them as something foreign.



Ministry of Ya'akov (James the Just)

James 1:1 tells us ;

Ya’akov (James, brother of Yahushua), a servant of Yahweh and of King Messiah Yahushua, to the twelve tribes scattered among the nations: Shalom.”

Again, did you get who James was writing to ?


A: They weren't pagan Gentiles !

They were Israelite Gentiles !

Have you ever noticed what Amos 9:9 says ?

For I will give the command, and I will sift the people of Israel among all the Gentiles as grain is sifted in a sieve, and not a kernal will reach the ground.” (Amos 9:9)


Rom 12:14-15 reads :

“(Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the Torah, do by nature things required by the Torah, they are a law for themselves, even though they do not have the Torah. They show that the requirements of the Torah are written on their hearts, their consciences also bearing witness, and their thoughts sometimes accusing them and at other times even defending them.)

Ministry of Peter





Hos 1:6-7, 10-11 tells us :

“I will no longer show love to Israel, that I should at all forgive them. Yet I will show love to Judah; and I will save them—not by bow, sword or battle, or by horses and horsemen, but I, Yahweh their Elohim, will save them…


Yet the Israelites (the northern tribes) will be like the sand on the seashore, which cannot be measured or counted. In the place where it was said to them, ‘You are not my people,’ they will be called ‘children of the living Elohim.’  The people of Judah and the people of Israel will come together; they will appoint one leader (Messiah) and will come up out of the land, for great will be the day of Yiz·reh·āl'  (El sows).”



Q: What is the "full message" ?

Again, Jer 31:31-34 tells us about the "New Covenant"







Romans 11:24 tells us :

After all, if you were cut out of an olive tree that is wild by nature, and contrary to nature were grafted into a cultivated olive tree, how much more readily will these, the natural branches, be grafted into their own olive tree!

From Ezek 37:17, we are reminded

Join them together into one stick so that they will become one in your hand.”

Eph 2:15 tells us that :

“[Messiah's] purpose was to create in Himself one new humanity out of the two, thus making peace.


Rom 11:26-27 quotes Is 59:20 :

…and in this way all Israel will be saved. As it is written: ‘The Deliverer  (Savior) will come from Zion (Jerusalem); He will turn godlessness away from Jacob (Israel).’ For this is my covenant unto them, when I shall take away their sins. (Isaiah 59:20)”


Yahushua's words of Matt 5:17-20 are devastatingly clear :

Mat 5:17  Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil (rightly interpret).
Mat 5:18 For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot 
(smallest letter in the AlephBetor one tittle (accent marks above the lettersshall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.
Mat 5:19 Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.
Mat 5:20 For I say unto you, That except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heave
n
.

SHALOM to you who were far off

Eph 2:11  Wherefore remember, that ye being in time past Gentiles in the flesh, who are called Uncircumcision by that which is called the Circumcision in the flesh made by hands;
Eph 2:12 That at that time ye were without Messiah
being aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, and without YHW
H in the world:
Eph 2:13  But now in Messiah Yahushua ye who sometimes were far off are made nigh by the blood of Messiah
.

John 10:16, Yahushua  mentions other sheep

I have other sheep that are not of this sheep pen. I must bring them also. They too will listen to my voice, and there shall be one flock and one shepherd.

Eph 2:14-18 tells us that Messiah Yahushua came to preach peace to those lost Israelites, who were far away.

For [Messiah] Himself is our peace (Shalom – perfect wholeness), who has made the two groups one and has destroyed the barrier, the dividing wall, by setting aside in His flesh the hostility for the Torah, with its commands and regulations. His purpose was to create in Himself one new humanity out of the two, thus making peace, and in one body to reconcile both of them to Yahweh through the gallows, by which He put to death their hostility. He came and preached peace to you who were far away (lost Israel) and peace to those who were near (Judah). For through him we both have access to the Father by one Spirit.

Is 57:18-19 is also a reference to the lost Israelites who are far away.

“‘I have seen their ways, but I will heal them; I will guide them and restore comfort to Israel’s mourners, creating praise on their lips. Peace, peace, to those far and near,’ says Yahweh. ‘And I will heal them.’


One NEW Man

Ezek 37:15-23 describes how YHWH will bring the two houses of Israel back to be one united house.

The word of Yahweh came to me: ‘Son of man, take a stick of wood and write on it, “BELONGING TO JUDAH AND THE ISRASELITES ASSOCIATED WITH HIM.” Then take another stick of wood, and write on it, “BELONGING TO JOSEPH (that is, to Ephraim) AND ALL THE ISRASELITES ASSOCIATED WITH HIM.” Join them together into one stick so that they will become one in your hand. When your people ask you, “Won’t you tell us what you mean by this?” say to them, “This is what the Sovereign Yahweh says: ‘I am going to take the stick of Joseph—which is in Ephraim’s hand—and of the Israelite tribes associated with him, and join it to Judah’s stick. I will make them into a single stick of wood, and they will become one in my hand. Hold before their eyes the sticks you have written on  and say to them, “This is what the Sovereign Yahweh says: ‘I will take the Israelites out of the nations where they have gone. I will gather them from all around and bring them back into their own land.  I will make them one nation in the land, on the mountains of Israel. There will be one king over all of them and they will never again be two nations or be divided into two kingdoms. They will no longer defile themselves with their idols and vile images or with any of their offenses, for I will save them from all their sinful backsliding, and I will cleanse them. They will be my people, and I will be their Elohim.

Messiah Died to Restore Israel

In John 11:49-52, Caiaphas prophesied that Messiah Yahushua died to restore the two houses of Israel.

“Then one of them, named Caiaphas, who was high priest that year, spoke up, ‘You know nothing at all! You do not realize that it is better for you that one man die for the people than that the whole nation perish.’  He did not say this on his own, but as high priest that year he prophesied that Yahushua would die for the Jewish nation, and not only for that nation but also for the scattered children of Yahweh, to bring them together and make them one.

MESSIAH YAHUSHUA said :

Matt 15:24I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel.”



LEGAL SEPARATION

Jer 3:8 explains :

I gave faithless Israel (northern tribes) her certificate of divorce and sent her away because of all her adulteries. Yet I saw that her unfaithful sister Judah (Jews) had no fear; she also went out and committed adultery.”


YHWH HATES DIVORCE !

Mal 2:16 tells us :

‘I hate divorce,’ says Yahweh, the Elohim of Israel, ‘because the man who divorces his wife does violence to the one he should protect, so be on your guard, and do not be unfaithful.







Did you see it - "YHWH dropped the charges against us", for our sins ?

That's what was "nailed to the tree (cross) !

RETURN to ME !

Jer 3:14-15 says :

Return, O backsliding children, says Yahweh; for I am married to you: and I will take you one of a city, and two of a family, and I will bring you to Zion: and I will give you Pastors according to My heart which shall feed you with knowledge and understanding.

MESSIAH YAHUSHUA could not RATIFY the Divorce, BUT, He did RATIFY the NEW COVENANT

Matt 26:27-29 explains :

“Then he took a cup (of Redemption), and when he had given thanks, he gave it to them, saying, ‘Drink from it, all of you. This is my blood of the New Covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins.  I tell you, I will not drink from this fruit of the vine from now on until that day when I drink it new with you in my Father’s Kingdom (at the Marriage Feast of the Lamb).’”

Hos 2:14-15, 19-20 tell us :

“Therefore, behold, I will allure her, will bring her into the wilderness, and speak comfort to her. I will give her vineyards from there, and the Valley of Achor as a door of hope; she shall sing there, as in the days of her youth, as in the day when she came up from the land of Egypt…I will betroth you to Me forever; yes, I will betroth you to Me in righteousness and justice, in lovingkindness and mercy; I will betroth you to Me in faithfulness, and you shall know Yahweh.”


Dr Charles Adelle Lewis Totten said :

I can never be too thankful to the Almighty that in my youth he used the late Professor Wilson to show me the difference between the TWO HOUSES. 

The very understanding of this difference is the KEY by which almost the entire Bible becomes intelligible, and I cannot state too strongly that the man who has not yet seen that Israel of the Scripture is totally distinct from the Jewish people, is yet in the very infancy, the mere alphabet, of Biblical study, and that to this day the meaning of seven-eighths of the Bible is shut to his understanding.


In Rom 10:5-13 we read :

Moses writes this about the righteousness that is grounded in the Torah: ‘The person who does these things will live by them.’ (Leviticus 18:5) Moreover the righteousness that is grounded in faith says: ‘Do not say in your heart, “Who will ascend into heaven?” (that is, to bring Messiah down) or “Who will descend into the deep?” (that is, to bring Messiah up from the dead).   What then does it say? “The word is near you; it is in your mouth and in your heart,” (Deuteronomy 30:12-14) that is, the Word of Faith that we preach:  If you pledge allegiance with your mouth, ‘Yahushua is Sovereign,’ and believe in your heart that Yahweh raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you pledge your allegiance and are saved.  As Scripture says, ‘Anyone who believes in him will never be put to shame.’ (Isaiah 28:16) For there is no difference between Jew and Gentile — the same Sovereign is sovereign of all and richly blesses all who call on him,  for, ‘Everyone who calls on the name of Yahweh will be saved.

I hope you can now see that, once you accept Messiah Yahushua as your Saviour, & King, you are now, a full member of Israel - although you were scattered for your "transgressions", you are now back in YHWH's family. WELCOME home !


If you'd like to read a study that provides physical evidence that you may be a "physical" Israelite, I encourage you to read :

"The Lost Tribes of Israel, Found" by Stephen Collins.

Introduction

There is often confusion about how the appointed times of YHWH are understood. This is because the English translations of the Hebrew, and/or Greek, are sometimes, not carefully defined, and because tradition has described them in a particular way.

The Hebrew word translated as appointed times or feasts is מועדים moedim (moed s).

YHWH’s appointed times, be they weekly (the 7th Day Sabbath), or annual, are all moedim.

Some moedim are chags חג (feasts), and some are chagags (pilgrimage chags).

Not all moedim are chags and/or chagags.

Some moedim are Shabbat Shabbatons (Sabbaths of rest).

 Others moedim are Shabbatons (rests).

Some moedim are neither, Shabbat Shabbatons, or Shabbatons.

ALL of YHWH’s moedim are His appointed times.

Not all YHWH’s appointed times are feasts, and/or pilgrimage feasts.

Not all YHWH’s appointed times are Sabbaths (as in 7th Day Sabbaths) because they have different work requirements.

The 7th Day Sabbath, and Yom Kippur have the requirement of doingno work”   לאכה    לא  (Lev 23:3, Lev 23:28, 30-31).

All of the other annual moedim have the requirement of doingno servile workכל  מלאכת  עבדה (Lev 23:7, 8, 21, 25, 35, 36).

no work” is related to the 7th day of the week when you are to refrain from the work you did, on the previous 6 days (Ex 23:12).

no servile workpossibly relates to the work the Hebrews did, when they were slaves to the Egyptians (Ex 1:14).

The following sections show the main characteristics of each of the moed, each "appointed time" of YHWH

THE 7th DAY SABBATH 

It is always called “the” Sabbath

Celebrate the Sabbath on the seventh day of each week (Gen 2:1, Exod 16:23-30)

1: It is :

YHWH's weekly Appointed Time, His moed, & is indicated in Lev 23:2 – the Hebrew word, moed is Strong’s Number, H4150

a Sabbath of Rest, a Shabbat ShabbatonLev 23:3

an everlasting OrdinanceExod 31:17

the sign of YHWH's Covenant with IsraelExod 31:13-17

2: It is NOT:

chag, a feast, or chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast

3: Its purpose is to :

remind us of YHWH's creative power as told in Gen 1 & 2 YHWH is our focus

remind us of YHWH's eternal covenant with Israel (Exod 31:17)

remember that our ancestors were slaves in Egypt, & that YHWH brought them out of Egypt with an out-stretched arm (Deut 5:12).

4:  On the 7th day Sabbath, we are commanded to :

Remember” the Sabbath – to zakar it – Exod 20:8

Remember to keep it set apart (holy) to YHWH - Exod 20:8   

Guard/Protect/Keep/Observe the Sabbath – Deut 5:12

Do no work on the Sabbath – Exod 31:14-15

Rest on the Sabbath – Lev 23:3

Cause no one else to work on the Sabbath – Exod 20:10

Have a set-apart (holy) gathering on the Sabbath – Lev 23:3

Kindle no fire on the Sabbath – Exod 35:3

5:  Because the following verses are not found in the first five books of YHWH’s Word, it seems logical that we are also encouraged to  :

Not to buy and/or Sell on the Sabbath – Neh 10:31 & Neh 13:15

Not to do things for your own pleasure on the Sabbath – Isaiah 58:13-14

6:  When we had a Temple, specific sacrifices were offeredNum 28:9-10

7:  Because we are commanded NOT to do any work on “the Sabbath”, all food preparation should be done on the 6th day

8: Some other associated Scriptures are – Gen 2:2-3, Exod 20:8-11, Exod 31:16, Lev 23:3-4, & Deut 5:14

PASSOVER

Celebrate YHWH's Passover on the 14th day of the first month of the Biblical Year

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

a chag, a Feast - Exod 12:14, Exod 34:25

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast - Exod 12:14

a memorial day - Exod 12:14

an everlasting OrdinanceExod 12:14

an annual moed - Lev 23

the first day of unleavened bread - Exod 12:18, Matt 26:17

the start of the seven days of unleavened bread

2: It is not :

a Shabbaton or a Shabbat Shabbaton

3: Its purpose :

Passover is to remind us of how YHWH protected & saved Israel's first-born from being destroyed by the tenth plague

4: We are commanded to :

A: have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

B: keep this day as a "memorial" (Exod 12:14)

C:have a Passover meal as part of our memorial  celebration (Exod 12:11)

D: keep no meat until morning (Num 9:12)

E: eat the Passover meal with Unleavened Bread, & bitter herbs (Exod 12:18, 8)

F: offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 28:19-25)

G: remove leaven from our houses (Exod 12:15)

5: Only circumcised males can part-take of the Passover meal (Exod 12:44, 48). Passover is a covenant renewal occasion.

6: Because cooking of the Passover meal is required, "cooking" is allowed.

7: No "servile work" is to be done (Lev 23:7)

8: Some other associated Scriptures are – Exod chapter 12, Lev 23:4-8, Num chapter 9, & Deut 16:1-8

The Feast of Unleavened Bread

Celebrate the Feast of Unleavened Bread on the 15th day of the first biblical month

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

a chag, a Feast - Lev 23:6, Exod 23:15

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast - Exod 12:14-16, Deut 16:16

an everlasting OrdinanceExod 12:17

part of the seven days of unleavened bread

an annual moed - Lev 23:4

2It is not :

a Sabbaton or a Shabbat Shabbaton

as is commonly believed, based on Exod 12:18, & Matt 26:17, the first day of unleavened bread

3: Its purpose is 

to remind us that our ancestors were slaves in Egypt, & YHWH delivered them from that slavery

4:  We are commanded to :

A: have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

B: eat unleavened bread (Exod 12:15)

C: offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 28:19-25)

5: Because it is a festival day, I believe we are allowed to "cook" meals on this day

6: No "servile work" is to be done (Lev 23:7)

7: Some other associated Scriptures are – Exod 12:17, 23:15, 34:18, Lev 23:6, & Num 28:17

Comment

It is important to note that Lev 23:5 & 6 are joined with the Hebrew letter, vav, translated as "and". This means that the command to eat unleavened bread for seven days, is not to be interpreted to mean that this day is the first day of unleavened bread

The First Day of Unleavened Bread and the seventh day of Unleavened Bread

Based on Exod 12:18, Matt 26:17 & Mark 14:12, the first day of unleavened bread is the day of Passover, the 14th day of the first biblical month.

1: Each is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

a chag, a Feast - Exod 23:15, since they are part of the seven days of Unleavened Bread

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast - Exod 12:14-16, Deut 16:16, since they are part of the seven days of Unleavened Bread

an everlasting OrdinanceExod 12:17

an annual moed - Lev 23:4

2: Each is not :

a Shabbaton or Shabbat Shabbaton

3: Its purpose is 

to remind us that our ancestors were slaves in Egypt, & YHWH delivered them from that slavery

4:  We are commanded to :

A: have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

B: eat unleavened bread (Exod 12:15)

C: offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 28:19-25)

5: Because each is a festival day, I believe we are allowed to "cook" meals on these days

6: No "servile work" is to be done (Lev 23:7)

7: Some other associated Scriptures are – Exod 12:17, 23:15, 34:18, Lev 23:6, & Num 28:17, Deut 16:16

First Fruits

Celebrated on the day that the sheaf of first-fruits of the harvest are waved before YHWH

It is celebrated on the Sunday after the 7th day Sabbaththat follows the day of Passover (Lev 23:11)

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

the first day of the counting of the Omer - Lev 23:15-16

an everlasting OrdinanceExod 12:17 as it applies to the seven days of Unleavened Bread

an annual moed - Lev 23:4

2: It is not :

a Shabbaton or a Shabbat Shabbaton

a chag, a Feast

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast

a day of doing "no servile" work, or no work at all

3: Its purpose is :

to acknowledge that YHWH is the provider of all our needs

4: We are commanded to :

A: have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

B: eat unleavened bread (Exod 12:15)

Coffer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple,  (Num 28:26-31)

D: start the count of the 50 days until the Feast of Shavuot (Lev 23:15-16)

Because Lev 23:11 uses the term "the Sabbath", we know that it is a reference to the seventh day Sabbath, & so the count of the Omer begins on the day after that seventh day Sabbath

5: Some other associated Scriptures are – Exod 23:16, 19, 34:26, Lev 2:12, 14, Lev 23:10-14, 20 & Num 28:26

Shavuot
Also called the Feast of Weeks and Pentecost

Celebrated by counting the 50 days of the Omer, starting on the Sunday of First Fruits (Lev 23:15-16, Deut 16:9)

A very good video on "How to count the 50 days to Shavuot" can be viewed @

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9y3L90OMbXI

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

a chag, a Feast - Exod 34:22, Deut 16:10 

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast - Exod 23:14-16, Deut 16:16,

the day after counting of 50 days of the Omer - Lev 23:15-16

an everlasting Ordinance Lev 23:21


an annual moed - Lev 23:4


2: It is not :

a Shabbaton or a Shabbat Shabbaton

3: Its purpose is to :

thank YHWH for the first-fruits of the wheat harvest (Exod 34:22), to rejoice before Him for His great blessings of the wheat harvest (Deut 16:11), & to remember that our ancestors were bondservants in Egypt (Deut 16:12)

4: We are commanded to :

A: have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

B: rejoice before YHWH (Deut 16:11)

C: do no "servile work"  (Lev 23:7)

D: remember that we were bondservants in Egypt (Deut 16:12)

E: offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 28:26-31)

5: Because it is a festival day, I believe we are allowed to "cook" meals on these days

6: Some other associated Scriptures are –
Exod 23:14-15, 34:22, Lev 23:4, 15-22, Deut 16:10-12

Links
Shavuot the feast of weeks or Pentecost
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7o-b2_XjQ_E

MTOI– Shavuot from Sinai to the upper room (also see very good Notes)
http://www.mtoi.org/teachings/shavuot_from_sinai_to_the_upper_room.shtml

Tom @ Eliyah.com – Shavuot article
http://www.eliyah.com/transcripts/html/20150502.html

MTOI– Shavuot The Launching Point
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=6&v=bZW3Q-hQTiA

TOM TERUAH

Also called the Feast of Trumpets

Celebrated on the first day of the seventh month of the biblical year

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

a Shabbaton, but not a Shabbat Shabbaton (Lev 23:24)

probably an everlasting Ordinance (but no reference found)

an annual moed - Lev 23:4

2: It is not :

Shabbat Shabbaton

a chag, a Feast

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast

3: Its purpose is to :

remind us of making a very loud noise by shouting, & blowing shofars before YHWH

4: We are commanded to :

A: have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

B: create a noise traditionally by shouting& by blowing the shofar (Lev 23:24, Num 29:1, Num 10:10)

C: do no "servile work"  (Lev 23:7)

D: offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 29:1-6)

5: Because it is a festival day, I believe we are allowed to "cook" meals on these days

6: Neh 8 recommends us to :


A: Read the Book of the Torah (Neh 8:2-5)

B: Make a free-will offering (Neh 8:10)

C: Rejoice before YHWH (Neh 8:10)

D: Eat the Fat, & drink sweet drink (Neh 8:10, 12)

E: Send portions to the poor (Neh 8:10)

7: Some other associated Scriptures are –
Exod 23:14-16, Lev 23:24-25, Num 29:1-6, Neh 8:2-12


Links

http://www.unlearnthelies.com/yom-teruah-the-feast-of-trumpets.html

Shofar Blasts video     https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yb_9Vt-Eso

 Mark Biltz @    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=shIMX5c08K0

http://www.hebrew4christians.com/Holidays/Fall_Holidays/Rosh_Hashannah/rosh_hashannah.html

http://www.lightofmashiach.org/yomteruah.html

http://blog.judahgabriel.com/2008/09/significance-of-yom-teruah-for.html

http://www.betemunah.org/teruah.html#_Toc368233932

YOM KIPPUR 

Also known as the "Day of Atonements"

Celebrated on the tenth day of the seventh month of the biblical year

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

Shabbat Shabbaton (Lev 23:32)

an everlasting Ordinance (Lev 23:31)

an annual moed - Lev 23:4

2: It is not :

a chag, a Feast

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast

3: Its purpose is to :

remind us that on this day each year, YHWH forgave all the sins of the Israelites before Messiah Yahushua's sacrifice on the stake

4: We are commanded to :

have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

Do no work on Yom KippurLev 23:27, 31

Afflict our souls - Lev 23:27,  32

Rest on Yom Kippur - Lev23:3

offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 29:7-11)

5: Related Scriptures - Lev 16:29,Lev 23:27-32, Num 29:7-11, Deut 16:13, 16

SUKKOT

Also known as the "Feast of Tabernacles"

Celebrated on the fifteenth day of the seventh month of the biblical year

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

an everlasting Ordinance (Lev 23:31)

an annual moed - (Lev 23:4)


shabbaton - (Lev 23:39)

a chag, a Feast   (Lev 23:34)

a chagag, a Pilgrimage Feast (Lev 23:39)

2: It is not :

Shabbat Shabbaton

3: Its purpose is to :

to acknowledge & thank YHWH for the harvest

4: We are commanded to :

have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

do no "servile work"  (Lev 23:7)

rest on the 15th day of the seventh month (Leve 23:39)

celebrate for seven days (Lev 23:34)

dwell in booths (Lev 23:42)

take branches of various trees & rejoice for the seven days (Lev 23:40)

offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 29:12-40)

5: Because it is a festival day, I believe we are allowed to "cook" meals on these days

6: Some other associated Scriptures are –
Exod 23:14-16, Lev 23:34-43, Num 29:13-34, Deut 16:13, 16

The Eight Great Day

Celebrated on the eight day following the Feast of Sukkot

1: It is :

an Appointed Time, a moed, as indicated in Lev 23:5-6 – it has Strong’s Number H4150

an everlasting Ordinance (Lev 23:41)

an annual moed - (Lev 23:4)


a Shabbaton, but not a Shabbat Shabbaton (Lev 23:24)

2: It is not :

Shabbat Shabbaton

3: Its purpose seems to :

remind us that the eighth day is about new beginnings which appears to be prophetic of the ultimate Eighth Day or the eighth millennium. On this day, the eighth day, YHWH will make everything new, & will dwell with mankind forever. All things will be restored, as it was before sin.

4: We are commanded to :

have a set-apart (holy) gathering (Lev 23:4)

do no "servile work" (Lev 23:7)

rest on the 8th day of the feastival of Sukkot (Leve 23:39)

5: Because it is a festival day, I believe we are allowed to "cook" meals on these days

offer specific sacrifices when we had a Temple, (Num 29:12-40)

6: Some other associated Scriptures are – Lev 23:36, Num 29:35-39, Deut 16:13, 16





A detailed scriptural analysis of the Jews’ religion described in Gal 1:13-14

What is the “Jews’ religion” referred to in Gal 1:13-14? 

What is its connection with Gal 2:11-14, Matt 3:7, Matt 23:13-15, & similar verses? 

How is it connected with John 5:1, 6:4 & 7:2, & the Jewish calendar ? 

Should believers in Messiah Yahushua trust in those who belong to it ?

Introduction

Over the past year or so, I have been studying the history of the Jews, from their time in Babylon until the 1st century, & what the Renewed Covenant scriptures tell us about them.

Quite recently, I have been studying the book of Galatians, & have been wondering about who, & what Paul describes as "the Jews' religion", specifically mentioned in Gal 1:13-14, but also referred to later in Paul's letter referred to the Galatians. I have based this study on the great work of Steve Martin in his video, "Galatians 2:1-14, Did Peter and Paul disagree about keeping Torah?"

In Gal 1:13-14, we read : 

Gal 1:13 For ye have heard of my conversation in time past in the Jews' religion, how that beyond measure I persecuted the assembly of YHWH, and wasted it: 

Gal 1:14 And profited in the Jews' religion above many my equals in mine own nation, being more exceedingly zealous of the traditions of my fathers.

My curiosity was raised when I read, & studied about Paul’s visit with “them which were of reputation”, namely, Peter, John, James, & the other apostles & disciples of Messiah Yahushua as was written in Gal 2:2. My interest increased still further, when I read, & studied about Paul’s “conflict” with Peter in Gal 2:11-14. Please note that I have expanded v14 because there are three different words translated as “Jews”, & I want their meanings to be clear. 

Gal 2:2 And I went up by revelation, and communicated unto them that gospel which I preach among the Gentiles, but privately to them which were of reputation, lest by any means I should run, or had run, in vain.

 Gal 2:11 But when Peter was come to Antioch, (Paul) withstood him (Peter) to the face, because he (Peter) was to be blamed

Gal 2:12 For before that certain came from James, he did eat with the Gentiles: but when they were come, he withdrew and separated himself, fearing them which were of the circumcision

Gal 2:13 And the other Jews dissembled (acted hypocritically) likewise with him; insomuch that Barnabas also was carried away with their dissimulation (deceit)

Gal 2:14 But when I saw that they (those of the Jewish religion), walked not uprightly according to the truth of the gospel (of Messiah Yahushua), I said unto Peter before them all, If thou, being a Jew, (one belonging to Judah), livest after the manner of Gentiles(non-Jews), and not as do the Jews, (after the manner of the Jews, including keeping the tradition of the elders), why compellest thou the Gentiles (non-Jews), to live as do the Jews (to judaize, or imitate the Jews)

I then decided to examine what we were told about Paul, & what he said about the “Jews’ religion”, reasoning that, he for much of his life, was a believing, & practicing member of this “Jews’ religion”, & therefore should know all about it.

The strategy I have used is as follows :

1: I introduced my examination by listing what I have found out about Paul.

2: Using a “court-type” style, I have provided “scriptural” witnesses to identify what the Jews’ religion was, who belongs to it, what they believe, & what actions they incorporate, in order to perpetuate the Jews' religion.

3: Then I have summarised what these witnesses tell us about the Jews’ religion.

4: I included some background information on the history of the Jews from their Babylonian captivity until the 1st century.

I have concluded my study by asking some significant questions for those who currently follow, the important aspects of the Jews’ religion.

Who was Paul, & what did he know about the Jews’ religion

Acts 21:39 & 22:3, tell us that Paul was a Jew, born in Tarsus, a city in Cilica. Acts 22:25 indicates that Paul was a Roman citizen.

In Acts 22:3, we are told that Paul was “brought up in this city at the feet of Gamaliel, and taught according to the perfect manner of the law of the fathers, and was zealous toward YHWH, as ye all are this day”.

Acts 5:34 refers to Gamaliel, as “one in the council, a Pharisee, … a doctor of the law, had in reputation among all the people”. It is believed that to be a disciple of Gamaliel, a young Jewish man needed to be among the brightest, & most zealous of Pharisees - only the very best young Pharisees could be mentored by Gamaliel. After Paul’s “training” by Gamaliel, I have read that Paul knew the Tanach so well, that he had it memorised. He certainly knew, & practised the Pharisaic “oral law”, called the tradition of the elders in Matt 15:2, in his life before his encounter with Messiah Yahushua (Acts 9).

We know from Acts 26 that Paul was a strict Pharisee, & the son of a Pharisee. In Acts 7 & 9, we know that he participated in the stoning of Stephen. In Acts 9, we are told that Paul “breathed threats & slaughter against the disciples”. In Gal 1:13-14, again, Paul tells the Galatians some interesting information when he writes, “For ye have heard of my conversation in time past in the Jews' religion, how that beyond measure I persecuted the church of YHWH, and wasted it: And profited in the Jews' religion above many my equals in mine own nation, being more exceedingly zealous of the tradition of my fathers”.

Clearly, Paul knew all the “ins & outs” of the “Jews’ religion”.

While the “Jews’ religion” was the religion that Paul originally believed in, practiced, & “profited in”, it is NOT the same spiritual walk that he practiced, after His encounter with Messiah Yahushua. This is why Paul had all the conflicting encounters with those of the Jews’ religion, during his ministry. (Acts 15, Gal 2:2). Sometimes, the “Jews’ religion” is referred to as “the circumcision” (Gal 2:7-8 is an example).

What else do we know about the “Jews’ religion” ? 

In order to answer this, I have decided to present my findings in the form of a “court-style” situation. I will be providing several “scriptural” witnesses, & will begin by examining very carefully, what John the Baptist, said about the scribes, Pharisees, & Sadducees; what Messiah Yahushua said about those who strongly believed in, & practised the “Jews’ religion”, namely the scribes, Pharisees, & the Sadducees . I want to examine all the evidence that I can find.

I know that many of you are very familiar with these verses, so I hope that you can be patient with me, because I want to examine all the evidence in this way.

Witness 1         John the Baptist

Key Verse        Matt 3:7 

Mat 3:7 But when he (John the Baptist) saw many of the Pharisees and Sadducees come to his baptism, he said unto them, O generation (offspring) of vipers, who hath warned you to flee from the wrath to come?

Accused           many of the Pharisees & Sadducees

Accusation       They were “O generation (offspring) of Vipers

Supporting Evidence   who hath warned you to flee from the wrath to come?

When               before Yahushua began His ministry

Comment         

Since John the Baptist is making this accusation before Yahushua began His ministry, isn’t it obvious that the Pharisees' & Sadducees' (bad) reputation must have been based on beliefs, & activities based on those beliefs, that had been developed much earlier than this time ? More on this history later.

Why does John make this accusation ? Clearly, their beliefs & actions must have “upset” him severely, for him to publicly attack them as v7 shows.

Witness 2         Messiah Yahushua

Key Verse        Matt 23:13 

Mat 23:13 But woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites(an actor, one who interprets, a pretender) for ye shut up the kingdom of heaven against men: for ye neither go in yourselves, neither suffer ye them that are entering to go in.

Accused           scribes & Pharisees

Accusation       

you (scribes & Pharisees) shut up the kingdom of heaven against men – for you neither go in, or suffer them that are entering to go in. 

Comment

I believe Yahushua is charging the scribes, Pharisees & Sadducees with “shutting up the kingdom of heaven against men", by taking away the “key of knowledge” (Luke 11:52), that is, the ability to use (pronounce) YHWH’s name. (There may be other possibilities).

NB – there are nine other times where Yahushua addresses the scribes & Pharisees with this phrase. (Matt 23:14, 15, 23, 25, 27, 29, Luke 11:42, 43,44). In each verse, He makes a different accusation. Please read these verses for yourself, so that you will have all the evidence to consider.

Q: Why would John the Baptist early in Yahushua’s ministry, & Messiah Yahushua Himself, criticise the scribes, Pharisees, & Sadducees publicly, in this way ? Did John, Yahushua, & their apostles & disciples know something that we don’t know, or haven’t considered ?

Witness 3         The Pharisees & scribes criticise the actions of the disciples of John, & of Yahushua

Key Verses       Matt 9:11, 14, 12:2, 15:2, Mark 2:16 & Luke 5:33 

Mat 9:11 And when the Pharisees saw it, they said unto his disciples, Why eateth your Master with publicans and sinners

Mat 9:14 Then came to him the disciples of John, saying, Why do we and the Pharisees fast oft, but thy disciples fast not

Mat 12:2 But when the Pharisees saw it, they said unto him, Behold, thy disciples do that which is not lawful to do upon the sabbath day

Mat_15:2 Why do thy disciples transgress the tradition of the elders? for they wash not their hands when they eat bread.

Mar 2:16 And when the scribes and Pharisees saw him eat with publicans and sinners, they said unto his disciples, How is it that he eateth and drinketh with publicans and sinners

Luk_5:33 And they said unto him, Why do the disciples of John fast often, and make prayers, and likewise the disciples of the Pharisees but thine eat and drink? 

Comment

Q: Are any of the above criticisms based on any written Torah commands ? A: No.

If these criticisms aren’t based on written Torah commands, then they must be based on “man-made”, oral law, namely, "tradition of the elders".

Clearly, the Pharisees, & scribes had “oral Torah” beliefs that differed from what John the Baptist & his disciples, & Messiah Yahushua, & His apostles had. Obviously, these Pharisees & scribes, who belonged to the “Jews’ religion”, were seriously, upset when some other Jews, including Messiah Yahushua & His apostles, disregarded what they considered to be very important “tradition of the elders” commands.

Witness 4         Yahushua prophesies the plots to kill Him

Key Verses       Matt 17:22-23, Mark 9:31

Prophesy       

The Son of man shall be betrayed into the hands of men (scribes, Pharisees, Sadducees): And they shall kill him, and the third day he shall be raised again 

Comment

Yahushua prophesies that the scribes, Pharisees & Sadducees whom He had criticised, would eventually kill Him.

Witness 5         Scriptural evidence that the “Jews” wanted to kill Yahushua

Key verses       Matt 26:4, John 5:18, 7:1 

Mat 26:4 And consulted that they (the Jews) might take Yahushua by subtilty, and kill him.

Joh 5:18 Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only had broken the sabbath, but said also that Elohim was his Father, making himself equal with Elohim. 

Joh 7:1 After these things Yahushua walked in Galilee: for he would not walk in Jewry, because the Jews sought to kill him

Comment

The scribes, Pharisaic Jews, & Sadducees wanted to kill Messiah Yahushua because :

1: He, His apostles & disciples did not follow some of their oral law, the tradition of the elders’ commands, that the Jews’ religion had – they were directly accused of this in Matt 15:2, 

Mat 15:2 Why do thy disciples transgress the tradition of the elders? for they wash not their hands when they eat bread

2: He publicly criticized them in verses such as Matt 23:13,

3: He publicly disapproved of their “tradition of the elders” in verses like Matt 15:6 & Mark 7:7 & 13, 

Mat 15:6 And honour not his father or his mother, he shall be free. Thus have ye made the commandment of YHWH of none effect by your tradition.  

4: It was His heavenly Father’s will.

Witness 6         The arrest, & trial of Yahushua

Key Verses       Matthew chapter 26, John chapter 18

Verses Summary

Matt 26:47-56, John 18:3-12     Yahushua is arrested by the officers of the chief priests, & Pharisees

Matt 26:57-68                Yahushua before Caiaphas – many false witnesses came

John 18:13, 19-24         Yahushua before Annas, & then Caiaphas

Comment 

Yahushua is betrayed by Judah into the hands of the officers of the chief priests, & Pharisees, (Matt 26:14-16), & when brought before Caiaphas, the scribes, the elders, & the council, they brought forward “false witnesses”, (Matt 26:57-68) in a failed attempt to convict Him of some “Torah breaking”. They eventually had Him killed, with some Roman involvement.

Witness 7         The Stoning of Stephen

Key verses       Acts 6:8-15, Acts chapter 7

Verses Summary

Acts 6:8     Stephen, full of faith & power, did great wonders & miracles among the people

Acts 6:9-10     Certain men, (of the synagogue – probably of the Jews’ religion), disputed with Stephen, but were unable to resist the wisdom & spirit by which he spoke   

Acts 6:11-13    These men suborned (introduced false evidence by collusion) witnesses – they stirred up the people, & had him brought to the council – where they set up false witnesses, claiming that he blasphemed against Moses & the Temple

Acts 7:1     The high priest asked Stephen if these things were so ?

Acts 7:2-53     Stephen replied with a very long speech, describing YHWH’s encounter with Abraham, Isaac, & Jacob, & the 12 Patriarchs. He explained YHWH’s relationship with Moses - Stephem spoke about the “Church (assembly) in the wilderness, & the golden calf rebellion. He mentioned Kings David & Solomon,  the work of the Prophets, & the betrayal & murder of the Just One (Messiah Yahushua).

Acts 7:54-60     The actual stoning of Stephen 

Comment

Those of the Jews’ religion, including the high priest, council members, & false witnesses, felt threatened by great wonders & miracles that Stephen performed because of his faith in, & the power of YHWH. These men set up a “trial-type” situation, in an attempt to discredit the work Stephen was doing, as a chosen servant of the apostles.

Again, those of the Jews’ religion, set up “false witnesses”, as they did at Messiah Yahushua’s “trial”, in an attempt to humiliate, & discredit Stephen, & what he stood for.

They decided Stephen was guilty – they stoned, & killed him. Paul as a former Jews’ religion member, participated by consenting to his death.

Witness 8         The persecution of the believers in Messiah Yahushua – Paul ravages the assembly

Key Verses      Acts 8:1-3, 9:1-2

Act 8:1  And Saul was consenting unto his death. And at that time there was a great persecution against the church which was at Jerusalem; and they were all scattered abroad throughout the regions of Judaea and Samaria, except the apostles

Act 8:2  And devout men carried Stephen to his burial, and made great lamentation over him. 

Act 8:3  As for Saul, he made havock of the church, entering into every house, and haling men and women committed them to prison. 

Act 9:1  And Saul, yet breathing out threatenings and slaughter against the disciples of the Lord, went unto the high priest, 

Act 9:2  And desired of him letters to Damascus to the synagogues, that if he found any of this way, whether they were men or women, he might bring them bound unto Jerusalem

Comment

Acts 8:1-3 provides evidence that, at the time of Stephen’s stoning, there was great persecution against the Assembly, presumably by the Jews’ religion.

Paul at that time, being a staunch, & extremely loyal believer in the Jews’ religion, who “made havoc” of the assembly (Acts 8:3). We are told in Acts 9:1 that, He was breathing threats, & slaughtered the disciples of Yahushua, when he went to the high priest, desiring letters to Damascus, & to the synagogues – Paul in his early life, clearly was very zealous about the beliefs of the Jews’ religion.

How is the Jew's Religion connected with John 5:1, 6:4 & 7:2, & the Jewish calendar ?  

Have you ever noticed that the Gospel of John is the only one that specifically makes a reference to "the feast of the Jews", or "the Jews' feast" ?

I have copied the appropriate verses below.

Joh 5:1  After this there was a feast of the Jews; and Yahushua went up to Jerusalem. 

Joh 6:4  And the passover, a feast of the Jews, was nigh. 

Joh 7:2  Now the Jews' feast of tabernacles was at hand. 

Q: Don't we know from Lev 23:2 that Passover & the other moedim, (appointed times), are Yahweh's set feasts, & appointed times ?

Lev 23:2 Speak to the sons of Israel, and you shall say to them, The set feasts of YAHWEH which you shall proclaim as holy gatherings, shall be these: These are My appointed feasts:

Q: Since we know, & John knows that the appointed times are Yahweh's, doesn't it seem odd that John is the only writer who describes them as "the feast of the Jews", or "the Jews' feast" ?

Comment

I know that I am speculating here since I can't "prove" it, but since I am unable to find any other explanation, could it be that John has described "Yahweh's feasts" this way because the Jerusalem Jews of the Jews' Religion, had a different calendar from the one that Yahushua, His apostles & disciples followed ?

The reason that I write this, is because in my article, "When did the Israelites keep the original Passover", I showed biblically how, & when the Original Passover of Exodus 12 was kept, & why it would be non-biblical, to keep it using an afternoon of the 14th of Aviv going into the 15th of Aviv scenario.

Evidence Summation 

1: At the time of Messiah Yahushua, the Jews’ religion was composed of scribes, Pharisees, & Sadducees.

2: The Jews’ religion held man-made beliefs, called the “tradition of the elders”, the oral law, that were different to the written Torah.

3: Within the Jews’ religion, they :

A: revered the “oral law”, which later developed into the Talmud, (the primary source of Jewish law, & theology), the Mishnah, (the written copy of the oral law), & the Gemara (the rabbinic commentary on the Jewish law). This oral law was revered above the written Torah of Moses.

B: taught that to be saved, you must first be circumcised, & then keep the Torah (based on the oral law teachings of the Talmud, Mishnah & the Gemara).

C: hated, & despised those who belonged to the Assembly of YHWH – those who believed in Messiah Yahushua, & practised all of YHWH’s written Torah that YHWH gave through Moses. (Again, refer to Acts 7, for specific details about the stoning of Stephen).

4: When someone disobeyed one of the Jews’ religion’s, the “tradition of the elders” commands, that person was criticised, and/or punished in some way.

5: If the disobeying of “tradition of the elders” command was deemed very serious, the offender could be tried, & when declared guilty, stoned for their offense.

In 2 Cor 11:23-25a, we have a list of the punishments inflicted upon Paul by those of the “Jews’ religion”, presumably, for breaking their “oral Torah” commands. Verses 20-21, provide the context for these punishments. Acts 7 gives many details of what they did to Stephen.

2Co 11:23 Are they ministers of Christ? (I speak as a fool) I am more; in labours more abundant, in stripes above measure, in prisons more frequent, in deaths oft. 

2Co 11:24 Of the Jews five times received I forty stripes save one

2Co 11:25a Thrice was I beaten with rods, once was I stoned. 

Again, it seems obvious that the “Jews’ religion” was the religion that many Pharisaic Jews, Sadducees, & scribes of the first century, including Paul, strongly believed in, & practiced.

6: Those of the Jews’ religion, in some cases, brought forward “false witnesses”, in an attempt to convict such an offender (see Yahushua’s & Stephen’s “trials”).

7: Within the Jews’ religion, there were different groups. We know there were scribes, Pharisees, & Sadducees, but we know that there were differences between the Pharisees, & the Sadducees, & that there were differences among those Pharisees who followed Shammai, & those who followed Hillel the elder.

8: While, there would have been common beliefs, because of these differences, there would have been some beliefs, & subsequent activities, where each group differed.

9: Those of the Jews’ religion, aggressively confronted anyone who disagrees with them over matters such as “being saved”.

10: Not all those supporting the Jews’ religion, were against Messiah Yahushua – Nicodemus, a ruler of the Jews, came to Yahushua by night (John 3:1-2), & Joseph of Arimathaea, is called an honourable counsellor in Mark 15:43.

11: Those of the Jews’ religion, “indoctrinated” ordinary Jews with their beliefs. The following is one example of how this affected Peter.

In Gal 2:11-14, we have the situation where Paul confronts Peter. 

Gal 2:11 But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed

Gal 2:12 For before that certain came from James, he did eat with the Gentiles: but when they were come, he withdrew and separated himself, fearing them which were of the circumcision. 

Gal 2:13 And the other Jews dissembled likewise with him; insomuch that Barnabas also was carried away with their dissimulation. 

Gal 2:14 But when I saw that they walked not uprightly according to the truth of the gospel, I said unto Peter before them all, If thou, being a Jew, livest after the manner of Gentiles, and not as do the Jews, why compellest thou the Gentiles to live as do the Jews?

Q: Why did Paul confront Peter saying, “I withstood him to the face” ?

A: Paul writes his answer in the next phrase, “because he was to be blame”, adding more details in the following verses.

Q: Why would Peter eat with the Gentiles, but, when those of the “Jews’ religion” came, Peter withdrew, & separated himself (from the Gentiles) ? 

A: Peter came to Antioch, where there were some Jewish believers in Messiah Yahushua, but mostly, Gentile believers.

B: While Peter is there, he & the other Jewish believers who were with him, ate with the Gentiles – they “fellowshipped” with them. 

C: When some Jews came down from James, Peter no longer ate with these Gentiles. 

D: In Acts 10Peter met with Cornelius – recall the “unclean animals” dropping-down vision that was to prepare Peter, so that he would go into Cornelius’ house (a Gentile’s house).  

In Acts 10:15Peter is told, “what YHWH has cleansed, call not you common”. 

Act 10:15 And the voice spake unto him again the second time, What YHWH hath cleansed, that call not thou common.

E: I believe that Peter stopped fellowshipping with the Gentiles because :

a: all his life, before he met Messiah Yahushua, Peter had been “indoctrinated” into believing all he had been taught about the “Jews’ religion”. He had believed that it was “unlawful” for a Jew to keep company with a Gentile, as he described in Acts 10:28, and

b: Peter also knew that those of the “Jews’ religion” punished anyone they found, seriously breaking their “oral Torah” commands – Peter feared for his life.

12: Those of the Jews’ religion used under-handed tactics to influence some of the Assembly of YHWH. Gal 2:4 is one example. 

Gal 2:4 And that because of false brethren (Jews’ religion) unawares brought in, who came in privily to spy out our liberty which we have in Christ Jesus, that they might bring us into bondage: (of the oral law)

Here, Paul is saying that some of these men of the Jews’ religion, are “pretending” to be part of the assembly of YHWH, (they are the false brethren), “to spy out” what was being said & done, waiting for an opportunity to attach them over some “doctrinal” matter.

13: While I appreciate that those of the Jews’ religion have some reverence for Moses, it seems to me that they only do it, based on their “tradition of the elders”. In John 5:42, Yahushua says of them that they “have not the love of YHWH in you”. That is the first problem, but, Messiah Yahushua makes many references to Moses, specifically in John 5:46-47, where He says : 

Joh 5:39 Search the scriptures; for in them ye think ye have eternal life: and they are they which testify of me. 

Joh 5:40 And ye will not come to me, that ye might have life. 

Joh 5:41 I receive not honour from men. 

Joh 5:42 But I know you, that ye have not the love of YHWH in you. 

Joh 5:43 I am come in my Father's name, and ye receive me not: if another shall come in his own name, him ye will receive. 

Joh 5:44 How can ye believe, which receive honour one of another, and seek not the honour that cometh from God only? 

Joh 5:45 Do not think that I will accuse you to the Father: there is one that accuseth you, even Moses, in whom ye trust. 

Joh 5:46 For had ye believed Moses, ye would have believed me: for he wrote of me. 

Joh 5:47 But if ye believe not his writings, how shall ye believe my words?

Q: Do the actions of those in the Jews’ religion, indicate that they, “believe what Moses wrote about Messiah Yahushua” ?

A: It seems to me that there are many of their actions that indicate that they “do not love YHWH, & nor believe what Moses wrote about Messiah Yahushua”.

Think about the people Yahushua is talking to - they are the religious leaders of Yahushua’s day - they look religious - they sound religious - they dress religiously - they look dedicated - they look devoted, but they did not love YHWH - that's what Messiah Yahushua said to them, "I know this about you – you have not the love of Yahweh in you". They certainly love their religion - they love the system that had been set up by their forefathers. But, as Messiah Yahushua points out in John 5:42, they didn’t have the love of YHWH in them.

If these religious leaders, & their followers, really loved YHWH, they would have wanted to know what He said about how they're supposed to live, & they would have wanted to know what He said about how they're supposed to worship, but again, Yahushua said to them "I know this about you - you don't have the love of YHWH in you".

Messiah Yahushua was not saying that they were not religious – He was not saying that they were  not devoted to the system they were involved in, but He was saying that they don't have the love of YHWH in them.

If we continue reading, in v43, Messiah Yahushua says, “I am come in My father's name, & you receive me not; if another shall come in his own name, him you will receive; how can you believe which receive honor of one another and seek not the honour that comes from Yahweh only”. As we continue reading in v45, Messiah Yahushua says to them something incredibly important. He says, “do not think that I will accuse you to the Father; there is one that accuses you”.

Who would that be ? How many people then, & now, could honestly answer that question if you were to ask them, “Who is the one who is going to accuse you before the Father ?” I wonder how many people would say, “Moses”.

14: Because John describes Yahweh's feasts as "the feast of the Jews" and "the Jews' feast", it seems probable that those of the Jew's Religion may have kept a different calendar that Yahushua, His apostles & disciples did.

I'd like to close this study by repeating the very important question that I have often written, namely, how do you really know that what you have believed, what you have been taught, what you have viewed, heard, or read, is true & correct ? I strongly believe that the only answer is to find, & test, ALL the evidence that you can find.


A demonstration of a method used to check the accuracy of biblical translations, including the reasons for using such a method

In order to explain why, & how I use concordances, lexicons, & scriptural dictionaries, I will use the following example. I hope it is helpful.


Suppose some one asks me what I think Col 2:16-17 means. My standard practice, & answer always is, let me check to see that what is translated, is how it scripturally reads.


Let me demonstrate this by comparing the English KJV version with a Greek-English Interlinear version. 


I do this by examining each Greek word, & checking its meaning with Thayer’s Lexicon, & Strong’s Concordance, & writing out the verse according to the meaning of each Greek word that is checked. Please examine the following method carefully, so that the reader will understand the process involved.


I have copied the Greek-English version, & the KJV of Col 2:16-17 below, with the Thayer’s Lexicon, & Strong’s Concordance information. 

The Greek-English translation is read, left to right, by focusing on the English words. I will show this by copying Col 2:16 here :

Col 2:16 NOT  THEREFORE  ANYONE  YOU   LET JUDGE   IN   MEAT   OR   IN   DRINK   OR   IN   RESPECT   OF FEAST   OR   NEW MOON   OR   SABBATHS

Col 2:16  μηG3361 NOT   ουνG3767 THEREFORE   τιςG5100 ANYONE   υμαςG5209 YOU   κρινετωG2919 [G5720] LET JUDGE   ενG1722 IN   βρωσειG1035 MEAT   ηG2228 OR   ενG1722 IN   ποσειG4213 DRINK,   ηG2228 OR   ενG1722 IN   μερειG3313 RESPECT   εορτηςG1859 OF FEAST,   ηG2228 OR   νουμηνιαςG3561 NEW MOON,   ηG2228 OR   σαββατωνG4521 SABBATHS,   

Col 2:17  αG3739 WHICH   εστινG2076 [G5748] ARE   σκιαG4639 A SHADOW   τωνG3588 OF THINGS   μελλοντωνG3195 [G5723] TO COME;   τοG3588 BUT   δεG1161 THE   σωμαG4983 BODY "IS"   τουG3588 OF THE   χριστουG5547 CHRIST.   


Col 2:16 Let no man therefore judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of an holyday, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days: 

Col 2:17 Which are a shadow of things to come; but the body is of Messiah. 


 Now for the analysis

The first Greek word in v16, μη. It is Strong’s Greek word number G3361. I hope that you can see that.

The following information is provided by Thayer’s Lexicon, & then Strong’s Concordance in e-Sword.

G3361

Thayer

Original: μή

Transliteration: me

Phonetic: may

Definition:

1. no, not lest

Origin: a primary particle of qualified negation (whereas G3756 expresses an absolute denial)

TDNT entry: None

Part(s) of speech: (none provided)

Strong's: 

A primary particle of qualified negation (whereas G3756 expresses an absolute denial); (adverbially) not (conjugationally) lest; also (as interrogitive implying a negative answer [whereas G3756 expects an affirmative one]); whether: - any but (that) X forbear + God forbid + lack lest neither never no (X wise in) none nor [can-] not nothing that not un [-taken] without. Often used in compounds in substantially the same relations.


From this information, I have determined that μη is translated as “not”.


By following this process through,  so that all the Greek words are examined for their appropriate meanings, I believe that the Greek-English Interlinear "scripturally" reads :

Col 2:16 “not accordingly anyone you judge in eating food or in drinking or in allotment festival or new moon or Sabbaths

Col 2:17 which are shadow the intended purpose the but body the Messiah


Q: Is the KJV an accurate translation ?

A: I believe so


The next step in my analysis is to check what the "context" of the target verse is.

Q: What is the context of Col 2:16-17, in the passage Col 2:6-20 ?
A: Col 2:6-11 is focused on Messiah Yahushua being received by the Colossians, & their being rooted in Him – Col 2:12-15 describes what He did for them, when they received Him as their Master.


Q: What is the meaning of v16-17 ?

A: Paul seems to have picked several currently pressing problem topics (food, drink, festivals, new moons & Sabbaths), that other non-believing Colossians, may have confronted the believing Colossians about. In addressing these, Paul is writing, “don’t let these non-believing Colossians “judge” you, by their standards.


Paul continues in v17, by writing that the topics that he has just mentioned, (food, drink, festivals, new moons & Sabbaths), are about future things. Paul concludes by saying, only let those who are part of the believing body of Messiah, make an assessment about these topics.


When I am in a discussion with someone else about my understanding of the meaning of a particular verse or passage, my method is :


1: Check that the translation is accurate, using the above method.

2: Ask the other person do they agree with the accurate translation.

3: Each person then gives her/his understanding of the agreed upon accurate translation.


I use this method so that, we are each discussing "the same", accurate translation.

Isn't it true that many people never TEST what they believe - isn't most of our faith borrowed ? Doesn't it come from our culture, our family, our own interpretation of our journey through the lens of our training. Isn't our “knowledge", therefore, a set of reminiscences, & our perception always incomplete, & full of omissions, & thus a subsequent combination of random memories ?

When was the last time you TESTED what you believe ?

Isn't it true that many people never TEST what they believe - isn't most of our faith borrowed ? Doesn't it come from our culture, our family, our denomination, our own interpretation of our journey through the lens of our training.  Isn't our “knowledge", therefore, a set of reminiscences, & our perception always incomplete, & full of omissions, & thus a subsequent combination of random memories ?


A devout Christian who I know, claims that they do not have to keep all the Torah (law) that they can, while I claim that I am commanded to keep all the Torah that I can.

Q: Isn’t one of us is deceived ?

If I am the one who is deceived, then I have been deceived into believing that I should search Torah, in order to learn to keep, & do it.

If I have been deceived into believing that I have be saved by grace through faith, & as a follower of the Messiah who saved me, I should walk as He walked, then I have also been deceived into believing that I should keep the 7th day Sabbath, that I should keep & observe the feasts of Lev 23, & that  I should obey dietary laws of Lev 11.

If he is the one who is deceived, then he has been deceived into believing that he doesn't have to keep Torah.

If he is the one who is deceived, then he has been deceived into believing that he should be saved by grace through faith, & as a follower of the one who saved him, he's been liberated from having to keep the sabbath, from observing the feasts of Lev 23, or be restricted by dietary laws of Lev 11.


In Gal 3:1, Paul addresses them with “O foolish Galatians”, who hath bewitched you”. Here is the whole verse :

Gal 3:1 O foolish Galatians, who hath bewitched you, that ye should not obey the truth, before whose eyes Messiah Yahushua hath been evidently set forth, crucified among you?


The Greek word translated as “foolish” is derived from G453, Anoetos, which means in this context, one who is not exercising his/her mind, or someone who is not thinking.

The Greek word translated as “bewitched” is from G940, Baskaino, which means to slander, or speak against something.

Q: What has been slandered or spoken against ?

A: YHWH’s Torah – these Galatians, of whom Paul says they have not exercised their minds, or they haven’t been thinking, have been deceived into thinking that they no longer have to keep YHWH’s Torah.

So, if someone has been deceived into believing that they do not have to keep YHWH’s Torah, are they being “foolish”, & haven’t they been bewitched ?


Can I ask you to decide, which scenario sounds more like the work that satan would do ?

1: would satan deceive people into believing that they have to obey YHWH's instructions, His Torah, or

2: would satan deceive someone into believing that they do not have to obey YHWH's Torah ?

Which one of those sounds more like something satan would do ?


Again, would satan deceive a man so that in his deceived state, he starts obeying YHWH’s Torah, or would satan deceive a man into believing that, since he's been saved by faith through grace, he doesn't have to keep YHWH’s Torah ?


I cannot find a place in the Bible where Messiah Yahushua said “depart from me ye workers who keep YHWH’s law, who obey Torah, depart from me for I knew you not” - that's not written in the Bible, is it ?


But I do find in Matt 7:21-23, where Messiah Yahushua warns us what He will say to the “lawless”, those not keeping YHWH's Torah,depart from Me, I never knew you”.


I cannot find a place where Messiah Yahushua said, “I came to keep the law, so that you won't have to”, but I do find a place where He said : 

“Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.  (Matt 5:17).


I cannot find a place where Messiah Yahushua said, "after My death, burial, & resurrection, you'll no longer be required to keep the sabbath, or observe YHWH’s feasts, or follow the dietary laws", but I do find a place where He said “as long as heaven & earth stand, not one jot or one tittle shall pass from the law" (Matt 5:18).


So does it make more sense to think that satan would deceive a man to keep YHWH’s Torah, or does it make more sense to think that satan would deceive a man to forsake YHWH’s Torah ?


If people say, "we're saved by grace through faith, & in being saved we should obey YHWH’s Torah", & others say "we're saved by grace through faith, & in being saved, we're no longer to keep YHWH’s Torah", again, both cannot be right - one is deceived, & we should not be so “foolish”, as to refuse to consider how ludicrous it is, to even think that satan is running around deceiving people into obeying YHWH's instruction, His Torah !

What decision will you make ?

This blog demonstrates how important it is to examine the origin of English words when studying the Bible.

There are many verses in Scripture that have either been poorly, and/or incorrectly translated, and/or are hard to understand.

Let me demonstrate by examining Gal 2:14.

The KJV reads as follows :

Gal 2:14 But when I saw that they walked not uprightly according to the truth of the gospel, I said unto Peter before them all, If thou, being a Jew, livest after the manner of Gentiles, and not as do the Jews, why compellest thou the Gentiles to live as do the Jews

Before I explain the problems with Gal 2:14, I need to address the context of the proceeding few verses (v11-14). 

There Paul confronted Peter about returning to the “Jews religion”, mentioned in Gal 1:13-14.  Paul’s condemnation of Peter has to do with believing that men are bound by the oral law of the “Jews' religion”. Their conflict was over Peter not fellowshipping with the believing Gentiles, when those of the “Jews' religion” were present, because they taught that fellowshipping with unsaved Gentiles was sinful – it definitely was not over, keeping or not keeping YHWH’s Torah. Evidence for this is that there is no mention of Torah, anywhere in the exchange between these two men – none.

If Paul didn't think the Gentiles should be taught to follow Torah, then I have a few questions for people to answer :

Q1: If Paul didn't think the Gentiles should be taught to follow Torah, then how do you explain this :

~ why did he teach them in assemblies that gathered every sabbath ? 

~ Why did he have Timothy circumcised in Acts 16, if he didn't believe that the Gentiles should be taught to keep Torah?  

~Why did he take a vow, and shave his head to prove to the Jews that he walked in obedience to Torah? 

~ Why did he still keep the feasts, if keeping the feasts was just a “Jewish” thing?

Q2: Wouldn’t Paul have been a hypocrite for confronting Peter about doing “Jewish” things, & then he, Paul, then did “Jewish” things?  

There was a huge difference between what Peter was doing, & what he did. Peter was following the "oral law" of men, while keeping the feasts, is obeying Torah.

Q3: Why did Paul, in Eph 2:10, talk about being created in Messiah Yahushua, to walk in “good works” which YHWH ordained - a clear reference to Torah ?

Q4: If Paul thinks that Torah is not to be followed,  why did he say in Rom 3:2, that the Jews have a great advantage? 

Clearly, Paul didn’t advocate the non-keeping of YHWH’s Torah, in Gal 2, & elsewhere.


Now back to our study verse, Gal 2:14.

If we look at this verse, we see that, in the KJV, the English words, “Jew” is written once, & “Jews” is written, twice. What we don’t see in English, is that there are three different Greek words that are translated as “Jew”, & “Jews”, twice. They are in order, G2453, Ioudaios, meaning a Judaean, one belonging to Judah, G2452, Ioudaikos, meaning, after the manner of the Jews, including keeping the traditions of the elders, & G2450, Ioudaizo, meaning to judaize, or imitate the Jews.

If I now translate this verse, & insert the meanings of these three words, together with three others,  that are not explained, we get :

Gal 2:14 But when I saw that they (those of the Jewish religion), walked not uprightly according to the truth of the gospel (of Messiah Yahushua), I said unto Peter before them all, If thou, being a Jew(one belonging to Judah), livest after the manner of Gentiles(non-Jews), and not as do the Jews(after the manner of the Jews, including keeping the traditions of the elders), why compellest thou the Gentiles (non-Jews), to live as do the Jews (to judaize, or imitate the Jews)

Now, if we apply this excellent Bible Study strategy, isn’t the meaning of what Paul was writing, much clearer, & less open to misunderstanding ? Can you now see why it is so important to examine the origin of the English words used in Bible Translations ?

Another example can be found in Exod 12:43-49 which I have copied below. It gives details of who can participate in the original Passover event, but in English, it is very confusing, & unclear who they are.

The KJV in v43, uses the word “stranger”, in v44, it uses the phrase, “every man’s servant”, in v45, it uses the terms, “foreigner” & “hired servant”, & in verses 48 & 49, it again uses, “stranger”. Can you see the problem ? Based on this English translation, can you know whom YHWH indicates can participate in His Passover ?

Exo 12:43 And YHWH said unto Moses and Aaron, This is the ordinance of the passover: There shall no stranger eat thereof: 

Exo 12:44 But every man's servant that is bought for money, when thou hast circumcised him, then shall he eat thereof. 

Exo 12:45 A foreigner and an hired servant shall not eat thereof. 

Exo 12:46 In one house shall it be eaten; thou shalt not carry forth ought of the flesh abroad out of the house; neither shall ye break a bone thereof. 

Exo 12:47 All the congregation of Israel shall keep it. 

Exo 12:48 And when a stranger shall sojourn with thee, and will keep the passover to YHWH, let all his males be circumcised, and then let him come near and keep it; and he shall be as one that is born in the land: for no uncircumcised person shall eat thereof. 

Exo 12:49 One law shall be to him that is homeborn, and unto the stranger that sojourneth among you

If we check the Hebrew, it becomes much clearer.

In v43, the Hebrew word translated as “stranger” is H1616, ger, meaning an apostate Israelite, or a non-Israelite, in v44, the meaning of “every man’s servant” is clearly defined in the verse – he is a bought male servant who has been circumcised, & therefore has become an Israelite, in v45, “a foreigner” is the Hebrew word, H8453, toshab, meaning a sojourner living with the Israelites, & a “hired servant” is someone who is hired to do a task. In verses 48 & 49, the stranger, the ger, is described as one who sojourns with you. In this case, this person is one who is converting to, or changing citizenship, to become an Israelite. (Remember Ruth, the daughter-in-law of Naomi, did this in Ruth 1:16).

So, if I now translate this verse, & insert the meanings of these words, we get :

Exo 12:43 And YHWH said unto Moses and Aaron, This is the ordinance of the passover: There shall no stranger (no apostate Israelite, or non-Israelite), eat thereof: 

Exo 12:44 But every man's servant that is bought for money, when thou hast circumcised him, then shall he eat thereof. 

Exo 12:45 A foreigner (a sojourner living with the Israelites), and an hired servant shall not eat thereof. 

Exo 12:46 In one house shall it be eaten; thou shalt not carry forth ought of the flesh abroad out of the house; neither shall ye break a bone thereof. 

Exo 12:47 All the congregation of Israel shall keep it. 

Exo 12:48 And when a stranger shall sojourn with thee, (a person who is converting to, or changing citizenship, to become an Israelite) and will keep the passover to YHWH, let all his males be circumcised, and then let him come near and keep it; and he shall be as one that is born in the land: for no uncircumcised person shall eat thereof. 

Exo 12:49 One law shall be to him that is homeborn, and unto the stranger that sojourneth among you (the person who is converting to, or changing citizenship to become an Israelite)

Again, if we apply this excellent Bible Study strategy, isn’t the meaning of who can participate in YHWH’s Passover, much clearer, & less open to misunderstanding ? Can you see why it is so important to examine the origin of the English words used in Bible Translations ?




 


This blog explores who Paul was, & the main reasons why he did not ever teach against keeping Yahweh’s Torah, with a focus on Gal 1, & 2 Pet 3:16

If we are going to TEST this commonly held Christian idea, shouldn’t we have the desire to really understand Paul, by honestly wanting to know as much as we can about him ?

In order to do this, surely we must search the Scriptures for all the details that are available about Paul. In doing that, I believe that we will need to apply the biblical principles of Isaiah 28:13, namely, to examine “precept upon precept, precept upon precept; line upon line, line upon line; here a little, and there a little”.

I strongly believe that we certainly should imitate what we are told the Bereans did in Acts 17:11. There it tells us “that they received the word with all readiness of mind (from Paul), and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things (that Paul told them), were so”.

Q: So what do we know about Paul ?

A:

Acts 21:39 & 22:3, tell us that Paul was a Jew, born in Tarsus, a city in Cilica. Acts 22:25 indicates that Paul was a Roman citizen.

In Acts 22:3, we are told that Paul was “brought up in this city at the feet of Gamaliel, and taught according to the perfect manner of the law of the fathers, and was zealous toward God, as ye all are this day”.

Acts 5:34 refers to Gamaliel, as “one in the council, a Pharisee, … a doctor of the law, had in reputation among all the people”. It is believed that to be a disciple of Gamaliel, a young man needed to be among the brightest, & most zealous of Pharisees - only the very best young Pharisees could be mentored by Gamaliel. After Paul’s “training” by Gamaliel, I have read that Paul knew the Tanach so well, that he had it memorised. He certainly knew, & practised the oral laws, the traditions of the elders, in his life before his encounter with Messiah Yahushua.

We know from Acts 26 that Paul was a strict Pharisee, & the son of a Pharisee. In Acts 7 & 9, we know that he participated in the stoning of Stephen. Paul “breathed threats & slaughter against the disciples” in Acts 9, & in Gal 1:13-14, Paul tells the Galatians some interesting information when he writes, “For ye have heard of my conversation in time past in the Jews' religion, how that beyond measure I persecuted the church of YHWH, and wasted it: And profited in the Jews' religion above many my equals in mine own nation, being more exceedingly zealous of the traditions of my fathers”.

Q: What is the “Jews’ religion” ?

A: In Gal 1:13-14, we see mention of the “Jews’ religion”, twice. Clearly, that was the Pharisaic religion that many Jews of the first century, including Paul, practiced. There are two main things that we need to know about these Pharisees.

1: They revere the “oral law”, including the Talmud, (the primary source of Jewish law & theology), the Mishnah, (the written copy of the oral law), & the Gemara (the rabbinic commentary on the Jewish law), even above the written Torah of Moses.

2: They taught that to be saved, you must first be circumcised, & then keep the Torah (based on the oral laws teachings of the Talmud, Mishnah & the Gemara).

While the “Jews religion” was the religion that Paul originally believed in, practiced, & “profited in”, it is NOT the same spiritual walk he practiced, after His encounter with Messiah Yahushua. This is why Paul had several conflicting encounters with those of the Jews’ religion, during his ministry. (Acts 15, Gal 2:2). Sometimes, the “Jews religion” are referred to as “the circumcision” (Gal 2:7-8 is an example).

In Acts 9, we read of Paul’s encounter with Messiah Yahushua, & later, in Gal 1:1, how he was appointed as an apostle to the Gentiles.

In Gal 1:17-18, we are told that Paul went into Arabia, & after three years, he went to Jerusalem to see Peter & James.

Q: Why might Paul have gone to Arabia ?

A: We are not told the reason in Scripture, but I am guessing that Paul may have gone to Mt Sinai, (Arabia), the mountain where YHWH gave the original Israelites His written Torah instructions, in order to reassess his scriptural thinking & beliefs, after his encounter with Messiah Yahushua.

Q: Why might Paul have visited with Peter, three years later ?

A: Again, we are not told, but perhaps it was to test what he had discovered about his revised beliefs, when in Arabia.

Q: What did Paul believe, & now practice after his encounter with Messiah Yahushua, his trip to Arabia, & his visit with Peter & James?

A:

Paul confesses to the Jews of Caesarea, saying in Acts 24:14 that “so worship I the Elohim of my fathers, believing all things which are written in the law and in the prophets”. Clearly, isn’t Paul declaring that he believed ALL things that Moses wrote, & what was written in the Prophets ? Surely, this would include YHWH’s written Torah ?

We also know from checking the book of Acts, & reading Paul’s epistles that specifically :

~ Paul observed the 7th day Sabbath (Acts 13:42, 17:2, 18:4),

~ he kept Passover (1 Cor 5:8).

~ Paul observed Shavuot (Pentecost) in Jerusalem (Acts 20:16);

~ he also kept the annual feasts of Lev 23 (Acts 18:21).

~ in Eph 4:25, Paul states that he believed in the Prophets (Zech 8:16), & the words of the Writings (Ps 4:4).

~ in 1 Tim 1:8-11, Paul calls the Torah "sound teaching", while in 2 Tim 2:15, he called the Torah the "word of Truth". 

Paul tells us that in 2 Tim 3:16 that “scripture (the Tanach) is written by inspiration of the Ruach (Holy Spirit), & is profitable for doctrine, reproof, correction & instruction in righteousness                                     

We also know that Paul took a Nazarite vow, according to Acts 18:18, & Acts 21:24-26, which was based on Num 6:18).

Clearly, these are the major, & significant reasons we can have to know that Paul kept YHWH’s Torah, & that he never taught against YHWH’s Torah.

In 2 Peter 3:15-16, we read that Peter calls Paul, a “beloved brother”, & in verse 16, he explains his understanding of how & what Paul wrote :

 

2Pe 3:16 As also in all (Paul’s) epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as (they do) also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction.

Peter begins by explaining that in “all Paul’s epistles” (letters), “some things are hard to understand”. This is extremely important to know because, we really need to understand what Paul has written.

The next part of this verse is very significant ! There Peter tells us that people who are “unlearned”, as well as “unstable”, wrest (distort, twist, pervert), what Paul has written.

Q: What are such people “unlearned” in ?

A: Based on the context, they must be unlearned about YHWH’s written Torah, because of his reference to “other scriptures”, which at the time this was written, could only be the Tanach.

Q: What does Peter mean, when he describes some people as “unstable” ?

A: Again, in this context, wouldn’t someone who is “unstable” have no fixed principles & views ? Would they be, as Eph 4:14 explains, be “tossed to & fro . . . with every wind of doctrine” ?

QWhat does Peter mean when he tells us that these unlearned & unstable people, “wrest” the hard things that Paul writes ?

AThe Greek word translated as “wrest” is streb’lo’o, which literally means to torture by twisting & wrenching apart. It seems to me that, “wrest” in this context means, to distort, to twist, to pervert, or even reversing, what is actually being written.

Isn’t it obvious from Peter’s comment that, even at the time of Peter's writing, people were “twisting” what Paul has written – isn’t it very obvious, that they do so now ?

Q: What are the “other scriptures” that Peter is mentioning ?

AAgain, we know that any “Renewed Covenant Scriptures (NT) would not be published, & widely distributed until much later than this time, so it must be a reference to the rest of the Tanach (OT), the writings of the Prophets, & the Psalms.

QWhat does Peter mean when he says, these “unlearned” & “unstable” people distort, twist & pervert, not only what Paul has written in his epistles, but these other scriptures ?

A: By embracing distorted, twisted & perverted doctrines, these unlearned & unstable people, bring a curse upon themselves, resulting in probably a loss of their own salvation, in other words, “their own destruction”.

So the lesson for us is that, if we are really going to comprehend, understand, & know the “things that are hard to understand” by Paul, shouldn’t we diligently read, & study what he read & studied, before, we read what he wrote.

If we look at 2 Pet 2:14, we see another reference to “unstable” souls – it is the same Greek word as Peter uses in 2 Peter 3:16.

2Pe 2:14 Having eyes full of adultery, and that cannot cease from sin; beguiling unstable souls: an heart they have exercised with covetous practices; cursed children:

In 2 Pet 2:1, we read about “false prophets” & “false teachers”, who “privily” shall bring damnable heresies. “privily” here means bring in secretly.

Q: Why would these "false prophets" & "false teachers", do this ?

A: Because they don’t want their “audiences” to know their real motives.

These false teachers use the Bible, but only certain verses as decoys, to manipulate others – this is twisting of Paul’s words. In doing this, a false teacher might say something like, “legalism is disobedience to YHWH”, in order to bring about “a damnable heresy”.

There are several verses, just in Paul’s letter to the Galatians that are hard to understand, including :

Gal 2:14, 2:16, 2:19, 3:2, 3:13, 3:24-25, 4:8, 4L21-31, 5L1-2, 5:14, 118, 6:2, 13, 14-15.

If we examine just Gal 2:14, we know that false teachers often say that it means “gentiles don’t have to keep the law, because Jews keep it”. This is “twisting” what Paul has written.

If you accept what these “false teachers” say Gal 2:14 means, haven’t you missed the warning, Peter said when he wrote that “some of what Paul writes is hard to understand” ? This makes absolutely no sense because, it was written by Paul who kept the law.

Another reason we can know that Paul kept YHWH’s Torah concerns what I’ll call, “Paul’s personal examination”. This may take a bit of time to explain, so I hope you can be patient.

In Gal 2:1 we read that “after 14 years, Paul, Barnabas & Titus went to Jerusalem”. If we examine

Gal 2:2, there are several things we need to investigate.

Q1: Why does Paul write that by “revelation”, he “communicated unto them that gospel which I preach among the Gentiles, but privately to them which were of reputation” ?

Q2What was the “gospel” Paul preached to the Gentiles ?

Q3Who were the “them which were of reputation” ?

Q4: Why did Paul meet with them “privately” ? 

Gal 2:1 Then fourteen years after I went up again to Jerusalem with Barnabas, and took Titus with me also. 

Gal 2:2 And I went up by revelation, and communicated unto them that gospel which I preach among the Gentiles, but privately to them which were of reputation, lest by any means I should run, or had run, in vain

A1: I believe the Ruach (Holy Spirit) prompted Paul to go to Jerusalem (by revelation).

A2: I’ll get to more details soon, but for now, it seems reasonable to assume that Paul wanted to CHECK, & TEST that, the gospel he was teaching for 14 years, was the same as the gospel, “them which were of reputation”, taught.

A3: The “them which were of reputation” were the apostles that walked, & lived with Messiah Yahushua for 3 years, specifically, Peter, John, & James.

A4: Paul met with them “privately” because he wanted to discuss with them what “their understanding” was of Messiah Yahushua’s gospel message – after all, they had “personal” contact with Messiah Yahushua. Even though, Paul too, got his instructions about the gospel from Messiah Yahushua, Paul wanted to double check that the gospel he had been teaching for 14 years, was the same gospel Messiah Yahushua had taught them.

Please note that at the end of Gal 2:2, Paul writes “lest by any means I should run, or had run, in vain”. Paul is really saying that, unless the gospel that he had been teaching for 14 years, was the same as the gospel Peter, John & James were teaching, THEN, his (Paul’s) teaching would have been “in vain” (of absolutely no value).

Because I don’t have a great deal of time to examine what Peter & James taught, I’ll focus briefly on what John taught. I believe that Peter & James’ understanding of Messiah Yahushua’s gospel message was the same as John’s.

In 1 John 2:1-6, we find the following : 

1Jn 2:1 My little children, these things write I unto you, that ye sin not. And if any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Messiah Yahushua the righteous

1Jn 2:2 And he is the propitiation (atonement) for our sins: and not for ours only, but also for the sins of the whole world. 

1Jn 2:3 And hereby we do know that we know him, if we keep his commandments

1Jn 2:4 He that saith, I know him, and keepeth not his commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him

1Jn 2:5 But whoso keepeth his word, in him verily is the love of YHWH perfected: hereby know we that we are in him. 

1Jn 2:6 He that saith he abideth in him ought himself also so to walk, even as he walked

Notice that John, in v1, mentions sin, & connects it with our advocate with the heavenly Father, Messiah Yahushua.

In v2, John says that Messiah Yahushua atones for the sins of the world.

V3 tells us that if we know (have a relationship) with Father YHWH, then we “keep HIS commandments”. John continues in v4, by writing that if someone says that they are in a relationship with YHWH (they know Him), but do not keep YHWH’s commandments, that person is a liar, & the Truth isn’t in him.

John then writes in v5 that, the person who keeps YHWH’s word, perfects YHWH’s love, resulting in him, being in YHWH.

I believe the crucial point John is making occurs in v6, where John writes, “He that saith he abideth in him ought himself also so to walk, even as he walked. If we are true disciples & believers in Messiah Yahushua, we must walk as He walked”.

Q: How did Messiah Yahushua walk ?

A: I’ll answer this by giving 4 examples.

1: Messiah Yahushua agreed with, supported & believed what Moses wrote (Matt 5:17-19).

~ He kept the 7th day Sabbath (Mark 1:21, Luke 4:16)

~ He kept the annual moedim (feasts) of Lev 23 (John 2;23, John 7:1-6, 10) .

~ He was circumcised on the 8th day (Luke 2:21-24)

~ He wore fringes on his garments (Luke 8:44), in accordance with  Num 15:38 & Deut 22:12.

~ Paul calls Him the firstfruits of those who have fallen (1 Cor 15:20).

~ He taught on fasting (Matt 6:16-18).  

~ In Luke 17:14, He told the ten lepers who were cleansed to show themselves to the priests, as was required by Lev 13:2.

There are 23 verses where Yahushua attributes the Torah to Moses. (Matt 8:4; 19:7, 8; 23:2; Mark 1:44; 10:3, 4; 7:10; Luke 5:14; 16:19, 31; 20:37; 24:27, 44; John 3:14; 5:39, 45, 46; 6:32; 7:19, 22, 23)

2: Messiah Yahushua explained the true meaning, & application of several of YHWH’s commandments. In Matt 5:27-32, He expands on the commandment of adultery, & in John 8:3-11, He applies the teaching of Deut 17:6-7, when the woman caught in adultery is brought to Him.

3: Messiah Yahushua prayed to His heavenly Father (Matt 14:23, Matt 26:36), & taught His disciples how to pray (Luke 11:1). In John 17:26, Messiah Yahushua says that He “declared unto them thy name, and will declare it”. Clearly, YHWH’s name is exceptionally important, (a) because it is written 6823 times in Scripture, & (b) because we are told to in various other verses we are told to :

~ bless His name (Ps 100:4)

~ exalt His name (Ps 34:3) &

~ praise His name (Ps 149:3)

~ hallow His name (Luke 11:2)

My research indicates that very few Christians know, or use YHWH’s name, so how can they bless, exalt, praise or hallow His name ?

4: In John 17:26, Messiah Yahushua says that He has “declared to them Your (YHWH’s) name”. Clearly, knowing, & using YHWH’s name is vitally important, if someone wants to have a relationship with Him.

Joh 17:26 And I have declared unto them thy name, and will declare it: that the love wherewith thou hast loved me may be in them, and I in them.

A third reason that we know that Paul didn’t teach against keeping YHWH’s Torah, could be based on his own personal experience.

In Gal 1:1, we read that Paul was an apostle ordained by Messiah Yahushua, & YHWH the Father, & definitely not by men. This was Paul’s experience. 

Gal 1:1 Paul, an apostle, (not of men, neither by man, but by Messiah Yahushua, and YHWH the Father, who raised him from the dead;)

Paul expounds upon this experience in verses 11-12, where he writes, “I certify you, brethren, that the gospel which was preached of me is not after man. For I neither received it of man, neither was I taught it, but by the revelation of Messiah Yahushua”.

If those things are true, & I believe that they are, then wouldn’t any person who thinks rationally, ask this question.

Is it possible for YHWH, & Messiah Yahushua, to call a man to go & teach something that would be different than what YHWH had said to Moses ?

If a person is sent by YHWH, does it make any sense to even imagine that YHWH would have spoken one message to Moses, & then said to Paul, “ I need you to go correct a few things I said to Moses”. It makes no sense, & defies logic !

Isn’t it ludicrous that YHWH would call Paul to go out & contradict what He, YHWH, said to Moses, especially when we read what YHWH said to Moses? Doesn’t YHWH say things to Moses like “this shall be a statute forever” (Exod 12:17), & “this is My name forever” (Exod 3:15), “the Sabbath is a sign forever” (Exod 31:17), & “You shall keep it (Passover) a feast to YHWH throughout your generations – you shall keep it a feast forever”(Exod 12:14) ?

If YHWH, through Moses, said those things were forever, would He now call Paul & say, “go tell people that I changed my mind, that they really were temporary”. To believe that, is to believe that which is absurd ! It's the epitome of what it means to be “unlearned” & “unstable”, to believe that YHWH would send Paul to contradict what he said to Moses. 

Have you ever investigated what happens to those who “speaks against Moses” ?

If you check out Num 12:1-16, I believe that you will see that, when Aaron & Miriam criticised Moses for taking the Ethiopian wife, “YHWH took that personally” (Num 12:9) 

Num 12:8 With him will I speak mouth to mouth, even apparently, and not in dark speeches; and the similitude of the LORD shall he behold: wherefore then were ye not afraid to speak against my servant Moses?

Num 12:9 And the anger of the LORD was kindled against them; and he departed.

Q: What happened to Miriam then ?

A: She became leprous, & was put out of the camp (v10 & v14)

In Num 16:1-33, we have the situation where Korah & others spoke against Moses. Verse 4 tells us that when Moses heard their complaint, “he fell on his face” (Moses remembered what happened to Miriam).

Q: What happened to Korah & his followers ?

A: Num 16:32 tells us that the ”earth opened her mouth & swallowed them up”.

YHWH certainly reacts in a very negative way to those who criticise Moses, & what YHWH told him to write.

Based on all this information, the only logical conclusion that I believe that we can reach is that, Paul never taught against YHWH’s Torah !